Castlery offers a curated selection of design-forward furniture in mid-century modern and contemporary styles, positioning itself as an affordable step-up in quality. IKEA is the global giant for budget-friendly, functional, flat-pack furniture defined by its accessible Scandinavian aesthetic and massive product range. The primary differences come down to price, assembly, materials, and overall shopping experience, with Castlery feeling more like a boutique brand and IKEA serving as a practical, one-stop superstore.
Let's look at everything you need to know to choose the right home retailer for your space.
Castlery: The Modern, Design-Forward Choice
Castlery is a direct-to-consumer furniture company known for its modern and mid-century-inspired designs that bridge the gap between expensive luxury brands and budget flat-pack options. It appeals to city dwellers and style-conscious shoppers who want unique, well-made pieces without a high-end price tag. By managing their design and production, they offer a polished aesthetic and better-than-average quality at a mid-range price.
- Product mix: A focused selection of living room, dining room, and bedroom furniture, including sofas, sectionals, beds, dining tables, chairs, and storage. They also offer a curated collection of lighting, rugs, and accessories.
- Style/vibe: Mid-century modern, contemporary, and minimalist. Expect clean lines, tapered legs, warm wood finishes (like walnut and acacia), and neutral fabrics that fit well in modern homes.
- Price point: Mid-range. Sofas typically cost between $799–$2,500, dining tables are $399–$899, and bed frames start around $499.
- Quality: A noticeable step up from budget retailers. Many pieces use solid wood frames (kiln-dried for durability), high-density foam cushions, and quality fabrics.
- Delivery & Assembly: Offers flat-rate shipping which includes contactless delivery. In-home setup and assembly services are available for an additional fee, saving you the hassle of building it yourself.
- Customization: Some sectional sofas offer orientation choices (left or right facing), and select products come in multiple fabric or leather options.
- Return policy: A 14-day return window for most items, though a return shipping fee applies. Items must be in their original packaging.
Castlery is excellent for customers who have outgrown budget furniture and are ready to invest in stylish, more durable pieces that look more expensive than they are.
Shop Castlery: castlery.com
IKEA: The Budget-Friendly Functional Giant
IKEA is a world-renowned Swedish brand famous for its affordable, stylish, and functional home solutions. From its iconic blue-and-yellow stores to its DIY flat-pack assembly, IKEA has made modern Scandinavian design accessible to the masses. Their business model focuses on high volume and efficiency, allowing them to offer an extensive range of products for every single room in the home at exceptionally low prices.
- Product mix: An enormous selection covering every home category imaginable. This includes furniture, kitchen cabinets, appliances, lighting, textiles, storage solutions, and even food items in their market hall.
- Style/vibe: Primarily Scandinavian and modern minimalism. The focus is on functionality, simplicity, light wood tones, and modular designs that can be adapted to various spaces.
- Price point: Highly affordable. You can find sofas like the EKTORP starting around $399, the KALLAX shelving unit from $69, and bed frames from as little as $150.
- Quality: Varies by product line. While most items use materials like particleboard and wood veneer to keep costs down, some higher-end series use more durable materials like solid wood. It is designed for functionality and price, not necessarily for lasting generations.
- Delivery & Assembly: Famously requires self-assembly. Customers transport items home themselves or arrange delivery for a fee. Assembly services can also be booked through third-party partners at an additional cost.
- Stores: Known for its huge, immersive warehouse-style stores where customers can browse fully decorated room settings for inspiration.
- Return policy: A generous 365-day return policy for unopened products and 180 days for opened products, making it very low-risk to try an item.
IKEA excels at offering practical, cost-effective solutions for students, first-time homeowners, renters, and anyone needing to furnish a space quickly and on a tight budget.
Shop IKEA: ikea.com
Castlery vs. IKEA Comparison
Price Comparison
This is the most significant difference between the two brands. IKEA is unequivocally the more affordable option. By using mass production, flat-pack logistics, and cost-effective materials, IKEA can price its goods far lower than most competitors. For example, a basic IKEA sofa can cost under $500, whereas a similar-sized sofa from Castlery will likely start closer to $800 or $1,000.
While Castlery is more expensive, it offers value in terms of design originality and material quality. It targets a customer who is willing to pay more for furniture that feels more substantial and unique. Castlery's pricing sits comfortably in the mid-range market - more than IKEA, but often less than stores like West Elm or Crate & Barrel.
Quality & Construction
Castlery generally offers superior quality and construction. Their furniture often uses more solid wood, kiln-dried hardwood frames, and higher-density foam than you'll typically find at IKEA. Finishes tend to be more refined, and the overall construction feels sturdier, which means pieces are more likely to last through multiple moves and years of heavy use.
