The Breville Infuser and Gaggia Classic are two of the most popular espresso machines for home use, but they cater to very different philosophies. The Breville Infuser is a modern machine packed with technology like digital temperature control (PID) and pre-infusion for user-friendly, consistent results, while the Gaggia Classic is a traditional, Italian-made workhorse built with commercial-grade parts for durability and exceptional espresso purity.
Here's everything you need to know to choose the right espresso machine from Breville or Gaggia for your morning coffee ritual.
Breville Infuser
The Breville Infuser is designed for the home barista who wants advanced features and precision without the complexity of a fully commercial machine. It stands out with a built-in pressure gauge and low-pressure pre-infusion technology, which gently soaks the coffee grounds before extraction to ensure a balanced and flavorful shot of espresso.
- What it is: A semi-automatic espresso machine that bridges the gap between beginner-friendly automation and manual control, known for its shot consistency features.
- Key features: Low-pressure pre-infusion, digital PID temperature control for water stability, 1600W Thermo-coil heating system, and a dedicated pressure gauge to monitor extraction.
- Price: Around $600
- Dimensions: 12.5" x 10.25" x 13.25" (Width x Depth x Height). It has a reasonable footprint for most kitchens.
- Materials/Construction: It has a brushed stainless steel finish with smartly integrated plastic components housing user-friendly digital controls.
- Style: Sleek, modern, and high-tech. Its polished steel and clear digital interface fit perfectly in contemporary kitchen designs.
- Pros: Excellent temperature stability with its PID. Pre-infusion leads to more consistent and forgiving shots. User-friendly and faster to learn than a fully manual machine. Includes helpful accessories like a razor dosing tool.
- Cons: More internal electronic components can mean more potential points of failure over many years. Not as repair-friendly or modifiable as the Gaggia Classic. Higher price point for an entry-level machine.
The Infuser is for the coffee enthusiast who values precision, consistency, and modern conveniences to make café-quality espresso at home with a gentler learning curve.
Shop this product: seattlecoffeegear.com/breville-infuser-espresso-machine-bes840xl
Gaggia Classic Pro
The Gaggia Classic Pro is a legendary machine in the espresso community, famous for its 'built-like-a-tank' construction and simple, effective design. It uses commercial-grade components in a home-sized package, appealing to purists who want to learn the fundamentals of espresso making on durable, straightforward hardware.
- What it is: A rugged, semi-automatic espresso machine that delivers an authentic, traditional Italian espresso experience.
- Key features: Commercial-grade 58mm chrome-plated brass portafilter and brew group, a powerful commercial-style steam wand, and simple three-switch operation.
- Price: Around $450
- Dimensions: 9.5" x 8" x 14.2" (Width x Depth x Height). Its tall, narrow profile is very space-efficient.
- Materials/Construction: A durable brushed stainless steel body houses a rugged interior with a brass brew group for excellent thermal stability.
- Style: Timeless, industrial, and utilitarian. It looks like a miniature version of a classic Italian café machine, appealing to those who appreciate heritage and function over frills.
- Pros: Extremely durable and built to last for decades with proper care. Uses commercial components that deliver exceptional espresso and steaming power. Easy to repair and has a massive community for modifications and upgrades. More affordable purchase price.
- Cons: Lacks precision features like a PID, leading to some temperature surfing for best results. Steeper learning curve to pull consistently good shots. Bare-bones approach means no pressure gauge or automatic features.
The Gaggia Classic Pro suits the aspiring barista who wants a machine that will last a lifetime, enjoys a hands-on process, and values the ability to repair or upgrade their machine.
Shop this product: wholelattelove.com/products/gaggia-classic-pro-rigid-stainless-steel
Breville Infuser vs. Gaggia Classic Comparison
User Experience & Features
The brewing experience is the biggest difference between these two machines. The Breville Infuser is feature-rich. It has a pressure gauge to give you real-time feedback and its PID and pre-infusion systems work automatically to create more consistent shots with less effort from the user. It is designed to take the guesswork out of the equation.
The Gaggia Classic Pro offers a much more analog, manual experience. You control everything with three simple rocker switches for power, brewing, and steam. There's no PID, meaning you may need to learn techniques like "temperature surfing" to hit the perfect brew temperature. It forces you to learn the craft of espresso by feel, which many enthusiasts enjoy, but it can be frustrating for beginners.
