The Circulon SteelShield and HexClad cookware lines both promise a durable, modern cooking experience, but they achieve it through different philosophies. HexClad uses a hybrid technology that combines a non-stick coating within a stainless steel hexagon pattern, making it exceptionally durable and great for searing. Circulon SteelShield opts for a more traditional design, featuring reinforced non-stick technology over a stainless steel base, prioritizing an easy-release surface with professional durability at a lower price point.
Here’s the complete comparison to help you choose the right cookware for your kitchen.
Circulon SteelShield Cookware
Circulon SteelShield is a premium cookware line that merges the professional look and durability of stainless steel with the convenience of an advanced non-stick surface. It's designed for home cooks who appreciate high-performance materials, even heat distribution, and easy cleanup without giving up the classic aesthetic of stainless steel pots and pans.
- What it is: A line of stainless steel cookware featuring a proprietary reinforced non-stick coating for enhanced durability and food release.
- Key features: Stainless steel construction for longevity, advanced non-stick interior, oven safe, dishwasher safe, and compatible with all stovetops, including induction.
- Price: Mid-range to premium, with individual frying pans starting around $50 and complete sets ranging from $150 to $400.
- Materials/Construction: A durable stainless steel body and base with a reinforced, layered non-stick coating on the interior cooking surface.
- Style: Sleek, timeless, and professional. The polished stainless steel exterior and black interior fit well in both modern and traditional kitchens.
- Pros: More affordable than HexClad, offers a truly non-stick experience for delicate foods like eggs, classic professional aesthetic, excellent for cooks who prioritize easy cleanup.
- Cons: Non-stick coating, while durable, is not fully metal utensil safe and will eventually wear down over time. Doesn't achieve the same hard sear as a true hybrid or stainless steel pan.
This cookware excels for home cooks seeking reliable, high-quality non-stick performance in a durable stainless steel package at a reasonable price.
Shop this product: circulon.com/collections/steelshield
HexClad Hybrid Cookware
HexClad has made a name for itself with its innovative hybrid cookware that blends the best qualities of stainless steel and non-stick into a single pan. Its signature hexagon pattern integrates non-stick "valleys" with stainless steel "peaks," creating a durable, scratch-resistant surface that can handle high-heat searing and metal utensils - a rare feature for non-stick cookware.
- What it is: Hybrid cookware using a tri-ply construction and a laser-etched hexagon design of stainless steel over a non-stick surface.
- Key features: Tri-ply construction for even heating, truly metal utensil safe, oven safe to 500°F, scratch-resistant, PFOA-free, and compatible with all cooktops.
- Price: Premium, with individual fry pans starting around $70 and cookware sets ranging from $200 up to $500 or more.
- Materials/Construction: Built with three layers - stainless steel on the outside, an aluminum core for conductivity, and another layer of stainless steel on the cooking surface with a non-stick coating etched into the design.
- Style: Modern and uniquely futuristic with its distinctive hexagon pattern and sleek black finish.
- Pros: Gets an excellent sear similar to a stainless steel pan, genuinely safe for metal utensils, highly durable and built to last, versatile for a wide range of cooking techniques.
- Cons: Higher price point, not as "slippery" as traditional non-stick (requires a little oil for best results), and can be heavier than other non-stick pans.
This is the ideal choice for an enthusiast cook who wants the searing power of steel and the convenience of non-stick, and is willing to invest in innovative, long-lasting cookware.
Shop this product: hexclad.com
Circulon SteelShield vs. HexClad Comparison
Materials & Construction
The core difference lies in their construction. The Circulon SteelShield is fundamentally a high-quality stainless steel pan with a very durable non-stick coating applied on top. This makes its surface uniform and slick. Think of it as a top-tier evolution of traditional non-stick.
HexClad, on the other hand, is a true hybrid. Its surface is a matrix of stainless steel and non-stick material. The stainless steel forms raised peaks, protecting the non-stick coating in the valleys below. This design is what allows for metal utensil use and gives it a unique cooking characteristic that is part steel, part non-stick.
