Brooklinen is a direct-to-consumer pioneer known for high-quality, classic bedding at an accessible price point, while Matteo is a premium brand centered on sustainable luxury, using organic and eco-friendly materials. Brooklinen appeals to shoppers seeking proven value and a generous trial period, whereas Matteo focuses on eco-conscious consumers willing to invest in ethically-produced textiles with a modern, understated aesthetic.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right home textiles brand for your bedroom.
Brooklinen: The Accessible Luxury Bedding Pioneer
Launched in 2014, Brooklinen disrupted the bedding industry by offering luxury-level comfort direct to consumers at more affordable prices. The brand is a go-to for young professionals and design-savvy shoppers seeking stylish, high-quality home essentials without the luxury markup. Their aesthetic is primarily classic and minimalist, making their sheets, comforters, and towels easy to integrate into most decor styles.
- Product mix: A comprehensive collection for the home, including bedding (sheets, duvet covers, quilts), bath towels, sleepwear, and home accessories like candles and blankets.
- Style/vibe: Classic, minimalist, and modern. You'll find a wide range of solid colors, subtle patterns, and timeless designs that don't go out of style.
- Price point: Mid-range. Their popular Luxe Sateen Sheet Sets start around $150, with duvet covers and bundles priced accordingly.
- Quality & Materials: Known for long-staple cotton percale and sateen weaves, linen, and blends. Materials are selected for comfort, softness, and durability.
- Return policy: One of the best in the industry with a 365-night trial on most items. Customers can return products within a year for a full refund.
- Sales: Holds several major sitewide sales per year, often around major holidays, offering significant discounts.
- Shopping Experience: Features a user-friendly website with thousands of positive customer reviews and has expanded to physical stores and partnerships with retailers like Nordstrom.
Brooklinen provides reliable quality and timeless style at a competitive price, backed by an unbeatable customer trial period.
Shop Brooklinen: brooklinen.com
Matteo: The Eco-Conscious Luxury Choice
Matteo is built on a foundation of sustainable luxury, prioritizing eco-friendly materials and ethical manufacturing practices above all else. The brand appeals to environmentally-conscious consumers who want premium, long-lasting bedding and understand how it's made. The aesthetic is clean, modern, and sophisticated, featuring a muted and refined color palette that suits contemporary and minimalist interiors.
- Product mix: A curated selection of bedding and sleep accessories, including sheet sets, duvet covers, pillowcases, and throws.
- Style/vibe: Modern, understated, and elegant. Features sleek finishes and muted earth tones, reflecting a refined minimalist style.
- Price point: Premium. Sheet sets typically range from $150 to $250, reflecting the cost of organic materials and responsible production.
- Quality & Materials: Focuses on organic and eco-friendly fabrics like linen, organic cotton, and Tencel. All products are OEKO-TEX certified, meaning they are free from harmful chemicals.
- Sustainability: This is Matteo's core value. They emphasize transparency in their supply chain, use eco-friendly dyes, and use certified sustainable materials.
- Return policy: Offers a satisfaction guarantee and flexible returns, though the trial period is not as extensive as Brooklinen's.
- Shopping Experience: Their website provides a sleek shopping experience rich with educational content about their materials and sustainability initiatives.
Matteo is the ideal choice for shoppers who want to invest in ethically-made bedding that is as kind to the planet as it is comfortable.
Shop Matteo: matteo.co
Brooklinen vs. Matteo Comparison
Price Comparison
Brooklinen is generally more accessible from a price perspective. Their sheet sets start at around $100 and they frequently run sitewide promotions and bundle discounts that provide excellent value. It's a brand where you feel you're getting a premium product for a mid-range price.
Matteo occupies a higher price tier, with sheet sets often starting around $150 and climbing from there. Their pricing reflects the high cost of certified organic materials, innovative fibers like Tencel, and ethical manufacturing processes. While Matteo may not offer promotions as often, the brand's value is positioned in sustainability and long-term durability.
Quality & Materials
Both brands deliver exceptional quality, but their material-sourcing philosophies differ. Brooklinen focuses on traditional luxury materials like long-staple cotton, renowned for its softness and strength. Their percale is crisp and cool, while their sateen is silky and smooth. It’s consistent, comfortable quality that has earned a loyal following.
Matteo prioritizes sourcing fabrics that are both luxurious and environmentally responsible. They use organic cotton, sustainable linen, and eco-friendly Tencel - all of which are OEKO-TEX certified to ensure they are free of harmful substances. This appeals directly to shoppers who want to know their bedding is safe for their health and the planet.
