Caraway is a modern cookware brand focused on stylish, non-toxic ceramic non-stick surfaces, offering cohesive sets that complement contemporary kitchens. In contrast, Nordic Ware is a classic American brand celebrated for its durable, high-performance bakeware, especially its iconic Bundt pans, and functional cookware made from materials like heavy-duty aluminum.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right cookware brand for your kitchen.
Caraway: The Modern, Non-Toxic Cookware Brand
Caraway is a direct-to-consumer brand that gained popularity for its thoughtfully designed, minimalist cookware that looks as good as it performs. Primarily targeting health-conscious and design-savvy home cooks, Caraway offers all-in-one sets with a focus on clean aesthetics and chemical-free cooking surfaces.
- Product mix: Complete cookware and bakeware sets, including frying pans, saucepots, and a Dutch oven. Also sells individual pieces, food storage containers, and tea kettles.
- Style/vibe: Modern and minimalist. Known for its sophisticated matte finishes and a palette of muted, earthy colors like cream, sage, navy, and gray.
- Price point: Premium, with their core Cookware Set starting at $395. Individual pans and pots typically range from $95 to $150.
- Quality: Features an aluminum core for even heating and a non-toxic ceramic coating that is free from PTFE, PFOA, lead, and other potentially harmful chemicals. The handles are stainless steel.
- Sustainability: The brand emphasizes eco-friendly practices by using non-toxic coatings, shipping in recycled packaging without single-use plastics, and supporting ethical manufacturing.
- Return policy: Offers a 30-day trial period, allowing customers to test the cookware at home and return it if not satisfied.
- Sales: Caraway occasionally holds sales events on its website, particularly around major holidays.
Caraway is the ideal choice for anyone looking to invest in a complete, aesthetically pleasing cookware set featuring a safe, non-toxic cooking surface.
Shop Caraway: carawayhome.com
Nordic Ware: The Classic American Bakeware Icon
Founded in 1946, Nordic Ware is a legendary American manufacturer famous for its high-quality bakeware, most notably the Bundt pan. The brand is a favorite among home bakers and professional chefs for its durable materials, reliable performance, and classic, often intricate designs.
- Product mix: Extensive range of bakeware including Bundt pans in countless shapes, baking sheets, cake pans, and roasting racks. Also offers cookware like griddles, frying pans, and stockpots.
- Style/vibe: Functional, classic, and timeless. While their primary focus is performance, many bakeware items feature beautiful, decorative patterns that have a vintage appeal.
- Price point: Mid-range and widely accessible. Signature Bundt pans are often priced between $20 and $50, while aluminum cookware can range from $30 to $100.
- Quality: Renowned for its heavy-duty cast aluminum construction, which promotes superior heat conductivity for even baking and browning. Their products are durable and resistant to warping.
- Customization: While not customizable in terms of color or finish, they offer an unparalleled variety of shapes and sizes, especially in their bakeware lines.
- Sales: Products are widely available through major retailers like Amazon, Target, and culinary specialty stores, with frequent discounts and promotions.
- Sustainability & Ethics: The vast majority of their products are proudly made in the USA. They focus on manufacturing durable, long-lasting products that reduce waste over time.
Nordic Ware offers reliable, American-made products that excel in performance, making it a go-to for serious bakers and practical home cooks.
Shop Nordic Ware: nordicware.com
Caraway vs. Nordic Ware Comparison
Price Comparison
Nordic Ware is significantly more affordable on an item-by-item basis. You can acquire a world-class baking sheet or a beautiful Bundt pan for under $40. Its pricing model encourages building a collection of specialized tools over time without a major upfront investment. This makes it an excellent choice for budget-conscious consumers or those who need specific a la carte pieces.
Caraway positions itself as a premium investment. Its main offering, the $395 cookware set, is a complete solution designed to cover all of your staple cooking needs. While the initial cost is higher, the value comes from getting a fully coordinated set with included storage solutions - something you'd have to piece together with other brands.
Quality & Materials
Both brands prioritize quality, but with different approaches. Caraway’s core feature is its proprietary ceramic non-stick surface, which is made without potentially harmful chemicals. It sits on top of an aluminum body that heats efficiently. While the non-stick properties are excellent, ceramic coatings require careful handling - no metal utensils and hand-washing is recommended - to preserve their longevity.
