The Brooklinen Luxe Sheets and Classic Sheets are two of the brand's most popular offerings, but they cater to very different preferences in feel, appearance, and price. The Classic collection, made with a crisp percale weave, is breathable and cool with a matte finish, making it the more affordable, hotel-style option. The Luxe collection uses a sateen weave from Egyptian cotton, resulting in a supremely soft, silky feel with a slight sheen and a higher price tag.
Here’s a detailed comparison to help you decide which Brooklinen sheet set is the right choice for your bed.
Brooklinen Classic Sheets
The Classic line is Brooklinen's flagship product, designed to feel like a crisp button-down shirt. Made from 100% long-staple cotton with a 270-thread count percale weave, these sheets are lightweight, breathable, and an excellent choice for those who tend to sleep warm. They have a cool, crisp hand-feel that softens with every wash.
- What it is: A lightweight and breathable percale sheet set that feels crisp and cool to the touch.
- Key features: 100% long-staple cotton, 270 thread-count percale weave for maximum breathability.
- Price: Starts around $100 for a starter set.
- Style: Timeless and versatile with a clean, matte finish. Ideal for minimalist or traditional bedroom decor.
- Materials/Construction: Made from 100% long-staple cotton, which is known for its strength and durability. The percale weave means one-thread-over, one-thread-under for a tight, crisp feel.
- Pros: Excellent for hot sleepers due to high breathability. A durable weave that holds up well to frequent washing. A classic, hotel-style feel and look. More affordable than the Luxe collection.
- Cons: Can feel too crisp for those who prefer a silky texture. Prone to wrinkling right out of the dryer. Might not feel exceptionally soft right out of the box.
This sheet set is perfect for hot sleepers or anyone who loves the classic, crisp feel of high-quality hotel bedding at an accessible price point.
Shop this product: brooklinen.com/collections/sheets/products/classic-sheet-set
Brooklinen Luxe Sheets
The Luxe collection is Brooklinen’s premium offering, designed for an indulgent, buttery-soft sleep experience. Crafted from 100% long-staple Egyptian cotton with a 480-thread count sateen weave, these sheets offer a luminous finish and a silky-smooth feel. They are slightly thicker and warmer than the Classic sheets, making them a cozy choice.
- What it is: A premium, silky-smooth sheet set made from long-staple Egyptian cotton with a rich sateen weave.
- Key features: 100% long-staple Egyptian cotton, 480 thread-count sateen weave for a supremely soft feel.
- Price: Starts around $150 for a starter set.
- Style: Elegant and polished with a subtle sheen that adds a touch of sophistication to the bedroom.
- Materials/Construction: Made from high-quality Egyptian cotton woven in a sateen weave (one-under, three-or-four-over), creating more surface area for that characteristic silky feel and luster.
- Pros: Exceptionally soft and smooth right out of the package. Drapes beautifully on the bed for a luxurious look. Naturally wrinkle-resistant compared to percale. Provides a cozier, slightly warmer sleep experience.
- Cons: Higher price point. Less breathable than percale, which may be a downside for very hot sleepers. The sateen weave can be slightly more susceptible to snagging from pet claws.
This sheet set delivers on its promise of luxury and is ideal for those who prioritize a silky-soft feel and an elegant appearance.
Shop this product: brooklinen.com/collections/sheets/products/luxe-sheet-set
Brooklinen Classic vs. Luxe Sheets Comparison
Materials & Feel
The primary difference between the Classic and Luxe sheets is how they feel, which comes down to their weave and cotton type. The Classic sheets use a percale weave, giving them a crisp, airy, and cool texture, much like a freshly pressed shirt - perfect for those who enjoy that 'cool side of the pillow' feeling. The Luxe sheets use a sateen weave with Egyptian cotton, resulting in a much silkier, smoother, and softer surface that drapes over the body with more weight.
In short, if you like crisp and breathable, choose Classic Percale. If you want buttery smooth and ultra-soft, choose Luxe Sateen.
