A Carbon Steel Pan and a Hexclad pan serve a similar purpose but get there through completely different philosophies. A carbon steel pan is a classic piece of cookware made from a single layer of iron and carbon that requires seasoning to build a natural non-stick surface, while Hexclad is a modern hybrid pan with a tri-ply construction combining stainless steel and a durable non-stick coating.
Here’s a detailed comparison to help you choose the right pan for your kitchen and cooking style.
Carbon Steel Pan
Beloved by professional chefs, a carbon steel pan is a versatile workhorse made from a single piece of steel alloy. It heats up rapidly, responds quickly to temperature changes, and with proper seasoning, develops an incredibly effective, renewable non-stick surface. It excels at high-heat cooking like searing steaks or stir-frying, improving with every use.
- What it is: A durable, lightweight pan made from an alloy of iron and carbon, known for developing a natural non-stick patina over time.
- Key features: Excellent heat conduction and responsiveness, lightweight design compared to cast iron, high-heat tolerance perfect for searing, handle is typically welded or riveted on.
- Price: Generally affordable, from $30 up to $100 for premium models.
- Style: Utilitarian and classic, with a rugged, professional kitchen aesthetic that develops a dark, seasoned patina with age.
- Materials/Construction: It's simply pressed or spun from a single sheet of carbon steel.
- Pros: A fraction of the price of premium cookware, can last a lifetime, becomes more non-stick over time, lightweight, and can handle extremely high temperatures for a perfect sear.
- Cons: Requires an initial seasoning process and ongoing maintenance, will rust if not dried properly and kept lightly oiled, reactive with acidic foods which can strip the seasoning.
This pan is ideal for the dedicated home cook who enjoys the process of caring for their cookware and wants a durable, affordable tool that rewards them with incredible performance.
Shop this product: lodgescastiron.com/collections/carbon-steel-pans
Hexclad Pan
Hexclad markets itself as the 'Rolls Royce' of pans, blending the best attributes of stainless steel, cast iron, and non-stick cookware. Its signature feature is a patented laser-etched hexagonal design - a network of stainless steel ridges that protect a non-stick coating in the valleys. This innovative construction allows for searing like stainless steel while providing the easy cleanup of a non-stick surface.
- What it is: A hybrid pan featuring a non-stick surface protected by a stainless steel hexagonal pattern.
- Key features: Hybrid stainless steel and non-stick performance, metal utensil safe, dishwasher safe, oven safe to 500°F, tri-ply construction for even heating, compatible with all cooktops including induction.
- Price: Premium, ranging from $100 to $200 for a single skillet.
- Style: Sleek and modern, with a distinctive high-tech appearance that stands out in a contemporary kitchen.
- Materials/Construction: Tri-ply construction with an aluminum core for even heating, sandwiched between layers of stainless steel with a PFOA-free ceramic honeycomb non-stick coating.
- Pros: Very low maintenance and easy to clean, highly scratch-resistant for a non-stick pan, provides great even heating, versatile enough for searing or delicate foods like eggs.
- Cons: High price point for a single pan, non-stick coating may eventually degrade over many years of use, heavy compared to carbon steel.
The Hexclad is built for busy home cooks who want premium, low-maintenance performance and are willing to pay for durable, hybrid technology that simplifies the cooking process.
Shop this product: hexclad.com/
Carbon Steel Pan vs. Hexclad Comparison
Materials & Construction
The core difference lies in their construction. A carbon steel pan is pure simplicity - a single layer of steel that is nearly indestructible. Its quality comes from the steel itself and its ability to take seasoning. It's built for a lifetime of heavy use.
A Hexclad pan is complex and engineered. Its tri-ply aluminum and stainless steel body provides excellent, even heat distribution, while the laser-etched non-stick surface is built for durability and convenience. While robust, the non-stick coating is the element that will ultimately define the pan's lifespan.
Cooking Performance & Maintenance
Carbon steel excels at extreme heat. It’s the go-to for searing a steak or stir-frying because it heats up incredibly fast and holds a high temperature. However, it requires significant maintenance. You must season it, avoid acidic foods, clean it carefully without soap initially, and keep it dry and oiled to prevent rust.
