The Brooklinen Classic and Luxe collections mainly differ in their feel, finish, and price. Classic Core sheets use a percale weave for a crisp, matte, and hotel-like feel that's highly breathable, whereas the more expensive Luxe Sateen sheets feature a sateen weave for a silky-smooth texture with a subtle sheen.
Here's a full breakdown of each sheet set to help you decide which Brooklinen option is right for your bed.
Brooklinen Classic Core Sheets
Brooklinen's Classic sheets are known for their crisp, cool feel, making them a popular choice for those who want durable and breathable bedding. Made from 100% long-staple cotton with a 270 thread count percale weave, they mimic the feel of five-star hotel sheets that keep you cool throughout the night.
- What it is: A percale weave sheet set made from long-staple cotton designed for a crisp and breathable sleep experience.
- Key features: 270 thread count, percale weave for a matte finish, "long" and "short" side labels on fitted sheets, OEKO-TEX certified for chemical safety.
- Price: Starts around $100 for a Core Queen set.
- Feel & Texture: Crisp, cool, and clean, like a freshly ironed button-down shirt. Becomes softer with each wash without losing its structure.
- Materials/Construction: 100% long-staple cotton with a one-up, one-down percale weave.
- Pros: Excellent breathability makes them ideal for hot sleepers. Durable and gets softer over time. More affordable than the Luxe collection. Crisp feel is loved by many.
- Cons: Can feel a bit rough out of the package before washing. Prone to wrinkling more than sateen sheets. Lower thread count might not feel as "plush" to some.
This sheet set is built for anyone who runs hot at night or prefers a crisp, non-silky texture in their bedding without a high price point.
Shop this product: brooklinen.com/products/classic-percale-core-sheet-set
Brooklinen Luxe Sateen Sheets
The Luxe collection is Brooklinen's premium, best-selling offering, designed for a buttery-smooth and slightly warmer sleep experience. These sheets use a 480 thread count sateen weave that drapes beautifully and provides a lustrous sheen, creating a more luxurious, hotel-suite feel right in your bedroom.
- What it is: A sateen weave sheet set made from long-staple cotton that prioritizes silky softness and a slightly luminous finish.
- Key features: 480 thread count, sateen weave for a silky feel and slight sheen, "long" and "short" side labels, OEKO-TEX certified.
- Price: Starts around $180 for a Core Queen set.
- Feel & Texture: Buttery-smooth, soft, and drapey with a silky surface. Feels incredibly gentle against the skin.
- Materials/Construction: 100% long-staple cotton with a one-under, three-over sateen weave.
- Pros: Incredibly soft and smooth right out of the box. The subtle sheen adds a touch of elegance. Naturally wrinkle-resistant. The higher thread count feels substantial and plush.
- Cons: A significant price increase over the Classic set. The sateen weave is less breathable, which might be a downside for hot sleepers. The luminous sheen may fade slightly over time with washing.
The Luxe Sateen sheets are perfect for someone who wants to invest in an exceptionally soft, luxurious-feeling bed and prefers a smoother, less crisp fabric.
Shop this product: brooklinen.com/products/luxe-sateen-core-sheet-set
Brooklinen Classic vs. Luxe Comparison
Feel & Texture
The most immediate and noticeable difference between the Classic and Luxe sheets is the touch. The Classic percale sheets are defined by their crispness. They are light and airy, providing a clean, cool-to-the-touch sensation that many people find refreshing, especially in warmer climates or for those who tend to sleep hot. They feel structured and will get progressively softer with each wash, but they will always retain that quintessential percale crispness.
The Luxe Sateen sheets, by contrast, are all about softness. Their sateen weave produces a buttery, silky texture that glides over the skin. They have a more substantial weight and a richer drape, contouring more closely to your body compared to the more aloof structure of percale. This smooth, fluid feel is often described as luxurious and cozy.
Materials & Thread Count
Both sheet sets are made from high-quality, 100% long-staple cotton, which means the fibers are longer and stronger, leading to more durable and softer fabric. The main difference lies in the weave and thread count. The Classic sheets have a 270 thread count and use a one-yarn-over, one-yarn-under percale grid weave. This simple weave allows air to pass through easily, which is why it's so breathable.
