Caraway offers design-forward, ceramic non-stick cookware focused on non-toxic materials and a minimalist aesthetic, making it an investment piece for modern kitchens. In contrast, Quince provides high-quality cookware in classic materials like stainless steel at a much lower, direct-to-consumer price point by cutting out middlemen.
Let's compare everything you need to know to choose the right cookware brand for your kitchen and cooking style.
Caraway: The Stylish, Non-Toxic Choice
Caraway is known for its Instagram-worthy ceramic cookware that combines a health-conscious, non-toxic coating with a sleek, minimalist design. The brand targets design-savvy home cooks who want beautiful, functional, and easy-to-clean pots and pans that look great on the stovetop. Their cohesive sets often come with clever storage solutions, making them a complete kitchen overhaul in a box.
- Product mix: Complete cookware sets, bakeware sets, and individual Dutch ovens, fry pans, saute pans, and saucepans.
- Style/vibe: Minimalist and contemporary with a signature color palette including shades like Perracotta, Sage, and Slate. Perfect for modern or Scandinavian-inspired kitchens.
- Price point: Mid-range to premium. A full cookware set starts at $395, with individual pieces ranging from $95 to $135.
- Quality & Materials: Features a ceramic non-stick coating that is free of PTFE, PFOA, and other toxic materials. The pans have an aluminum core for even heating and are oven-safe up to 550°F.
- Customization: While sets are pre-configured, you can build your own set by purchasing pieces individually in a wide range of colors.
- Sales: Caraway occasionally runs promotions during major shopping holidays like Black Friday, but full-priced items are the norm.
- Return policy: Offers a 30-day return policy for unused products in their original packaging.
- Delivery & Assembly: Products arrive fully assembled in thoughtfully designed, eco-friendly packaging that includes built-in storage organizers for lids and pans.
Caraway is ideal for those who prioritize a non-toxic cooking surface and a unified, modern aesthetic, and are happy to invest more for style and convenience.
Shop Caraway: carawayhome.com
Quince: The High-Quality, Value-Driven Essential
Quince is a direct-to-consumer brand whose mission is to offer luxury-quality essentials, from clothing to home goods, at radically lower prices. They achieve this with a factory-direct model that eliminates traditional retail markups. Their cookware collection focuses on durable, long-lasting materials like stainless steel, appealing to practical home cooks who want performance and value over trendy colors.
- Product mix: Quince's home selection includes stainless steel cookware sets, non-stick fry pans, bedding, towels, and decor. Their offerings extend well beyond the kitchen.
- Style/vibe: Classic, timeless, and functional. The polished stainless steel offers a professional, industrial look that works in almost any kitchen design.
- Price point: Very affordable for the quality. A 10-piece stainless steel cookware set is typically under $200.
- Quality & Materials: Most famously offers durable 3-ply and 5-ply stainless steel cookware with an aluminum core for excellent heat conduction. Their cookware is oven-safe (usually to 500°F) and induction-compatible.
- Sustainability: The company is transparent about its factories and committed to sustainable packaging and ethical production practices.
- Sales: Quince's prices are already low due to their business model, so they do not run traditional sales. The price you see is the final, accessible price.
- Return policy: Generous 365-day return policy, even on used items, showcasing their confidence in their products.
- Delivery & Assembly: Cookware ships directly to you, fully assembled and ready to use, with a focus on simple, sustainable packaging.
Quince is the go-to for shoppers seeking professional-grade cookware materials like stainless steel without paying premium brand prices.
Shop Quince: quince.com
Caraway vs. Quince Comparison
Price Comparison
This is the most significant difference between the two brands. A full cookware set from Caraway costs around $395. A comparable stainless steel set from Quince is often priced between $150 and $200. Quince is the clear winner on price, offering exceptional value for high-quality materials.
Caraway positions itself as a premium lifestyle brand where you pay for the stylish design, specific colorways, non-toxic ceramic coating, and clever storage solutions. Quince's model is about stripping away brand and marketing costs to deliver durable, quality goods at the lowest possible price point. Your choice here depends on whether you view cookware as a function-first utility or a design-first statement piece.
Style & Aesthetic
Caraway stands out for its modern, minimalist design and trendy color palette. Its cookware is made to be seen, suiting kitchens with a clear aesthetic vision, whether it's Scandinavian, minimalist, or contemporary. The matching colors and cohesive design make their sets very visually appealing.
