The Brooklinen Classic Percale and Luxe Sateen sheets are both fan favorites, but they cater to very different sleep preferences. The Classic Percale has a crisp, cool, and matte finish much like a freshly ironed dress shirt, making it ideal for hot sleepers. The Luxe Sateen, in contrast, offers a silky, buttery-soft feel with a lustrous sheen, delivering a warmer and more indulgent sleep experience.
Here's everything you need to know to choose the right Brooklinen sheets for your bed.
Brooklinen Classic Percale Sheets
The Classic Percale sheets are Brooklinen's homage to high-end hotel bedding, designed for those who want to sleep cool and comfortable. They feature a traditional one-over, one-under percale weave that remains crisp and airy night after night. These sheets are known for their exceptional breathability and durable, matte finish that gets softer with every wash.
- What it is: A lightweight and breathable sheet set made from 100% long-staple cotton with a crisp percale weave.
- Key features: 200 thread count, matte finish, OEKO-TEX certified for chemical safety, gets softer over time.
- Price: Starts at $139 for a Queen Core Sheet Set.
- Style: A clean, minimalist, and casual aesthetic that works well with modern or coastal decor styles.
- Materials/Construction: 100% long-staple cotton woven in a percale weave for maximum breathability and a crisp feel.
- Pros: Exceptionally cool and breathable, ideal for hot sleepers. Crisp, hotel-like feel. Durable and becomes softer with each wash. Less prone to pilling than sateen.
- Cons: Prone to wrinkling, especially right out of the dryer. May feel slightly rough to start for those used to silky sheets.
These sheets are perfect for anyone who runs hot at night or loves the classic, cool-to-the-touch feel of traditional hotel bedding.
Shop this product: brooklinen.com/products/classic-percale-sheets
Brooklinen Luxe Sateen Sheets
The Luxe Sateen collection is Brooklinen’s answer to pure indulgence and everyday luxury. Using a four-over, one-under sateen weave, these sheets have a silky-smooth feel and a subtle, attractive sheen that elevates any bedroom. They are slightly thicker and warmer than their percale counterparts, making them a popular choice for those seeking a cozy, plush, and opulent sleep experience.
- What it is: A premium sheet set made from 100% long-staple cotton with a buttery-soft, slightly luminous sateen weave.
- Key features: 480 thread count, silky-smooth feel, subtle sheen, OEKO-TEX certified for chemical safety.
- Price: Starts at $169 for a Queen Core Sheet Set.
- Style: An elegant, sophisticated sheen that complements glam, traditional, or luxurious bedroom designs.
- Materials/Construction: 100% long-staple cotton in a sateen weave, which exposes more threads on the surface for a silk-like feel.
- Pros: Incredibly soft and smooth from the first night. Naturally wrinkle-resistant. Beautiful drape and lustrous finish look great on the bed. Cozier and warmer for cooler climates or cold sleepers.
- Cons: Less breathable than percale and can retain body heat. The sheen may fade over time with repeated washing. Higher price point.
This collection is an excellent choice for sleepers who prioritize a silky soft texture and a luxurious look, especially those who tend to sleep cool.
Shop this product: brooklinen.com/products/luxe-sateen-sheets
Classic Percale vs. Luxe Sateen Comparison
Feel & Texture
The most significant difference lies in how each sheet feels against your skin. The Classic Percale is defined by its crispness. Think of a freshly pressed, high-quality collared shirt - it's smooth, structured, and cool. It has a matte texture that softens into a comfortable, relaxed fabric over time.
The Luxe Sateen, on the other hand, is all about silky softness. Its sateen weave creates a buttery-smooth surface that glides over the skin. It feels more substantial and plush right out of the package, delivering an immediate sense of luxury.
Breathability & Temperature
If you're a hot sleeper, this is your deciding factor. Percale's one-over, one-under weave creates tiny pores that allow air to circulate freely. This makes the Classic Percale sheets highly breathable, wicking away moisture and body heat to keep you cool and comfortable all night.
Luxe Sateen's tighter weave feels cozier and traps more warmth. While still made from breathable cotton, it's a much better option for cold sleepers, people in cooler climates, or anyone who loves to feel snug and warm in bed. Hot sleepers may find Luxe Sateen too insulating.
