Caraway prioritizes aesthetic, non-toxic ceramic cookware with a sleek, minimalist design, while GreenPan offers a wider variety of affordable ceramic non-stick options for budget-conscious consumers. Meanwhile, HexClad occupies the premium performance space with its innovative stainless steel and non-stick hybrid design built for durability and high-heat cooking.
Let's compare these three popular cookware brands to help you decide which is a better fit for your kitchen.
Caraway: The Stylish Non-Toxic Choice
Caraway is a direct-to-consumer brand that captured the market with its visually stunning, thoughtfully designed cookware sets. Its appeal lies in combining a modern, minimalist aesthetic with a non-toxic ceramic coating that is free from PTFE, PFOA, and other harmful chemicals. Caraway is designed for the modern home cook who values both style and health-conscious materials.
- Product mix: Sells curated cookware sets, bakeware, and individual pots and pans. Their core set typically includes a fry pan, saucepan, sauté pan, and Dutch oven, along with a clever modular storage system.
- Style/vibe: Minimalist and contemporary. Known for its signature palette of soft, muted colors like sage, cream, and perracotta that look great on the stovetop and on open shelving.
- Price point: Mid-range. A complete four-piece cookware set typically costs around $395–$495, positioning it as an accessible premium choice.
- Quality: Features a mineral-based ceramic non-stick coating over an aluminum core for even heating. The construction is sturdy enough for daily use and designed for low to medium-heat cooking to preserve the non-stick surface.
- Key features: Non-toxic coating, included pan racks and lid holder for organization, and an eye-catching design. Pans are oven-safe up to 550°F.
- Warranty: Offers a limited lifetime warranty that covers manufacturing defects.
- Best for: Health-conscious cooks, design enthusiasts, and anyone living in a smaller space who appreciates the included storage solutions.
Caraway excels at delivering beautiful, easy-to-use, non-toxic cookware that looks as good as it performs for everyday cooking tasks.
Shop Caraway: carawayhome.com
GreenPan: The Affordable Ceramic Cookware Pioneer
GreenPan was one of the first brands to introduce ceramic non-stick cookware to the market as a healthier alternative to traditional PTFE coatings. Since 2007, it has built a reputation for providing reliable, non-toxic, and wallet-friendly cookware. With an extensive product lineup, GreenPan caters to a broad audience, from students stocking their first kitchen to families needing durable everyday pans.
- Product mix: Offers a massive range of cookware lines, individual pieces, sets, griddles, woks, and specialty pans. Their selection is far broader than Caraway or HexClad's.
- Style/vibe: Practical and versatile. Designs range from classic stainless steel looks to pans with vibrant, colorful exteriors, emphasizing function and durability.
- Price point: Affordable to mid-range. Individual pans can be found for as little as $30, while full sets generally range from $100 to $300, making it the most accessible brand of the three.
- Quality: Uses its proprietary Thermolon ceramic non-stick, which is free of PFAS, PFOA, lead, and cadmium. Various lines feature reinforced coatings for improved scratch resistance and longevity.
- Sustainability: The company focuses on sustainable manufacturing, using recycled aluminum in many products and operating with eco-friendly practices.
- Availability: Widely available online and at major retailers like Amazon, Target, and Williams-Sonoma.
- Best for: Budget-conscious shoppers, beginners, and anyone looking for a specific type or size of non-toxic pan without a big investment.
GreenPan is the go-to for dependable, non-toxic ceramic cookware that combines performance with exceptional value for money.
Shop GreenPan: greenpan.us
HexClad: The High-Performance Hybrid
HexClad markets itself as the "pinnacle of hybrid cookware," blending the best attributes of stainless steel, cast iron, and non-stick pans into one product. Its patented laser-etched hexagon design allows for searing like stainless steel while providing the easy cleanup of a non-stick surface. This brand targets serious home cooks and professionals who demand versatility and extreme durability in the kitchen.
- Product mix: Offers a full range of hybrid frying pans, woks, saucepans, and stock pots available individually or in sets. They also sell grilling pans and high-end Japanese Damascus steel knives.
- Style/vibe: Modern, industrial, and professional. The sleek, dark hexagon pattern on the cooking surface gives it a distinctive, high-tech look.
- Price point: Premium. Individual pans start around $150, and cookware sets often range from $400 to over $600. It's a significant investment meant to last a lifetime.
- Quality & Durability: Features a tri-ply construction (aluminum core between two layers of stainless steel) for excellent heat control. The non-stick surface is PFOA-free and uniquely protected by the steel hexagon structure, making it scratch-resistant and safe for metal utensils.
- Performance: Oven safe up to 500°F, compatible with all cooktops (including induction), dishwasher safe, and allows for high-heat searing - a task where traditional non-stick pans fail.
- Warranty: Backed by a lifetime warranty, highlighting its promise of longevity.
- Best for: Avid home cooks, chefs, and anyone who wants cookware that can sear, sauté, and simmer without worrying about scratching the surface.
HexClad delivers on its promise of an all-in-one pan that provides professional-grade results and withstands the rigors of serious cooking.
Shop HexClad: hexclad.com
Caraway vs. GreenPan vs. HexClad Comparison
Price Comparison
When it comes to cost, the three brands serve entirely different market segments. GreenPan is the clear winner for affordability. With sets often under $200 and individual pans around $30-$50, it makes non-toxic cooking accessible to everyone. Caraway sits comfortably in the middle, offering a premium look and feel for a mid-range price of around $395 for its popular set, you're paying for the curated design and included storage system as much as the pan itself.
HexClad is a premium investment. With sets easily exceeding $600, its pricing reflects the advanced hybrid technology, tri-ply construction, and a lifetime warranty promising decades of performance. The value here is in longevity and versatility, making it a "buy it for life" choice for those who cook frequently.
