Brooklinen offers direct-to-consumer luxury sheets with a modern, minimalist aesthetic at a more accessible price point, while Pottery Barn provides classic, timeless bedding with an emphasis on heirloom quality and a traditional retail experience. Key differences lie in Brooklinen's generous 365-day return policy and sharper focus on OEKO-TEX certified materials, versus Pottery Barn's in-store shopping advantage and use of premium cottons like Egyptian and Supima.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right bedding for your home.
Brooklinen: The Modern, Affordable Luxury Bedding Brand
Founded in 2014, Brooklinen disrupted the bedding industry with its direct-to-consumer model, promising hotel-quality sheets without the retail markup. The brand appeals to design-savvy millennials and anyone seeking high-quality, comfortable bedding with a clean, contemporary look. They focus on transparency, customer experience, and making luxury a bit more attainable.
- Product mix: Primarily known for bedding, including sheet sets, duvet covers, quilts, and pillows. They also offer bath towels and loungewear.
- Style/vibe: Modern, minimalist, and Scandinavian-inspired. Their collections feature clean lines, solid neutral colors, and subtle patterns that fit easily into contemporary decor.
- Price point: Mid-range luxury. A classic queen sheet set typically costs between $99 and $179, depending on the material. Bundles provide additional savings.
- Quality & Materials: Utilizes 100% long-staple cotton for both their crisp percale and smooth sateen weaves. They also offer linen and flannel. Many of their products are OEKO-TEX certified for chemical safety.
- Fit & Sizing: Offers a full range of sizes, including California King and Split King. Sheets are known for having deep pockets to accommodate thicker mattresses.
- Return policy: Extremely generous 365-day return and exchange policy, even on gently used items, which allows customers to truly test their bedding.
- Sales: Holds major sales events a few times a year, most notably around Black Friday and their anniversary, offering significant discounts.
- Shopping Experience: Primarily online through their user-friendly website. They have a few physical showrooms in major cities but are built around e-commerce convenience.
Brooklinen delivers a straightforward way to get high-end, stylish bedding with one of the best trial periods in the industry, making it a low-risk choice for online shoppers.
Shop Brooklinen: brooklinen.com
Pottery Barn: The Classic American Home Choice
A home furnishing giant since 1949, Pottery Barn is a go-to for shoppers seeking a complete home aesthetic that feels classic, comfortable, and well-made. Their bedding collections reflect this ethos, offering timeless designs that complement traditional and transitional homes. Their appeal is rooted in quality craftsmanship and the ability to build a cohesive, elegant bedroom look.
- Product mix: A complete home furnishings retailer offering everything from furniture and rugs to lighting, decor, and extensive bedding collections.
- Style/vibe: Timeless, elegant, and classic American style. Expect more textured weaves, subtle patterns (like pinstripes or embroidered details), and a warm, inviting color palette.
- Price point: Mid-range to upper-mid-range. A basic queen sheet set starts around $129 and can go up to $249+ for premium organic or specialty materials.
- Quality & Materials: Known for premium materials like soft and durable Egyptian cotton, Supima cotton, and Belgian flax linen. They offer many organic and sustainably sourced options.
- Fit & Sizing: Comprehensive sizing available, including options with deep pockets. The sheets have a substantial, slightly heavier feel that conveys quality.
- Return policy: Policies are more traditional, typically offering a 30-day return window for most non-furniture items with proof of purchase.
- Sales: Frequent sales and promotions occur throughout the year, especially around seasonal changes and holidays like Memorial Day and Labor Day.
- Shopping Experience: Omni-channel. You can shop on their detailed website or visit one of their many physical showrooms to see and feel the bedding before buying.
Pottery Barn is the ideal choice for those building a classic, coordinated space who value in-person shopping and an established brand reputation for durability.
Shop Pottery Barn: potterybarn.com
Brooklinen vs. Pottery Barn Sheets Comparison
Price Comparison
Brooklinen generally holds an edge in affordability. Their popular Luxe Sateen Sheets (Queen) are often priced lower than comparable sets at Pottery Barn. With their direct-to-consumer model cutting out middleman costs, Brooklinen passes those savings to the customer. While both brands run sales, Brooklinen's sticker price for "affordable luxury" is consistently more accessible.
Pottery Barn is positioned as a more premium brand, and their prices reflect that. A queen set in organic percale or Egyptian cotton will typically cost more than a similar offering from Brooklinen. Shoppers at Pottery Barn are paying for the brand's long-standing reputation, classic designs, and physical retail presence.
Quality & Materials
Both brands prioritize high-quality textiles, but with different focuses. Brooklinen is transparent about using 100% long-staple cotton, a key indicator of softness and durability, and proudly highlights its OEKO-TEX certification for chemical safety. Their sheets feel lightweight yet durable, earning a reputation for being exceptionally soft and breathable right out of the box.
