The Breville Precision Brewer and Bonavita Precision Coffee Brewer both make excellent coffee, but they cater to very different users. The Breville brewer is a feature-rich machine built for coffee enthusiasts who want full control over every variable - including brew time, temperature, and flow rate. In contrast, the Bonavita from Bonavita is a simple, no-frills workhorse designed to do one thing perfectly: brew consistently great coffee with one-touch ease.
Here's everything you need to know to decide which coffee maker from Breville or Bonavita is right for your kitchen.
Breville Precision Brewer
The Breville Precision Brewer is the go-to choice for home coffee brewers who want total control. It's packed with customizable settings that mimic various brewing methods, from pour-over to cold brew, all housed in a premium stainless steel body. This machine is for tinkerers and coffee hobbyists who enjoy dialing in the perfect cup.
- What it is: A highly advanced and customizable 60 oz drip coffee maker with multiple brewing modes.
- Key features: Six brewing modes (Gold, Fast, Strong, Iced, Cold Brew, My Brew), precise and adjustable temperature control (PID), adjustable bloom time and flow rate, dual filter basket compatibility (cone and flat bottom).
- Price: $250 - $300
- Dimensions: 12.4" x 6.7" x 15.7"
- Materials/Construction: Brushed stainless steel casing with a thermal carafe.
- Style: Modern and sophisticated with a bright LCD screen and an industrial-chic aesthetic.
- Pros: Unmatched customization for a home brewer. Can brew both cold brew and hot coffee. Maintains exact water temperature for optimal extraction. Premium build quality. Includes both cone and basket filter inserts.
- Cons: Significantly more expensive than simpler models. The array of options can be overwhelming for casual users. Larger countertop footprint than the Bonavita.
The Breville Precision Brewer is ideal for the coffee connoisseur who wants to experiment with every part of the brewing process and is willing to pay for premium quality and features.
Shop this product: breville.com/us/en/products/coffee/bdc450.html
Bonavita Precision Coffee Brewer
Bonavita’s brewer, typically the 8-cup model, has a cult following for its simplicity and consistently excellent performance. It focuses on the essentials of great coffee - precise water temperature and even saturation - without any complicated settings or modes. It's designed to bring out the best in your beans with a simple push of a button.
- What it is: A user-friendly, high-performance drip coffee maker known for its reliability and excellent value.
- Key features: One-touch brewing process, optional pre-infusion mode to bloom grounds, powerful 1500-watt heater for maintaining optimal temperature (195°-205°F), large showerhead for excellent saturation.
- Price: $150 - $200
- Dimensions: Approximately 8" x 8" x 15"
- Materials/Construction: Combination of stainless steel and BPA-free plastic with a stainless steel thermal carafe.
- Style: Utilitarian and minimalist, its form is dictated entirely by its function.
- Pros: Extremely easy to use. Excellent performance and consistency for the price. Maintains SCA-certified brewing temperature. Compact and fits easily on most countertops.
- Cons: Lacks any customization or brew options. Utilitarian design isn't as visually impressive. The plastic components may feel less premium compared to the Breville.
The Bonavita brewer is perfect for anyone who wants consistently fantastic coffee without the fuss and prefers a machine that prioritizes performance over features.
Shop this product: bonavita.com/collections/brewers
Breville Precision Brewer vs. Bonavita Comparison
Features & Customization
This is the most significant point of difference. The Breville Precision Brewer is designed for total control, featuring six unique presets. The "My Brew" setting lets you adjust bloom time, flow rate, and brew temperature yourself, giving you pour-over levels of precision in an automatic machine. You can even brew true cold brew over several hours.
The Bonavita offers the opposite experience. It has one button to start the brew and an optional pre-infusion mode you can activate by holding the button. Its entire design philosophy is built around a single, optimized brewing process that works perfectly every time. It’s simple, effective, and requires no learning curve.
