The main difference between Buffy and Brooklinen sheets lies in their core materials and brand focus. Buffy exclusively uses eco-friendly eucalyptus fabric, making them ideal for hot sleepers and sustainability-focused shoppers who want a soft, silky feel. Brooklinen offers a much wider variety of traditional materials, including cotton percale, sateen, and linen, appealing to customers who prioritize fabric choice, style options, and classic luxury.
Here's a detailed comparison to help you decide which brand's sheets are the right fit for your bed.
Buffy Sheets
Buffy is a modern bedding brand built entirely around sustainability and eco-conscious comfort. Their signature sheets are crafted from Tencel Lyocell, a smooth, cooling fabric made from responsibly sourced eucalyptus. This defines their product line, which is designed to be gentle on the skin, naturally hypoallergenic, and perfect for those who tend to sleep warm.
- What it is: Eco-friendly, sustainably-made bedding focusing on cool, breathable sheets made from eucalyptus fabric.
- Key features: Extremely soft and smooth-to-the-touch feel, moisture-wicking and temperature-regulating properties, and a naturally hypoallergenic construction.
- Price: Around $150 - $180 for a core sheet set.
- Style: Minimalist and modern with a limited palette of muted, soothing earth tones and solids.
- Materials/Construction: The brand's signature sheets are made of 100% eucalyptus Tencel Lyocell fibers, sourced from sustainably managed forests and produced in a closed-loop system that recycles water. They are OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certified for chemical safety.
- Pros: A top choice for sustainability. Fantastically soft, silky, and cooling, making it great for hot sleepers. Naturally gentle on sensitive skin.
- Cons: Limited material choice - it's eucalyptus or nothing. Fewer colors and patterns compared to other brands. Pocket depth fits standard mattresses but may be snug on very thick ones.
Buffy sheets are for the eco-conscious sleeper who prioritizes cooling comfort and a silky feel over a wide range of styles.
Shop this product: buffy.co
Brooklinen Sheets
Brooklinen has become a dominant force in the direct-to-consumer bedding world by offering "internet-famous" premium sheets without the traditional luxury markups. Their main appeal is variety - they provide high-quality bedding in multiple fabrics, including crisp cotton percale, smooth luxe sateen, and airy linen, along with a vast selection of classic and limited-edition colors and patterns.
- What it is: High-quality, direct-to-consumer bedding offering a wide range of fabrics, styles, colors, and patterns.
- Key features: Diverse material selection (sateen, percale, linen), many color and pattern choices, deep pocket options for thicker mattresses, emphasis on durability and long-staple cotton quality.
- Price: Ranges from about $130 (Classic Percale) to over $200 (Linen) for a core set, with frequent sales and bundle deals available.
- Style: Timeless and versatile, with options ranging from simple solids to contemporary prints and stripes that fit a wide array of bedroom decor styles.
- Materials/Construction: Core materials include 100% long-staple cotton for durability (in both percale and sateen weaves) and Washed Linen made from European flax. The brand also offers more sustainable options like their Heathered Cashmere and Organic Cotton collections.
- Pros: Huge selection lets you choose your ideal fabric feel. Durably constructed for longevity. Caters to different design tastes with many colors and patterns. Generous 365-day return policy.
- Cons: While they have sustainable initiatives, it's not the brand's primary focus. Can be more expensive than Buffy, especially for linen or sateen sets.
Brooklinen is aimed at shoppers looking for premium, durable sheets with extensive options in fabric type, color, and pattern.
Shop this product: brooklinen.com
Buffy vs. Brooklinen Comparison
Materials & Comfort
Your choice here comes down to a matter of focus versus variety. Buffy specializes in one material and does it exceptionally well. Their eucalyptus Tencel Lyocell sheets have a distinct smooth, silky, almost drape-like feel that is cool to the touch and wicks away moisture. It's an excellent option for anyone who consistently battles night sweats or finds traditional cotton too warm.
Brooklinen offers a bedding buffet. For a crisp, cool, hotel-sheet feel, their Classic Percale is a fan favorite. If you prefer a warmer, silkier, and shinier look, the Luxe Sateen is a better fit. For a relaxed, airy, and textured bed, their Linen collection is ideal. You can truly customize your sleep experience based on your specific comfort preference.
Style & Aesthetics
Buffy's aesthetic is clean, modern, and soothing. Their color palette consists mainly of pale, nature-inspired tones like white, grey, blush, and light blue. This minimalist approach complements contemporary and Scandinavian-style bedrooms perfectly but offers little for those wanting bold designs or intricate patterns.
