Choosing between modern direct-to-consumer bedding brands can be tough, especially when comparing the popular Brooklinen with a newer, compelling alternative like Pebble. Brooklinen is known for its wide variety of high-quality fabrics and versatile styles like its earthy Oak Stripe pattern, while Pebble focuses on sleek, minimalist aesthetics and a strong commitment to sustainable materials. Both offer premium bedding at comparable mid-range prices, but they appeal to slightly different priorities in style and environmental consciousness.
Here’s a detailed look at how these two brands compare to help you decide which is the right choice for your bedroom.
Brooklinen Bedding
Brooklinen has become a household name since launching in 2014, making luxury-level sheets, duvet covers, and home textiles accessible to everyone. The brand built its reputation on premium materials like long-staple cotton and linen, offered in a broad range of weaves, colors, and classic patterns. Brooklinen’s aesthetic is modern but approachable, blending seamlessly into many decor styles, with popular colorways like their Oak Stripe offering a go-to choice for a natural, Scandinavian-inspired look.
- What it is: A direct-to-consumer brand offering a wide selection of premium bedding, including sheets, duvet covers, pillows, and comforters.
- Key features: Sheets made from long-staple cotton, including options for crisp percale and silky-smooth sateen. Offers linen, heathered cashmere, and flannel collections. Bundles allow for easy mix-and-match styling.
- Price: Sheet sets start around $100, duvet covers range from $150 to $250.
- Style: Versatile and modern with a wide range of solid colors, subtle textures, and classic patterns (stripes, windowpane). Fits well in contemporary, minimalist, and transitional bedrooms.
- Materials/Construction: Known for durable, high-quality long-staple cotton, European flax linen, and cozy fabric blends. Products are typically OEKO-TEX certified for chemical safety.
- Pros: Long-standing reputation for quality and comfort. Extensive selection of fabrics, colors, and patterns. Risk-free 365-day return policy gives you plenty of time to decide. Versatile designs fit many aesthetics.
- Cons: So many options can feel overwhelming. Sustainability is a recent focus rather than a core principle from its inception. Popular items can sometimes go out of stock.
Brooklinen is a great choice for shoppers looking for a reliable, trusted brand with a huge selection of tested and loved bedding options to suit any comfort preference or style.
Shop this product: brooklinen.com
Pebble Bedding
Pebble is a more recent addition to the online bedding market, distinguishing itself with a strong emphasis on sustainability and a highly curated, minimalist aesthetic. The brand focuses on creating sleep products that are both thoughtfully designed and environmentally conscious. Their collection includes premium sheets and duvet covers made from materials like long-staple cotton and linen, but with a clear commitment to using eco-friendly dyes and transparent production standards.
- What it is: A modern, eco-conscious bedding brand offering a curated selection of sheets, duvet covers, and sleep essentials with a minimalist aesthetic.
- Key features: High-grade fabrics like long-staple ELS cotton and linen. Focus on breathability and softness. Products feature reinforced stitching for longevity and eco-friendly dyes.
- Price: Sheet sets start around $120, duvet covers range from $180 to $250.
- Style: Sleek and understated minimalism. Features a muted color palette, soft neutral tones, and subtle textures that create a calming, contemporary atmosphere.
- Materials/Construction: Focus on premium and eco-conscious fabrics, including organic cotton and recycled blends. Emphasizes responsible sourcing and manufacturing.
- Pros: Strong commitment to sustainability and ethical production. Highly curated, refined aesthetic is perfect for minimalist interiors. High-quality construction designed for durability. Streamlined shopping experience.
- Cons: Limited selection of colors and patterns compared to Brooklinen. A newer brand with less history and fewer customer reviews. Slightly higher starting price point for some items.
Pebble is the ideal choice for quality-driven minimalists and eco-conscious shoppers who value transparent sourcing and understated elegance in their bedding.
Shop this product: pebblehome.com
Brooklinen vs. Pebble Comparison
Materials & Construction
Both Brooklinen and Pebble champion the use of high-quality fabrics, primarily long-staple cotton and linen, prized for their softness, breathability, and durability. Brooklinen is well-known for offering distinct weaves like their cool, crisp Classic Percale or their buttery smooth Luxe Sateen, giving customers clear choices based on their sleep preferences. Their construction is solid, and products are OEKO-TEX certified, ensuring they are free from harmful chemicals.
Pebble also uses premium long-staple cotton and sources high-quality linen but weaves its sustainability mission into its material choices, such as using eco-friendly dyes and promoting responsible manufacturing processes. The craftsmanship equally emphasizes longevity with details like reinforced stitching. While both produce excellent products, Pebble's core mission centers on creating textiles with a lower environmental impact.
