The Breville Barista Express and the Barista Express Impress are two top-tier home espresso machines from Breville that differ primarily in user experience. The classic Barista Express is a semi-automatic machine that provides full manual control over grinding, dosing, and tamping, making it a favorite for aspiring home baristas. The newer Barista Express Impress automates the trickiest parts - dosing and tamping - with an "Impress Puck System" designed to deliver perfect, consistent results with far less effort and expertise required.
Here’s a detailed look at what separates these two machines to help you decide which one belongs on your countertop.
Breville Barista Express
The Breville Barista Express has long been the gold standard for all-in-one home espresso machines. It integrates everything you need to go from bean to espresso - a grinder, a brew head, and a steam wand - into one compact unit. This machine is designed for the hands-on user who enjoys the craft of coffee making and wants total control over every step of the process.
- What it is: A fully-featured semi-automatic espresso machine with a built-in conical burr grinder for users who want to learn and perfect their barista skills.
- Key features: Integrated conical burr grinder, precise digital temperature control (PID), dose-control grinding dial, manual steam wand for milk texturing, and a pressure gauge for optimal extraction feedback.
- Price: ~$749.95
- Dimensions: 12.6" W x 12.2" D x 13.1" H
- Materials/Construction: Brushed stainless steel casing with a durable build quality designed for longevity.
- Style: A classic, almost industrial aesthetic with prominent dials, buttons, and a pressure gauge that give it a professional look and feel.
- Pros: Offers complete control over the brew process. A fantastic machine for learning the art of espresso. Excellent value for a complete bean-to-cup setup. Proven reliability and a massive community of users for tips and support.
- Cons: Has a significant learning curve, getting consistent results takes practice. Manual tamping can be messy and inconsistent for new users. The process of dialing in a shot is more involved and takes more time.
The Barista Express is the ideal choice for the coffee enthusiast who wants to dive deep into the world of espresso and doesn't mind the process of learning and experimentation.
Shop this product: breville.com/us/en/products/espresso/bes870.html
Breville Barista Express Impress
The Barista Express Impress is Breville's answer to the most common struggles faced by home espresso novices: inconsistent dosing and tamping. It takes the beloved core of the original Express and adds a revolutionary guided tamping system that ensures a perfect puck every time. It’s built for consistency and ease of use without sacrificing the quality of the final espresso shot.
- What it is: A user-friendly "assisted manual" espresso machine that simplifies tamping and dosing to eliminate the guesswork.
- Key features: The intelligent "Impress Puck System," which features assisted tamping from a side lever (applies 22lbs of pressure with a 7º twist) and intelligent dosing that automatically adjusts based on the last shot. It also has a precision conical burr grinder with 25 settings.
- Price: ~$899.95
- Dimensions: 13" W x 14.9" D x 16.1" H
- Materials/Construction: High-quality brushed stainless steel exterior, featuring the addition of the robust mechanical assisted tamping mechanism.
- Style: Sleek and modern, retaining the classic Breville look but with the noticeable and functional addition of the tamping lever on the machine's left side.
- Pros: Massively reduces the learning curve for beginners. Delivers incredibly consistent tamping and dosing. Minimizes coffee ground mess on your counter. Allows new users to pull cafe-quality shots almost immediately.
- Cons: More expensive than the original Express model. Removes manual control over tamping for those who want to perfect the skill. The assistance mechanism adds a layer of mechanical complexity.
This machine is perfect for beginners who want exceptional espresso without the steep learning curve, or for anyone who values consistency and convenience in their coffee routine.
Shop this product: breville.com/us/en/products/espresso/bes876.html
Barista Express vs. Barista Express Impress Comparison
Brewing Experience & Control
This is where the two machines diverge the most. The classic Barista Express offers a pure, unfiltered barista experience. You are in charge of every step: grinding, distributing the grounds evenly in the portafilter, and tamping with just the right amount of pressure. This provides ultimate control but requires trial and error to master. A new user might pull several sour or bitter shots before finding the perfect formula.
The Barista Express Impress streamlines this process entirely. After you grind, you pull a lever on the side of the machine, which delivers a perfect, level, 22-pound tamp every single time. Its "Intelligent Dosing" system even checks the tamped level and tells you if you need a tiny bit more or if it's perfect, ensuring your dose is correct for the next shot. You trade fine-tuned manual control for a repeatable, almost fool-proof process.
