Caraway is a modern DTC brand offering stylish, non-toxic ceramic-coated cookware designed for aesthetics. Pyrex, on the other hand, is a heritage brand known for its remarkably durable and affordable glass bakeware and storage containers. The primary difference is in their core materials and function: Caraway excels with stovetop pots and pans that are design-forward, while Pyrex is the go-to for versatile, oven-safe glass bakeware.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right kitchenware for your home.
Caraway: The Modern, Non-Toxic Cookware Brand
Caraway is a digital-native brand that has gained popularity for its beautiful, thoughtfully designed kitchenware that prioritizes health and minimalism. They appeal to design-conscious millennials and home cooks seeking items that are as stylish as they are functional, with a strong focus on non-toxic materials. The entire shopping experience is curated to feel premium and intentional, right down to the eco-friendly packaging.
- Product mix: A focused collection of ceramic-coated cookware (fry pans, saucepans, dutch ovens) and bakeware sets. They also offer food storage, prep ware, and tea kettles to create a cohesive kitchen collection.
- Style/vibe: Minimalist, modern, and very colorful. Caraway's signature is its wide range of matte, contemporary colors that stand out on a stovetop and open shelving.
- Price point: Mid-range to premium. Individual cookware pieces usually start around $95, while their best-selling 4-piece Cookware Set is priced at $395. It's an investment in both function and form.
- Quality &, Materials: Features an aluminum core for even heating and a mineral-based ceramic non-stick coating. This coating is free from PTFE (like Teflon), PFOA, lead, and cadmium.
- Sustainability: Caraway actively promotes its use of non-toxic materials, ships in plastic-free recycled packaging, and uses manufacturing processes that release fewer emissions than traditional non-stick coatings.
- Warranty: Offers a limited one-year warranty that covers manufacturing defects.
- Shopping Experience: Primarily sold direct-to-consumer through the Caraway website, which provides a premium, curated shopping journey. They can also be found at retailers like Crate & Barrel and Zola.
Caraway delivers a complete, aesthetic-driven solution for consumers who want healthy, easy-to-use stovetop cookware that beautifies their kitchen.
Shop Caraway: carawayhome.com
Pyrex: The Classic, Versatile Kitchen Staple
Pyrex is an iconic American brand that has been a fixture in kitchens for over a century. Synonymous with durability and reliability, its heat-resistant glass products are workhorses for baking, meal prep, mixing, and food storage. Pyrex targets families, avid bakers, and budget-conscious consumers who value practicality and longevity above all else.
- Product mix: Extensive range of glass products including baking dishes, pie plates, mixing bowls, measuring cups, and food storage containers with lids.
- Style/vibe: Utilitarian, classic, and functional. The design is transparent and no-frills, focusing purely on practicality. Some sets feature simple patterns or colored lids for organization.
- Price point: Very affordable and accessible. Individual pieces often cost less than $10, and multi-piece bakeware or storage sets typically run from $30 to $50.
- Quality &, Materials: Made from durable borosilicate or tempered soda-lime glass, depending on the region. It is designed to withstand high oven temperatures and resist stains and odors.
- Dimensions/Scale: Offers an enormous variety of standardized sizes and shapes, from small single-serving containers to large casserole dishes designed for family meals.
- Shopping Experience: Widely available everywhere, from big-box stores like Target and Walmart to grocery stores and online retailers like Amazon, making it incredibly easy to find and purchase.
Pyrex remains the unmatched king of affordable, multi-functional glassware that can handle nearly any task from the oven to the freezer, year after year.
Shop Pyrex: pyrex.com
Caraway vs. Pyrex Comparison
Price Comparison
There is a vast price difference between these two brands. Pyrex is built for mass-market affordability, with entire sets often costing less than a single Caraway pan. You can get a robust 8-piece Pyrex mixing bowl set for around $40, while a single Caraway bakeware piece might cost over twice that.
Caraway operates in the premium space. A full set runs several hundred dollars, reflecting its positioning as a design-forward, specialty item that combines aesthetics with non-toxic technology. You're paying for the sleek design, curated colors, and specific non-stick ceramic material.
Style &, Aesthetic
This is where the brands are most different. Caraway's entire value proposition is built around its minimalist, modern aesthetic. The cookware is designed to be displayed proudly, with cohesive, matte color palettes that fit seamlessly into contemporary kitchen designs. Each set comes with modular magnetic pan racks and a canvas lid holder for perfect organization.
Pyrex, conversely, is all about function over form. Its look is classic, clear, and utilitarian. While perfectly presentable, its primary goal is not to be a statement piece of decor, it’s a tool intended for heavy use in baking, roasting, and storing food without fuss.
