The Breville BES870XL Barista Express and the Rancilio Silvia are two of the most popular home espresso machines, but they target very different users. The Breville from Breville is an all-in-one solution with a built-in grinder and user-friendly features, making it ideal for beginners, while the Silvia by Rancilio is a famously durable, commercial-grade machine that offers superior performance and longevity for the serious espresso enthusiast.
Here's everything you need to know to decide which of these iconic espresso machines belongs on your kitchen counter.
Breville The Barista Express Impress
The Breville Barista Express is the go-to choice for aspiring home baristas who want an all-in-one machine without the hassle. It simplifies the espresso-making process by integrating a conical burr grinder, precise dose control, and a pressure gauge, taking much of the guesswork out of pulling a great shot.
- What it is: A user-friendly, semi-automatic espresso machine with a built-in grinder.
- Key features: Integrated conical burr grinder, precise dose control grinding, digital temperature control (PID), pressure gauge for optimal extraction, powerful steam wand.
- Price: Around $700 - $750
- Style: Modern and sleek, with a polished stainless steel finish that looks at home in contemporary kitchens.
- Materials/Construction: Features a stainless steel boiler and body, with some durable plastic components in the grinder and housing.
- Dimensions: 12.5" x 13.2" x 16.9"
- Pros: Excellent value with an included grinder. Easy for beginners to learn on. Sleek, all-in-one design saves counter space. Pressure gauge provides instant feedback for improving technique.
- Cons: Built-in grinder is good but not as powerful or consistent as high-end standalone grinders. Longevity is more in line with a consumer appliance rather than a commercial machine. Some core components are plastic.
This machine is perfect for anyone who wants café-quality espresso at home without needing a separate grinder or a deep understanding of espresso theory from day one.
Shop this product: breville.com/us/en/products/espresso/bes870.html
Rancilio Silvia
The Rancilio Silvia is a legendary semi-automatic espresso machine that's earned a cult following for its robust build and exceptional performance. Made with commercial-grade parts, it's a simple, powerful workhorse designed to produce outstanding espresso for decades when properly cared for.
- What it is: A professional-grade, manual semi-automatic espresso machine for home use.
- Key features: Commercial-grade 58mm group head and portafilter, large brass boiler for excellent temperature stability, powerful articulating steam wand, simple three-switch interface.
- Price: Around $700 - $800 (machine only)
- Style: Classic, industrial Italian espresso maker aesthetic with a heavy-duty brushed stainless steel housing.
- Materials/Construction: Built with a heavy-duty stainless steel frame, a lead-free brass boiler, and commercial-quality internal components for unmatched durability.
- Dimensions: 9.2" x 11.4" x 13.4"
- Pros: Incredible durability and longevity, built to last for decades. Produces truly cafe-quality espresso. Powerful steam wand is excellent for microfoam. Holds its resale value extraordinarily well.
- Cons: Requires a separate, high-quality burr grinder (a significant extra cost). Has a steep learning curve for beginners and is less forgiving of mistakes. Lacks built-in features like a shot timer or pressure gauge.
The Silvia is for the serious espresso hobbyist who prioritizes shot quality and build longevity over convenience and is willing to invest time and money into their setup.
Shop this product: ranciliogroup.com/rancilio/silvia/
Breville BES870XL vs. Rancilio Silvia Comparison
User Experience & Learning Curve
The experience of using these two machines couldn't be more different. The Breville Barista Express is designed to guide you. Its integrated grinder adjusts dose size automatically, and the prominent pressure gauge tells you if your extraction is in the ideal range. It holds the hand of a new user, making it far easier to get a decent shot right out of the box.
The Rancilio Silvia, by contrast, is a fully manual experience. It has three simple switches - power, brew, and steam - and that's it. It expects you to know what you're doing. Mastering it requires practice, patience, and a separate high-quality grinder to control your variables. While the Silvia is much harder to learn, those who master it can produce consistently better espresso than what's possible on the Breville.
