The Caraway Fry Pan and Saute Pan share the same non-toxic ceramic finish and modern aesthetic, but they are fundamentally different tools designed for distinct cooking tasks. The Fry Pan features sloped, curved sides ideal for tossing ingredients and achieving a perfect sear, while the Saute Pan has high, straight walls and a matching lid, making it built for one-pot meals, simmering sauces, and braising.
Here's a detailed comparison to help you choose the right piece of Caraway cookware for your kitchen.
Caraway Fry Pan
The Caraway Fry Pan is the daily workhorse of the kitchen, designed for quick, high-heat cooking tasks that require frequent movement. Its iconic sloped sides aren't just for looks, they facilitate easy tossing of vegetables and allow you to slide foods like omelets and fish filets directly onto a plate without breaking them. This pan is the go-to for breakfast, quick sears, and weeknight stir-fries.
- What it is: A non-toxic ceramic non-stick skillet with gently sloped sides, designed for frying, searing, and sautéing.
- Key features: Non-stick ceramic surface, sloped sides for easy flipping, no lid included, 10.5" diameter provides ample cooking surface.
- Price: $95
- Dimensions: 10.5" diameter, 1.8-quart capacity, weighs 2.8 lbs.
- Materials/Construction: Aluminum core for fast, even heating, non-toxic ceramic coating (free of PTFE, PFOA, PFAs), stainless steel handle.
- Style: Sleek, minimalist design available in multiple modern colors like Cream, Sage, and Marigold to match contemporary kitchen aesthetics.
- Pros: Excellent non-stick performance makes cooking and cleanup simple. Perfect shape for tossing and flipping ingredients. Lightweight and easy to maneuver. Heats up quickly and evenly.
- Cons: Lower sides lead to more splattering with wet ingredients. Not ideal for cooking with large amounts of liquid or sauce. Does not come with a lid.
This pan is your best choice for everyday high-heat tasks like cooking eggs, searing proteins, and making quick stir-fries where maneuverability is key.
Shop this product: carawayhome.com/products/fry-pan
Caraway Saute Pan
The Caraway Saute Pan is a versatile powerhouse designed for one-pan meals that often involve both searing and simmering. Its high, straight walls maximize the flat cooking surface, reduce splattering, and contain liquids perfectly. This, combined with its included lid, makes it the ideal vessel for everything from developing rich pasta sauces to braising meats and creating a flavorful curry.
- What it is: A deep, straight-sided pan with a wide base and a matching tight-fitting lid for versatile cooking.
- Key features: High, vertical sides to prevent splatters and hold liquid, large flat cooking surface, includes a matching lid.
- Price: $145
- Dimensions: 11.8" diameter, 4.5-quart capacity, weighs 4 lbs (pan only).
- Materials/Construction: Identical to the Fry Pan: aluminum core, non-toxic ceramic coating, stainless steel handle.
- Style: Matches the iconic look of all Caraway cookware, ensuring a cohesive set no matter which pieces you own.
- Pros: Extremely versatile - can sear, fry, simmer, braise, and stew. Deep sides effectively contain splatters and sauces. Comes with a lid to trap heat and moisture. Larger capacity is great for families or meal prepping.
- Cons: Heavier and bulkier than the fry pan. Straight sides make tossing or flipping ingredients more difficult. Takes up more space in the cabinet and on the stovetop.
This pan is for cooks who love making saucy one-pot dinners, braised dishes, and anything that requires shallow-frying and then simmering.
Shop this product: carawayhome.com/products/saute-pan
Caraway Fry Pan vs. Saute Pan Comparison
Function & Design
The most significant difference lies in the shape and intended function. The Fry Pan has classic sloped sides, which create a wider opening and encourage evaporation. This design is perfect for getting a crisp sear on a steak or tossing vegetables, as moisture can escape easily. The curved walls also make it the superior tool for flipping omelets or pancakes.
In contrast, the Saute Pan features straight, high sides and a broader flat base. This design maximizes stovetop contact for even searing and provides volume for adding liquids. The tall walls do an excellent job of preventing splatters and help contain sauces, making it the clear winner for dishes like chicken piccata, curries, or shakshuka where contents need to be contained and simmered under a lid.