Pottery Barn leans on premium material names like Egyptian and Supima cotton, known globally for their extra-long staples that create incredibly soft and resilient yarns. Their sheets often have a slightly heavier, more substantial hand-feel, suggesting a product built for longevity. While they also offer organic options, their emphasis is more on timeless luxury materials than on specific eco-certifications across the line.
Style & Aesthetic
The style difference is quite clear. Brooklinen's aesthetic is distinctly modern and minimalist. Think solid colors, simple windowpane patterns, and crisp white sheets that fit perfectly in a contemporary or Scandinavian-style bedroom. Their design philosophy is versatile and unfussy, making their sheets easy to mix and match.
Pottery Barn offers a classic, and at times more traditional, look. Their collections feature more subtle jacquard weaves, embroidered borders, and a palette of warm, muted tones. This style works beautifully in traditional, transitional, or farmhouse homes, creating an inviting and polished atmosphere.
Shopping Experience & Return Policies
This is a major point of difference. Brooklinen is built for the online shopper, offering detailed product pages and an incredible 365-day return policy. This year-long trial period removes nearly all the risk of buying bedding sight unseen and shows immense confidence in their product.
Pottery Barn provides the classic retail experience. Being able to go into a store, touch the fabric swatches, and see the colors in person is a significant advantage for many shoppers. However, their return policy is a standard 30 days for bedding, which is far less flexible than Brooklinen's.
Sustainability & Ethics
Brooklinen makes its commitment to sustainability a key part of its brand identity. Widespread OEKO-TEX certification ensures their products are free from harmful chemicals, which is a major comfort for many consumers. They are transparent about their manufacturing partners and efforts to minimize their environmental footprint.
Pottery Barn has also made significant strides in this area, offering a large selection of GOTS-certified organic cotton bedding and participating in Fair Trade USA programs. Their sustainability efforts are integrated into their larger corporate structure, but it may require more digging on their website to find specific details compared to the front-and-center approach of digital-native brands like Brooklinen.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice comes down to your personal style, shopping preferences, and what you value most in bedding.
Choose Brooklinen if:
- You prefer a modern, minimalist, or contemporary aesthetic.
- You want the best value and prioritize affordability for luxury-quality sheets.
- An exceptional, risk-free return policy (365 days) is important to you.
- You are comfortable shopping exclusively online and rely on customer reviews.
- Chemical safety is a priority and you look for OEKO-TEX certification.
Choose Pottery Barn if:
- You love a classic, traditional, or timeless home decor style.
- You prefer seeing and feeling materials in a physical store before buying.
- You are purchasing other home furnishings and want a coordinated look.
- You value heirloom-quality materials like Egyptian or Supima cotton.
- You have a slightly higher budget and prioritize brand legacy and durability.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Brooklinen or Pottery Barn cheaper?
Generally, Brooklinen is cheaper. Their direct-to-consumer model allows them to offer high-quality sheets at a lower price point than Pottery Barn, with queen sets often starting under $150. While Pottery Barn has sales, its everyday prices are typically higher.
Which brand has better quality sheets?
Both brands offer excellent quality, but they define it differently. Brooklinen focuses on the durability and softness of long-staple cotton with OEKO-TEX certification. Pottery Barn focuses on premium, heritage materials like Egyptian and Supima cotton known for their luxurious feel and longevity. The "better" one depends on your personal preference for fabric weight and feel.
What is Pottery Barn's return policy for sheets?
Pottery Barn generally offers a 30-day return window for most bedding with proof of purchase. This is significantly shorter than Brooklinen's 365-day trial period.
Which sheets are softer, Brooklinen or Pottery Barn?
Softness is subjective. Brooklinen's Luxe Sateen sheets are renowned for their silky-smooth feel right away. Pottery Barn's Egyptian cotton sheets are exceptionally soft and tend to get even softer with each wash. The best way to know is to try them, though Brooklinen's generous return policy makes this an easier proposition.
Are Brooklinen sheets worth it?
Yes, for most people, Brooklinen sheets offer an excellent balance of quality, comfort, and price. The positive reviews, certifications, and unbeatable return policy make them a reliable choice for upgrading your bedding.
Does Pottery Barn have deep pocket sheets?
Yes, both Pottery Barn and Brooklinen offer deep pocket options on their fitted sheets to accommodate taller mattresses and toppers, typically fitting mattresses up to 15 or 16 inches deep.
Which brand is better for a modern bedroom style?
Brooklinen is the clear winner for modern bedrooms. Their minimalist color palette, clean lines, and simple patterns are designed to complement contemporary aesthetics.
Can I wash and dry sheets from both brands at home?
Yes, sheets from both Brooklinen and Pottery Barn are machine washable and dryable. It's always best to follow the specific care instructions on the product tag, such as washing in cool or warm water and tumbling dry on low, to prolong their life.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
