Caraway offers modern, ceramic-coated non-stick cookware with a minimalist aesthetic, focusing on ease of use and health-conscious materials. In contrast, Staub is a heritage French brand specializing in premium, enameled cast iron cookware known for its superior heat retention and heirloom-quality durability. The choice between them comes down to daily convenience and sleek design versus classic performance and culinary tradition.

Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right cookware for your kitchen.

Caraway: The Modern, Non-Toxic Choice

Caraway is a direct-to-consumer brand that gained popularity for its thoughtfully designed, non-toxic cookware. With a clean aesthetic available in a range of stylish pastel and neutral colors, it appeals to home cooks who value a modern look, simplicity, and materials free from chemicals like PTFE and PFOA. This brand is tailored for everyday use, making cooking and cleanup as straightforward as possible.

• Product mix: Caraway focuses on core kitchen essentials, famously sold in a comprehensive 4-piece set that includes a fry pan, saucepan, sauté pan, and Dutch oven. Individual pieces are also available.
• Style/vibe: Clean, minimalist, and contemporary. The signature look features matte color finishes and stainless-steel hardware, designed to be displayed on the countertop or stove.
• Price point: Mid-range. The complete cookware set typically retails for around $395, with individual pans and pots costing between $95 and $150.
• Quality & Materials: An aluminum core ensures even and fast heating, while the proprietary ceramic non-stick surface is free from harmful chemicals. The cookware is relatively lightweight compared to traditional materials.
• Best for: Daily cooking tasks like frying eggs, sautéing vegetables, and simmering sauces. It's an excellent choice for health-conscious individuals and those furnishing their first apartment or looking for an easy-maintenance kitchen upgrade.
• Return policy: Offers a 30-day trial period, allowing customers to test the cookware at home and return it if it doesn't meet their expectations.
• Delivery & Assembly: Products arrive fully assembled in eco-friendly, recyclable packaging with clever storage solutions like magnetic pan racks and a canvas lid holder.
• Sustainability: The brand emphasizes its non-toxic materials and ships products in plastic-free packaging, reflecting a commitment to wellness and environmental responsibility.

Caraway is a great fit for anyone who wants stylish, high-performing non-stick cookware that simplifies the entire cooking and cleaning process.

Shop Caraway: carawayhome.com

Staub: The Heirloom-Quality Cast Iron Pick

Founded in the Alsace region of France, Staub is a benchmark for premium enameled cast iron cookware. Favored by professional chefs and serious home cooks, Staub's pieces are culinary workhorses known for their exceptional durability and performance, especially for slow-cooking methods. Each item, particularly their iconic cocottes (Dutch ovens), is crafted to last a lifetime, blending traditional manufacturing with functional kitchen innovations.

• Product mix: Extensive range of enameled cast iron, including Dutch ovens, braisers, grill pans, skillets, and baking dishes. They also offer ceramic bakeware and kitchen tools.
• Style/vibe: Classic, timeless, and substantial. The deep, vibrant matte enamel finishes and classic silhouettes give pieces an heirloom quality that feels at home in both traditional and modern kitchens.
• Price point: Premium. A signature 5.5-quart cocotte can cost between $300 and $400, reflecting its quality and positioning as a long-term culinary investment.
• Quality & Materials: Heavy-gauge cast iron provides unparalleled heat retention and even distribution. The interior is coated with a matte black enamel that promotes browning and seasoning over time, while the exterior features multiple layers of chip-resistant enamel.
• Best for: Braising, stewing, roasting, searing, and baking. It excels at low-and-slow cooking methods where consistent, even heat is crucial for tender results. Its beautiful appearance makes it perfect for oven-to-table serving.
• Return policy: Returns are typically handled by individual retailers (like Zwilling, its parent company, or stores like Williams Sonoma) and usually require items to be unused.
• Delivery & Assembly: Staub pieces are heavy and shipped securely packaged. No assembly is required.
• Sustainability: The brand's sustainability comes from its longevity. A Staub cocotte is a "buy it for life" product, reducing consumer waste by eliminating the need for replacement.

Staub is an investment for passionate cooks who need high-performance, durable cookware that delivers exceptional results and can be passed down for generations.

Shop Staub: staub.com

Caraway vs. Staub Comparison

Price Comparison

There is a clear distinction in pricing between these two brands. Caraway is positioned in the accessible mid-range market, you can acquire a complete four-piece set for around $395. This bundle approach offers great value, equipping a kitchen with all its core pieces in one purchase.

Staub operates in the premium category, with single pieces often costing as much as an entire Caraway set. A classic Staub Dutch oven starts around $200 and can easily exceed $400 for larger sizes or special colors. While the initial cost is significantly higher, Staub's value is in its lifelong durability and specialized performance, making it a long-term investment rather than an everyday purchase.

