Brooklinen is a direct-to-consumer brand offering modern, high-quality bedding at an accessible price point, focusing on sustainable materials and a relaxed aesthetic. In contrast, Hotel Collection delivers a more traditional, luxurious experience inspired by five-star hotels, featuring classic designs, sateen finishes, and a higher price tag. The primary difference is Brooklinen's value-driven, modern approach versus Hotel Collection's premium, classic luxury focus.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right bedding brand for your home.
Brooklinen: The Affordable Luxury Bedding Brand
Brooklinen launched in 2014 and quickly became a dominant force in the online bedding market by selling high-quality home essentials directly to consumers. Their mission is to provide simple, beautiful products without the expensive markups of traditional retail. They cater to shoppers who want the comfort of hotel-quality linens but prefer a modern, minimalist style and a straightforward, transparent buying process.
- Product mix: A wide range of home essentials, including sheets, duvet covers, pillows, comforters, towels, loungewear, and home accessories.
- Style/vibe: Modern, minimalist, and versatile. Their linens come in a broad palette of solid colors and simple, subtle patterns that can fit into nearly any decor style.
- Price point: Mid-range, offering excellent value. Sheet sets typically start around $100 and can go up to $250 for premium options like linen. Bundle deals and frequent sales provide additional savings.
- Quality: Known for using high-quality, long-staple cotton, linen, and Tencel. All their cotton products are OEKO-TEX certified, meaning they are free from harmful chemicals.
- Return policy: One of the best in the industry, offering a 365-day return or exchange window, even if the product has been used.
- Sales: Holds several sales events throughout the year, especially around major holidays, offering discounts of 15-25% off sitewide.
- Sustainability: The brand is transparent about its ethical manufacturing processes and uses eco-friendly packaging to reduce its environmental footprint.
Brooklinen is an ideal choice for anyone seeking high-quality, stylish, and comfortable bedding at a fair price, backed by an unbeatable customer-friendly trial period.
Shop Brooklinen: brooklinen.com
Hotel Collection: The High-End Hotel Experience at Home
Hotel Collection aims to bring the opulent feel of a luxury hotel straight to your bedroom. The brand is associated with premium materials, high thread counts, and classic elegance. Often sold through major department stores, its products appeal to consumers who are willing to invest more for a top-tier look and feel, prioritizing a polished, sophisticated aesthetic and durable, long-lasting quality.
- Product mix: Focused primarily on bedroom essentials, including sheets, duvet covers, pillowcases, comforters, and decorative shams.
- Style/vibe: Classic, elegant, and sophisticated. Its collections often feature refined and neutral colors like ivory, gray, and white, with sateen finishes and subtle patterns to create a timeless, upscale look.
- Price point: Upper-mid to luxury. Sheet sets generally start around $150 and can exceed $400 for sets made with premium materials like Egyptian cotton and high thread counts.
- Quality: Emphasizes luxurious materials, particularly Egyptian cotton with a sateen weave, which provides a silky-smooth and lustrous feel. Their products are designed for durability and a polished finish.
- Fit & Sizing: Offers a full range of sizes, including deep-pocket options to accommodate pillow-top and thicker mattresses.
- Shopping Experience: Primarily sold through major department stores and their websites. The return policy and customer service experience will depend on the specific retailer.
- Durability/Warranty: Hotel Collection linens are crafted for long-term use, mirroring the durability standards required by the hospitality industry.
Hotel Collection is for the shopper who values a timeless, traditionally luxe aesthetic and wants to invest in premium materials to replicate a five-star hotel sleep experience.
Shop Hotel Collection: hotelcollection.com
Brooklinen vs. Hotel Collection Comparison
Price Comparison
This is one of the biggest distinctions between the two brands. Brooklinen positions itself as an affordable luxury brand, with its bestselling Luxe Sateen Sheet Sets starting around $179 for a queen size. They offer bundles and frequent sales that can significantly lower the price, making hotel-quality bedding accessible to a wider audience.
Hotel Collection operates in the premium and luxury space. Its sheet sets typically start over $150 at discounted prices and can rise to over $400 for higher thread-count options in Egyptian cotton. The price reflects its high-end positioning and distribution through traditional retail channels. If budget is a primary concern, Brooklinen offers far better value.
Quality & Materials
Both brands deliver high-quality products but focus on different attributes. Brooklinen uses strong, long-staple cotton for its sheets, which are known for both softness and durability over time. Their OEKO-TEX certification also provides peace of mind that the fabrics are free of harmful substances.