Materials & Construction
This is where the Rancilio Silvia truly shines. It is built like a commercial machine, using heavy-gauge stainless steel for the frame and a large brass boiler. This "prosumer" construction is why some Silvias are still in operation after 15-20 years. Every component is designed for durability and performance.
The Breville is well-made for a consumer kitchen appliance, featuring a stainless steel finish and a water path. However, it incorporates more plastic parts, particularly in the grinder assembly and internal housing, which are more likely to wear out or break over time. The Silvia is built for decades, the Breville is built for years.
Price & Value
While the initial prices appear similar ($700-$800), the true cost of getting started differs greatly. The Breville BES870XL is an all-in-one package, for ~$750, you have everything you need to start brewing. This represents incredible value for someone entering the hobby.
The Rancilio Silvia's ~$800 price tag is only for the machine itself. To use it effectively, you must pair it with a capable burr grinder, which can easily cost an additional $200-$400. The Silvia is a bigger long-term investment, but its legendary durability and potential for superior espresso can justify the higher total cost for dedicated enthusiasts.
Style & Footprint
The Breville has a modern, appliance-like aesthetic. Its polished finish, digital display, and integrated hopper give it a high-tech look that fits well in contemporary kitchens. It has a larger overall footprint due to the built-in grinder.
The Silvia boasts a timeless, industrial design. Its boxy shape and simple brushed steel exterior look like a miniaturized version of a machine from a classic Italian cafe. It's more compact than the Breville, making it a good fit for tighter spaces, assuming you have room for a separate grinder nearby.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both machines are excellent choices, but they are designed for two completely different home baristas.
Choose the Breville BES870XL Barista Express if:
- You're a beginner wanting an all-in-one machine to start your espresso journey.
- You value convenience and want to save counter space by not having a separate grinder.
- You appreciate helpful features like a pressure gauge and automatic dosing.
- Your budget for a complete setup is under $800.
Choose the Rancilio Silvia if:
- You are serious about the craft of making espresso and enjoy a hands-on process.
- You prioritize build quality and want a machine that could last for 15+ years.
- You already have a high-quality burr grinder or are willing to invest in one.
- You want commercial-grade steam power for perfectly textured milk.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the Barista Express and the Silvia?
The main difference is convenience versus control. The Breville Barista Express is an all-in-one appliance with a built-in grinder and user aids. The Rancilio Silvia is a manual, "prosumer" machine with commercial parts that requires a separate grinder and more skill to use.
Which machine makes better espresso?
With an experienced barista and a high-quality grinder, the Rancilio Silvia can produce better, more consistent espresso due to its superior temperature stability and commercial-grade group head. However, a beginner will likely make better espresso faster on the Breville because it's much more forgiving.
Do I need a separate grinder for the Rancilio Silvia?
Yes, absolutely. A high-quality burr grinder capable of fine, consistent espresso grinds is essential to get good results from the Silvia. This is a significant additional cost to consider.
Is the Breville Barista Express good for beginners?
Yes, it's one of the best machines for beginners. The integrated grinder, preset dose amounts, and pressure gauge help new users understand the basics of espresso and troubleshoot their shots without feeling overwhelmed.
How long does the Rancilio Silvia last?
With proper care and maintenance (like regular descaling and backflushing), a Rancilio Silvia can easily last 10-20 years. Its simple, robust construction makes it easy to repair, and parts are widely available.
Which has a better steam wand for frothing milk?
The Rancilio Silvia is known for its powerful commercial-style steam wand, which creates excellent microfoam for latte art once you master it. The Breville's steam wand is also quite capable for home use but has less power and takes longer to steam milk.
What is the total cost of getting started with each machine?
The Breville Barista Express is around $700-$750 for the entire setup. For the Rancilio Silvia, you should budget around $800 for the machine plus at least $200-$400 for a capable espresso grinder, bringing the total starting cost to $1,000-$1,200.
Can I use pre-ground coffee with these machines?
While you technically can, it's strongly discouraged for both. Freshly ground coffee is critical for good espresso. The Breville comes with a dual-wall (pressurized) filter basket that can make pre-ground coffee work, but the results will be inferior.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