Style & Aesthetics
Visually, the difference lies in the finish. The Classic sheets have a clean, uniform matte finish that looks timeless and simple, working well with almost any decor style. The Luxe sheets have a subtle, elegant sheen or luster, a byproduct of the sateen weave, which gives them a more polished and upscale appearance.
For a minimalist, no-fuss look, the Classic set is a natural fit. For a bed that looks more luxurious and refined, the Luxe set’s luminous finish offers a distinct advantage.
Price & Value
There's a noticeable price gap between the two. The Classic collection is Brooklinen’s more budget-friendly line, offering access to high-quality, long-staple cotton without a steep investment. The Luxe collection comes at a premium, reflecting its use of higher-thread-count Egyptian cotton and the more complex sateen weaving process.
The Classic sheets provide outstanding value for everyday durability and comfort, especially for hot sleepers. The Luxe sheets are a worthwhile splurge for those who prioritize a truly indulgent, silky touch and want to invest in a more luxurious sleep experience. Both come with a 365-day return policy, giving you confidence in your purchase.
Who Each One Works Best For
The Classic sheets are ideal for hot sleepers, individuals who love a crisp feel, and budget-conscious shoppers looking for the best balance of quality and price. They're a workhorse set that improves with age and stands up to frequent use.
The Luxe sheets are better suited for people who prioritize softness above all else. They are perfect for anyone seeking a 5-star hotel bed experience at home, those who tend to sleep cool, and shoppers willing to invest more for an elegant aesthetic and buttery-smooth feel.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both sheet sets are great investments in your comfort, but they serve different sleep preferences and priorities.
Choose the Classic Sheets if:
- You're a hot sleeper who needs maximum airflow and breathability.
- You love the crisp, cool feel of a traditional hotel sheet.
- You're looking for a durable, high-quality set at a more accessible price point.
- You prefer a simple, matte look for your bed linens.
Choose the Luxe Sheets if:
- You prioritize a silky, buttery-soft texture over a crisp feel.
- You want to recreate the feeling of a luxurious hotel bed at home.
- You are willing to spend more for an ultra-premium, indulgent experience.
- You prefer bedding with a polished, slightly luminous finish.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Brooklinen Classic and Luxe sheets?
The main difference is the weave and material, which affects the feel. Classic sheets have a percale weave that feels crisp and cool. The Luxe sheets use a sateen weave that feels incredibly soft and silky.
Which Brooklinen sheets are better for hot sleepers?
The Classic Percale sheets are much better for hot sleepers. The percale weave is renowned for its breathability, allowing for greater airflow and keeping you cool throughout the night. Luxe Sateen is denser and sleeps slightly warmer.
Do the Luxe sheets look shiny?
They don't look shiny, but they do have what's often described as a subtle sheen or soft luster. It’s an elegant, polished look that gives the sheets a premium appearance without being overly glossy.
Which sheets are softer?
Luxe sheets are distinctly softer with a silk-like feel right out of the package. While Classic sheets do soften with each wash, they will always retain a degree of their signature crispness and won't achieve the buttery texture of the Luxe Sateen.
How do I care for Brooklinen sheets?
Both sets are easy to care for. Brooklinen recommends washing them in cold water with similar colors and fabrics, and tumbling dry on a low setting. It's best to remove them from the dryer promptly to reduce wrinkling.
Do Brooklinen sheets wrinkle easily?
Being 100% cotton, both will wrinkle to some extent. The Classic Percale sheets are more prone to wrinkling due to their crisp weave. The Luxe Sateen sheets are naturally more wrinkle-resistant and will appear smoother right out of the wash.
Which sheet set is more durable?
Both sets are very durable because they use high-quality long-staple cotton. Percale (Classic) is a very tight and strong weave known for its longevity. Sateen (Luxe) can be slightly more delicate and may be more likely to snag, but it holds up well with proper care.
Are Brooklinen sheets worth the price?
Many customers find that both sets are worth their respective prices. They offer high-end materials and construction without the traditional retail markup. Plus, Brooklinen's 365-day return and exchange policy allows you to try them out risk-free in your own home to decide for yourself.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
