Closets by Design provides a high-end, full-service experience, creating fully customized and professionally installed storage systems tailored to your exact space. In contrast, IKEA offers affordable, modular wardrobe systems that you design, purchase, and assemble yourself. The primary difference is the model: a bespoke, done-for-you service versus a budget-friendly, hands-on DIY solution.
Let's compare these two popular organization solutions to help you decide which is right for your home and budget.
Closets by Design: The Custom Built-In Solution
Closets by Design is a franchise-based company specializing in tailored organization systems for every part of the home, from walk-in closets to garages and home offices. Their entire process is built around professional guidance, starting with an in-home consultation with a designer who measures your space, discusses your needs, and creates a 3D model of your future closet. This premium service is for homeowners seeking a permanent, high-quality, built-in solution that perfectly matches their home's aesthetic.
- Product mix: Custom storage systems for walk-in closets, reach-in closets, dressing rooms, laundry rooms, garages, pantries, and home offices.
- Style/vibe: Fully customizable to any aesthetic, from classic and traditional to modern and minimalist. Customers select from a wide array of finishes, hardware, and accessories.
- Price point: Mid-to-high end. Projects typically start around $2,000 for a simpler system and can easily reach $10,000 or more for large, detailed walk-in closets with premium features.
- Quality: High-quality materials like thermally fused laminate (TFL) or wood veneers provide a durable, furniture-grade finish. Professional installation ensures structural integrity and a perfect fit.
- Fit & Sizing: Completely custom-made to fit the exact dimensions of your space, making it an ideal choice for rooms with slanted ceilings, awkward corners, or unusual layouts.
- Shopping Experience: A full-service model that includes a free in-home design consultation, professional measurements, 3D design rendering, and final professional installation.
- Delivery & Assembly: All manufacturing, delivery, and installation are handled by their professional team, ensuring a seamless experience for the customer. Lead times can vary from a few weeks to a couple of months depending on location and complexity.
Closets by Design is the go-to for a permanent, professionally managed closet project where premium materials and a perfect fit are the main priorities.
Shop Closets by Design: closetsbydesign.com
IKEA: The Affordable DIY Wardrobe
IKEA is a global home furnishings giant known for functional, affordable, and stylish ready-to-assemble furniture. Their approach to closets centers on modular systems, like the highly popular PAX wardrobe, which lets customers mix and match frames, doors, and interior organizers to create a semi-custom solution. IKEA serves budget-conscious consumers who are comfortable with self-service shopping and DIY assembly and want a modern storage solution without the custom price tag.
- Product mix: Modular wardrobe systems (PAX), open storage systems (ALGOT), and a vast selection of interior organizers (KOMPLEMENT series) including drawers, shelves, clothes rails, and shoe organizers.
- Style/vibe: Signature Scandinavian design - modern, minimalist, and functional. Options range from simple white finishes to more traditional wood-look panels and mirrored or glass doors.
- Price point: Highly affordable. A complete PAX wardrobe system can range from $200 for a basic setup to over $1,000 for a large, multi-unit configuration with extensive interior organizers.
- Quality: Primarily particleboard and fiberboard with foil or laminate finishes. The quality is reliable for its price point but is not as robust or long-lasting as the materials used in permanently installed custom closets.
- Fit & Sizing: Comes in standard modular sizes. While the modularity offers good flexibility, it won't provide the perfect wall-to-wall, floor-to-ceiling fit of a true custom system and may leave gaps in rooms with non-standard dimensions.
- Shopping Experience: A full DIY experience. Customers use online planning tools or get help in-store to design their system, transport the flat-packed boxes home themselves (or arrange delivery), and handle assembly.
- Delivery & Assembly: Delivered flat-packed for self-assembly using pictorial instructions. Professional assembly is available for an extra fee through third-party services like TaskRabbit.
IKEA is an unbeatable choice for renters, first-time homeowners, or anyone needing a quick, stylish, and highly affordable storage system they can build themselves.
Shop IKEA: ikea.com
Closets by Design vs. IKEA Comparison
Price Comparison
There is a significant price difference between the two brands. IKEA is squarely in the budget category, with a standard wardrobe costing a few hundred to just over a thousand dollars. The total cost is transparent and depends on the specific modules and organizers you select. It's an accessible price point for nearly any shopper.
Closets by Design is a premium investment. With prices starting around $2,000 and frequently exceeding $10,000, you are paying for custom craftsmanship, higher-grade materials, and a complete design and installation service. The final cost covers expert labor and a product tailored to your home, reflecting a much higher value and permanence.