Performance & Consistency
Both machines are celebrated for their ability to brew coffee at the Specialty Coffee Association (SCA) Golden Cup Standard, which means maintaining a water temperature between 195°F and 205°F. Both use wide showerheads to ensure the coffee grounds are evenly saturated, leading to a balanced extraction.
The Bonavita is relentlessly consistent out of the box. The Breville allows for consistent results once you've found a setting you like, but its true strength is versatility rather than single-minded consistency. For a user who just wants a great drip coffee every morning with no changes, the Bonavita delivers flawlessly.
Dimensions & Design
The Breville has a striking, premium appearance with its brushed stainless steel body, clear water tank, and large LCD screen. It’s larger and designed to be a centerpiece appliance. The Bonavita is more understated and compact, with a mix of stainless steel and plastic parts. Its design is practical and space-efficient, meant to blend in rather than stand out.
Price & Value
The Breville Precision Brewer costs around $100-$150 more than the Bonavita. The value proposition for the Breville is its extensive feature set - you get a cold brewer, an iced coffee maker, and a highly customizable drip machine all in one. If you'll use those features, the price is justified.
The Bonavita offers exceptional value by delivering pro-level brewing performance at a mid-range price. Its value lies in durability and simplicity, it does one job, and it does it as well as machines that cost twice as much. For budget-conscious buyers focused solely on the quality of hot drip coffee, the Bonavita is a clear winner in value.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both coffee makers produce excellent results, but they serve different needs and are built for different people.
Choose the Breville Precision Brewer if:
- You enjoy the process of customizing your coffee to find the perfect brew.
- You want the versatility to make hot coffee, iced coffee, and true cold brew.
- A premium, modern design that complements your kitchen is important to you.
- Your budget allows for a higher-end appliance with advanced technology.
Choose the Bonavita Precision Coffee Brewer if:
- You want a simple, one-touch machine that works perfectly every time.
- You prioritize consistently brewed coffee and don't need extra features.
- You are looking for the best performance and brew quality for your money.
- You have limited counter space and need a more compact brewer.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the Breville and Bonavita brewers?
The primary difference is customization versus simplicity. The Breville offers six brew modes and near-total control over brewing variables. The Bonavita offers one reliable brew mode with simple one-touch operation.
Are both brewers SCA certified?
Yes, both Breville and Bonavita models are consistently recognized and certified by the Specialty Coffee Association (SCA) for meeting their rigorous standards for home brewing, particularly regarding water temperature and brewing time.
Which coffee maker is more reliable?
Both brands have a strong reputation for reliability. Due to its simpler mechanics and fewer electronic components, the Bonavita is often cited by users as a long-lasting workhorse with fewer potential points of failure.
Does the Breville make better coffee?
Not necessarily. It makes coffee with more *control*. For a user who dials in the settings, the Breville can produce a cup tailored exactly to their preferences. The Bonavita, however, makes an exceptional, balanced cup of coffee without any user input needed. The quality is comparable, the process is different.
Can you use different filter types with the Breville brewer?
Yes, one of the Breville's key features is that it includes interchangeable inserts for both flat-bottom basket filters and cone filters, allowing you to experiment with how different filter shapes affect extraction.
Is the Breville Precision Brewer worth the extra money?
If you will frequently use its advanced settings, like the "My Brew" mode, or make cold brew and iced coffee, then yes, its versatility justifies the price. If you only plan to brew standard drip coffee, the Bonavita offers better value.
Which brewer is easier to clean?
The Bonavita is generally easier to clean due to its simpler construction. The carafe, filter basket, and showerhead are all easily removable. The Breville has more parts, but its cleaning cycle and clear instructions make maintenance straightforward.
Do these machines come with a thermal carafe?
Yes, both the Breville Precision Brewer and the standard Bonavita 8-Cup Brewer come with a double-walled stainless steel thermal carafe to keep your coffee hot for hours without the scorching effect of a hot plate.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