Quality &, Materials
Both brands offer high-quality products, but their materials serve entirely different purposes. Caraway's non-toxic ceramic coating on an aluminum body is designed for superior stovetop performance - providing an easy-to-clean, non-stick surface for frying, sautéing, and simmering.
Pyrex's tempered or borosilicate glass is engineered for thermal resistance, making it the superior choice for oven use. It can go from the freezer to a preheated oven (with caution) and handle high baking temperatures beautifully. It's non-porous and won't stain or absorb odors, making it ideal for storing acidic foods like tomato sauce.
Product Selection
Pyrex offers a significantly broader and more diverse range of products. Their catalog includes every imaginable size and shape of baking dish, measuring cup, mixing bowl, and storage container you could need. It's a comprehensive system for baking, food prep, and storage.
Caraway offers a more curated, focused collection. They have expanded from their core cookware set into bakeware, linens, and prep items, but the assortment is intentionally limited to essential, high-style pieces that work together as a single aesthetic system.
Shopping Experience
Shopping for Caraway is a premium, digital-first experience. Their website is sleek and informative, educating customers about non-toxic materials and product benefits. In contrast, Pyrex is an effortless add-to-cart item available at almost any major retailer, found on shelves you walk past every week. Caraway feels like a considered purchase, while Pyrex is an accessible commodity.
Sustainability &, Ethics
Caraway places sustainability and non-toxic commitments at the forefront of its marketing. Their chemical-free materials, eco-friendly packaging, and ethical manufacturing practices are core selling points for their target audience.
Pyrex's sustainability claim is rooted in its incredible longevity. A single Pyrex dish can famously last for generations, preventing countless disposable containers and lower-quality pans from ending up in landfills. The durability of glass makes it an inherently eco-friendly choice over its lifespan.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice comes down to your primary kitchen needs, your aesthetic goals, and your budget.
Choose Caraway if:
- You're looking for chic, high-performance stovetop cookware.
- Non-toxic, chemical-free cooking surfaces are a top priority for you.
- You want your kitchenware to be a core part of a modern, cohesive kitchen design.
- You value a curated, all-in-one set that includes its own minimalist storage solution.
Choose Pyrex if:
- Your primary needs are baking, roasting, meal prep, and food storage.
- You need affordable, incredibly durable, and reliable kitchen workhorses.
- Versatility is key - you want pieces that can go from the oven to the table to the fridge.
- You prefer buying practical, no-fuss items that are readily available at most stores.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Caraway or Pyrex cheaper?
Pyrex is significantly cheaper. A multi-piece set of Pyrex glassware often costs less than a single Caraway saucepan. Pyrex is one of the most budget-friendly kitchenware brands available, while Caraway is positioned as a mid-range to premium investment.
Which has better quality?
Both brands are known for excellent quality within their respective categories. Pyrex is synonymous with durability and can last for decades of heavy use in the oven, microwave, and dishwasher. Caraway's quality is centered on its effective non-stick performance, even heating, and premium finish, though its ceramic surface requires careful maintenance to prolong its life.
Which brand is better for baking?
Pyrex is unequivocally better for baking. Its glass bakeware is specifically designed to handle high oven temperatures, provide even heat for casseroles and cakes, and is safe for broiling in many cases. While Caraway offers bakeware, Pyrex's material and vast product range make it the superior choice for bakers.
Is Caraway actually non-toxic?
Yes. Caraway's main claim is that its ceramic cookware is free from potentially harmful chemicals often found in traditional non-stick pans, such as PFOA, PTFE, lead, and cadmium.
Can Caraway cookware go into the oven?
Yes, Caraway cookware is oven-safe up to 550°F, making it versatile for starting dishes on the stovetop and finishing them in the oven. However, its lids are not oven safe.
Is Pyrex dishwasher safe?
Yes, almost all Pyrex glassware is dishwasher safe, making cleanup extremely simple and convenient. The plastic lids are also typically top-rack dishwasher safe.
Which brand is better for food storage and meal prep?
Pyrex is the market leader for food storage and meal prep. Its range of lidded glass containers is perfect for storing leftovers, as glass does not stain, warp, or absorb odors. The ability to reheat food in the same container (in a microwave or oven) adds to its convenience.
Where are Caraway and Pyrex made?
Caraway products are designed in New York and manufactured in facilities in China. Pyrex glassware has been historically manufactured in the United States, with a main plant in Charleroi, Pennsylvania, though some products may be made globally.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