Style & Aesthetic
Style is a key differentiator between the brands. Brooklinen offers a broad and versatile aesthetic. With dozens of colors and a constantly updated selection of classic patterns - from simple stripes like their popular Oak Stripe linens to windowpane checks - they cater to a wide decorating audience. Their look is modern, approachable, and easily integrated into many different types of bedrooms.
Pebble, on the other hand, embraces a more refined and minimalist design philosophy. Their color palette is more restrained, focusing on soft neutrals, earthy tones, and subtle textures that create a serene and cohesive look. This curated approach appeals to those who favor an uncluttered, consciously designed space and prefer quality over a vast quantity of options.
Price & Value
When it comes to price, Brooklinen and Pebble are very competitive. A set of queen sheets from either brand will typically fall in the $100-$150 range, with duvet covers landing between $150 and $250 depending on the material. Pebble's prices are sometimes slightly higher at the entry level, but overall they occupy the same space in the "affordable luxury" market.
Both provide excellent value by offering direct-to-consumer pricing that cuts out the traditional retail markup. The choice here comes down less to cost and more to what you value: Brooklinen's extensive variety and reputation or Pebble's focused design and eco-conscious credentials.
Sustainability & Ethics
While Brooklinen has taken steps to become more sustainable and ensures its products meet OEKO-TEX standards, sustainability is the central pillar of Pebble's brand identity. Pebble is vocal about its commitment to eco-friendly practices, from sourcing organic and recycled materials to using non-toxic dyes and transparent production methods. For shoppers who make environmental impact a top priority in purchase decisions, Pebble has a clear advantage. Brooklinen provides quality and safety but doesn't lead with sustainability as its primary mission.
For the eco-conscious buyer, Pebble is the more aligned choice. For shoppers focused mainly on performance and style, Brooklinen remains an outstanding and responsible option.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands offer fantastic products, but they are built for slightly different customers and priorities.
Choose Brooklinen if:
- You want a wide variety of colors, patterns, and fabric types to choose from.
- You appreciate a brand with a long-standing, well-earned reputation for quality and customer satisfaction.
- You enjoy mixing and matching styles to create a personalized look.
- You're looking for a one-stop shop that can outfit your entire bedroom and bathroom.
Choose Pebble if:
- Sustainability and eco-friendly manufacturing are top priorities for you.
- You prefer a minimalist, understated aesthetic with a curated color palette.
- You appreciate a "less is more" approach and prefer not to be overwhelmed by choice.
- You want your bedding to reflect refined simplicity and conscious consumption.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Brooklinen and Pebble?
The main difference is their focus. Brooklinen focuses on offering a huge variety of styles, fabrics, and colors, catering to a broad audience with its trusted reputation. Pebble focuses on a curated, minimalist aesthetic with sustainability at the core of its mission, appealing to eco-conscious consumers who prefer a modern, understated look.
Which brand is more affordable?
Both brands are very similarly priced and occupy the same mid-to-premium tier in the bedding market. While some entry-level sheet sets at Pebble might be slightly more than Brooklinen's, the prices are generally comparable across their collections.
Which brand is better for hot sleepers?
Both brands offer excellent options for hot sleepers. Brooklinen's Classic Percale sheets are famously cool and crisp, and their linen bedding is also very breathable. Pebble also offers breathable long-staple cotton and linen designed for good airflow, making either brand a solid choice depending on your style preference.
Are the colors accurate to the photos online?
Both brands do a good job of representing their colors online. However, screen variations and lighting in your room can affect how a color appears. It's often helpful to order swatches if available or to read customer reviews that mention color accuracy before making a final decision.
Do both brands offer a trial period?
Brooklinen is famous for its generous 365-day return and exchange policy on most items, which is one of the best in the industry. Pebble offers a more standard, but still flexible, return policy. Always check their websites for the most current policy details before purchasing.
Is Pebble a sustainable brand?
Yes, sustainability is a core part of Pebble's brand identity. They emphasize using eco-friendly materials like organic cotton, non-toxic dyes, and responsible manufacturing processes. This is a primary reason shoppers choose Pebble.
Which sheets feel softer, Brooklinen or Pebble?
Softness is subjective and depends on the fabric. Brooklinen's Luxe Sateen sheets will feel silky smooth, while their percale is crisp and their linen is airy. Pebble's long-staple cotton is also known for its incredible softness. If you prioritize a silky feel, Brooklinen’s Luxe Sateen is a well-known option designed specifically for that experience.
Can I find Brooklinen or Pebble products in stores?
Both Brooklinen and Pebble operate primarily as direct-to-consumer online brands, which helps them keep prices competitive. Brooklinen has opened a few physical store locations in major cities, but for most customers, the shopping experience will be online for both brands.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
