Buffy is an eco-conscious brand that specializes in lightweight, breathable comforters made from innovative, sustainable materials like recycled fibers. In contrast, Brooklinen offers a broader range of bedding with a focus on hotel-quality luxury, providing comforters in various materials including down, down alternative, and linen.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right home decor retailer for your space.
Buffy: The Eco-Conscious Comfort Brand
Buffy is a modern sleep brand known for its core focus on sustainable and environmentally responsible bedding. Their flagship comforters are designed for a cozy yet airy sleep experience, appealing to eco-conscious consumers who prioritize hypoallergenic qualities and temperature regulation in a minimalist package.
- Product mix: Buffy's selection is focused primarily on sleep goods, including their signature Buffy Cloud Comforter, pillows, duvet covers, and sheet sets.
- Style/vibe: Minimalist, clean, and modern. Their products feature soft, neutral colors and a sleek, simple aesthetic designed to create a calming sleep environment.
- Price point: Mid-range, with their popular queen-size comforter typically retailing for around $200–$250.
- Quality & Materials: The comforter's fill is Buffy's signature Cloud material, made from recycled PET plastic bottles, which mimics the softness of down. The shell is a soft, organic cotton fabric that is OEKO-TEX certified to be free of harmful chemicals.
- Sustainability: This is Buffy's key differentiator. They use recycled fibers and eco-friendly manufacturing processes, making them a leader in sustainable bedding.
- Trial Period: Buffy offers a 30-night risk-free trial, allowing you to sleep with the comforter before making a final decision.
Buffy delivers an innovative, hypoallergenic, and seriously soft comforter perfect for modern shoppers who value sustainability as much as comfort.
Shop Buffy: buffy.co
Brooklinen: The Modern Bedding Authority
Brooklinen has established itself as a go-to direct-to-consumer brand for high-quality, luxurious home essentials at reasonable prices. They offer a comprehensive range of products beyond bedding, with an aesthetic that blends modern sophistication with timeless comfort, aiming to bring a five-star hotel feel into your home.
- Product mix: An extensive collection of home goods, including multiple comforter options (down, down alternative, linen), sheets, pillows, towels, and even home accessories.
- Style/vibe: Versatile and stylish, ranging from timeless neutrals to more textured options like linen. Their aesthetic is one of everyday luxury suitable for both modern and traditional decor.
- Price point: Competitively mid-range, with queen-size comforters typically ranging from $150 to $250 depending on the fill material. They are known for frequent sales and promotions.
- Quality & Materials: Brooklinen uses premium materials like ethically sourced down with high fill power for warmth, plush microfiber in their down alternative options, and 100% European flax for their linen comforters.
- Trial Period: The brand stands behind its products with an exceptionally generous 365-day trial period and a straightforward return process.
- Shopping Experience: Brooklinen offers a polished online shopping experience with detailed guides, customer reviews, and filters to help you find the perfect product.
Brooklinen provides a diverse selection of high-quality, stylish bedding, giving customers the ultimate choice in material and feel.
Shop Brooklinen: brooklinen.com
Buffy vs. Brooklinen Comparison
Price Comparison
Both brands operate in a similar mid-range price tier, but with key differences. The Buffy Comforter has a relatively fixed price, typically around $200-$250 for a queen. Its value is tied to the unique, sustainable materials and hypoallergenic properties.
Brooklinen’s pricing has more variance based on your choice of material. A queen down-alternative comforter can start around $150, while their ethically sourced down and linen options are closer to Buffy's price point or slightly higher. If you're looking for the lowest entry cost, Brooklinen's down-alternative is often cheaper. However, for premium materials, both brands are priced competitively.
Quality & Materials
Your choice here comes down to innovation vs. tradition. Buffy uses a proprietary "Cloud fill" made from recycled PET fibers, encased in an organic cotton shell. The result is a uniquely lightweight, fluffy yet breathable comforter that is entirely vegan and hypoallergenic. It's an excellent choice for those with sensitivities or who prioritize sustainable manufacturing.
Brooklinen focuses on offering a range of proven, high-quality materials. Whether you want the classic plush warmth of ethically sourced down, the cozy and affordable feel of their down-alternative microfiber, or the airy, textured touch of 100% linen, they have an option. Brooklinen's materials are about providing a luxurious, hotel-style experience with more choice for the consumer.
