Coyuchi is known for its relaxed, coastal aesthetic and deep commitment to GOTS-certified organic materials and eco-friendly production. In contrast, Boll & Branch focuses on a more classic, refined style of luxury in its organic textiles, with an industry-leading emphasis on Fair Trade certification and supply chain ethics.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right sustainable bedding brand for your home.
Coyuchi: The Coastal Organic Choice
Founded over 30 years ago, Coyuchi is a pioneer in the organic home textiles space. The brand is dedicated to creating high-quality, sustainable bedding and bath linens using natural, GOTS-certified organic fibers. Its aesthetic is deeply rooted in nature, featuring textured weaves and earthy colors that evoke a serene, laid-back coastal vibe, making it a favorite among environmentally-conscious consumers who don't want to sacrifice style or comfort.
- Product mix: A full range of bedding, including sheets, duvet covers, and quilts. Also offers bath linens, towels, robes, loungewear, throws, and curtains.
- Style/vibe: Coastal, minimalist, and relaxed luxury. The brand heavily features natural textures like crinkled percale, linen, and matelassé, in a palette of muted, earthy tones.
- Price point: Mid to high-range. Organic sheet sets typically start around $200, while individual bath towels range from $30 to $60.
- Quality & Materials: Focused on 100% organic cotton, linen, and other natural fibers. Products are GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard) and OEKO-TEX certified, ensuring they are free from harmful substances. The fabrics are known for their breathability and for getting softer with each wash.
- Certifications: A leader in sustainable certifications, prioritizing GOTS, Fair Trade, and Made Safe standards across its product range.
- Sales: Holds seasonal sales and special promotions throughout the year. Signing up for an email list is a great way to get notified.
- Return policy: Offers a 30-day return policy for items in their original condition.
Coyuchi is ideal for those who want beautiful, long-lasting linens that feel gentle on the skin and are made with respect for the planet.
Shop Coyuchi: coyuchi.com
Boll & Branch: The Ethical Luxury Leader
Boll & Branch has quickly become a powerhouse in the bedding industry by pairing premium, long-staple organic cotton with a radical commitment to transparency and ethical production. The brand was the first linen company to be Fair Trade Certified, ensuring fair wages and safe conditions for its artisans from the farm to the factory. Its aesthetic is classic, refined, and versatile, appealing to those who seek understated elegance and want their purchase to support a more equitable supply chain.
- Product mix: Primarily focused on bedding, with a wide selection of sheets, duvet covers, comforters, and pillows. Also offers towels, robes, blankets, and some sleepwear.
- Style/vibe: Classic, refined, and minimalist elegance. Their style is less about texture and more about smooth, plush finishes in timeless, versatile colorways.
- Price point: Premium. Their popular Signature Hemmed Sheet Sets start around $220-$250, with bath towels generally priced between $40 and $80.
- Quality & Materials: Exclusively uses 100% long-staple organic cotton, which results in exceptionally soft, smooth, and durable fabrics that resist pilling. All products are GOTS and OEKO-TEX certified.
- Certifications: A major point of distinction is their deep commitment to Fair Trade certification, guaranteeing ethical treatment and wages for all workers involved in production.
- Sales: Sales are less frequent than at other retailers, typically centered around major holidays like Black Friday/Cyber Monday, which reinforces their premium positioning.
- Return policy: Provides a generous 30-day risk-free trial, allowing you to sleep on their sheets before making a final decision.
Boll & Branch is the go-to for shoppers who prioritize an ethical mission and want to invest in classic, ultra-soft bedding that will last for years.
Shop Boll & Branch: bollandbranch.com
Coyuchi vs. Boll & Branch Comparison
Price Comparison
Both brands operate in the premium and luxury bedding space, so neither is a budget option. However, there are slight differences. Coyuchi often has a slightly more accessible entry point, with sheet sets beginning around $200 and towels starting near $30. Its frequent sales can also make it more affordable.
Boll & Branch is positioned firmly in the premium category, with its signature sheet sets starting closer to $220-$250 and towels around $40-$80. The brand’s pricing reflects its investment in long-staple organic cotton and its comprehensive Fair Trade certified supply chain. While you might pay a little more, that premium supports the brand's ethical mission.
Style & Aesthetic
The visual difference between the two brands is one of the clearest differentiators. Coyuchi champions a relaxed, natural, and coastal aesthetic. Think crinkled percales, slubby linens, and textured matelassé quilts in beautiful, nature-inspired colors like taupe, seafoam, and clay. Their style is perfect for creating a serene, comfortable, and slightly rustic or bohemian bedroom.