Nordic Ware's reputation is built on its robust cast aluminum. This material is incredibly durable, resistant to rust and warping, and provides remarkably even heat distribution, which is critical for baking. Their pieces are workhorses designed to withstand high temperatures and frequent use for years, even decades. Many of their cookware pieces have traditional non-stick surfaces, but their uncoated aluminum bakeware is a professional standard.
Style & Aesthetic
There is a clear divide in aesthetics. Caraway is designed for the modern, style-conscious kitchen. Its clean lines, handle design, and curated color palette are made to be displayed. If your kitchen has a minimalist, Scandinavian, or contemporary feel, a Caraway set will look like it was designed specifically for your space.
Nordic Ware leans into a classic, functional aesthetic. Their forms are driven by performance, though an element of beauty is undeniable in their intricately detailed cake and Bundt pans. They don't offer coordinated color sets, instead, their appeal lies in their timeless, professional-grade appearance that fits well in traditional, farmhouse, or eclectic kitchens.
Product Selection
Caraway offers a tightly curated selection. You can buy frying pans, a saucepan, a sauté pan, and a Dutch oven. This is part of their "less is more" philosophy, providing the essential pieces most home cooks need without overwhelming them with choices. It’s perfect for someone wanting to replace their entire cookware collection at once.
Nordic Ware, on the other hand, boasts a vast and diverse catalog. It is truly a baker's paradise, with pans for every conceivable type of cake, bread, or pastry. Beyond baking, they offer specialty items like griddles, waffle irons, and roasting pans. This deep selection is ideal for cooking hobbyists and anyone looking for a specific tool for a specific job.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice comes down to your cooking habits, design preferences, and main priorities in the kitchen.
Choose Caraway if:
- You prioritize a toxin-free, non-stick cooking surface.
- You want a cohesive, modern-looking set of cookware that complements your kitchen decor.
- You are looking for an all-in-one solution and are willing to make a higher upfront investment.
- You value clever design elements like integrated storage systems.
Choose Nordic Ware if:
- You are a passionate baker or frequently roast meats and vegetables.
- You value extreme durability and products that are built to last for generations.
- You want to build your cookware collection piece by piece on a more accessible budget.
- You prioritize American-made products from a brand with a decades-long reputation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Caraway or Nordic Ware cheaper?
Overall, Nordic Ware is significantly cheaper. Individual bakeware and cookware pieces are very affordably priced, often under $50. Caraway is a premium brand with a higher price point, focusing on complete sets that cost several hundred dollars.
Which has better quality cookware?
Both offer high quality, but for different purposes. Caraway’s quality is in its effective non-toxic ceramic coating and modern design. Nordic Ware’s quality lies in its heavy-duty cast aluminum construction that provides incredible durability and even heating, especially for baking.
Is Caraway cookware really non-toxic?
Yes, Caraway's main selling point is its ceramic-based coating that is free from polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE, like Teflon), perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA), lead, and cadmium, making it a safer alternative to many traditional non-stick pans.
Which brand is better for baking?
This isn't a contest - Nordic Ware is the definitive winner for baking. Their entire brand legacy is built on creating the highest-quality bakeware, and their selection, performance, and durability are unmatched in that category.
How long do Caraway pans last?
The lifespan of a Caraway pan depends heavily on care. To protect the ceramic non-stick coating, you should avoid metal utensils, high heat, and dishwashers. With proper gentle care, they can last for several years, but the coating will eventually wear down, as is the case with all non-stick surfaces.
Where is Nordic Ware made?
A majority of Nordic Ware's products, including its famous cast aluminum bakeware, are designed and manufactured in Minneapolis, Minnesota. The company is proud of its American-made heritage.
Can you put Caraway pans in the oven?
Yes, Caraway pans are oven-safe up to 550°F, which makes them versatile for searing a steak on the stovetop and finishing it in the oven.
Is Nordic Ware dishwasher safe?
It depends on the product. Their classic, uncoated aluminum bakeware should be hand-washed to prevent discoloration and damage. However, some of their other product lines may be listed as dishwasher safe, so it's best to check the care instructions for each specific item.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