Materials & Construction
Both machines feature brushed stainless steel housings, but their internals showcase different philosophies. Gaggia is famous for its commercial-grade components. The heavy-duty 58mm portafilter and group head are made of chrome-plated brass, which retains heat far better than the stainless steel used in many consumer machines. This commitment to traditional, rugged parts is why Gaggias from decades ago are still in use.
The Breville Infuser is also well-built, but its construction focuses on integrating modern technology. It uses more sophisticated electronics for its PID and pre-infusion features. While it feels solid, the reliance on electronics means it’s generally less repairable at home and may not have the multi-decade lifespan of the simpler Gaggia.
Price & Value
The Gaggia Classic is consistently the more affordable option, typically priced around $450. Its value comes from its longevity and performance, you're paying for core, commercial-quality components that produce excellent espresso. It's often seen as one of the best long-term investments in home coffee.
Priced around $600, the Breville Infuser's higher cost reflects its advanced features. Its value lies in convenience and consistency. You get modern technology like a PID, a pre-infusion mode, and a pressure gauge without having to jump to a much more expensive machine.
Style & Aesthetics
In terms of looks, the choice comes down to personal taste. The Breville Infuser is polished and modern, with its dials, display, and shiny steel finish fitting perfectly into a contemporary kitchen aesthetic alongside other premium appliances.
The Gaggia Classic is a style icon for a different reason. Its design is timeless and utilitarian, reflecting its Italian espresso heritage. The simple lines and rocker switches give it a more industrial, professional look that appeals to those who prefer classic, function-driven design.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both the Infuser and the Classic are fantastic machines, but they shine for different types of coffee lovers.
Choose the Breville Infuser if:
- You want user-friendly features that help you pull consistent shots right away.
- You value precision controls like a digital PID to maintain perfect water temperature.
- You appreciate a modern aesthetic with clear feedback from a pressure gauge.
- You prioritize a streamlined workflow over manual tinkering.
Choose the Gaggia Classic if:
- You're on a tighter budget but still want authentic, cafe-quality espresso.
- You value extreme durability, repairability, and a machine that could last a lifetime.
- You enjoy the hands-on process of making espresso and want to master the craft.
- You see yourself possibly modifying or upgrading your machine in the future.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the Breville Infuser and Gaggia Classic?
The main difference is technology vs. tradition. The Breville Infuser uses modern electronics (PID, pre-infusion) for consistency and ease of use. The Gaggia Classic uses heavy-duty, traditional components for durability and a more hands-on espresso experience.
Which machine is better for beginners?
The Breville Infuser is generally easier for a complete beginner to get good results from quickly, as its features help create more forgiving extractions. The Gaggia Classic has simpler controls but a steeper learning curve to master the variables of espresso making.
Does the Breville Infuser have a built-in grinder?
No, the Breville Infuser does not have a built-in grinder. You'll need a separate coffee grinder. The model with a grinder is the Breville Barista Express.
Can I use pre-ground coffee in these machines?
Yes, both machines come with "dual-wall" or pressurized filter baskets designed to work with pre-ground coffee by artificially creating pressure. However, for the best results, using freshly ground beans with the standard non-pressurized baskets is highly recommended.
What is pre-infusion and why is it important?
Pre-infusion, a key feature of the Breville Infuser, is when the machine uses an initial burst of low water pressure to gently saturate the coffee puck. This helps settle the coffee grounds and can prevent channeling (when water finds an easy path and bypasses some of the coffee), leading to a more even and flavorful extraction.
Is the Gaggia Classic difficult to maintain?
No, its simplicity makes it easy to maintain. Regular maintenance involves cleaning the group head, backflushing with a blind basket, and descaling the boiler, which are standard practices for all espresso machines. Because of its popularity, there are countless guides online for every maintenance task.
Which machine has a better steam wand for milk foam?
The Gaggia Classic Pro is widely praised for its powerful, commercial-style steam wand, which can create professional-quality microfoam for latte art once you master it. The Breville Infuser's steam wand is also quite capable, but many find the Gaggia's raw power to be superior for more experienced users.
Which machine will last longer?
Most experts would agree the Gaggia Classic is more likely to last longer. Its simple mechanical design and lack of complex electronics mean there are fewer points of failure. The machine is completely serviceable, and spare parts are cheap and widely available.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
