The Brooklinen Down Pillow and Down Alternative Pillow offer different sleep experiences tailored to specific needs, but the main differences are fill material, care, and price. The Down Pillow uses ethically sourced natural down and feathers for a soft, insulating, "sinking" feel, while the Down Alternative Pillow uses a hypoallergenic synthetic fill that offers resilient support and is machine washable.
Here’s everything you need to know to choose the right Brooklinen pillow for your sleep style and preferences.
Brooklinen Down Pillow
Brooklinen's classic Down Pillow is designed for a traditional, luxurious hotel-like feel. It's filled with premium, natural down and feathers, giving it a light, airy, and compressive quality that molds gently around your head and neck. Ideal for sleepers who prioritize a true "cloud-like" softness and the natural breathability that only down can provide.
- What it is: A premium pillow filled with a blend of ethically sourced duck down and feathers.
- Key features: Available in three density options (Plush, Mid-Plush, Firm) to suit different sleep positions. It has a smooth 100% cotton sateen shell.
- Price: ~$129 - $149 per pillow.
- Materials/Construction: The fill varies by firmness, Plush is all down, while Mid-Plush and Firm options are a cluster-and-feather mix. The outer shell is a durable 400-thread count cotton.
- Pros: Exceptionally soft and luxurious feel. Conforms closely to your head and neck for personalized comfort. Naturally breathable and insulating for good temperature regulation. Lightweight and easy to shape.
- Cons: More expensive than down alternative options. May trigger allergies for sensitive individuals. Requires more delicate care - spot cleaning or dry cleaning is often recommended. Needs regular fluffing to maintain loft.
This pillow is for the sleeper who wants a genuine five-star hotel experience at home and values the superior softness and malleability of natural down.
Shop this product: brooklinen.com/products/down-pillow
Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow
The Brooklinen Down Alternative Pillow offers a plush, cozy feel designed to mimic down using hypoallergenic materials. Filled with shaved, soft microfibers, it delivers a more supportive and resilient loft that bounces back easily. This pillow is a practical solution for allergy sufferers, vegans, or anyone looking for an affordable, easy-to-care-for option without sacrificing comfort.
- What it is: A hypoallergenic pillow filled with synthetic microfiber that mimics the softness of down.
- Key features: Available in three firmness levels (Plush, Mid-Plush, Firm). 100% long-staple cotton shell and fully machine washable for easy maintenance.
- Price: ~$69 - $89 per pillow.
- Materials/Construction: Filled entirely with 100% polyester microfibers, making it 100% vegan. It features the same comfortable 400-thread count cotton sateen shell as the down version.
- Pros: Fully hypoallergenic and resistant to dust mites. Significantly more affordable than real down. Very easy to clean - just toss it in the washing machine. Holds its shape well and is more resistant to flattening over time.
- Cons: Doesn't have the same light, "sinking" feel as natural down. Can sometimes retain more heat than its down counterpart. The fill may eventually clump after many washes, though it's designed to be resilient.
This pillow is a great choice for anyone with allergies, those who prefer animal-free products, or sleepers who want a supportive, easy-to-wash pillow at a very accessible price point.
Shop this product: brooklinen.com/products/down-alternative-pillow
Down Pillow vs. Down Alternative Pillow Comparison
Comfort & Support
The comfort and feel are the most notable differences between these two pillows. The Down Pillow is exceptionally soft and malleable, it cradles your head, creating a plush, sinking sensation that many sleepers love. It’s perfect for those who want a pillow they can squish and shape to their liking. This makes it a great fit for side and back sleepers who need contouring support for their neck and shoulders.
The Down Alternative Pillow, while designed to be soft, is noticeably more supportive and resilient. The microfiber fill provides cushioning without the deep compression of real down, so it tends to hold its shape better throughout the night. It offers a consistently plush surface that feels slightly bouncy. This balanced profile makes it adaptable to nearly any sleeping position, including stomach sleepers who need a softer-yet-supportive loft.
Materials & Construction
Both pillows feature the same high-quality 400-thread count, 100% cotton sateen shell, so the exterior feels identical - smooth, soft, and breathable. The magic is on the inside. The Down Pillow uses natural duck down and feathers, which are lightweight, breathable, and an excellent insulator. Brooklinen sources these materials with a certification from the Responsible Down Standard (RDS).
