There's something uniquely satisfying about popping open a pint of Talenti. Known for its sophisticated flavors, incredibly smooth texture, and that iconic clear jar, it hits the sweet spot between an everyday treat and a gourmet indulgence.
If you're a fan of Talenti's high-quality ingredients and artisanal approach but are curious about what else is out there in the world of premium gelato and ice cream, you're in the right place. From small-batch creameries to brands perfecting classic Italian recipes, here are 25 similar brands worth adding to your freezer.
1. Gelato Fiasco
Gelato Fiasco crafts authentic Italian gelato with a passionate focus on locally sourced, high-quality ingredients. They are celebrated for their bold and inventive flavors like Bourbon Caramel and Kaffir Lime, which are created using traditional small-batch techniques.
Similar to Talenti, Gelato Fiasco prioritizes artisanal methods and premium quality. However, they stand out with their creative and often unexpected flavor combinations and a strong commitment to local sourcing, making them a fantastic choice for those who love unique taste experiences.
Shop now at gelatofiasco.com
2. Ciao Bella
Ciao Bella is all about creating premium gelato and sorbet with a diverse range of both classic favorites and imaginative new flavors. Made with natural, sustainably sourced ingredients, their products deliver an authentic Italian taste with a modern, eco-conscious approach.
Like Talenti, Ciao Bella is for shoppers seeking high-quality, artisanal frozen desserts. They differentiate themselves with an even broader flavor lineup and a sharp focus on organic ingredients, making them a great fit for the eco-aware gelato lover.
Shop now at ciaobellagelato.com
3. Gelato University
Taking a traditionalist's approach, Gelato University produces authentic Italian gelato using time-honored recipes and high-quality ingredients sourced directly from Italy. Expect perfectly executed classics like Pistachio and Stracciatella that emphasize natural flavor and a velvety smooth texture.
While sharing Talenti's artisanal spirit, Gelato University appeals more to purists who value Old World methods and deep-rooted Italian heritage. It's the perfect brand for when you're craving a taste of Italy in its most authentic form.
Shop now at gelatouniversity.com
4. Ample Hills Creamery
Ample Hills is a craft ice cream brand known for its wildly inventive, chunky, and dessert-inspired flavors. With signature creations like Ooey Gooey Butter Cake and Salted Crack Caramel, they pack each pint with high-quality ingredients and a playful, whimsical vibe.
Where Talenti offers sophisticated simplicity, Ample Hills delivers a fun, over-the-top indulgence. If you enjoy Talenti's quality but are looking for a frozen treat with more mix-ins and a bit more personality, Ample Hills is a must-try.
Shop now at amplehills.com
5. Lavazza Gelato e Sorbetto
Leveraging their world-renowned coffee expertise, Lavazza creates rich, coffee-forward gelato and sorbetto based on authentic Italian recipes. Their products combine the brand's signature flavor intensity with the delightfully smooth and creamy texture gelato lovers expect.
This brand is the perfect crossover for coffee connoisseurs and gelato enthusiasts. It offers Talenti's sophistication but with a deep focus on bold, expertly crafted coffee flavors that truly stand out.
Shop now at lavazzagelato.com
6. Gelato Go
Gelato Go offers a straightforward and accessible take on authentic Italian gelato, focusing on traditional recipes and fresh, natural ingredients. Their lineup includes core classics like Pistachio, Lemon, and Chocolate, all made with a pure, artisanal approach.
Similar to Talenti, Gelato Go prioritizes genuine flavor, but with a more direct and often locally-focused appeal. It’s an excellent choice for a simple, no-fuss gelato made just the way it should be.
Shop now at gelatogo.com
7. Giapo
Based in New Zealand, Giapo is a high-concept artisanal gelato brand that turns dessert into an art form. Celebrated for innovative flavor combinations and stunning, artistic presentation, their creations feature unique ingredients and luxe touches like black sesame and gold leaf accents.
If Talenti is classic sophistication, Giapo is avant-garde creativity. It is the go-to for adventurous eaters who want their gelato to be an unforgettable, boundary-pushing experience.
