Castlery provides modern, stylish furniture at an affordable, mid-range price point, focusing on versatile designs with a minimalist and Scandinavian feel. In contrast, Joybird specializes in bold, retro-inspired statement pieces with extensive customization options, positioning itself in the mid-to-high end of the market.
Let's compare these two brands to help you decide which is the right choice for your home and style.
Castlery: The Modern & Affordable Choice
Castlery is a modern furniture brand that blends contemporary, mid-century modern, and minimalist styles into functional and affordable collections. Their target audience includes urban dwellers and young professionals who need quality, stylish pieces that fit well in apartments or modern homes without a luxury price tag. The brand emphasizes durable construction and sustainable materials, offering a balanced approach to design and practicality.
- Product mix: A full range of home furnishings, including sofas, sectionals, beds, dining sets, coffee tables, and storage solutions.
- Style/vibe: Clean, modern, and versatile designs with influences from mid-century modern and Scandinavian aesthetics. The overall look is understated, with clean lines and neutral color palettes.
- Price point: Mid-range and accessible. Sofas and sectionals typically start around $799, while dining tables begin at $399.
- Quality: Construction features solid wood frames, engineered wood, and durable upholstery fabrics like polyester blends and performance textiles.
- Sizing: Offers a wide range of furniture well-suited for both compact apartments and larger living spaces, with many smart modular and space-saving designs.
- Shopping Experience: Primarily an online retailer with an intuitive website and physical showrooms in select cities for in-person viewing.
- Sustainability: Committed to responsible sourcing with materials like FSC-certified wood and transparent manufacturing processes.
- Delivery & Assembly: Offers reliable delivery and assembly services with transparent scheduling and updates.
Castlery excels at providing well-designed, contemporary furniture that offers great value for its price, making it ideal for budget-conscious consumers who don't want to compromise on modern style.
Shop Castlery: castlery.com
Joybird: The Retro & Customizable Brand
Joybird has built its reputation on high-quality, custom-made furniture celebrated for its bold, retro-inspired designs and vibrant personality. The brand appeals to homeowners who want their furniture to make a statement and reflect their unique style. With a strong commitment to craftsmanship and sustainability, Joybird focuses on creating personalized foundation pieces like sofas, sectionals, and chairs that are built to last.
- Product mix: Specializes in upholstered furniture like sofas, chairs, and sectionals, but also offers beds, dining furniture, and case goods.
- Style/vibe: Distinctly eclectic and retro, drawing heavily from mid-century modern design with a flair for unique silhouettes and a vast array of vibrant colors.
- Price point: Mid- to high-range. Sofas generally start at around $1,200, with prices increasing based on fabric and configuration choices.
- Quality: Renowned for using premium materials, including kiln-dried hardwood frames, high-resilience foam, and a wide selection of durable, high-performance fabrics.
- Customization: The defining feature of Joybird. Extensive customization options, allowing customers to choose every detail from fabric type and color to leg finish from a massive library of over 50 options, many more than Castlery.
- Shopping Experience: A leading online custom furniture retailer that offers free design consultations and a generous return policy. They empower shoppers to create totally unique pieces from the comfort of their homes.
- Sustainability: Strong eco-credentials, with a focus on FSC-certified wood, responsible raw materials sourcing, and eco-friendly packaging.
- Delivery & Assembly: Made-to-order pieces require longer lead times, but white-glove delivery is often available.
Joybird is the go-to brand for design-savvy individuals looking for unique, highly personalized furniture with a vintage charm and are willing to invest in premium craftsmanship.
Shop Joybird: joybird.com
Castlery vs. Joybird Comparison
Price Comparison
Castlery is the more budget-friendly option. With sofas starting at around $799 and frequent sales, the brand makes stylish, modern furniture accessible to a wider audience, including first-time homebuyers and renters. Joybird occupies a higher price tier, with its customizable sofas starting around $1,200 and quickly increasing in price with premium fabric selections and larger configurations.
While Joybird’s prices reflect its premium materials and bespoke, made-to-order process, Castlery delivers excellent value for good-quality, on-trend pieces. If your primary concern is staying within a specific budget, Castlery offers more competitive pricing without significant sacrifices in style or quality.
Style & Aesthetic
The clearest difference between the two brands lies in their design aesthetic. Castlery offers a versatile, understated modern look. Its collections feature clean lines, neutral colors, and simple silhouettes that fit seamlessly into contemporary, Scandinavian, or minimalist interiors. The brand’s furniture is designed to complement existing decor rather than dominate a space.