Quality & Materials
All three brands boast non-toxic cooking surfaces, but their core construction and durability differ significantly. Caraway and GreenPan both use mineral-based ceramic coatings over aluminum bases. Caraway's is smooth and aesthetically pleasing, while many GreenPan lines feature reinforced Thermolon coatings designed for better durability. Still, any ceramic-only coating requires care - low-to-medium heat and no metal utensils - to prolong its life.
HexClad's material is in a league of its own. By combining stainless steel and non-stick in a hybrid design, it protects the PFOA-free non-stick valleys from damage. This makes it safe for metal utensils and resistant to the scratches that can ruin a typical non-stick pan. Its underlying tri-ply stainless steel body also provides superior heat distribution and retention compared to the aluminum cores of Caraway and GreenPan.
Style & Aesthetic
Style is where Caraway truly shines. Its curated color palette, matte finish, and streamlined handles have made it an Instagram favorite. The pans are designed to be displayed, fitting perfectly into modern, minimalist, and Scandinavian-style kitchens. Included with sets is a magnetic pan rack and canvas lid holder that reinforce its brand promise of beauty and organization.
GreenPan prioritizes function over fashion, but still offers a wide array of practical and sometimes colorful designs to suit any kitchen. Its aesthetic is more mainstream and less distinctive than Caraway's. HexClad boasts a professional, high-tech aesthetic. The sleek stainless finish and unique hexagon pattern look serious and sophisticated, telegraphing that it is a piece of high-performance equipment rather than a decor object.
Shopping Experience
Caraway primarily sells directly to consumers through its chic, user-friendly website, creating a seamless and curated brand experience. HexClad follows a similar model, emphasizing its technology and lifetime warranty through its own online store. GreenPan has the broadest reach. In addition to its website, its products are readily available at major retailers, making it easy to see in person or pick up on your next shopping run.
Sustainability & Ethics
All three brands are built on the premise of offering healthier, non-toxic cookware free from PFOA and PFAS. Caraway emphasizes this heavily in its marketing, alongside its eco-friendly packaging and manufacturing processes that release fewer emissions than traditional non-stick production. GreenPan is also a leader in this area, operating its own factories to control quality and using recycled materials.
HexClad's sustainability angle is focused on longevity. By creating an incredibly durable product backed by a lifetime warranty, it helps reduce the waste generated by consumers who have to replace worn-out non-stick pans every few years.
Which One Should You Choose?
The best choice depends entirely on your cooking habits, budget, and what you value most in a pan.
Choose Caraway if:
- Your kitchen aesthetic is just as important as cooking performance.
- You want a complete, matching set with a clever storage solution included.
- You are a health-conscious cook who needs safe, non-toxic daily pans.
- You cook mostly on low to medium heat and prefer hand-washing your cookware.
Choose GreenPan if:
- You are on a tight budget but still want safe, non-toxic cookware.
- You need just one or two specific pans rather than a full set.
- You want a wide variety of shapes, sizes, and collection styles to choose from.
- You're a beginner cook looking for a reliable, easy-to-use entry point into quality cookware.
Choose HexClad if:
- You are a serious, frequent cook who wants professional-grade performance and durability.
- You want the freedom to sear at high temperatures and use metal utensils.
- You are looking for a long-term investment that will last for decades.
- You value versatility and want a single pan that can do almost everything.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which cookware is more durable: Caraway, GreenPan, or HexClad?
HexClad is by far the most durable. Its hybrid stainless steel and non-stick design is scratch-resistant, dishwasher-safe, and safe for metal utensils. Caraway and GreenPan use ceramic-only coatings, which are more susceptible to scratches and wear over time and require more careful handling.
Which brand is the most affordable?
GreenPan is the most affordable brand of the three. It offers great value with individual pans starting as low as $30 and full sets available for $100-$300, making it an excellent choice for budget-conscious shoppers.
Are all three brands non-toxic?
Yes, all three brands offer non-toxic cooking surfaces. Caraway and GreenPan use mineral-based ceramic coatings free of PTFE, PFOA, PFAS, lead, and cadmium. HexClad's non-stick component is PFOA-free and is designed to create a safe, stable cooking surface.
Is Caraway's ceramic coating better than GreenPan's?
Both use high-quality ceramic non-stick coatings. GreenPan's Thermolon coating comes in various reinforced versions across its different lines, some of which are designed for enhanced durability. Caraway focuses on a single, consistently smooth coating across its product line. The primary differences often come down to the design and overall construction of the pan rather than a significant performance difference in the coatings themselves.
Can you sear meat properly in all three pans?
HexClad excels at searing. Its stainless steel peaks get hot enough to create an excellent crust on steaks or burgers, which is something pure ceramic cookware like Caraway and GreenPan cannot do as effectively. Ceramic pans should generally be used on low-to-medium heat to protect the coating.
Which brand is best for a beginner cook?
GreenPan is the best brand for a beginner cook. It's affordable, easy to use, and forgiving. Its low price point makes it an ideal way to get comfortable in the kitchen with quality, non-toxic pans without making a huge financial commitment.
Can you put all of these pans in the oven?
Yes, but to different temperature limits. Caraway pans are oven-safe up to 550°F. HexClad pans are oven-safe up to 500°F. GreenPan's oven-safe temperature varies by product line, but most are safe up to at least 350-400°F or higher.
Do Caraway, GreenPan, and HexClad offer lifetime warranties?
Caraway and HexClad both offer limited lifetime warranties that protect against manufacturing defects. GreenPan's warranty is typically a limited two-year warranty on the non-stick coating and a lifetime warranty on other parts of the pan, although this can vary by collection.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
