While both Casper and Brooklinen offer popular direct-to-consumer sheets, they differ primarily in materials, style options, and price. Casper provides simple, modern, and budget-friendly sheets, often made from comfortable and easy-care cotton blends. Brooklinen focuses on luxury, offering a wider range of premium materials like long-staple cotton and linen, more color and pattern choices, and a more sophisticated aesthetic at a higher price point.
Here’s everything you need to know to decide which bedding brand is the right fit for your bedroom.
Casper Sheets
Casper, the brand that famously simplified mattress shopping, applies a similar philosophy to its bedding. Their sheets are designed for universal comfort, focusing on softness, breathability, and hassle-free care. With a minimalist and modern aesthetic, Casper sheets are a straightforward choice for anyone looking to upgrade their bedding without getting lost in complicated options.
- What it is: Mid-range bedding from a popular sleep brand, designed to be soft, durable, and easy to maintain.
- Key features: Soft and breathable fabrics, often made from cotton blends or Tencel for a cozy feel. Known for a secure fit with snug elastic corners.
- Price: Approximately $100 - $150 for a queen set.
- Style: Simple, modern, and minimalist. Primarily offered in neutral and uncomplicated solid colors like white, gray, and blush.
- Materials/Construction: Often made from cotton and microfiber or polyester blends. These materials are chosen for their balance of softness, wrinkle resistance, and affordability.
- Pros: More affordable price point. Extremely easy to care for and resists wrinkling. Soft and comfortable right out of the package. Simple and modern design complements most decor styles.
- Cons: Limited selection of colors and styles. Fabric blends may not feel as crisp or luxurious as 100% long-staple cotton. Not the best option for those seeking certified organic or specialty materials.
Casper sheets are ideal for those who prioritize affordability, ease of care, and a simple, modern look for their bedroom.
Shop this product: casper.com/bedding/
Brooklinen Sheets
Brooklinen has built its brand on offering high-end, luxury-quality bedding without the traditional retail markup. They provide a vast selection of materials, weaves, colors, and patterns, allowing customers to find the exact feel and look they want. Their focus on premium materials like long-staple cotton and responsible manufacturing makes them a favorite for discerning shoppers.
- What it is: A direct-to-consumer luxury bedding brand known for its high-quality materials, stylish designs, and variety of options.
- Key features: Wide variety of fabrics including Classic Percale (crisp and cool) and Luxe Sateen (silky and smooth). OEKO-TEX certification ensures fabrics are free of harmful chemicals. Features “long” and “short” side labels on fitted sheets.
- Price: Approximately $130 - $200 for a queen set.
- Style: Sophisticated and highly versatile. A huge range of solid colors, limited edition patterns, and classic designs appeals to many decorative tastes.
- Materials/Construction: Primarily made from high-quality, long-staple cotton, giving the sheets superior durability, softness, and breathability. They also offer linen and Tencel options.
- Pros: Feels luxurious and high-end. Superior durability due to long-staple cotton fibers. Huge selection of styles, colors, and fabric weaves. Strong commitment to ethical production with OEKO-TEX certification.
- Cons: Higher price point. Some weaves, like their popular percale, are prone to wrinkling. The sheer number of options can be overwhelming for some buyers.
Brooklinen sheets are perfect for anyone willing to invest in premium materials for a more luxurious feel, style versatility, and long-term durability.
Shop this product: brooklinen.com/collections/sheets
Casper vs. Brooklinen Sheets Comparison
Materials & Quality
This is the most significant difference between the two brands. Casper often uses cotton blends that incorporate materials like polyester to enhance softness and reduce wrinkles, making them easy to care for. While comfortable, these materials don't offer the same crispness or long-term durability as premium, all-cotton options.
Brooklinen built its reputation on using 100% long-staple cotton, which has longer, stronger fibers that create a smoother and more durable fabric. Their offerings like Classic Percale provide a crisp, cool feel, while the Luxe Sateen weave is silky and buttery. This focus on premium, OEKO-TEX certified materials gives Brooklinen a clear edge in overall quality and feel.
Style & Aesthetic
Casper aligns with a minimalist, modern aesthetic. Their color palette is tight and focused, typically featuring solid neutrals that easily fit into clean, contemporary bedroom designs. If you prefer an uncluttered look and aren't focused on intricate patterns or bold colors, Casper’s offerings are clean and effective.