Brooklinen is the clear winner for design flexibility. They offer dozens of core colors and regularly release limited-edition patterns, from windowpane checks to pinstripes and florals. Whether your room is classic, contemporary, or bohemian, you can likely find a Brooklinen set to match.
Sustainability & Ethics
Sustainability is Buffy's reason for being. Their eucalyptus is sourced from renewable forests that are much less water-intensive than cotton. The Tencel manufacturing process uses a closed-loop system, recycling over 99% of its water and solvents. If your primary goal is to buy an environmentally responsible product, Buffy is hard to beat.
Brooklinen has made positive strides in sustainability, offering organic cotton and linen collections and ensuring their products are OEKO-TEX certified. However, their brand identity is built on choice and quality first, with ethical production being an important but secondary pillar. Buffy's commitment is deeper and central to their entire brand mission.
Price & Value
The pricing for both brands is relatively competitive, but they occupy slightly different positions. Buffy offers one core product type with consistent, mid-tier pricing. Brooklinen's prices vary more widely by material - their entry-level Percale sheets are often cheaper than Buffy's sets, while their Luxe Sateen and Linen command a higher price. Brooklinen is also known for hosting site-wide sales around holidays, which can offer significant savings. In terms of long-term value, both brands produce durable sheets that stand up to regular washing.
Shopping Experience & Policies
Both brands provide excellent, streamlined online shopping. Product pages are detailed and informative. The biggest differentiator is the trial period. Buffy offers a standard 30-night sleep trial to make sure you love their sheets. Brooklinen has one of the most generous policies in the industry, giving customers an entire 365 days to try out their products and return them if they're not satisfied. This exceptionally long trial can provide significant peace of mind for first-time buyers.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands deliver exceptional sheets, but they are designed for different shoppers.
Choose Buffy if:
- Sustainability and eco-friendly manufacturing are your top priorities.
- You are a hot sleeper and need sheets that are cool to the touch and moisture-wicking.
- You love a silky, smooth, and lightweight feel versus the crispness of cotton.
- You prefer a simple, minimalist aesthetic with a natural color palette.
Choose Brooklinen if:
- You want more choices in fabric - from crisp cotton to smooth sateen or airy linen.
- You enjoy having a wide variety of colors and patterns to match your decor.
- You have an extra-deep mattress that requires deep-pocket sheets for a secure fit.
- You want the security of an exceptionally long 365-day return policy.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Buffy and Brooklinen sheets?
The fundamental difference is material and variety. Buffy focuses on a single, highly sustainable material - eucalyptus Tencel Lyocell - known for its cooling and soft properties. Brooklinen provides a wide selection of materials, primarily cotton (percale and sateen) and linen, giving you more choices for feel and style.
Are Buffy sheets actually cooling?
Yes. The eucalyptus Tencel fabric is naturally temperature-regulating and moisture-wicking. The fibers absorb moisture more effectively than cotton, pulling heat and sweat away from your body, which helps you stay cooler and drier throughout the night.
Which Brooklinen fabric is best?
It depends entirely on your personal preference. Their Classic Percale is light, crisp, and breathable, like traditional high-end hotel sheets. The Luxe Sateen is slightly heavier, incredibly smooth, and has a subtle sheen for a more luxurious, silky feeling. Their Washed Linen is the most breathable and has a casual, textured look that gets softer with every wash.
How do I care for Buffy eucalyptus sheets?
Buffy recommends washing their sheets in a cool or cold cycle with a mild detergent and tumble drying on a low-heat, low-tumble setting. Avoid using bleach or fabric softeners, as they can damage the natural fibers.
Will Brooklinen sheets fit my deep mattress?
Yes, Brooklinen is a great choice for deep mattresses. Their fitted sheets are designed to fit mattresses up to 15 inches deep, and they clearly label them so you can shop with confidence.
Which brand is more sustainable?
Buffy has built its entire brand around sustainability. From sourcing eucalyptus to their closed-loop manufacturing process, their environmental commitment is at the core of every product. While Brooklinen offers sustainable options, Buffy is the undisputed winner for the most eco-conscious choice.
Are Brooklinen sheets worth the money?
Many customers find Brooklinen sheets to be worth the price due to their high-quality materials, like long-staple cotton, and durable construction. They are built to last longer than cheaper alternatives, making them a good long-term value. Their generous 365-day trial period also removes much of the financial risk.
What is the return policy for each brand?
Buffy offers a 30-night, risk-free sleep trial. Brooklinen famously offers a 365-day return policy, allowing you an entire year to decide if their bedding is right for you, on the condition that products can be returned for store credit after the first wash.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