Durability & Care
Both sheet sets are made from durable long-staple cotton, ensuring they hold up well to regular use and washing. Percale's tighter weave makes the individual threads very strong, and the fabric gets softer without losing its crisp character. Its main downside is a tendency to wrinkle heavily, pulling sheets directly from the dryer can help, but they'll never be crease-free.
Sateen is naturally more wrinkle-resistant and drapes beautifully on the bed. However, the longer floats in its weave that create its silky feel are also more prone to snagging or pilling than percale over the very long term. Following care instructions - washing in cold water and tumble drying on low - is key to preserving its sheen and softness.
Price & Value
The Classic Percale sheets are more budget-friendly, costing about $139 for a queen set. Their value comes from their exceptional durability and function, especially for those who need a cool sleeping environment. For hot sleepers, the price is easily justified by the comfort they provide.
At around $169 for a queen set, the Luxe Sateen sheets command a higher price for their premium, luxurious feel and aesthetic. The value here lies in the indulgent experience - if you prioritize a buttery-soft texture and an elegant look, the extra cost is well worth it.
Style & Aesthetic
Your design preference matters too. The Classic Percale’s matte finish lends a casual, relaxed, and airy look to a bedroom. It’s perfect for minimalist, Scandinavian, modern farmhouse, or coastal aesthetics where clean lines and simplicity are key.
The Luxe Sateen’s slight sheen gives off a more formal and elegant vibe. Its lustrous appearance suits more sophisticated, glamorous, or traditional bedroom decor. The way it drapes creates a soft, inviting look that makes a bed feel like a centerpiece.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both Brooklinen sheet sets are excellent choices, but they are designed for very different people.
Choose the Classic Percale if:
- You're a hot sleeper or live in a warm climate.
- You love the crisp, cool feel of classic hotel sheets.
- You prefer a casual, matte look for your bedding.
- You prioritize breathability over a silky texture.
- You don't mind a few natural wrinkles for that lived-in look.
Choose the Luxe Sateen if:
- You prefer a silky, buttery-soft feel that glides against the skin.
- You tend to sleep cold or live in a four-season climate.
- You want your bedding to have an elegant, lustrous sheen.
- You dislike wrinkles and want your bed to look smooth and pristine.
- You prioritize a plush, luxurious experience over an airy one.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between Brooklinen's Classic Percale and Luxe Sateen?
The primary difference is the weave. The Classic Percale uses a one-yarn-over, one-yarn-under weave, creating a crisp, matte, and breathable fabric. The Luxe Sateen uses a one-under, four-over weave, resulting in a silky, smooth fabric with a subtle sheen that traps more warmth.
Which sheets are better for hot sleepers?
The Classic Percale sheets are unequivocally better for hot sleepers. Their open weave allows for maximum airflow, helping to dissipate body heat and keep you feeling cool and dry through the night.
Do Brooklinen sheets get softer?
Yes, both types get softer with each wash. The Percale sheets lose any initial stiffness and become wonderfully soft and pliable while retaining their signature crispness. The Sateen sheets become even more buttery and supple with washing.
Which fabric wrinkles more?
Percale is much more prone to wrinkling than sateen. If a perfectly smooth bed is important to you, the Luxe Sateen will be a better choice as it drapes better and resists wrinkling naturally.
Is a higher thread count always better?
Not necessarily. While Luxe Sateen has a higher thread count (480) than Classic Percale (200), it doesn't mean it's "better," just different. The fabric's feel is determined more by the type of weave and quality of cotton. Percale's weave is optimal at a lower thread count to maintain its breathability.
How should I care for my Brooklinen sheets?
Brooklinen recommends washing your sheets separately in cool or warm water with a mild liquid detergent. To maintain their quality, tumble dry on low heat and remove them promptly. Avoid using bleach, as it can damage the natural cotton fibers.
Which set is more durable?
Both are made with high-quality long-staple cotton and are very durable. The simple, tight weave of percale can give it a slight edge in long-term wear, as its surface is less prone to snagging or pilling compared to the longer threads on the surface of sateen fabric.
Can I mix and match Percale and Sateen pieces?
Absolutely. Many people enjoy the best of both worlds. A common combination is pairing a breathable Classic Percale fitted sheet with a silky-soft Luxe Sateen flat sheet and pillowcases for a balanced feel.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