Style & Aesthetic
Buffy's style is quintessentially minimalist and modern. Their comforters are designed with a clean, unassuming look that blends seamlessly into contemporary bedrooms. The focus isn't on a bold design statement but on creating an atmosphere of soft, serene comfort. The aesthetic is perfect for anyone who loves Scandinavian or uncluttered design.
Brooklinen's aesthetic is more versatile and leans towards timeless elegance. Their products come in classic neutrals and are designed to be easily layered and styled. While still modern, the feel is more sophisticated and aligns with a "luxury hotel at home" vibe. With more material variety comes more textural diversity, allowing you to achieve different looks, from the crispness of percale to the relaxed drape of linen.
Trial Period & Returns
This is one of the most significant differences between the two brands. Buffy offers a 30-night trial, which is adequate for you to decide if you like the feel and temperature regulation of their comforter.
Brooklinen takes confidence to another level with an exceptional 365-day trial period on most of their products. This gives you a full year to test the comforter through every season, making it a virtually risk-free purchase. For shoppers who are hesitant or want maximum peace of mind, Brooklinen has a clear advantage.
Sustainability & Ethics
While both brands make ethical efforts, Buffy is the clear winner if sustainability is your number one priority. Their entire brand identity is built around eco-friendly practices, from using recycled plastic bottles to create their fill to using organic, chemical-free cotton. They are highly transparent about their mission to reduce environmental impact.
Brooklinen practices responsible sourcing, using ethically sourced down and natural linen fibers. They are OEKO-TEX certified for many products, ensuring chemical safety. However, their core focus is on luxury and quality, with sustainability being an important but secondary feature, unlike at Buffy where it is the central mission.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends on your style preferences, budget, and priorities. Both brands offer quality bedding, but they cater to different sleepers and values.
Choose Buffy if:
- You are an environmentally conscious shopper who wants products made from recycled and sustainable materials.
- You are a hot sleeper or live in a warmer climate and need a lightweight, highly breathable comforter.
- You have allergies or sensitive skin and need a certified hypoallergenic option.
- You prefer a simple, minimalist aesthetic that feels clean and modern.
Choose Brooklinen if:
- You want the choice between different materials like traditional down, airy linen, or a plush down-alternative.
- You are trying to achieve a luxurious "hotel bedding" feel and aesthetic in your bedroom.
- You want the peace of mind that comes with an industry-leading 365-day trial period.
- You plan on buying a full set of matching sheets, pillows, and other accessories from one brand.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Buffy or Brooklinen cheaper?
Brooklinen often has a lower entry-level price with its down alternative comforters starting around $150. Buffy's comforter is typically priced around $200-$250. However, when comparing Brooklinen's premium down or linen versions, the prices become very similar.
Which comforter is better for hot sleepers? Buffy or Brooklinen?
The Buffy comforter is specifically engineered to be lightweight and breathable, making it an excellent choice for hot sleepers. While Brooklinen's linen comforter is also very breathable, Buffy's core design prioritizes temperature regulation across its flagship model.
What are Buffy and Brooklinen comforters made of?
Buffy's comforter is filled with its signature "Cloud fill," made of recycled PET plastic fibers, and has an organic cotton shell. Brooklinen offers a variety, including ethically sourced down clusters, a plush microfiber down-alternative, and 100% European flax linen.
Do both Buffy and Brooklinen offer a trial period?
Yes, but the lengths are very different. Buffy offers a 30-night trial period, while Brooklinen offers a much more generous 365-day trial period on most of its bedding.
Is Buffy really eco-friendly?
Yes, sustainability is at the core of Buffy's mission. They utilize recycled materials to create their signature fill and use organic, chemical-free fabrics. This is their primary differentiator in the market.
Can I machine wash Buffy and Brooklinen comforters?
Yes, many comforters from both brands are machine washable, but it's crucial to check the specific care instructions on the product tag. Washing a comforter at home often requires a large-capacity washer and dryer, and some materials, like down, have specific care requirements.
Which brand has a better return policy?
Brooklinen has a better return policy due to its 365-day trial window, compared to Buffy's 30 nights. This extended period gives customers much more flexibility and time to ensure the product is right for them.
Which comforter feels more like a hotel bed?
Brooklinen's brand ethos is built around replicating the five-star hotel experience. Their down and down-alternative comforters, especially when paired with their popular percale or sateen sheets, are designed specifically to provide that luxurious, crisp, and plush hotel bed feeling.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