Style & Aesthetic
Brooklinen’s design ethos is classic and highly versatile. With a broad palette of colors and a mix of timeless patterns and simple solids, their collections can seamlessly blend into nearly any interior design, from traditional to modern Farmhouse. It’s an easy and safe choice for building a beautiful bedroom.
Matteo leans into a more defined modern minimalist aesthetic. Their color palette is more muted and sophisticated, focusing on earthy, understated tones that create a serene and calming environment. The designs are simple, elegant, and perfectly aligned with contemporary, eco-conscious decor styles.
Shopping Experience
Brooklinen provides an excellent shopping experience, both online and increasingly in-person. Their website is easy to navigate, packed with helpful customer reviews, and their market-leading 365-night trial gives shoppers ultimate peace of mind. You can try their products for a full year and return them if you're not satisfied.
Matteo's online experience is sleek and informative, educating customers about the benefits of their eco-friendly materials and ethical practices. While their return policy is clear and customer-friendly, it doesn't match the year-long trial offered by Brooklinen. The trade-off is a deeper connection to the brand's sustainable mission.
Sustainability & Ethics
This is the clearest point of distinction between the two brands. While Brooklinen has adopted more sustainable practices like eco-friendly packaging, its main focus has always been on delivering quality and value. Sustainability is a feature, but not its core selling point.
For Matteo, sustainability is the entire mission. Every product is crafted with environmental responsibility in mind, from the certified organic fibers to the non-toxic dyes and transparent supply chain. If making eco-conscious purchasing decisions is a non-negotiable for you, Matteo is the obvious front-runner.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands offer excellent, high-quality bedding, but they're designed for different customers with different priorities.
Choose Brooklinen if:
- You want accessible luxury and great value for your money.
- You prefer classic designs and a wide variety of colors and patterns.
- An exceptional return policy is important - you love the security of a 365-night trial.
- You enjoy shopping for sales and bundle deals to get the best price.
Choose Matteo if:
- Sustainability is your top priority and you want certified eco-friendly and organic materials.
- You prefer a modern, minimalist aesthetic with sophisticated, muted color palettes.
- You are willing to invest more in bedding from a brand with a transparent and ethical supply chain.
- You value knowing your bedding is OEKO-TEX certified and free from potentially harmful chemicals.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Brooklinen or Matteo cheaper?
Brooklinen is generally cheaper. Their products are positioned at a mid-range price point, and the brand regularly offers sales and discounts that provide significant savings, making luxury bedding more accessible.
Which brand has better quality bedding?
Both brands offer high-quality bedding, so "better" depends on your values. Brooklinen uses premium materials like long-staple cotton praised for its comfort and durability. Matteo's quality is defined by its superior sustainable materials, including organic cotton and Tencel, which are both soft, breathable, and ethically produced.
What makes Matteo bedding sustainable?
Matteo's sustainability commitment is comprehensive. They use organic, OEKO-TEX certified fabrics, eco-friendly dyes, and focus on maintaining a transparent supply chain with ethical labor practices. This ensures their products are safe for consumers and have a lower environmental impact.
Can you return items to both brands?
Yes, but the policies differ greatly. Brooklinen famously offers a 365-night trial on most of its products, allowing you to return them within a full year. Matteo has a more traditional but still flexible return policy with a satisfaction guarantee.
Which brand is better for hot sleepers?
Both brands have excellent options. Brooklinen's Classic Percale collection is made with a one-over-one-under weave that makes it incredibly crisp, light, and breathable. Matteo offers bedding made from naturally cooling fibers like linen and Tencel, which are known for their moisture-wicking and temperature-regulating properties.
Which style is more versatile?
Brooklinen's classic and minimalist designs, along with their wider range of colors and simple patterns, make their bedding slightly more versatile for different interior aesthetics. Matteo's modern, sophisticated look is incredibly chic but fits best within consciously minimalist and contemporary decor schemes.
What types of fabrics does each brand offer?
Brooklinen’s core offerings include long-staple cotton in percale and sateen weaves, linen, chambray, and heathered cashmere. Matteo specializes in sustainable fabrics like organic cotton, linen, and innovative materials like soft, breathable Tencel.
How do Brooklinen and Matteo sheets fit?
Both brands design their fitted sheets to accommodate modern mattresses. You can expect reliable, true-to-size fits and deep pockets that comfortably fit over thicker mattresses and mattress toppers without slipping off.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