Capacity & Sizing
While their diameters seem similar on paper, their capacity is worlds apart. The Fry Pan holds 1.8 quarts, suitable for preparing a meal for one or two people or cooking components of a larger meal. The Saute Pan boasts a much larger 4.5-quart capacity, making it a better fit for cooking family-sized meals, batch cooking, or preparing dishes with lots of volume like leafy greens or pasta sauces.
Materials & Construction
There is no difference here - both pans are built to the same high standards. Both feature a durable aluminum core for excellent heat conduction, a non-toxic ceramic coating for foolproof non-stick cooking, and a comfortable stainless steel handle. You can expect the same level of quality, cooking performance, and easy cleanup from either pan. Both pieces are also oven-safe up to 550°F, increasing their versatility.
Price & Value
The Fry Pan comes in at $95, while the Saute Pan is priced at $145. The price difference mainly reflects the Saute Pan's larger size, greater material usage, and the inclusion of a perfectly fitted lid. The Fry Pan offers great value as an everyday essential you'll likely use daily for specific tasks. The Saute Pan offers value through its versatility, it can perform many of the Fry Pan’s functions (like searing) while also handling tasks that the Fry Pan cannot, such as simmering and braising.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both pans are fantastic additions to any kitchen, but they excel at different things. Your personal cooking style should guide your choice.
Choose the Caraway Fry Pan if:
- You primarily cook breakfast foods like eggs, pancakes, and bacon.
- Your go-to meals involve searing proteins and quick-frying vegetables.
- You value lightweight maneuverability and the ability to easily toss food.
- You already own a stockpot or saucepan for liquid-based cooking.
Choose the Caraway Saute Pan if:
- You love making one-pan meals with sauces and gravies.
- You frequently cook for a family or enjoy batch cooking for the week.
- You hate stovetop splatter and want high walls to contain the mess.
- You need a single, versatile pan that can do almost everything from frying to braising.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the Caraway Fry Pan and Saute Pan?
The primary difference is their shape. The Fry Pan has sloped sides for easy flipping and tossing, making it ideal for high-heat, quick cooking. The Saute Pan has high, straight sides and a lid, designed to contain liquids and reduce splatters, making it best for saucy dishes and one-pot meals.
Can I sear a steak in the Saute Pan?
Yes, absolutely. The Saute Pan has a large, flat bottom that provides excellent surface contact for a great sear. However, the Fry Pan's sloped sides make it slightly easier to baste the steak with butter and herbs.
Do I need both the Fry Pan and the Saute Pan?
While one can often substitute for the other in a pinch, they are designed as complementary tools. Serious home cooks will find uses for both. If you have to choose just one, the Saute Pan is more versatile. However, if you already have pots for sauces, the Fry Pan is a daily-use essential you won't regret buying.
Does the Saute Pan come with a lid?
Yes, the Caraway Saute Pan includes a matching lid with its purchase. The Fry Pan does not come with a lid.
Can both pans go in the oven?
Yes, all Caraway cookware, including the Fry Pan and Saute Pan, is oven-safe up to 550°F, making them great for recipes that start on the stovetop and finish in the oven.
How do you clean these pans?
Thanks to the ceramic non-stick surface, cleaning is very easy. Simply wash with warm, soapy water and a non-abrasive sponge after the pan has cooled down. Avoid using metal utensils and high heat to preserve the life of the non-stick coating.
Is the $50 price difference for the Saute Pan worth it?
The value is in its versatility and included lid. If you regularly cook meals with sauces or braise meats, the Saute Pan's ability to handle those tasks makes it well worth the extra cost. If you're mainly frying and searing, the Fry Pan is a more economical and effective tool for the job.
Which pan is better for a small kitchen?
If storage space is a concern, the Fry Pan has a smaller footprint and is easier to store. The Saute Pan is larger and bulkier, especially with its lid, so it will take up more cabinet space.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
