While both Calphalon and Caraway offer non-toxic ceramic cookware, they cater to very different needs and priorities. Calphalon is an established brand known for its reliable, budget-friendly cookware that's widely available, focusing on function over form. Caraway is a newer direct-to-consumer brand that leads with modern design, vibrant colors, and an eco-conscious philosophy, all at a more premium price.
Here's a detailed comparison to help you decide which ceramic cookware brand is the right choice for your kitchen and cooking style.
Calphalon Ceramic Cookware
Calphalon is a fixture in the cookware industry, trusted by millions for its durable and high-performing kitchen essentials. Their ceramic non-stick collection brings this reputation to a line that is free of PTFE and PFOA, offering a trusted and health-conscious option for everyday home cooks who value reliability and accessibility above all else.
- What it is: A ceramic non-stick cookware line from a legacy brand, designed for durable performance and everyday cooking.
- Key features: Features a non-toxic, ceramic-based non-stick coating that is free of PTFE and PFOA, often paired with a hard-anodized aluminum core for excellent heat conduction and durability.
- Price: Ranges from $30 for individual pieces to between $150 and $300 for complete sets.
- Style: Traditional and functional with a modern, sleek touch. Finishes are typically neutral, featuring classic shades like black, gray, and white that fit into any kitchen decor.
- Materials/Construction: Hard-anodized aluminum bodies are commonly used, which provide even heating and are more durable than standard aluminum. The handles are designed for an ergonomic and comfortable grip.
- Pros: Affordable and provides great value for the price. Widely available online and in major department stores. Built on a reputation for long-lasting performance. Even and consistent heating.
- Cons: The aesthetic is more utilitarian and lacks the color variety of other brands. Some users report the non-stick coating can wear down over time with heavy use.
This cookware is a great choice for home cooks who need dependable, no-frills non-stick pans from a brand they can trust and easily find in stores.
Shop this brand: calphalon.com
Caraway Cookware
Caraway has quickly become a leader in the modern cookware market by pairing a health-conscious, non-toxic mission with a sophisticated and colorful design sense. Marketed towards a new generation of home cooks, Caraway focuses on a curated, aesthetically pleasing experience, from the beautifully designed products to the included storage solutions.
- What it is: A direct-to-consumer ceramic cookware brand that emphasizes non-toxic materials, sustainable practices, and minimalist, vibrant design.
- Key features: Ceramic non-stick coating is free of PTFE, PFOA, PFAS, lead, and cadmium. Sets come with a modular magnetic pan rack and a canvas lid holder for organized storage. Minimalist design with stainless steel handles.
- Price: Premium pricing, with sets starting at $395 and individual pieces hover around $95-$125+.
- Style: Modern, minimalist, and Scandinavian-inspired. Available in a signature palette of distinctive, matte colors like Perracotta, Sage, and Marigold that are designed to be displayed.
- Materials/Construction: An aluminum core for fast and even heat distribution is covered by a non-toxic, mineral-based ceramic coating.
- Pros: Stunning design and wide array of color choices. Made with a truly non-toxic coating free from harmful chemicals. Comes with a thoughtful pan and lid storage system. Excellent non-stick performance.
- Cons: Significantly more expensive than traditional cookware brands. Primarily sold online, limiting opportunities to see it in person before buying. The curated set limits individual size options.
Caraway cookware is aimed at the design-savvy, health-conscious home cook who sees their pots and pans as part of their kitchen's decor and is willing to invest in ethically sourced materials.
Shop this brand: carawayhome.com
Calphalon vs. Caraway Comparison
Materials & Construction
Both brands use an aluminum core for its superior heat conductivity, ensuring there are no hot spots. Calphalon often uses a hard-anodized aluminum, which makes the exterior extra durable and resistant to scratches. Their focus is on building a workhorse pan that lasts.
Caraway also uses an aluminum core but places huge emphasis on its non-toxic, mineral-based ceramic coating, which is free of not just PTFE and PFOA but also lead, cadmium, and PFAS. While both brands feature quality construction, Caraway’s branding and mission are more deeply rooted in the story of non-toxic materials and processes.