Hexclad offers a much more forgiving experience. It provides even heat from its aluminum core, and the hybrid surface can achieve a decent sear while also handling delicate items like eggs or fish with ease. Cleanup is simple - it’s dishwasher safe, and you don’t have to worry about seasoning or rust. The non-stick surface delivers convenience from day one without any break-in period.
Price & Value
This is a major point of difference. You can get a high-quality, long-lasting carbon steel pan for $40-$70. Given that it can perform for decades, it offers exceptional value for money if you’re willing to provide the upkeep. It's a small investment for a lifetime tool.
Hexclad sits on the premium end of the market, with skillets often costing over $100. The value proposition is in its hybrid technology, convenience, and scratch-resistant durability. You are paying a premium for an easy-to-use, versatile, and well-built product that requires almost no special care.
Style & Versatility
Carbon steel has a raw, industrial aesthetic. It's not about being pretty, it's about being functional. As it seasons, it develops a deep black patina that looks authentic and professional. It’s versatile enough for the stove, oven, or even a grill.
Hexclad has a polished, modern look. The gleaming "hexagrid" is distinctive and speaks to cutting-edge technology. It’s designed to look good hanging from a pot rack in a contemporary kitchen and works seamlessly across all types of cooktops, including induction.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both pans are excellent performers, but they cater to very different types of home cooks.
Choose a Carbon Steel Pan if:
- You are on a budget but want professional-level searing performance.
- You enjoy the process of maintaining and seasoning your cookware.
- You want a pan that can get ripping hot for the perfect crust on meats.
- You value heirloom-quality tools that can last an entire lifetime.
Choose a Hexclad Pan if:
- Your priority is convenience and easy cleanup - you want dishwasher-safe cookware.
- You are willing to invest more for a durable, non-stick surface that resists scratching from metal utensils.
- You want one versatile pan that can handle everything from steaks to omelets.
- You prefer a modern aesthetic and engineered, high-tech cookware.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between a Carbon Steel Pan and Hexclad?
The main difference is the surface. A carbon steel pan is made from natural steel that you must season to build a natural non-stick layer. A Hexclad pan has a factory-applied ceramic non-stick coating protected by a stainless steel structure for immediate, low-maintenance use.
Which pan sears steak better?
For purists, a properly seasoned carbon steel pan will achieve a superior sear. It can tolerate higher temperatures than most non-stick pans, leading to a deeper, faster crust formation without overcooking the interior of the steak.
Can I use metal utensils on Hexclad?
Yes, one of the main selling points of Hexclad is its scratch resistance. The stainless steel ridges are raised above the non-stick coating, protecting it from spatulas, tongs, and whisks.
How do you care for a carbon steel pan?
After cooking, clean it with hot water and a gentle brush while still warm (avoid harsh soap). Dry it completely on the stove over low heat for a minute, then wipe a very thin layer of cooking oil inside before storing. This prevents rust and builds the seasoning.
Which pan will last longer?
A carbon steel pan will almost certainly last longer. With no coating to wear out, it can be used for generations and can always be stripped and re-seasoned if the surface is ever damaged. A Hexclad pan is very durable, but its non-stick coating has a finite lifespan, likely lasting many years but not indefinitely.
Is Hexclad worth the high price?
If you value top-tier convenience, non-stick performance, and easy cleanup, Hexclad can be a worthwhile investment. It combines the roles of two or three different pans into one durable, versatile piece. For users who prioritize performance over convenience, the value may not be as compelling.
Can both pans be used in the oven?
Yes, both are typically oven-safe. Carbon steel pans can usually withstand very high temperatures (often 600°F+), making them great for oven-finishing dishes. Hexclad pans are also oven-safe but are generally rated to a lower temperature, around 500°F.
Which pan is lighter?
Carbon steel pans are generally lighter than hybrid pans like Hexclad. Because Hexclad features a multi-layer tri-ply construction, it's a bit heavier and more substantial than a single layer of carbon steel of the same size.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