Dimensions & Scale
The machines have a very similar countertop presence, defined by their all-in-one design. The Barista Express is slightly more compact, measuring 12.6" wide by 13.1" tall. The Barista Express Impress is a bit larger to accommodate the tamping mechanism, coming in at 13" wide and 16.1" tall. Both machines require decent vertical clearance under cabinets, but the taller Impress model is something to double-check if you have lower-than-average upper cabinets.
Price & Value
The Barista Express typically costs around $750, while the Barista Express Impress is priced at about $900. That $150 premium buys you convenience, consistency, and a significantly smaller mess. For a newcomer who might otherwise get frustrated and give up, the extra cost for the Impress is tremendous value, guaranteeing good coffee from day one.
For someone who embraces the learning process or who already knows how to tamp correctly, the classic Barista Express provides better financial value. It delivers the same internal coffee-making hardware for less money, provided you supply the skill.
Who Each One Works Best For
Choosing between these two comes down to what you want out of your morning coffee routine. The original Barista Express is for the hobbyist, the tinkerer, and the aspiring expert. It’s for the person who sees making an espresso as a craft to be learned and perfected. You’ll develop real muscle memory and a deep understanding of how variables like grind size, dose, and tamp pressure affect the final cup.
The Barista Express Impress is designed for the coffee lover who prioritizes the destination (a delicious cup of espresso) over the journey. It's for beginners who feel intimidated by the nuances of tamping, for busy households where speed is key, or for anyone who simply wants a machine that helps them get it right every time without much fuss. It provides a cafe-quality experience with training wheels included.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both machines from Breville produce exceptional espresso, but they serve two very different home baristas.
Choose the Barista Express if:
- You want to fully immerse yourself in the art of making espresso.
- You value complete manual control over every shot variable.
- You enjoy the ritual and process of perfecting your technique.
- You're on a slightly tighter budget and are willing to invest time to learn.
Choose the Barista Express Impress if:
- You're new to making espresso and want consistent, high-quality results from the start.
- You find the idea of manual tamping and dosing messy, inconsistent, or frustrating.
- You value speed and convenience in your daily routine.
- You are willing to pay a premium to eliminate the most common points of user error.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the Barista Express and the Impress?
The main difference is the "Impress Puck System" on the Barista Express Impress. This system provides assisted tamping with a lever that delivers a consistent 22lbs of pressure and adds intelligent dosing to ensure the correct amount of coffee is used, simplifying the two trickiest steps for beginners.
Is the Barista Express Impress worth the extra money?
For a beginner or anyone prioritizing convenience and consistency, the extra cost is absolutely worth it. It removes the steep learning curve and ensures great espresso right out of the box. For experienced users or those who want total manual control, the original Express offers better value.
Can you tamp manually with the Barista Express Impress?
No, the machine is designed to work exclusively with its assisted tamping lever. The ergonomics and workflow are built around this system, so using a separate, manual tamper would defeat the purpose of the machine.
Which machine is better for beginners?
The Barista Express Impress is unequivocally better for beginners. Its guided system eliminates the most frustrating parts of learning espresso, allowing anyone to pull quality shots immediately.
Do both machines have a built-in grinder?
Yes, both models are all-in-one machines that feature an integrated conical burr grinder, allowing you to go from whole beans to fresh espresso without needing separate equipment.
Is the coffee quality the same on both machines?
With a skilled operator, the classic Barista Express can produce espresso of the same, or even slightly more tailored, quality. However, the Barista Express Impress will produce high-quality espresso more consistently and reliably, especially for novice or intermediate users, because it eliminates major sources of human error.
How do the steam wands compare on both models?
The steam wands are practically identical on both machines. They both feature Breville's powerful manual steam wand that allows you to control the aeration and temperature of milk, making them equally capable of creating the silky microfoam needed for latte art.
What kind of maintenance do they require?
Both machines require the same basic maintenance: regular cleaning of the group head, steam wand, portafilter, and drip tray. They will also both signal when it's time for a more thorough cleaning cycle or descaling. There is no significant difference in maintenance needs between the two models.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
