Breville is a premium brand crafting high-performance, feature-rich coffee and espresso machines for enthusiasts, while Mr. Coffee is a household name focused on producing affordable, straightforward, and reliable brewers for everyday use. Key differences hinge on price, materials, and technology, with Breville offering stainless steel construction and precision control for a high price, versus Mr. Coffee's simple plastic designs built for value and convenience.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right coffee maker for your kitchen.
Breville: The Premium Choice for Home Baristas
Breville is an Australian brand known for its thoughtfully designed, high-quality kitchen appliances that blend professional performance with consumer-friendly interfaces. Their coffee and espresso machines are aimed at home baristas and coffee lovers who value precision, durability, and a modern aesthetic. They are considered an investment piece for those serious about their coffee ritual.
- Product mix: Extensive range of high-end espresso machines, drip coffee makers, grinders, and all-in-one brewers like the Barista Express. They are leaders in machines that offer a high degree of user control.
- Style/vibe: Sleek, modern, and sophisticated. The dominant look is brushed stainless steel with clean lines and intuitive digital displays, designed to be a centerpiece on a kitchen counter.
- Price point: Mid to high-end. Drip coffee makers start around $300, while their popular espresso machines range from $500 to over $2,500 for advanced models.
- Quality & Materials: Constructed with durable, high-quality materials like stainless steel and precision-engineered internal components. Build quality is a major selling point, with products designed to last many years.
- Key Features: Advanced technology is standard. Features often include integrated burr grinders, precise temperature control (PID), programmable settings, and powerful steam wands for microfoam milk frothing.
- Warranty: Typically comes with a 1- or 2-year limited product warranty, reflecting the brand's confidence in its craftsmanship.
With its focus on performance and construction, Breville is the go-to for coffee lovers willing to invest in superior results and design.
Shop Breville: breville.com
Mr. Coffee: The Affordable & Reliable Classic
Since the 1970s, Mr. Coffee has been a staple in American households, earning a reputation for making simple, effective, and budget-friendly coffee makers. The brand caters to the casual coffee drinker who wants a dependable and easy way to brew a pot of coffee without complex features or a high price tag. Their appeal lies in their accessibility and straightforward operation.
- Product mix: A wide variety of basic drip coffee makers, alongside some single-serve machines and simple espresso makers. The focus is on fundamental brewing for the mass market.
- Style/vibe: Practical and functional. Designs are typically made of black or white plastic with simple switches and dials, prioritizing utility over style.
- Price point: Highly affordable. Most of their popular 12-cup drip coffee makers are priced between $30 and $70, making the brand accessible to nearly everyone.
- Quality & Materials: Primarily built with lightweight plastics and basic internal components. While reliable for daily use, they are not intended for long-term durability in the same way premium machines are.
- Key Features: Simplicity is key. Common features include auto-pause for grabbing a cup mid-brew, simple on/off switches, and some models offer a delay-brew timer.
- Warranty: Products typically include a 1-year limited warranty.
Mr. Coffee excels at providing dependable, no-fuss coffee brewing at an unbeatable price point, making it a perfect choice for budget-conscious households.
Shop Mr. Coffee: mrcoffeebrand.com
Breville vs. Mr. Coffee Comparison
Price Comparison
There is a massive price disparity between the two brands. A top-of-the-line Mr. Coffee machine might cost around $100, while this is well below the entry-level price for even the most basic Breville drip coffee maker. Breville's espresso machines start around $500 and can easily exceed $2,000.
Mr. Coffee wins on sheer affordability, offering incredible value for anyone who just needs a standard cup of coffee. Breville's value comes from its performance, features, and durability, it's a long-term investment for a superior coffee experience.
Style & Aesthetic
The visual difference is stark. Breville machines are designed to be shown off, featuring brushed stainless steel, elegant lines, and a modern feel that complements high-end kitchens. They look and feel like premium appliances.
Mr. Coffee's design is purely utilitarian. Made mostly of plastic, their machines are functional and compact but lack any aesthetic flair. They are designed to do a job, not to make a design statement.
Quality & Construction
Breville's commitment to quality is evident in its material choice. Heavy-duty stainless steel housings, high-quality internal boilers, and commercial-style components mean these machines are heavy, sturdy, and built to withstand years of daily use.
Mr. Coffee machines are lightweight and made almost entirely of plastic. While perfectly functional, the build quality reflects the low price point. They are known for getting the job done reliably for a few years but are not considered a "buy-it-for-life" appliance.
Features & Brewing Technology
This is where Breville truly separates itself. Breville machines are packed with technology, from thermocoil heating systems and digital temperature controls for precise espresso extraction to integrated burr grinders and programmable settings that let users craft the perfect coffee.
Mr. Coffee intentionally keeps it simple. Its features are focused on convenience, not craft. This includes things like having a clock to pre-program your brew time, a warming plate to keep coffee hot, and an auto-pause function. They do one thing - brew drip coffee - and do it simply.
Shopping Experience
Finding a Mr. Coffee machine is easy. They are available at almost all major big-box retailers like Target and Walmart, as well as on Amazon and in grocery stores. It's a convenient, mass-market product.
Breville is sold at more discerning retailers, including specialty appliance stores, high-end department stores like Williams-Sonoma and Best Buy, and directly from their website. The shopping experience is more considered, often involving research into specific models and features.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands make popular coffee makers, but they serve completely different needs and budgets.
Choose Breville if:
- You view coffee as a hobby and want to craft cafe-quality drinks at home.
- You are willing to invest a significant amount for superior performance, durability, and a modern design.
- You want an all-in-one machine with features like a built-in grinder and milk steamer.
- Build quality and premium materials like stainless steel are important to you.
Choose Mr. Coffee if:
- You want a simple, reliable pot of coffee every morning with zero fuss.
- Your primary concern is budget, and you need a highly affordable option.
- You have no need for espresso, milk frothing, or other specialty features.
- You value simplicity and ease of use over all other factors.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Breville or Mr. Coffee cheaper?
Mr. Coffee is significantly cheaper. Most of their coffee makers cost under $100, while Breville's machines start at several hundred dollars and can cost well over a thousand.
Which has better quality construction?
Breville has far superior build quality. Its use of stainless steel and premium internal components makes it more durable and long-lasting compared to the primarily plastic construction of a Mr. Coffee machine.
Is Breville worth the money?
For coffee enthusiasts who will use the advanced features and appreciate the build quality, Breville is widely considered to be worth the investment. It provides a level of control and consistency that cheaper machines cannot match.
How long do Mr. Coffee machines last?
With regular cleaning and care, a Mr. Coffee maker can typically be expected to last between 2 to 5 years. Their lifespan is consistent with their low price point.
Which brand is better for espresso?
Breville is the clear winner for espresso. It is one of the leading brands in the home espresso machine market, offering a range of models for everyone from beginners to experienced home baristas. Most Mr. Coffee models do not make true espresso.
Which brand is easier to use?
Mr. Coffee is easier to use for basic drip coffee. Its machines often require just adding water, grounds, and pressing a single button. While Breville machines are user-friendly, their advanced features come with a steeper learning curve.
Can you get Breville at mass retailers like Target?
Typically, no. You'll find Breville products at specialty kitchen stores, upscale department stores, and online. Mr. Coffee is a fixture at mass retailers like Target and Walmart.
Which one is best for a quick morning coffee before work?
For convenience and speed for a standard pot of coffee, Mr. Coffee is ideal. Many of their models have a "Brew Now" function or can be programmed the night before, so coffee is ready when you wake up. For a quick espresso drink, however, a Breville machine heats up fast and delivers on demand.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
