Castlery offers modern, mid-century inspired furniture aimed at urban dwellers with a focus on affordability and a direct-to-consumer online model. In contrast, Crate & Barrel is a well-established retailer known for its timeless, classic designs, higher price points, and extensive physical showrooms that complement its online presence.
Let's compare everything you need to know to choose the right home furnishing brand for your space.
Castlery: The Modern & Affordable Choice
Castlery is a direct-to-consumer furniture brand that has gained popularity for its stylish, on-trend designs that don’t come with a high-end price tag. Originating in Singapore, it targets style-conscious young professionals and families who want a modern or mid-century aesthetic, particularly for apartments and contemporary homes where space and budget are key considerations.
- Product mix: A curated selection of furniture for the living room, dining room, bedroom, and outdoor spaces. They specialize in sofas, sectionals, dining sets, and bed frames.
- Style/vibe: Predominantly mid-century modern and Scandinavian. You'll find clean lines, tapered legs, functional forms, and a palette of neutral tones with occasional pops of color.
- Price point: Mid-range and very competitive. Sofas typically range from $799 to $2,500, dining tables start around $499, and bed frames are often in the $600–$1,500 range.
- Quality: Good for the price point, featuring materials like kiln-dried hardwood frames, high-density foam cushions, and options for performance fabrics.
- Dimensions/Scale: Many pieces are designed with compact, urban spaces in mind, offering apartment-friendly sofas and scalable dining solutions.
- Sales: Holds frequent sales events and promotions, often offering 15-25% off during holiday weekends and seasonal clearances.
- Return policy: Offers a 14-day return policy, though return shipping fees may apply.
- Delivery & Assembly: Provides free delivery on orders over a certain threshold, with self-assembly often required for case goods.
Castlery provides an excellent balance of modern style and value, making it a go-to for shoppers who want a designer look without the designer cost.
Shop Castlery: castlery.com
Crate & Barrel: The Timeless & Classic Retailer
As a long-standing American retailer founded in 1962, Crate & Barrel has built a reputation for high-quality, enduring furniture and home goods. The brand caters to established homeowners looking for investment pieces that blend modern sensibilities with classic, lasting style. It offers a comprehensive shopping experience with beautiful showrooms, robust online tools, and free design services.
- Product mix: An extensive selection of home furnishings, including indoor and outdoor furniture, but also a vast array of kitchenware, tableware, bedding, bath essentials, and decor.
- Style/vibe: Modern-classic and transitional. The designs are sophisticated and versatile, easily pairing with various interior styles from traditional to contemporary.
- Price point: Mid-to-upscale. Sofas generally start around $1,200 and can exceed $5,000, dining tables begin at $800, and larger bedroom pieces can cost over $2,000.
- Quality: Known for superior craftsmanship, using materials like solid wood, high-performance fabrics, and sturdy metal frames. Pieces feel substantial and are built for longevity.
- Dimensions/Scale: Offers a wide variety of sizes, with many pieces scaled for larger homes and rooms, including deep sectionals and long dining tables.
- Services: Provides free in-store and virtual design services, helping customers plan their spaces, select fabrics, and coordinate entire rooms.
- Return policy: Generally offers a 30-day return policy for non-furniture items. Furniture returns are accepted within a specific window but may incur restocking fees.
- Delivery & Assembly: Offers multiple delivery options, including white-glove service that includes delivery, assembly, and placement in the home.
Crate & Barrel is a trusted source for well-made, classic furniture and decor that serves as a long-term foundation for a home.
Shop Crate & Barrel: crateandbarrel.com
Castlery vs. Crate & Barrel Comparison
Price Comparison
The most significant difference between the two brands is price. Castlery is distinctly more accessible, with sofas starting around $799 and dining sets as low as $499. This positioning makes it an excellent choice for first-time homebuyers, renters, and anyone furnishing a space on a tighter budget.
Crate & Barrel operates in a mid-to-upscale price bracket. A similar-sized sofa will likely start closer to $1,200, and dining tables start from $800. While both brands hold sales, Crate & Barrel's baseline prices are consistently higher, reflecting its investment in premium materials, extensive retail footprint, and comprehensive customer service.
Style & Aesthetic
Castlery's aesthetic is firmly planted in the modern, mid-century, and Scandinavian design worlds. Its pieces feature clean lines, organic shapes, and a minimalist feel perfect for contemporary or urban homes. While stylish, the collections are more trend-focused.
