Coyuchi is a premium brand focused on 100% organic, sustainably sourced home textiles with a natural, rustic aesthetic, while Brooklinen positions itself as an accessible luxury brand, offering a wider variety of modern styles and materials at more wallet-friendly prices. The core difference lies in priority: Coyuchi champions certified organic materials and eco-conscious production above all else, which is reflected in its higher price point. Brooklinen concentrates on quality, style, and value for the modern direct-to-consumer shopper.
Let's compare everything you need to know to choose the right bedding brand for your home.
Coyuchi: The Organic and Sustainable Choice
Coyuchi has built its reputation on an unwavering commitment to environmental responsibility and organic textiles. Since its founding, the brand has been a go-to for shoppers seeking premium linens made from natural fibers without synthetic chemicals. Their target customer values sustainability, transparency, and a timeless, relaxed aesthetic, and is willing to invest in heirloom-quality pieces.
- Product mix: Bedding (sheets, duvet covers, pillows), bath linens (towels, robes, mats), and home goods like throws and table linens.
- Style/vibe: Natural, relaxed, and timeless. Features neutral color palettes, earthy tones, and subtle textures that suit rustic, coastal, and minimalist interiors.
- Price point: Luxury to upper-mid-range. A queen sheet set typically starts around $200, and individual bath towels range from $40 to $80.
- Quality & Materials: The brand's hallmark is its use of 100% organic cotton and linen. Many products are GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard) and Fair Trade Certified, ensuring high environmental and ethical standards.
- Sustainability: This is Coyuchi's core identity. They use non-toxic dyes, employ water-saving manufacturing processes, and provide detailed transparency about their sourcing and production.
- Return policy: You can return items within 30 days for a full refund and within one year for store credit.
Overall, Coyuchi is the ideal choice for someone who prioritizes certified organic and sustainable materials and desires a natural, understated home style.
Shop Coyuchi: coyuchi.com
Brooklinen: The Accessible Luxury Bedding Brand
Brooklinen became a major player in the home goods market by offering high-quality, comfortable bedding directly to consumers at a highly competitive price. The brand focuses on creating a straightforward shopping experience and providing premium-feeling products without the traditional luxury markup. They appeal to a wide audience, from first-time apartment dwellers to families looking for durable, stylish staples.
- Product mix: Extensive collection of bedding and bath products, including sheets, comforters, pillows, towels, and robes. They also offer loungewear and home accessories.
- Style/vibe: Modern, clean, and versatile. Their popular sateen and percale sheets come in classic solids, stripes, and limited edition patterns that work well with almost any decor style.
- Price point: Mid-range and accessible. A queen sheet set starts between $100 and $150, with bath towels ranging from $20 to $50 each.
- Quality & Materials: Known for using high-quality materials like long-staple cotton, available in different weaves such as crisp percale and silky-smooth sateen. While not all items are organic, they prioritize comfort and durability.
- Sales: Brooklinen frequently runs promotions and sales, particularly around major holidays, offering discounts and bundle deals that enhance their value proposition.
- Return policy: Brooklinen has one of the most generous policies in the industry, offering a 365-day window for returns or exchanges.
Brooklinen is a practical choice for shoppers seeking a mix of high quality, modern design, and affordability backed by an excellent customer experience.
Shop Brooklinen: brooklinen.com
Coyuchi vs. Brooklinen Comparison
Price Comparison
The price gap between Coyuchi and Brooklinen is one of the most significant differentiators. Coyuchi is positioned firmly in the premium category, with queen sheet sets starting around $200. This higher cost is justified by their use of 100% organic certified materials and commitment to Fair Trade practices. You are paying for a product that meets strict environmental and ethical standards from farm to finish.
Brooklinen offers a more accessible entry into quality bedding. A queen set from Brooklinen can be found for as low as $120, and frequent sales and bundling options offer even better value. While both brands provide excellent products, Brooklinen is the clear winner for shoppers who are budget-conscious but still desire a luxurious feel.
Style & Aesthetic
Coyuchi embraces a natural, earthy aesthetic. Their color palette consists of soft neutrals, muted pastels, and natural tones derived from low-impact dyes. Textures play a key role, with organic cotton and linen providing a relaxed, "perfectly undone" look that's ideal for rustic, coastal, or minimalist decor. The vibe is calming, organic, and timeless.
Brooklinen’s style is more modern and clean. They excel at classic solid colors and simple, versatile patterns like stripes and windowpane checks. Their branding is fresh and appeals to those who want stylish, hotel-quality bedding that feels contemporary and polished. Brooklinen is the better choice for easily integrating bedding into a wide variety of modern interior design schemes.