Style & Aesthetic
With Closets by Design, the style possibilities are nearly limitless. Since each system is custom-designed, you can choose finishes and hardware that perfectly match your home's existing decor, whether it's ornate traditional or sleek contemporary. The result is a seamless built-in that looks like a natural part of the room's architecture.
IKEA’s aesthetic is distinctly Scandinavian Modern. While there are a decent number of door styles, colors, and finishes to choose from within a system like PAX, the overall look is consistent with IKEA's minimalist branding. It's a clean and modern style that works well in many homes but is less adaptable than a fully custom design.
Quality & Construction
Closets by Design uses thick, furniture-grade materials like TFL and wood veneer, which are more resistant to scratching, warping, and sagging over time. The professional installation ensures every joint is secure and every unit is perfectly level and anchored, leading to a highly durable, long-term installation.
IKEA systems are primarily made from particleboard and fiberboard with light exterior foils. While engineered to be sturdy for everyday use, they are more susceptible to damage from moisture and less robust over decades of use than the solid construction of a custom build-out. The quality of the final build also depends heavily on the skill of the person assembling it.
The Shopping Experience
The entire experience with Closets by Design is high-touch and service-oriented. A professional guides you from the very first measurement to the final wipe-down after installation. It's designed to be stress-free and deliver a perfect result without you lifting a finger.
Shopping at IKEA is a self-directed, hands-on process. You are responsible for measuring your own space, designing the configuration (though planners are available in-store), navigating the warehouse, and either assembling the unit yourself or arranging for a third-party service to do it. It offers immense control and savings but requires significant effort from the buyer.
Fit & Installation
This is where Closets by Design truly shines. Because their systems are custom-cut, they can fit any space perfectly - including awkward angles, sloped ceilings, and unconventional nooks. Their professional installers handle everything to create a true built-in look that maximizes every single inch of available space.
IKEA wardrobes come in fixed widths, depths, and heights. This modular approach works beautifully in standard rooms but can be challenging in older homes or oddly shaped spaces. You'll likely have gaps between the unit and the wall or ceiling, which prevents a true "built-in" appearance without additional custom trim work.
Which One Should You Choose?
The choice ultimately comes down to your budget, time, interest in DIY, and desire for a permanent, custom solution.
Choose Closets by Design if:
- You're looking for a permanent, long-term investment in your home.
- You have an awkwardly shaped space with slopes, corners, or non-standard dimensions.
- You want a completely hands-off, professional service from design to installation.
- Your budget is higher, and you prioritize premium materials and a perfect built-in look.
Choose IKEA if:
- You are working with a tight budget.
- You are a renter and need a storage system you can potentially take with you when you move.
- You enjoy DIY projects or are willing to hire someone for assembly.
- You need a functional solution quickly and have a standard-sized room.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Closets by Design or IKEA cheaper?
IKEA is significantly cheaper. A complete IKEA PAX system often costs between $300 and $1,500, whereas a basic Closets by Design project starts around $2,000 and can easily exceed $10,000.
Which has better quality furniture?
Closets by Design offers higher quality in terms of both materials and construction. Their use of thicker, more durable materials and professional installation results in a sturdier, longer-lasting system designed to be a permanent part of your home.
How long does the process take for each?
With IKEA, you can often design, purchase, and build your closet over a single weekend. The process with Closets by Design is much longer, typically taking several weeks from the initial consultation to the final installation day.
Can I customize my IKEA wardrobe?
Yes, IKEA's systems are highly customizable on a modular level. You can choose the frame size, door style, and select from dozens of KOMPLEMENT interior organizers like shelves, drawers, and pull-out trays to tailor the inside to your needs.
Is Closets by Design worth the money?
For homeowners seeking a premium, permanent, custom-fit solution, Closets by Design is often considered worth the investment. It can increase home organization and potentially add to resale value by providing high-quality, built-in storage.
Do I have to assemble IKEA furniture myself?
IKEA furniture is designed for self-assembly, but if you'd rather not build it yourself, you can book an assembly service through a partner like TaskRabbit directly from IKEA's website or in-store.
Which is better for renters?
IKEA is the clear winner for renters. Its freestanding units do not require permanent alterations to the property and can be disassembled and moved to a new home. Custom built-ins from Closets by Design are permanent installations.
Does Closets by Design have a warranty?
Yes, Closets by Design franchises typically offer a lifetime warranty on their products, covering defects in materials and workmanship for as long as you own the home. Be sure to check with your local franchise for their specific warranty terms.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