IKEA, on the other hand, prioritizes affordability, which often means using materials like particleboard, MDF, and lightweight veneers. While perfectly functional for everyday use and surprisingly durable for the price, IKEA furniture isn't typically considered "forever furniture." It serves its purpose well but may not hold up as well over the long term, especially if disassembled and reassembled.
Style & Aesthetic
Both brands draw heavily from modern and Scandinavian influences, but their executions differ. Castlery leans more into the mid-century modern aesthetic, with details like rounded edges, tapered wooden legs, and tailored upholstery. Their collection feels curated and cohesive, aiming for a sophisticated yet approachable look that feels current and intentional.
IKEA’s style is more utilitarian and broadly Scandinavian. Their designs are clean, simple, and hyper-functional, intended to blend into any home with ease. While stylish, IKEA pieces have become so common that they are instantly recognizable, which can be a drawback for those seeking a more unique look.
Delivery & Assembly
The assembly process is a key distinction. IKEA is built on a DIY model - you pick it, you haul it, you build it. While this keeps costs low, the time and effort required for assembly can be a major disadvantage for many. You can pay for delivery and assembly services, but these extra costs can significantly increase your total price.
Castlery offers a more traditional furniture shopping experience. While items require some assembly, it is generally less complex than IKEA's. More importantly, they offer in-home setup services, and many customers opt for this to avoid the hassle. This makes the overall process much simpler and more convenient, especially for large items like sectionals and dining tables.
Shopping Experience
Shopping at IKEA is a well-known physical retail experience: you navigate a massive, maze-like showroom, write down product numbers, and then pick the flat-packed boxes from a giant warehouse. It can be fun and inspiring but also crowded and overwhelming. Their online store is functional but doesn't quite replicate the in-person journey.
Castlery is primarily an online, direct-to-consumer brand. Their website is sleek and user-friendly, providing detailed product information, imagery, and reviews to help you buy with confidence from home. For those who want to see products in person, Castlery operates a limited number of physical showrooms in major cities, offering a boutique feel compared to the sprawling IKEA campus.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands are strong contenders in their respective markets, but they serve different needs and priorities.
Choose Castlery if:
- You're investing in key pieces and want something that will last longer.
- Your style is mid-century modern or contemporary, and you want a curated, design-forward look.
- You have a mid-range budget and are looking for good value in terms of design and quality.
- You'd rather avoid the headache of complex DIY assembly.
Choose IKEA if:
- Your primary concern is budget and getting the most for your money.
- You need a wide variety of items to furnish an entire apartment or home quickly.
- You don't mind assembling furniture yourself (or are willing to pay for the service).
- You're furnishing a temporary space, a child's room, or need highly functional and modular storage.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Castlery or IKEA cheaper?
IKEA is significantly cheaper than Castlery across almost every product category. IKEA's business model is optimized for extreme affordability through high volume and flat-pack design, whereas Castlery focuses on providing higher quality and more unique designs at a mid-range price point.
Which has better quality furniture?
Castlery has better quality furniture. They use more durable materials like solid wood frames and higher-quality fabrics, resulting in pieces that are sturdier and built to last longer than the particleboard and veneer common in most IKEA products.
Do I have to assemble Castlery furniture?
Most Castlery furniture requires some assembly, but it is typically simpler than IKEA's. Crucially, Castlery offers an in-home delivery and assembly service for a fee, which is a convenient option many customers choose for larger items.
Which brand is better for small apartments?
Both brands are excellent for small apartments. Castlery designs many of its pieces with urban living in mind, offering well-proportioned sofas and tables. However, IKEA's modular systems like KALLAX and BESTÅ offer unparalleled flexibility and storage optimization for tiny spaces.
Can you see the furniture in person before buying?
Yes, but your options differ greatly. IKEA has hundreds of huge retail stores all over the world. Castlery is primarily an online store but operates a small number of showrooms in major metropolitan areas for customers who want to see the quality firsthand.
Which store has a better return policy?
IKEA has one of the most generous return policies in the industry, allowing returns on most products for up to 365 days (if unopened). Castlery offers a much shorter 14-day return window and charges a return-shipping fee.
What style is Castlery furniture?
Castlery's style is primarily mid-century modern, contemporary, and minimalist. Their pieces feature clean lines, organic shapes, tapered legs, and materials like walnut wood and boucle fabric that are hallmarks of these design movements.
Is IKEA furniture difficult to assemble?
It can be. While IKEA is famous for its instruction manuals that use pictures instead of words, complex pieces like wardrobes or media units can be time-consuming and frustrating for an inexperienced person to build. Simpler items like tables or small shelves are typically very straightforward.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