Boll & Branch, on the other hand, embodies a more classic, refined, and timeless elegance. Their focus is on smooth, sateen or percale weaves with a luxurious drape and subtle, clean finishes. The color palette sticks to classic neutrals and soft tones that fit seamlessly into almost any decor, from traditional to modern minimalist. If creating a crisp, hotel-like bed is your goal, Boll & Branch is the better fit.
Quality & Materials
You can't go wrong with quality from either brand, as both use 100% GOTS-certified organic cotton. Coyuchi utilizes a wider range of natural textiles, including exceptionally breathable linen and textured cotton weaves that are designed to become softer and more comfortable with time. Their products have a lived-in luxury feel right out of the box.
Boll & Branch distinguishes itself by using long-staple organic cotton exclusively. These longer fibers create yarns that are stronger, finer, and smoother, resulting in fabric that is incredibly soft to the touch and highly resistant to pilling. Their focus on this specific type of cotton gives their sheets a signature plushness and silky-smooth feel.
Sustainability & Ethics
Both Coyuchi and Boll & Branch are leaders in ethical and sustainable textiles, but they emphasize different aspects of the movement. Coyuchi has a strong environmental focus, championing organic farming, eco-friendly processing, and water conservation. They are GOTS certified, meaning their entire production process meets strict environmental and social criteria.
Boll & Branch's mission is deeply rooted in social responsibility. While they are also GOTS certified, their trademark is their Fair Trade certification. This goes a step further to ensure that the farmers and factory workers in their supply chain are paid fair, living wages and work in safe and healthy conditions. If the human-centered, social aspect of sustainability is your primary concern, Boll & Branch’s commitment is unparalleled.
Shopping Experience
Both brands offer excellent direct-to-consumer online shopping experiences. Their websites are clean, informative, and provide extensive detail about their products, materials, and certifications. They both offer free shipping thresholds and customer-friendly return policies.
The main difference lies in their return windows. Coyuchi offers a standard 30-day return policy on unused items. Boll & Branch stands out with its 30-day risk-free trial, which allows you to wash and even sleep on the bedding to ensure you love it before committing, offering greater peace of mind for an investment purchase.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends on your personal style, priorities, and what you value most in your linens.
Choose Coyuchi if:
- You love a relaxed, coastal, and natural design aesthetic.
- You appreciate textured fabrics like linen and crinkled percale that have a lived-in feel.
- Prioritizing organic materials and eco-friendly manufacturing processes is most important to you.
- You want high-end organic bedding at a slightly more accessible price point.
Choose Boll & Branch if:
- You prefer a classic, refined, and timeless style with a smooth, soft finish.
- Fair Trade certification and ethical treatment of workers is your number one priority.
- You want exceptionally plush, silky-soft sheets made from long-staple organic cotton.
- You are looking for an investment piece and appreciate a risk-free trial period.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Coyuchi or Boll & Branch cheaper?
Generally, Coyuchi is slightly more affordable. Its sheet sets start at a lower price point and the brand tends to run more frequent sales and promotions than Boll & Branch.
Which brand has better quality fabric?
Both brands offer exceptional quality made from GOTS-certified organic cotton, so it's a matter of preference. If you define quality by plush, smooth softness and durability, Boll & Branch's long-staple cotton may feel higher-quality. If you value natural textures and unique weaves like linen, you might prefer the quality of Coyuchi's materials, which are designed to wear in beautifully over time.
Are both Coyuchi and Boll & Branch organic?
Yes, both brands use 100% organic cotton and are fully certified by the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS), which is the leading standard for organic textiles.
Which brand is more sustainable?
This depends on how you define sustainability. Both are excellent choices. Coyuchi has a heavy focus on environmental sustainability, including organic farming practices and water-saving measures. Boll & Branch's focus is on social sustainability through its pioneering Fair Trade certification, ensuring ethical treatment and fair wages for workers.
Which sheets are softer?
Boll & Branch sheets are famous for their immediate silky-smooth and plush softness due to the long-staple cotton sateen weaves. Coyuchi's softness is often described as more natural and lived-in, their percale and linen sheets get progressively softer and cozier with every wash.
What makes Boll & Branch different?
Their primary differentiator is being the first home textile company to be Fair Trade Certified. Their complete dedication to ethical production and transparency in their supply chain, from the cotton farmer to the final product, is what truly sets them apart in the market.
What is Coyuchi's aesthetic known for?
Coyuchi is known for its serene, coastal-inspired aesthetic. Their products feature natural textures, relaxed weaves, and an earthy, muted color palette that creates a calm and inviting atmosphere.
Can you return products to both brands?
Yes, both brands have customer-friendly return policies. Coyuchi accepts returns of unwashed and unused items within 30 days. Boll & Branch offers a 30-day "risk-free trial," allowing you to wash and sleep on the sheets and still return them if you're not satisfied.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