Joybird, in contrast, is all about personality and making a statement. Its aesthetic is rooted in retro and vintage designs with unique shapes, vibrant colors, and eclectic patterns. A Joybird piece is meant to be a focal point, perfect for homeowners who want their furniture to have character and stand out.
Quality & Construction
Both brands prioritize quality construction, but their approaches lead to different outcomes. Castlery uses reliable materials like solid wood frames, engineered wood components, and durable polyester-blend fabrics suitable for everyday use. Their furniture is built to be sturdy and functional, offering solid construction for its price point.
Joybird positions itself as a more premium brand by using superior materials like kiln-dried hardwood for all its frames, which provides a higher level of durability and longevity. Paired with high-resistance fabrics and meticulous craftsmanship, a Joybird item is truly built to withstand years of heavy use. While you pay more for it, the quality is often a noticeable step up.
Customization Options
Here, Joybird has a decisive advantage. Customization is at the core of its business model. Nearly every upholstered piece can be personalized with dozens - sometimes hundreds - of fabric options ranging from performance velvets to top-grain leather in almost any color imaginable. This allows shoppers to create a truly one-of-a-kind piece tailored to their exact preferences.
Castlery offers some customization, such as a choice between a few standard fabrics or colors for certain collections, but the options are far more limited. Their focus is on offering well-curated, ready-to-ship designs rather than a fully bespoke experience.
Sustainability & Ethics
Both Castlery and Joybird demonstrate a strong commitment to environmental responsibility. Each brand sources wood from FSC-certified forests, ensuring it comes from sustainably managed sources. They also focus on eco-friendly manufacturing processes and reducing waste.
Joybird often goes a step further with detailed transparency reports about their material sourcing and eco-friendly dyes, which may appeal more to environmentally conscious consumers who value deep-dives into supply chains.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands offer quality home furnishings, but they cater to very different customers and priorities.
Choose Castlery if:
- You're on a moderate budget and looking for great value.
- You prefer a modern, minimalist, or Scandinavian aesthetic with clean lines.
- You need versatile, space-efficient furniture that works well in apartments or smaller rooms.
- You want stylish furniture quickly without waiting for custom manufacturing times.
Choose Joybird if:
- You want to fully customize your furniture, choosing from a massive range of fabrics and colors.
- You love bold, retro-inspired styles that make a statement.
- You are willing to invest more for premium materials like kiln-dried hardwood frames.
- Creating a unique, personalized piece is more important than a quick delivery.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Castlery or Joybird cheaper?
Overall, Castlery is significantly cheaper than Joybird. With sofas starting at $799 compared to Joybird's $1,200 entry point, Castlery is the more affordable, budget-conscious option.
Which has better quality furniture?
Both offer good quality, but Joybird generally uses more premium materials, such as kiln-dried hardwood frames and high-performance fabrics. This enhanced construction offers superior durability, justifying its higher price point. Castlery offers very respectable quality for its price range.
Which brand is better for mid-century modern style?
Both brands draw heavily from mid-century modern design principles. Castlery's take is more subdued and minimalist, focusing on clean lines and function. Joybird is more playful and retro, using vibrant colors and bold silhouettes that call back to the classic MCM era.
Does Castlery or Joybird offer more customization?
Joybird is the clear winner for customization. Its entire business model revolves around offering extensive personalization options, from hundreds of fabric choices to different leg finishes.
Which brand is better for small apartments?
Castlery is generally better for small apartments. Their product line includes many compact, scalable, and modular designs created with urban living and smaller footprints in mind.
Are Castlery and Joybird sustainable companies?
Yes, both brands are committed to sustainability. They use materials like FSC-certified wood and focus on responsible manufacturing. Joybird provides slightly more detailed transparency about its eco-friendly practices.
What is the main aesthetic difference between Castlery and Joybird?
The main difference is understated modern versus bold retro. Castlery's aesthetic is clean, versatile, and contemporary. Joybird's is eclectic, colorful, and makes a strong vintage-inspired design statement.
Do Castlery and Joybird have physical stores?
Castlery has physical showrooms in several major cities that allow you to see and feel the furniture before buying. Joybird operates primarily online but does have a few select showroom locations in the US.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