The Down Alternative Pillow is filled with advanced polyester microfibers shaved to mimic the texture of down clusters. This fill is entirely synthetic, making it 100% vegan and naturally resistant to common allergens. The construction is focused on providing consistent loft and durability through many wash cycles.
Price & Value
There's a considerable price difference here. The Brooklinen Down Pillow is a premium product, costing nearly twice as much as its alternative counterpart. A standard size pillow runs about $129. If you are prepared to invest in the luxury feel and longevity that comes with natural down, it provides excellent value compared to other high-end bedding brands.
The Down Alternative Pillow offers incredible value at around $69 for a standard size. It delivers a comfortable, supportive sleep experience and comes with the convenience of easy machine washing, all for a budget-friendly price. For sheer practicality and affordability, the down alternative is the clear winner for most shoppers.
Allergies & Maintenance
This is a major deciding factor. If you suffer from allergies, the choice is simple: the Down Alternative Pillow is hypoallergenic and will not harbor dust mites or trigger sensitivities like natural feathers can. It’s also incredibly easy to maintain - just put it in the washer and dryer for a quick refresh. Most stains come out easily and it remains fresh with regular cleaning.
The Down Pillow is not inherently hypoallergenic. While its high-quality down is well-cleaned, it can still be an issue for highly sensitive individuals. Care requires much more effort, spot treating, airing out, and occasional professional cleaning or very gentle washing cycles are recommended to preserve the delicate down clusters and prevent damage.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both the Brooklinen Down and Down Alternative pillows are excellent choices, but they are built for different sleepers.
Choose the Down Pillow if:
- You're seeking an authentically luxurious, five-star hotel feel.
- You love a soft pillow that you can sink into and mold perfectly to your neck.
- You prioritize natural materials and appreciate their superior temperature regulation.
- You don't have allergies to down or feathers and don't mind more dedicated care.
Choose the Down Alternative Pillow if:
- You have allergies or are sensitive to dust and prefer hypoallergenic bedding.
- You want a pillow that's incredibly easy to clean in your own washing machine.
- You are shopping on a budget but still want a well-made, comfortable pillow.
- You prefer slightly more resilient and consistent support that doesn't significantly compress overnight.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the main difference between the Brooklinen Down and Down Alternative pillows?
The core difference is the fill: the Down Pillow uses natural duck down and feathers for a soft, malleable feel, while the Down Alternative uses synthetic, hypoallergenic microfibers for resilient, easy-care support. This also affects price, care instructions, and suitability for allergy sufferers.
Which Brooklinen pillow is better for side sleepers?
Both pillows work for side sleepers, but you must choose the right firmness level. Many side sleepers prefer the Mid-Plush or Firm options in either the Down or Down Alternative to ensure proper head and neck alignment. The Down Pillow excels at contouring to the space between your shoulder and neck.
Is the Brooklinen Down Pillow ethically sourced?
Yes, Brooklinen states their down pillows are certified by the Responsible Down Standard (RDS), ensuring the down and feathers come from animals that have been treated ethically.
How do you wash the Down Alternative pillow?
It's very easy to clean. You can machine wash it in a cold, gentle cycle with mild detergent. Tumble dry on a low setting, and it’s helpful to add dryer balls to help fluff the pillow back up.
Does the natural Down Pillow have a smell?
Like many natural-fill products, there might be a very faint "feathery" scent when the pillow is brand new, but it typically dissipates quickly after being unboxed and aired out. High-quality, clean down like Brooklinen's generally doesn't have a strong odor.
Which pillow holds its shape better?
The Down Alternative Pillow is engineered to be more resilient and will generally hold its shape and loft better with less daily fluffing. The natural Down Pillow is designed to be compressive and will require a quick shake each morning to redistribute the fill.
Will the Down Pillow go flat?
Over time, any pillow will lose some of its loft. Natural down is susceptible to gradual compression but can last several years with proper care and regular fluffing. The pillow doesn't typically go completely flat quickly, but it will need to be replaced after a few years of use.
Are both pillows available in a king size?
Yes, both the Down and Down Alternative pillows are available in Standard and King sizes, and both come in three different firmness levels (Plush, Mid-Plush, and Firm) to match your preferences.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
