Castlery offers a wide array of stylish, modern furniture for the entire home at an accessible mid-range price, while Thuma focuses specifically on premium, sustainably sourced bedroom furniture with a minimalist, Japandi-inspired aesthetic. The key difference is scope and price: Castlery provides an affordable, one-stop shop for trendy home furnishings, whereas Thuma is an investment in minimalist design and eco-conscious craftsmanship for the bedroom.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right furniture brand for your space.
Castlery: The Modern & Affordable Choice
Castlery is a direct-to-consumer brand that has quickly become a go-to for shoppers seeking on-trend, contemporary furniture that doesn't demand a luxury budget. Their collections are perfect for urban dwellers and young families, offering a blend of mid-century modern, Scandinavian, and minimalist styles. Castlery's main appeal lies in its ability to deliver design-forward pieces that are both functional and affordable.
- Product mix: A complete home furnishing solution, including sofas, sectionals, bed frames, dining sets, storage units, chairs, and home accessories.
- Style/vibe: Clean lines and modern silhouettes define their aesthetic, which fuses mid-century, contemporary, and Scandinavian influences into versatile pieces.
- Price point: Mid-range and budget-friendly. Sofas typically cost $799–$2,500, bed frames start around $599, and dining tables begin at $499.
- Quality: Uses solid woods like acacia and walnut, kiln-dried hardwood frames for upholstery, and durable fabrics. The quality is solid for the price, providing good value and longevity.
- Dimensions/Scale: Offers a wide variety of dimensions, including compact sofas for apartments and larger sectionals for family rooms, as well as extendable dining tables.
- Sustainability: Actively uses FSC-certified timber and works towards reducing its environmental footprint with eco-friendly packaging and responsible sourcing.
- Delivery & Assembly: Most items are designed for easy self-assembly. Delivery is free in many metro areas, with assembly services available for an additional fee.
- Sales: Frequently runs sales and bundle deals, especially around major holidays, making their furniture even more accessible.
Castlery is the ideal choice for shoppers who want to furnish their space with stylish and contemporary pieces without overspending.
Shop Castlery: castlery.com
Thuma: The Sustainable Bedroom Brand
Thuma is a brand built on the philosophy of creating thoughtful, minimalist, and eco-conscious bedroom furniture. Their standout product, "The Bed," became a viral sensation for its Japanese joinery-inspired easy assembly and timeless design. Thuma appeals to consumers who prioritize sustainability, high-quality materials, and a "buy it for life" mentality when it comes to furniture.
- Product mix: Highly curated and focused on the bedroom. The core offering is their signature bed frame, complemented by nightstands, dressers, mattresses, and trays.
- Style/vibe: Minimalist, timeless, and heavily influenced by Japandi (a hybrid of Japanese and Scandinavian) design. The look is simple, functional, and elegant.
- Price point: Premium. "The Bed" starts at around $995 for a Twin and goes up from there, reflecting the sustainable materials and high-end construction.
- Quality: Exceptional craftsmanship is a core value. Pieces feature solid, upcycled rubberwood, rounded edges, and Japanese joinery techniques that allow for assembly without tools or metal hardware.
- Warranty: Confidence in their quality is backed by a lifetime warranty on their bed frames and other core furniture.
- Sustainability: A main pillar of the brand. Thuma uses Greenguard Gold certified, upcycled, and eco-friendly materials, and plants one tree for every product sold.
- Delivery & Assembly: Renowned for its incredibly simple, tool-free assembly that can be done by one person in minutes. Shipping is free.
- Return policy: Offers a generous 100-day trial, allowing you to try their products in your home risk-free.
Thuma is designed for those seeking an intentional, sustainable, and beautifully crafted centerpiece for their bedroom that will last a lifetime.
Shop Thuma: thuma.co
Castlery vs. Thuma Comparison
Price Comparison
There is a clear distinction in pricing between the two brands. Castlery firmly occupies the mid-range market, making stylish full-home furnishings accessible. A queen-sized bed frame might run you $600-$900, while a three-seater sofa often falls between $1,000 and $2,000. Frequent sales and promotions can bring these prices even lower, making it a strong value proposition.
Thuma targets the premium end of the market. Its queen-sized bed frame starts well over $1,000, and its accompanying accessories are priced similarly. The higher cost reflects their commitment to sustainable, high-quality materials, tool-free assembly design, and a lifetime warranty. Thuma rarely offers discounts, positioning its products as a long-term investment rather than a quick buy.
Style & Aesthetic
Castlery's aesthetic is broad and trendy, mixing and matching elements of mid-century modern, Scandinavian, and contemporary design. Their large catalog means you can find pieces that are bold and statement-making or subtle and understated. This versatility makes it easy to furnish an entire home in a cohesive yet dynamic style that reflects current trends.