Quality & Materials
When it comes to materials, both brands excel in quality, but with different focuses. Coyuchi's entire brand is built on using 100% organic fibers, primarily cotton and linen. Their adherence to GOTS and Fair Trade certifications means every piece is produced with minimal environmental impact and without harsh chemicals, which can be a huge benefit for those with sensitive skin.
Brooklinen's focus is on high-quality conventional materials. They are known for their long-staple cotton, which results in stronger, softer, and more durable threads. Their sateen sheets are exceptionally smooth, while their Classic Percale is crisp and cool. While they do not have the same level of organic certification as Coyuchi, the quality of their craftsmanship is highly regarded.
Sustainability & Ethics
Coyuchi leads the industry in sustainability and ethics. From sourcing GOTS-certified organic cotton to ensuring Fair Trade labor practices in their supply chain, their entire business model is centered on environmental and social responsibility. For shoppers where sustainability is a non-negotiable factor, Coyuchi is the undisputed choice.
Brooklinen has made positive steps towards sustainability by focusing on responsible manufacturing and using eco-friendly packaging. They have goals to reduce their carbon footprint and conserve resources. However, it is not the central pillar of their brand identity in the same way it is for Coyuchi. They offer a good balance for the average consumer, but dedicated eco-conscious shoppers will find Coyuchi's mission more aligned with their values.
Shopping Experience & Return Policies
Brooklinen disrupted the market with its customer-first approach. Their website is easy to navigate, they offer fast shipping, and their return policy is exceptional. They offer a 365-day 'any reason' return or exchange window, giving customers complete peace of mind to try their products at home.
Coyuchi provides a more boutique-like shopping experience that focuses on education around their sustainable practices. Their return policy is also good, offering a full refund within 30 days and store credit for up to a year, but it isn't as long-lasting as Brooklinen's. For flexibility and a low-risk purchase, Brooklinen takes the lead.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right brand depends entirely on your personal priorities for style, budget, and ethics.
Choose Coyuchi if:
- Your top priority is buying certified organic and sustainably made products.
- You prefer a natural, relaxed, and earthy aesthetic with muted tones and textures.
- You are willing to invest more in bedding that meets high ethical and environmental standards.
- You have sensitive skin and want sheets made without harsh synthetic chemicals or dyes.
Choose Brooklinen if:
- You're looking for the best balance of quality, comfort, and price.
- You prefer a modern, clean, and polished style with a wide range of colors and simple patterns.
- You love a generous return policy and appreciate frequent sales and promotions.
- You want that crisp or silky "luxury hotel" feeling from your cotton sheets.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Coyuchi or Brooklinen cheaper?
Without a doubt, Brooklinen is cheaper. Their queen sheet sets start at a significantly lower price point (around $120-$150) compared to Coyuchi's (starting around $200). Frequent sales make Brooklinen an even more budget-friendly option.
Which has better quality bedding?
Both brands offer high-quality products, but "better" depends on your criteria. Coyuchi's quality is rooted in its GOTS-certified organic materials and sustainable construction, focusing on durability and eco-friendliness. Brooklinen's quality comes from its use of strong long-staple cotton and refined weaves like percale and sateen for exceptional feel and comfort.
Can you return products to both stores?
Yes, but Brooklinen has a far more generous policy. You can return items to Brooklinen for up to 365 days. Coyuchi offers a full refund within 30 days and store credit for up to one year.
Are Coyuchi products really organic?
Yes. Coyuchi's core promise is organic textiles. Most of their cotton products are certified by the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS), which is one of the strictest certifications for organic textiles.
Which brand is better for hot sleepers?
Both brands offer excellent options. Brooklinen's Classic Percale collection is specifically designed to be light, crisp, and breathable, making it a favorite for hot sleepers. Coyuchi's organic cotton percale or linen sheets are also naturally breathable and cool.
Does Brooklinen ever go on sale?
Yes, Brooklinen frequently has sales, especially around major holidays like Black Friday, Cyber Monday, and Presidents' Day. They also offer bundle-and-save discounts year-round.
Which brand feels softer?
This is subjective. Brooklinen's Luxe Sateen sheets are known for being silky-smooth right out of the box. Coyuchi's materials have a more natural, lived-in softness that often gets better and more comfortable with every wash, especially their Cloud Brushed flannel and relaxed linen.
Why is Coyuchi so expensive?
Coyuchi's pricing reflects the cost of sourcing 100% certified organic cotton, paying fair wages to workers (Fair Trade certification), and using environmentally safe production processes. The entire supply chain is more complex and costly than conventional textile manufacturing.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