Style & Aesthetic

Caraway’s design is unmistakably modern and minimalist. With its smooth matte surfaces, clean lines, and curated color palette of soft pastels and jewel tones, it feels fresh and contemporary. It’s cookware designed to complement a stylish, uncluttered kitchen aesthetic and is often displayed on open shelving or stands.

Staub embodies a timeless, rustic elegance. Its vibrant, deep-colored enamel finishes have a slight texture that feels classic and substantial. The designs, rooted in traditional French culinary equipment, are beautiful enough for oven-to-table presentation and add a sense of robust quality and heritage to any kitchen setting.

Quality & Construction

Caraway cookware uses a lightweight aluminum core for quick, even heating, coated with a proprietary ceramic non-stick surface. This construction makes it easy to handle and ideal for quick-cooking techniques. However, like all non-stick coatings, the ceramic surface will eventually degrade with use over several years and requires care to avoid scratches from metal utensils.

Staub's construction is all about mass and thermal retention. The heavy-gauge enameled cast iron absorbs heat slowly and retains it for a very long time, making it superior for searing, braising, and baking. The black matte interior enamel is formulated to be more durable than non-stick surfaces and actually improves with use, creating a patina that develops better browning over time. Its sheer weight is a testament to its durability.

Recommended Uses

Caraway excels at everyday, quick-turnaround meals. It’s perfect for making omelets, pan-searing fish fillets, and simmering sauces - tasks where its non-stick surface prevents sticking and ensures cleanup is fast and easy. Its lightweight nature makes it easy for cooks of all abilities to handle daily.

Staub's cookware is designed for more intensive, slow-cooking applications. Its Dutch ovens are champions of pot roasts, stews, chilis, and homemade bread. The heavy lid with self-basting spikes creates a perfect environment for braising tough cuts of meat into tender morsels. While it can handle everyday tasks, its true strength shines in recipes that require stable, long-lasting heat.

Which One Should You Choose?

Both Caraway and Staub offer excellent products, but they cater to very different types of cooks, kitchens, and priorities.

Choose Caraway if:

• You want easy-to-clean, hassle-free cookware for everyday meals.
• You prioritize a modern, minimalist aesthetic and love its stylish color options.
• A non-toxic cooking surface is a top priority for you and your family.
• You prefer lightweight pans and pots that are easy to maneuver around the kitchen.
• You're looking for a complete, coordinated set to outfit your kitchen all at once.

Choose Staub if:

• You are a passionate cook who loves slow-cooking methods like braising, roasting, and stewing.
• You want to invest in heirloom-quality cookware that you may use for the rest of your life.
• Superior heat retention for a perfect sear or consistent simmering is important to you.
• You appreciate the 'oven-to-table' appeal of beautifully crafted, timeless cookware.
• Weight is not a concern, and you appreciate the stability that a heavy pot provides.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Caraway or Staub more expensive?

Staub is significantly more expensive per piece. A single Staub Dutch oven can cost nearly as much as an entire cookware set from Caraway. Caraway offers better value for outfitting a full kitchen, while Staub is a premium investment intended for a lifetime of use.

Which has better quality cookware?

This depends on the definition of quality. For sheer longevity and specialized cooking performance (especially heat retention), Staub is higher quality. Its enameled cast iron is built to last for generations. Caraway has excellent quality for its category - modern non-stick - with a durable ceramic coating and smart design, but all non-stick surfaces have a finite lifespan.

Is Caraway cookware dishwasher safe?

While Caraway states its cookware is dishwasher safe, they strongly recommend handwashing with a non-abrasive sponge to prolong the life of the ceramic non-stick coating. This will ensure it performs optimally for as long as possible.

Can you use metal utensils on Staub cookware?

It's best to avoid metal utensils on any enameled surface, including Staub, to prevent chipping or scratching the enamel. Wood, silicone, or nylon utensils are recommended to keep the interior in perfect condition.

Which is better for a beginner cook?

Caraway is generally better for a beginner cook. Its non-stick surface is very forgiving, it's lightweight and easy to handle, and the pre-made set provides all the essentials. Staub requires more familiarity with heat control and proper care for cast iron.

Which is better for cooking on an induction stove?

Both Caraway and Staub are fully compatible with induction stovetops, as Caraway has a magnetic steel base and Staub is made of cast iron.

Is the non-stick on Caraway going to last?

Caraway's ceramic non-stick coating is designed to be durable. However, like any non-stick pan, its performance will diminish over time with heavy use and washing. With proper care (avoiding high heat, metal utensils, and harsh detergents), it should last for several years.

Does Staub cookware need to be seasoned?

Unlike raw cast iron, Staub's enameled cast iron does not require seasoning before first use. The black matte interior develops a natural patina over time which improves its cooking properties, but no formal seasoning process is needed.

At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.

Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.