Brooklinen is the clear winner for anyone who wants options. Catering to a wide range of design tastes, they offer an extensive library of core colors, seasonal collections, and tasteful patterns. This variety makes it much easier to match specific decor or use your bedding as a statement piece in your bedroom design.
Price & Value
Casper sheets are generally more affordable, with queen sets often priced under $150. For this price, you get a reliable, comfortable, and low-maintenance bedding set from a trusted brand. It's a great value for students, first-time apartment owners, or anyone on a budget.
Brooklinen positions itself as an affordable luxury brand, with their core queen sets typically starting around $150 and going up from there. While the initial cost is higher, the investment often pays off in longevity. The high-quality materials resist pilling and thinning better over time, potentially saving you money in the long run by not needing to be replaced as frequently.
Care & Durability
Thanks to their blended fabrics, Casper sheets are exceptional when it comes to ease of care. They are designed to come out of the dryer relatively wrinkle-free and maintain their softness with minimal fuss. This makes them a practical choice for busy households or anyone who doesn’t want to iron their sheets.
Brooklinen sheets, particularly the 100% cotton percale, are known to wrinkle more. Sateen is less prone to wrinkling but lacks the crispness of percale. However, what you trade in wrinkle resistance, you gain in durability. Long-staple cotton fibers are less likely to break, meaning Brooklinen sheets are less prone to pilling and thinning over years of washing.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands offer excellent products, but they cater to very different preferences and priorities.
Choose Casper if:
- You're on a budget and want the best quality for around $100-$150.
- You want sheets that are easy to wash and don't wrinkle much.
- You prefer a simple, modern look with neutral, solid colors.
- You value out-of-the-box softness over crisp, hotel-style bedding.
Choose Brooklinen if:
- You're willing to invest more for a distinctly luxurious, high-end feel.
- You want a wide variety of choices in color, pattern, and fabric weave (like crisp percale or silky sateen).
- Material quality and certifications like OEKO-TEX are important factors for you.
- You are looking for durable, long-lasting sheets that will hold up well over time.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Casper and Brooklinen sheets?
The primary difference is in the materials and options. Casper focuses on simple, easy-care cotton blends with a minimalist aesthetic, while Brooklinen offers a wide variety of premium 100% long-staple cotton sheets in many colors and weaves for a more luxurious experience.
Are Brooklinen sheets worth the extra cost?
For many, yes. The higher price of Brooklinen sheets reflects the superior quality of the long-staple cotton, which contributes to better durability, breathability, and feel. If you value fine materials and longevity, the investment is worthwhile.
Which brand is better for hot sleepers?
Brooklinen is generally better for hot sleepers because they offer a Classic Percale sheet set. The percale weave is a simple one-over-one grid that is exceptionally light and breathable, making it feel cool to the touch. It's a fantastic option for those who tend to overheat at night.
Are Casper sheets 100% cotton?
Not always. Casper offers different sheet sets, some of which are 100% cotton, but many of their popular Hyperlite sheets are blends that include other materials like Tencel to enhance certain qualities. Always check the specific product description before purchasing.
Do Brooklinen sheets wrinkle easily?
This depends on the weave. Their Classic Percale sheets are known for being airy and crisp, but this weave naturally wrinkles more. Their Luxe Sateen sheets have a tighter, silkier weave and are much more wrinkle-resistant. You can choose based on your preference for feel versus maintenance.
How deep are the pockets on Casper and Brooklinen sheets?
Both brands offer sheets designed to fit modern mattresses. Their fitted sheets typically accommodate mattresses up to 15 inches deep, ensuring a secure fit without slipping off the corners.
Which brand has a better return policy?
Both have generous policies. Brooklinen offers a full year (365 days) for returns or exchanges, even after washing and sleeping on them. Casper offers a 30-night trial on bedding. Both reflect confidence in their products, but Brooklinen’s policy is exceptionally long.
Are Casper and Brooklinen sheets sold in stores?
Both are primarily direct-to-consumer online brands. However, Casper has its own retail stores and has partnered with retailers like Target and Nordstrom. Brooklinen has a few of its own retail locations but is not widely available in third-party stores.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