Thuma's aesthetic is much more focused and refined. It's the definition of minimalist, platform-style Japandi design, emphasizing natural wood tones, simplicity, and functionality. Thuma isn’t trying to follow every trend, instead, it offers quiet, timeless pieces designed to create a serene and uncluttered bedroom environment. Its look is unmistakable and integrates seamlessly into calm, modern interiors.
Quality & Materials
Castlery offers quality that matches its price point. You’ll find solid wood construction, kiln-dried hardwood frames on sofas, and durable upholstery. While they may use engineered wood in some non-structural areas to keep costs down, the overall feel is sturdy and made for everyday life, often backed by a warranty of up to 5 years.
Thuma prioritizes premium, eco-friendly materials above all else. Its bed frames are made from solid, upcycled rubberwood, and their simple construction using thoughtful joinery instead of a tangle of screws makes them feel exceptionally solid and durable. The attention to detail, from the rounded corners to the cushion-coated slats, is immediately noticeable and justifies the higher price tag for those who value ethical craftsmanship.
Product Selection
This is one of the biggest differentiators. Castlery is a whole-home solution. You can outfit your living room, dining room, bedroom, and office with their coordinated collections. Their expansive catalog means you have thousands of options across categories, styles, and colors.
Thuma's selection is deliberately narrow, centering almost exclusively on creating "The Perfect Bedroom." You can buy "The Bed," "The Nightstand," and "The Dresser." This hyper-focused approach means they do one thing and do it exceptionally well, but for shoppers looking to furnish beyond the bedroom, Thuma isn't a viable option.
Sustainability & Ethics
Both brands prioritize responsible practices, but to different degrees. For Castlery, sustainability is an important feature, they use FSC-certified wood and are working to reduce their carbon footprint. It is a valued aspect of their production process.
For Thuma, sustainability is the core of their brand identity. From using upcycled and repurposed wood to their Greenguard Gold certification (ensuring low chemical emissions) and their partnership with One Tree Planted, every decision seems to be made through an eco-conscious lens. Consumers who vote with their dollar for ethical practices will find Thuma's a compelling choice.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends entirely on your needs, budget, and priorities. Both brands create excellent products, but they cater to very different shoppers.
Choose Castlery if:
- You're furnishing multiple rooms and want a cohesive source for your furniture.
- You're more budget-conscious but still want a stylish, modern aesthetic.
- You appreciate a wide selection of styles, from mid-century modern to contemporary.
- You need versatile pieces in various sizes to fit a small apartment or a larger home.
Choose Thuma if:
- You are focused on creating a serene, high-end bedroom and want to invest in a "forever bed."
- Sustainability and eco-friendly materials are at the top of your priority list.
- You love minimalist, Japandi-inspired design.
- You hate complicated assemblies and value the ease of tool-free construction and a lifetime warranty.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Castlery or Thuma cheaper?
Castlery is significantly cheaper than Thuma. Castlery operates in the mid-range price category, offering stylish furniture at accessible price points, while Thuma is a premium brand with higher prices that reflect its sustainable materials and lifetime warranty.
Which has better quality furniture?
Both offer good quality, but "better" depends on your priorities. Thuma uses premium, eco-conscious materials and construction techniques designed to last a lifetime, putting it in a higher tier of quality. Castlery offers very solid quality for its price point, with durable frames and solid wood construction that provides excellent value.
Is the Thuma bed worth buying?
For many shoppers, yes. If you value sustainable craftsmanship, an easy tool-free assembly process, minimalist design, and want a "buy it once, buy it right" piece of furniture with a lifetime warranty, the Thuma bed is worth the investment.
What style is Thuma furniture?
Thuma embodies a minimalist and Japandi (a blend of Japanese and Scandinavian) aesthetic. Its designs are simple, functional, and focus on the natural beauty of the wood, creating a calm and uncluttered vibe.
Does Castlery furniture require assembly?
Yes, most furniture from Castlery requires some assembly. However, it is designed to be straightforward. For those who prefer not to build it themselves, assembly services are often available for an extra fee.
Which is better for small apartments?
Castlery is generally better for small apartments because it offers a much wider variety of products in different sizes. You can find apartment-sized sofas, compact dining tables, and other small-space solutions, whereas Thuma's product line is limited primarily to standard-sized bedroom furniture.
Does Thuma offer more than just beds?
Yes, but their selection is limited. In addition to their famous bed frame, Thuma also offers matching nightstands and dressers, all within their signature minimalist aesthetic. They are laser-focused on creating a complete, curated bedroom collection.
Which brand is more sustainable?
While Castlery engages in responsible sourcing, Thuma has built its entire brand identity around sustainability and ethical manufacturing. From using upcycled wood to its various green certifications and reforestation partnerships, Thuma is the more overtly eco-conscious choice.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
