The Breville and Cuisinart ice cream makers cater to different home chefs, with the primary difference centering on built-in compressors, price, and overall design. Breville models are premium machines with self-refrigerating compressors for spontaneous ice cream making, wrapped in a sleek stainless steel body. Cuisinart offers a wider range of affordable options, including popular freezer-bowl models that require advance planning but deliver reliable results at a lower cost.
Here's a detailed comparison to help you find the right ice cream maker for your kitchen.
Breville Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker
Breville's ice cream maker is a high-performance appliance designed for the serious home cook who values convenience and precision. It features a built-in compressor, which means you can make batch after batch of ice cream, gelato, or sorbet without ever needing to pre-freeze a bowl. Its smart features, like adjustable hardness settings and a pre-cool function, take the guesswork out of achieving perfect texture every time.
- What it is: A premium, self-refrigerating ice cream maker with a built-in compressor.
- Key features: 12 hardness settings (for sorbet, frozen yogurt, gelato, and ice cream), a powerful built-in compressor, pre-cool function, and a keep-cool setting that holds temperature for up to 3 hours.
- Price: Around $499.95.
- Style: Modern and minimalist, with a brushed stainless steel finish that complements other high-end kitchen appliances.
- Materials/Construction: Durable stainless steel housing with a sturdy build designed for longevity.
- Pros: No pre-freezing required, allowing for spontaneous use. Highly consistent results thanks to precise controls. Can make multiple batches back-to-back. Sleek, premium aesthetic.
- Cons: Significant price difference compared to freezer-bowl models. It is heavier and takes up more counter space.
The Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop is built for the ice cream enthusiast who wants a top-of-the-line machine that provides ultimate control and convenience.
Shop this product: breville.com/us/en/products/ice-cream/bci600.html
Cuisinart ICE-21 Ice Cream Maker
Cuisinart offers a range of ice cream makers, with their freezer-bowl models being extremely popular for their simplicity, reliability, and affordability. The ICE-21 is a workhorse that consistently produces smooth, creamy results without any complicated settings or features. Its straightforward design requires you to freeze the double-insulated bowl for 12-24 hours beforehand, making it a great choice for those who can plan their dessert-making in advance.
- What it is: An affordable and highly dependable ice cream maker that uses a pre-frozen bowl.
- Key features: Double-insulated 1.5-quart freezer bowl, a simple on/off operation, and an easy-lock transparent lid with a large spout for adding mix-ins.
- Price: Around $69.95.
- Style: Functional and practical with a clean, classic look. Available in multiple colors to fit different kitchen decors.
- Materials/Construction: Sturdy plastic base with a durable, double-insulated freezer bowl.
- Pros: Very budget-friendly. Extremely simple to operate. Compact footprint on the counter. Consistently good results for basic ice cream and sorbet. Comes in fun color options.
- Cons: Requires you to pre-freeze the bowl for at least 12 hours. Can only make one batch at a time before the bowl needs to be refrozen. The plastic construction feels less premium than the Breville.
The Cuisinart ice cream makers are perfect for casual users, families on a budget, or anyone new to homemade ice cream who wants a reliable machine without a big investment.
Shop this product: cuisinart.com/shopping/appliances/ice_cream_makers/ice-21/
Breville vs. Cuisinart Comparison
Price & Value
Cuisinart is the clear winner on price. Their popular freezer-bowl models are a fraction of the cost of a Breville compressor machine, making homemade ice cream highly accessible. The value is excellent for users who only make ice cream occasionally.
The Breville Smart Scoop is a significant investment. Its value lies in its convenience, precision, and performance. For frequent users or dessert aficionados, the ability to make ice cream on impulse and achieve perfect results every time justifies the higher cost.
Performance & Convenience
Convenience is Breville's main strength. The built-in compressor eliminates the need to plan ahead and freeze a bowl, allowing you to go from craving to creamy dessert in about an hour. It can also make consecutive batches and has a "keep cool" feature that prevents your finished product from melting.