The Luxe sheets feature a higher 480 thread count with a three-yarn-over, one-yarn-under sateen weave. This structure exposes more of the thread surface, creating that signature silky feel and lustrous sheen. The tighter weave makes the fabric thicker and less breathable than percale, offering a bit more warmth.
Style & Appearance
Visually, the Classic sheets have a simple, matte finish. Their look is clean, modern, and understated, fitting perfectly into minimalist or casual bedroom aesthetics. They can look more wrinkled after washing, giving them a relaxed, lived-in appearance unless ironed.
The Luxe sheets possess a slight, elegant sheen that catches the light beautifully, making the bed look more polished and inviting. This luminous finish provides a more upscale, refined look suited for more formal or sophisticated decor. They are also naturally more wrinkle-resistant, keeping the bed looking smoother with minimal effort.
Price & Value
The Classic Core Sheet Set is the more accessible option, with a queen set typically starting under $150. It offers fantastic value by providing the durability and comfort of long-staple cotton in a breathable weave at a mid-range price point.
The Luxe Sateen Sheet Set represents a step up in both luxury and price, with a queen set usually starting closer to $200. The higher cost reflects the higher thread count and more complex weave that results in its signature buttery feel. For those who prioritize ultimate softness above all, the Luxe line provides excellent value as a luxury product.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both collections offer excellent quality, but your choice will come down to personal preference for feel, sleep temperature, and budget.
Choose the Classic Core Sheets if:
- You are a hot sleeper or live in a warm climate.
- You love the crisp, clean feel of traditional hotel-style sheets.
- You prefer bedding with a modern, matte finish.
- You are shopping on a slightly tighter budget but still want high-quality cotton.
Choose the Luxe Sateen Sheets if:
- You prioritize a silky, buttery-soft feel in your bedding.
- You want your bed to have a luxurious, polished look with a slight sheen.
- You tend to sleep cool and enjoy a cozier, weightier sheet.
- You want sheets that are naturally wrinkle-resistant and are willing to invest more.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Brooklinen Classic and Luxe?
The primary difference is the weave. Classic uses a percale weave, which feels crisp, matte, and breathable like traditional hotel sheets. Luxe uses a sateen weave, which feels silky-smooth, has a slight sheen, and is less breathable.
Which Brooklinen sheets are better for hot sleepers?
The Classic Percale sheets are much better for hot sleepers. The percale weave is significantly more breathable, allowing for better airflow to keep you cool throughout the night.
Do Brooklinen sheets get softer with washing?
Yes, both collections get softer with each wash. The Classic Percale sheets in particular lose any initial stiffness and develop a very soft yet crisp handle over time, while the Luxe Sateen sheets maintain their buttery smoothness.
What does "long-staple cotton" mean?
Long-staple cotton refers to cotton with longer individual fibers. Sheets made from it are stronger, softer, and more durable, as there are fewer fiber ends exposed. This reduces pilling and fraying compared to short-staple cotton.
Do the Luxe Sateen sheets pill?
Because they are made from high-quality long-staple cotton, Brooklinen Luxe Sateen sheets are highly resistant to pilling. Following proper care instructions, like washing with cool water and avoiding high heat, will ensure their longevity.
Are the Luxe sheets worth the extra cost?
This is subjective. If you highly value a silky, ultra-soft feel and a more elegant appearance directly out of the box, then the Luxe set is often considered worth the investment. If you prioritize breathability and a crisp feel, you'll be perfectly happy with the more affordable Classic set.
Which sheets wrinkle more?
The Classic Percale sheets are more prone to wrinkling due to their crisp structure. The Luxe Sateen sheets are naturally wrinkle-resistant because of their weave and drape, so they come out of the dryer looking much smoother.
How deep are the pockets on the fitted sheets?
Both Classic and Luxe fitted sheets have deep pockets designed to fit mattresses up to 15 inches thick, making them compatible with most modern mattresses, including those with toppers.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