Quince offers a classic and timeless aesthetic. Polished stainless steel cookware has a professional, chef-inspired look that is versatile and never goes out of style. It fits seamlessly into both modern and traditional kitchens, prioritizing performance over a particular color trend. It's for the cook who prefers a more understated, industrial, or classic look.
Quality & Construction
Both brands offer high-quality products, but with different materials. Caraway's signature feature is its non-toxic ceramic non-stick surface. This is a huge selling point for health-conscious consumers, but like all non-stick coatings, it requires careful use and will eventually wear out over time.
Quince's specialty is multi-ply stainless steel, which is celebrated for its durability, heat distribution, and longevity. With proper care, a stainless steel set can last for decades. It is more forgiving of high heat and metal utensils than non-stick surfaces. For longevity and robust performance, Quince's stainless steel has the edge.
Product Selection
Caraway is a specialized kitchenware brand. Its focus is entirely on cookware, bakeware, food storage, and related accessories. This allows them to go deep on product features, like the pan and lid storage systems included with their sets.
Quince is a broad lifestyle retailer. While their cookware selection is excellent, it is just one category among many, including bedding, cashmere sweaters, and leather bags. This makes them a great one-stop shop for outfitting a home, but they don't have the same narrow focus as Caraway.
Shopping Experience
Both brands are direct-to-consumer and provide a great online shopping experience. Caraway's website is highly visual and design-focused, immersing you in their brand aesthetic. Their "unboxing" experience is premium and includes their storage solutions, making it an exciting purchase to receive.
Quince's website is more straightforward and information-driven, with a strong emphasis on transparency. They provide detailed information about the materials and the factories where their products are made. Their 365-day return policy is unmatched and removes virtually all risk from making a purchase.
Sustainability & Ethics
Both companies make sustainability a priority. Caraway's approach centers on a healthier home environment with its non-toxic coatings and on shipping its products in plastic-free, recycled packaging. They focus on eco-friendly materials from start to finish.
Quince's focus is on supply chain ethics and efficiency. By shipping directly from the factory, they reduce the carbon footprint associated with warehousing and middlemen. They are also committed to using ethical factories and sustainable materials across all their product categories.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both Caraway and Quince deliver high-quality products, but they cater to very different priorities and budgets.
Choose Caraway if:
- A non-toxic, chemical-free cooking surface is your highest priority.
- You value a specific modern aesthetic and want your cookware in colors like sage, cream, or navy.
- You appreciate clever storage solutions and want your pots and pans neatly organized.
- You view your cookware as a key part of your kitchen's overall design.
Choose Quince if:
- You are looking for the absolute best value for your money.
- You prefer the longevity and durability of classic stainless steel cookware.
- You want professional-grade performance that excels at searing and high-heat cooking.
- You appreciate a brand with a radically transparent business model and a fantastic return policy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Caraway or Quince cheaper?
Quince is significantly cheaper. Due to its factory-direct model, a complete cookware set from Quince is typically half the price (or less) of a comparable set from Caraway.
Which has better quality cookware?
Both have excellent quality, but for different purposes. Caraway offers a high-quality, non-toxic ceramic surface. Quince offers durable, multi-ply stainless steel construction known for superior heat retention and longevity. For sheer durability and a lifetime of use, steel from Quince is the more robust material.
Is Caraway cookware non-toxic?
Yes. This is one of Caraway's main selling points. Their ceramic non-stick coating is made without toxic materials like PFOA, PTFE, lead, and cadmium, ensuring a healthier cooking experience.
Is Quince cookware induction compatible?
Yes, Quince's stainless steel cookware is fully compatible with all cooktops, including induction. Caraway cookware is also induction compatible.
Can Caraway pans go in the oven?
Yes, Caraway pots and pans are oven-safe up to 550°F, which is suitable for most home cooking and baking needs.
Which brand is better for a beginner cook?
Caraway might be easier for beginners due to its non-stick surface, which is very forgiving. However, Quince's low price point and durable construction make it a fantastic, low-risk investment for someone learning to cook with stainless steel.
Which brand is more durable?
Quince's stainless steel cookware is generally more durable. Stainless steel is resistant to scratches, dents, and high heat and can last for decades. Any non-stick coating, including Caraway's high-quality ceramic, will eventually degrade with use and requires more careful handling.
Can you return cookware to Quince?
Yes. Quince has an industry-leading 365-day return policy. This generous window allows you to try the cookware extensively to ensure it’s the right fit for your kitchen.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