Cooking Performance & Durability
For searing steaks, chicken, or vegetables, HexClad has a clear advantage. The raised stainless steel hexagons make direct contact with food, enabling a hard, caramelized sear that traditional non-stick pans like the SteelShield can't typically achieve. However, for delicate foods like eggs or crepes, the Circulon SteelShield provides a more traditional, effortless non-stick release.
In terms of durability, HexClad's design is engineered for longevity and abuse. You can use metal spatulas and whisks without worry. While the SteelShield is scratch-resistant and far more durable than cheap non-stick pans, it is not completely immune to damage from sharp metal tools and will show wear sooner than a HexClad pan under aggressive use.
Price & Value
Circulon SteelShield holds the advantage in affordability. A single pan or a full set will generally cost significantly less than the HexClad equivalent, making it a great value for someone who wants professional-grade performance without a premium price tag.
HexClad is positioned as a long-term investment. Its higher cost is justified by its unique hybrid technology and its promise to withstand metal utensils and years of heavy use. For serious cooks who often replace their non-stick pans, HexClad could offer better long-term value.
Style & Aesthetics
This comes down to personal taste. Circulon SteelShield has a timeless, professional kitchen aesthetic with its gleaming, polished stainless steel construction. It's a classic look that never goes out of style. HexClad has a bold, modern, and high-tech appearance. Its signature interlocking hexagon pattern is instantly recognizable and signals cutting-edge kitchen gear.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both cookware lines offer excellent performance, but they cater to different types of cooks and priorities.
Choose Circulon SteelShield if:
- You're a home cook who prioritizes a fuss-free, superior non-stick surface.
- Your budget is a primary consideration, and you want great performance for the cost.
- You primarily cook things that benefit from an easy-release surface, like eggs, pancakes, and fish.
- You prefer the classic, gleaming look of professional stainless steel cookware.
Choose HexClad if:
- You want the best of both worlds: the searing power of steel and the easy cleanup of non-stick.
- Durability is your top concern and you want to freely use metal utensils without worry.
- You are investing in a "buy it for life" pan and are willing to pay a premium for it.
- A modern, high-tech aesthetic appeals to you.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Circulon SteelShield and HexClad?
The primary difference is the technology. Circulon SteelShield uses a highly durable, reinforced non-stick coating applied to a stainless steel pan. HexClad uses a hybrid surface where a stainless steel pattern is raised above a non-stick coating, allowing it to function as both steel and non-stick cookware.
Is HexClad really metal utensil safe?
Yes. The raised stainless steel hexagons on the cooking surface act as a guard, protecting the recessed non-stick coating from scratches that would be caused by metal utensils.
Is Circulon SteelShield scratch-proof?
It is highly scratch-resistant compared to standard non-stick pans, but it is not scratch-proof. To preserve its life, it's still best to avoid sharp metal utensils, knives, and abrasive scouring pads.
Which pan is better for searing steak?
HexClad is unequivocally better for searing steak. Its stainless steel pattern allows for direct high-heat contact, creating a superior crust and caramelization that traditional non-stick surfaces cannot replicate.
Which is a better non-stick pan for eggs?
For slippery, out-of-the-pan eggs with little to no oil, the Circulon SteelShield offers a more consistently non-stick experience. While HexClad can cook eggs well with a little fat, its hybrid surface isn't as effortlessly slick as a pure non-stick coating.
Are both pans oven-safe?
Yes, both lines of cookware are oven-safe, making them versatile for recipes that start on the stovetop and finish in the oven. HexClad is typically rated safe up to 500°F, while you should check specific Circulon SteelShield product details for its exact temperature tolerance.
Do I need to use oil with HexClad?
For the best performance, yes. A small amount of cooking oil or fat allows food to release easily from the stainless steel components of the pan's surface, similar to how you would cook on a standard stainless steel or cast-iron skillet.
Which brand offers better value for money?
This depends on your definition of value. Circulon SteelShield offers better upfront value, delivering excellent cooking performance for a lower initial cost. HexClad offers better long-term value for cooks who want extreme durability and versatility, potentially saving money by outlasting several generations of regular non-stick pans.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