Crate & Barrel offers a more timeless and versatile style. Its designs blend modern forms with classic elements, resulting in a sophisticated look that won't feel dated in a few years. Their pieces are designed to be foundational, fitting into a broad variety of interior designs, from traditional to modern farmhouse.
Quality & Construction
Both brands prioritize quality materials, but their approach differs. Castlery uses durable components like kiln-dried hardwood frames and high-density foam, ensuring its furniture is built to last beyond its affordable price point. It offers great durability and construction for what you pay.
Crate & Barrel takes quality and construction a step further. Their furniture often features solid wood (as opposed to veneers or engineered wood), superior joinery, and premium upholstery fabrics. The pieces tend to be heavier and more substantial, reflecting a build quality designed for decades of use. You're paying for a higher level of craftsmanship and material sourcing.
Product Selection & Sizing
Crate & Barrel offers a much broader home goods catalog. Beyond furniture, it's a premier destination for kitchenware, registry items, bakeware, and textiles. Castlery is more specialized, focusing almost exclusively on core furniture categories for main living areas.
In terms of sizing, Castlery pieces are often well-suited for smaller living spaces like apartments and condos. They offer many space-efficient sofas, modular sectionals, and more compact dining solutions. Crate & Barrel carries furniture in a wider range of sizes, including large-scale sectionals and extendable dining tables designed for more expansive homes.
Shopping Experience
Shopping with Castlery is a digital-first experience. Their website is easy to navigate, with helpful tools like 3D visualizations. While they have a few showrooms in major cities, the brand largely relies on its online platform. This model helps keep their prices down.
Crate & Barrel excels at the omnichannel experience. Customers can browse online and then visit one of their many showrooms to see, touch, and test out furniture in person. They also offer valuable in-store and virtual design services, which is a significant advantage for those needing guidance on a room layout or fabric selection.
Sustainability & Ethics
Both companies are committed to improving their environmental impact. Castlery is transparent about its manufacturing and focuses on responsible sourcing and eco-friendly packaging. Crate & Barrel has a more established and comprehensive sustainability program, with a strong emphasis on using FSC-certified wood and ensuring fair labor practices throughout its supply chain.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice comes down to your personal style, budget, and long-term goals for your space.
Choose Castlery if:
- Your design taste leans heavily toward mid-century modern or Scandinavian styles.
- You are furnishing your first home or apartment and need stylish pieces at a great value.
- You live in a smaller space and need furniture that is scaled appropriately.
- You are comfortable buying furniture online without seeing it in person first.
Choose Crate & Barrel if:
- You prefer timeless, classic designs that will not go out of style.
- You're looking for an investment piece and are willing to pay more for superior quality and durability.
- You value the ability to see and test furniture in a showroom before you buy.
- You need a wide range of products, including kitchenware and decor, or want to use free design services.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Castlery or Crate & Barrel cheaper?
Castlery is significantly cheaper. On average, a comparable piece of furniture from Castlery will cost 30-50% less than at Crate & Barrel, making it the more budget-friendly option.
Which has better quality furniture?
Crate & Barrel generally has higher-quality furniture due to its use of premium materials like solid wood frames and higher-grade fabrics. However, Castlery offers excellent quality and durability for its more accessible price point.
What is the main style difference between Castlery and Crate & Barrel?
Castlery focuses on trend-driven mid-century modern and Scandinavian aesthetics. Crate & Barrel's style is more timeless and versatile, blending modern forms with classic, enduring design elements.
Does Castlery have physical stores?
Castlery is primarily an online, direct-to-consumer brand, though it does operate a small number of physical showrooms in select major cities for customers who want to see products in person.
Which brand is better for small apartments?
Castlery is generally better for small apartments. Many of its collections are designed with compact dimensions, and they offer a variety of "apartment-sized" sofas and flexible modular pieces.
Which is better for families?
This depends on the family's needs. Crate & Barrel's construction often feels more robust for heavy use over many years. However, Castlery offers a wide range of affordable performance fabrics that are stain-resistant and easy to clean, which is a major plus for households with kids and pets.
Can you return furniture to both stores?
Yes, both brands accept furniture returns, but policies differ. Castlery offers a 14-day window but may charge for return shipping. Crate & Barrel's policy is generally more flexible on non-furniture items but may have restocking fees for returned furniture.
Does Crate & Barrel offer design help?
Yes, Crate & Barrel offers complimentary design services both in-store and virtually. Their designers can help with everything from space planning to selecting fabrics and finishes.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
