The Brooklinen All Season Comforter and the Ultra-Warm Comforter are designed with the same high-quality materials but serve different needs based on their fill weight and warmth. The All Season is a versatile, mid-weight option ideal for year-round use in most climates, while the Ultra-Warm is significantly thicker and more insulated, built specifically for cold sleepers and harsh winters.
Here's everything you need to know to choose the right Brooklinen comforter for your bed.
Brooklinen All Season Comforter
The All Season Comforter is Brooklinen’s most popular choice, designed to strike the perfect balance between cozy warmth and breathability. It’s the go-to option for those who want a single, reliable comforter that works seamlessly from spring to winter in moderate climates without feeling too heavy or too light.
- What it is: A medium-weight comforter available in down or down-alternative fill, intended for versatile year-round comfort.
- Key features: Box-stitched construction to keep fill evenly distributed, 100% Long-Staple Cotton sateen shell for softness, corner loops for securing a duvet cover.
- Price: Around $159 (down alternative) to $359 (down) for a Queen size.
- Weight/Feel: Lightweight to medium feel that offers a cozy layer without trapping excess heat. Provides just enough fluff and substance for most sleepers.
- Pros: Extremely versatile for year-round use. Breathable cotton shell prevents overheating. Available in hypoallergenic down-alternative. Bestselling model that suits the widest range of people. Easy to machine wash.
- Cons: May not be warm enough for those in very cold climates without an extra blanket. Some users who prefer a heavy, weighted feel might find it too light.
This comforter is the ideal choice for anyone in a temperate climate or for sleepers who want a single comforter that stays comfortable through multiple seasons.
Shop this product: brooklinen.com/products/down-comforter
Brooklinen Ultra-Warm Comforter
The Ultra-Warm Comforter is Brooklinen’s specialized solution for maximum insulation. Packed with extra loft and fill, it’s engineered to provide exceptional warmth on the coldest nights, making it perfect for cold sleepers, drafty rooms, or intense winters.
- What it is: A heavyweight, maximum-fill comforter in either down or down-alternative, built for cold weather and people who are always chilly.
- Key features: Same box-stitched construction for even fill, soft 100% Long-Staple Cotton sateen shell, and corner loops for duvet covers. The key difference is the higher volume of fill material.
- Price: Around $209 (down alternative) to $499 (down) for a Queen size.
- Weight/Feel: Significantly loftier and heavier than the All Season. Provides a plush, cloud-like feeling with substantial warmth and a more "tucked-in" weight.
- Pros: Exceptionally warm for freezing temperatures. Perfect for cold sleepers who consistently need extra layers. Luxurious, high-loft appearance makes a bed look extra inviting. Same high-quality shell and construction as other Brooklinen comforters.
- Cons: Far too hot for summer or warm-weather use. Higher price point due to the extra fill. Bulkier and more difficult to fit into a home washing machine.
This comforter works best for those living in cold regions or anyone who prioritizes sleeping snugly and warm above all else during winter months.
Shop this product: brooklinen.com/products/down-comforter
Brooklinen All Season vs. Ultra-Warm Comparison
Warmth & Fill Power
The primary difference between these two comforters lies in fill volume. While both use the same quality materials - either Canadian duck down with 700 fill power or a hypoallergenic synthetic down-alternative - the Ultra-Warm version contains significantly more of it. This extra fill makes it substantially warmer and more insulating.
The All Season is designed for a room temperature around 65-72°F, offering a comfortable middle ground. The Ultra-Warm excels in bedrooms that dip below 65°F, trapping more body heat and keeping you toasty even when it's frigid outside.
Weight & Tactile Feel
Weight directly impacts how a comforter feels. The All Season is light enough that you can move freely without feeling restricted, making it ideal for restless sleepers. It drapes comfortably over your body without being heavy.
The Ultra-Warm has a noticeable heft and is much puffier due to its higher loft. This creates a deeply cozy, "tucked-in" sensation that many people find comforting. If you love the feel of a weighty, plush blanket, the Ultra-Warm delivers that experience.
Materials & Construction
In terms of build quality, both comforters are identical. They both feature a 400-thread count, 100% long-staple cotton sateen shell that feels smooth, soft, and breathable. They are also both built with a baffle-box construction, meaning internal fabric walls create individual pockets to keep the fill from shifting and clumping, ensuring consistent warmth across the entire surface. The only difference is what’s inside those boxes.
Price & Value
The Ultra-Warm costs more than the All Season - typically $40-$140 more depending on the fill type and size. The added cost comes directly from the increased amount of fill material used. The best value depends entirely on your needs. For most people, the All Season offers year-round value and is a more practical investment. For someone in a cold climate who would otherwise use multiple blankets or supplemental heating, the Ultra-Warm's price is justified by its superior performance and comfort.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both comforters are excellent choices, but they cater to very different sleepers and environments.
Choose the All Season if:
- You live in a temperate climate with moderately cold winters.
- You tend to sleep warm or have good central heating.
- You want one versatile comforter that you can use for most of the year.
- You prefer lighter bedding that doesn’t feel restrictive.
- You want the best overall value for average sleeping conditions.
Choose the Ultra-Warm if:
- You live in an area with harsh, cold winters.
- You self-identify as a "cold sleeper" who is always reaching for another blanket.
- You love the plush, heavy, high-loft feel of a hotel-style comforter.
- Your bedroom is drafty or you keep your thermostat low at night.
- Warmth is your absolute top priority and seasonal versatility is less important.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the main difference between the Brooklinen All Season and Ultra-Warm?
The main difference is the amount of fill inside. The Ultra-Warm comforter has significantly more down or down-alternative fill, making it heavier, loftier, and much warmer than the All Season version. The All Season is designed for versatile year-round use, while the Ultra-Warm is a specialist for cold climates and cold sleepers.
Which comforter is better for couples?
The All Season is generally the safer bet for couples, as it breathes well and accommodates different body temperatures more easily. The Ultra-Warm can be too insulating if one person sleeps hot, potentially causing discomfort for the warmer partner.
Are both comforters machine washable?
Yes, both the All Season and Ultra-Warm comforters are designed to be machine washable. However, the Ultra-Warm's bulkiness may require a large-capacity, front-loading washing machine to ensure a proper clean without damaging the comforter or the appliance.
Do I need a duvet cover for my Brooklinen comforter?
While not strictly required, using a duvet cover is highly recommended. All Brooklinen comforters come with corner loops to secure a cover. A cover protects the comforter from dirt and oils, dramatically reducing how often you need to wash the comforter itself and extending its lifespan.
Will the fill shift or clump over time?
No. Both comforters feature a baffle-box construction, which creates individual chambers that hold the fill in place. This design prevents the down or down-alternative from shifting to the edges or clumping in one spot, ensuring even warmth and loft.
Is the down-alternative version as good as the down version?
Brooklinen's down-alternative fill is designed to mimic the properties of real down. It's hypoallergenic, easier on the budget, and provides excellent warmth. Natural down is typically a bit lighter for its level of warmth, more breathable, and has a longer lifespan if cared for properly. The choice comes down to budget, allergy concerns, and personal preference.
Is the Ultra-Warm comforter too heavy to sleep under?
It's weighty but not necessarily "heavy" in a restrictive way. The weight comes from the plush, airy fill, so it feels substantial and cozy rather than oppressive. However, if you are very sensitive to weight on your body, the All Season would be a better choice.
Which comforter is a better overall value?
The All Season offers better value for the majority of sleepers because of its versatility across seasons. You get more use out of it during the year for a lower price point. The Ultra-Warm is a valuable investment for those who genuinely need its high level of insulation to sleep comfortably in the winter.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