Cuisinart's freezer-bowl models require foresight. You must clear freezer space and store the heavy bowl for 12-24 hours before use. Once you make a batch, you have to wash and refreeze the bowl before making more, which is less ideal for parties or large families. However, once the bowl is frozen, the machine itself is fast and efficient.
Materials & Construction
Breville uses premium materials, dominated by brushed stainless steel. The machine feels substantial, durable, and looks like a professional-grade appliance. It's built to last and to be a showpiece on the countertop.
Cuisinart's construction is primarily durable plastic. While it's perfectly reliable and sturdy for its intended use, it doesn't have the same high-end feel as the Breville. It’s functional and designed for easy storage and use, not necessarily for display.
Style & Aesthetics
Breville offers a sleek, modern, and professional aesthetic that easily integrates into contemporary kitchen designs. Its polished look and digital interface are designed for those who appreciate stylish, high-tech appliances.
Cuisinart models are more utilitarian and classic in their styling. While some models come in various fun colors, the overall look is focused on practicality. It's a friendly, approachable appliance rather than a design statement.
Size & Capacity
Both brands offer standard home-use capacities, typically around 1.5 to 2 quarts. The Breville compressor model has a larger overall footprint and is heavier, requiring a dedicated spot on the counter. Cuisinart’s freezer-bowl models are smaller and lighter on the counter, but their bulky freezer bowls demand significant, long-term space in your freezer.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands produce excellent ice cream, but they are designed for very different users and priorities.
Choose Breville if:
- You want to make ice cream, gelato, or sorbet on a whim without any planning.
- You value precision controls for achieving different textures and consistencies.
- A premium, stainless steel design is important to you.
- You plan to make ice cream frequently or need to make multiple batches at once for gatherings.
Choose Cuisinart if:
- You're working with a tighter budget and want fantastic results for a lower price.
- You don't mind planning and pre-freezing the bowl a day in advance.
- You're looking for a simple, no-fuss machine that's easy for the whole family to use.
- You expect to make ice cream occasionally rather than weekly.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Breville and Cuisinart ice cream makers?
The primary difference is the cooling method. Breville machines have built-in compressors, so they refrigerate themselves. Most popular Cuisinart models use a freezer bowl that must be frozen for 12-24 hours before use. This makes Breville more convenient but also much more expensive.
Which is better for a beginner?
Cuisinart is often recommended for beginners due to its low cost and simple operation. It’s an accessible way to start making homemade ice cream. However, a beginner with a larger budget may find Breville easier to use since it removes the pre-freezing step entirely.
Do I really need to pre-freeze the Cuisinart bowl?
Yes, absolutely. The pre-frozen bowl is the machine's sole source of cold. If it's not frozen completely solid, your ice cream base won't churn and freeze properly, resulting in a soupy mess.
How long does it take to make ice cream in each?
Churn time is similar for both, typically 20-40 minutes. The big difference is the prep time. Breville is ready in minutes with its pre-cool function. Cuisinart requires 12-24 hours to freeze the bowl before you can even start.
Is the Breville Smart Scoop worth the money?
For avid dessert makers, yes. Its ability to create different frozen desserts with precise hardness control, along with its on-demand convenience, makes it a powerful kitchen tool. If you plan to use it weekly, its build quality and performance justify the investment.
Which machine is easier to clean?
Both are quite easy to clean. Most of the parts that come into contact with the ice cream base - the bowl, paddle, and lid - are removable for hand washing. Neither brand typically recommends putting the bowls or paddles in the dishwasher.
Can you make gelato in a Cuisinart freezer-bowl model?
You can make a gelato-style base and churn it in a Cuisinart, but true gelato is churned at a slower speed to incorporate less air. Models like the Breville Smart Scoop have a dedicated gelato setting and paddle, offering more authentic results. Cuisinart also offers a compressor model with a gelato paddle if that feature is important to you.
How much space does the Cuisinart freezer bowl take up?
A Cuisinart freezer bowl is roughly 8 inches in diameter and 6 inches tall. It's a bulky item that needs a permanent spot in a freezer with enough clearance, which can be a challenge in smaller or packed freezers.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