Hotel Collection often emphasizes high thread counts (typically 500 and up) and premium fibers like Egyptian cotton. Their signature sateen weave gives the sheets a lustrous sheen and a silky-smooth feel directly out of the package. While both are built to last, Hotel Collection sheets often have a heavier, more substantial feel associated with high-end hotel bedding.
Style & Aesthetic
The brands' styles cater to two different design philosophies. Brooklinen’s aesthetic is modern, clean, and versatile. With a wide range of colors and simple patterns, their bedding can chameleon into many different decors, from Scandinavian minimalist to casual contemporary. It feels fresh and inviting.
Hotel Collection focuses on classic, timeless elegance. Think crisp white linens, subtle jacquard patterns, and sophisticated neutral tones. Its style is unapologetically traditional and designed to create a formal, polished bedroom that looks like it belongs in a luxury suite.
Shopping Experience
Shopping with Brooklinen is a seamless direct-to-consumer experience. Their website is easy to navigate, and they are famous for their 365-night trial period, which lets you try their products at home for a full year. This drastically reduces the risk for a first-time buyer.
Hotel Collection is mainly available through retailers such as Macy’s. This allows you to potentially see and feel the product in a physical store before buying. However, your experience, including shipping and returns, is subject to the retailer's policies, which are generally far less generous than Brooklinen's.
Return Policies
There is a clear winner here. Brooklinen offers a 365-day return and exchange policy on all of its products, even after they've been used and washed. This exceptional policy demonstrates their confidence in their products and commitment to customer satisfaction.
The return policy for Hotel Collection products depends entirely on the retailer you purchase them from. Department stores typically offer a return window of 30-90 days, and most will not accept used or washed bedding. This makes shopping for Hotel Collection items a much higher-stakes decision.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands offer excellent products, but they are designed for very different shoppers. The right choice comes down to your priorities in style, budget, and shopping preferences.
Choose Brooklinen if:
- You prefer a modern, relaxed, and minimalist design aesthetic.
- Getting the best value for your money is a top priority.
- You want the security of a year-long trial to make sure you love your bedding.
- You value sustainable practices and chemical-free certified fabrics.
- You want a wide variety of colors and fabric choices, such as percale, sateen, and linen.
Choose Hotel Collection if:
- You want to recreate the specific look and feel of a five-star hotel bed.
- You have a higher budget and are willing to invest in premium-priced linens.
- You prefer a classic, traditionally elegant style with a silky sateen finish.
- You prioritize a high thread count and materials like Egyptian cotton.
- You prefer to shop at department stores where you might be able to see products in person.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Brooklinen or Hotel Collection cheaper?
Brooklinen is consistently more affordable than Hotel Collection. With a direct-to-consumer model and frequent sales, Brooklinen offers an excellent price-to-quality ratio, making it the better choice for budget-conscious shoppers who still want a high-quality product.
Which brand has better quality sheets?
It depends on your definition of "quality." Brooklinen's long-staple cotton sheets are exceptionally durable, soft, and breathable. Hotel Collection focuses on luxury benchmarks like high thread counts and premium Egyptian cotton for a smoother, silkier feel. Both are high-quality, but they excel in different areas.
Which is better for hot sleepers?
Brooklinen is generally the better option for hot sleepers. Their Classic Percale sheets are famously crisp and cool to the touch, and their linen options offer superior breathability. Hotel Collection's focus on sateen weaves, which are less breathable by nature, may feel warmer to some people.
Can you return washed sheets to both brands?
You can return washed and used sheets to Brooklinen within its 365-day trial period - it’s a key part of their customer promise. For Hotel Collection, this is almost never the case, most department stores will not accept washed bedding for return unless there is a clear manufacturer defect.
Are Brooklinen sheets OEKO-TEX certified?
Yes, all of Brooklinen's cotton bedding is OEKO-TEX certified, ensuring that it's been tested and found free from harmful substances and chemicals. This is a significant plus for anyone concerned about health and sustainability.
Where are Hotel Collection products sold?
Hotel Collection bedding and home items are primarily sold in major department stores like Macy's and on their respective websites. They are not a direct-to-consumer brand like Brooklinen.
Does Hotel Collection really feel like hotel bedding?
Yes, Hotel Collection is designed specifically to emulate the feel of luxury hotel linens - they often have a heavier weight, a silky sateen finish, and a polished appearance that is characteristic of an upscale hotel room.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