Style & Aesthetics
There's a clear distinction in design philosophy between the two. Calphalon cookware has a classic, utilitarian design that is sleek and professional. Its neutral black and gray color schemes are made to fit in, not stand out. The look is timeless and functional.
Caraway's primary selling point, beyond its non-toxic promise, is its style. The cookware features a minimalist design with beautiful, unique color choices in modern matte finishes. These pans are designed to be left on the stovetop or displayed on open shelving, acting as a statement piece in the kitchen.
Price & Value
Calphalon offers considerable value. A complete set can often be purchased for under $300, making it an accessible choice for anyone setting up a kitchen or looking to upgrade an existing set without a major financial commitment. The brand delivers solid, long-lasting performance for the price.
Caraway is an investment piece. At $395 for a 4-piece set, it is priced on the higher end of the consumer market. The value in Caraway lies in the combination of its safe materials, unique design, vibrant color options, and the inclusion of its custom storage solutions, which add to the overall user experience.
Shopping Experience & Availability
Calphalon is incredibly easy to find. You can purchase their cookware from their website, Amazon, and big-box retailers like Target, Walmart, and Bed Bath & Beyond. This broad availability allows you to see the product in person and often take advantage of retailer-specific sales.
Caraway operates primarily through a direct-to-consumer model on its own website. This creates a curated, high-end shopping experience complete with free shipping and a 30-day trial period. While they have recently entered selective exclusive retailers like Crate & Barrel, their availability remains limited compared to Calphalon.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both cookware brands are excellent non-toxic options, but they cater to different cooks with different priorities.
Choose Calphalon Ceramic if:
- You prioritize budget and dependable performance over aesthetics.
- You want to purchase cookware from a familiar, long-standing brand.
- You prefer to shop in-store and handle products before buying.
- You need a wider variety of individual pan sizes and types rather than a curated set.
Choose Caraway if:
- Design and aesthetics are a top priority, and you want cookware that complements your kitchen decor.
- A completely non-toxic and eco-conscious manufacturing process is important to you.
- You appreciate thoughtful add-ons like the included pan and lid storage organizers.
- You are willing to invest a premium price for cookware that combines style and health.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Calphalon Ceramic and Caraway?
The main difference is their core focus. Calphalon Ceramic prioritizes reliable performance and affordability from an established brand. Caraway's focus is on modern design, color, and a thoroughly non-toxic, eco-conscious story, which comes with a premium price tag.
Is Caraway cookware worth the higher price?
For many, yes. If your priorities include kitchen aesthetics, strictly non-toxic materials, and organized storage, the higher price is justified. The beautiful design and colors bring joy to cooking and can make you want to display your cookware. For those focused purely on function, a brand like Calphalon might offer better value.
Which brand's non-stick is more durable?
Both brands offer durable ceramic non-stick coatings, but proper care is crucial for longevity. No ceramic non-stick is indestructible. To maintain it, avoid metal utensils, high heat, and abrasive scrubbers. Users report good durability from both, but hard-anodized Calphalon bodies may resist exterior dings better over time.
Are both brands oven-safe?
Yes, both brands design their cookware to be oven-safe, which adds to their versatility. Caraway cookware is oven-safe up to 550°F. Calphalon's temperature limits vary by line but are typically oven-safe to around 400°F-500°F. Always check the specific product instructions.
Can you use metal utensils on Calphalon Ceramic or Caraway?
It's strongly recommended that you do not use metal utensils on any ceramic non-stick cookware, including Calphalon and Caraway. Metal can scratch and compromise the non-stick surface. Always use wood, silicone, or nylon utensils to preserve the non-stick coating.
Which brand is better for induction cooktops?
Both Caraway and many of Calphalon's newer lines are compatible with all stovetops, including induction. Caraway features a stainless steel plate on the bottom for induction compatibility. If buying Calphalon, just be sure to check the product specifications, as not all of their older lines are induction-ready.
How do you clean and care for ceramic cookware?
For both brands, allow the pan to cool completely before cleaning. Use a mild soap and a soft sponge or cloth to wash by hand. Avoid abrasive cleaners and the dishwasher, as the high heat and harsh detergents can degrade the non-stick coating over time. Proper hand-washing will dramatically extend the life of your cookware.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