Shop now at giapo.com
8. Breyers Gelato Indulgences
Breyers brings a line of affordable premium gelato featuring rich textures and decadent, dessert-like flavors such as Tiramisu. This line shares Talenti’s focus on indulgence but is more widely available at a slightly lower price point.
This is a great option when you're craving a luxurious treat but are looking for something you can easily grab at most grocery stores without a gourmet price tag. It brings that indulgent experience to a more accessible level.
Shop now at breyers.com
9. Gelatiamo
Gelatiamo creates authentic Italian gelato with a strong commitment to traditional techniques and simple, natural ingredients, many of which are sourced locally. You'll find beautifully executed classics like Stracciatella and Lemon Sorbet in their lineup.
Like Talenti, the spirit is artisanal, but Gelatiamo often places a greater emphasis on local sourcing and a community-focused ethos, offering a taste of tradition with a local touch.
Shop now at gelatiamo.com
10. Maggie Mudd’s
Maggie Mudd's is a small-batch ice cream and gelato maker known for putting creative, gourmet twists on classic flavors. Think unique options like Lemon Basil alongside perfected mainstays like Cookie Dough, all crafted with high-quality ingredients.
While Talenti leans toward refined simplicity, Maggie Mudd’s is all about fun and flavor exploration. It’s perfect for those who want a premium treat that is both packed with flavor and doesn't take itself too seriously.
Shop now at maggiemudd.com
11. Cremalosa
Cremalosa is all about premium Italian-style gelato, with a deep focus on authentic ingredients and traditional, regional recipes. Their offerings often showcase flavors like Sicilian pistachio and Piemontese hazelnut, promising a true taste of Italy.
Comparable to Talenti in its dedication to quality, Cremalosa distinguishes itself by highlighting specific regional Italian flavors, offering a more geographically focused and traditional gelato experience.
Shop now at cremalosa.com
12. Yasso
Yasso offers a different kind of premium frozen treat: indulgent pints and bars made from Greek yogurt. While prioritizing health-conscious benefits like lower calories and higher protein, they don't skimp on delicious flavors like cookies & cream and chocolate chip.
Although it isn't gelato, Yasso shares Talenti’s dedication to quality ingredients and innovative flavors. It's a fantastic alternative for anyone looking for a satisfying, high-protein dessert that still feels like a treat.
Shop now at yasso.com
13. Casa Bianchi
Casa Bianchi produces classic Italian-style gelato with a strong focus on traditional recipes and high-quality, natural ingredients. Their flavor lineup often includes pure and simple options like vanilla, chocolate, and seasonal fruits, emphasizing clean flavors and artisanal craftsmanship.
Like Talenti, the approach is authentic and quality-driven. However, Casa Bianchi tends to lean more towards traditional Italian simplicity, showcasing how great a gelato can be with just a few excellent ingredients.
Shop now at casabianchi.com
14. Pappagallo Gelato
Pappagallo specializes in small-batch, handcrafted gelato with a spotlight on seasonal specials and unique local flavors. Their commitment to freshness and artisanal production gives them a boutique feel, similar to Talenti's premium, craft-focused ethos.
The main difference is Pappagallo’s hyper-local and seasonal approach, often resulting in a unique, community-based flavor menu that changes with the season. It’s perfect for feeling connected to local ingredients.
Shop now at pappagallogelato.com
15. Gelato Messina
Hailing from Australia, Gelato Messina is famous for its creative and whimsical flavors like Salted Caramel Brownie and Lychee & Rose. Everything is handcrafted daily with top-tier ingredients, striking a perfect balance between traditional techniques and bold innovation.
Gelato Messina matches Talenti’s quality but really shines in its wild flavor creativity and artistic presentation, making it a dream brand for those who love experimental and exciting gelato.
Shop now at gelatomessina.com
16. La Gelateria
La Gelateria delivers an authentic taste of Italy with its focus on natural ingredients and traditional recipes. Their flavor offerings include beloved classics and rotating seasonal specials, all made with a simple philosophy of high-quality ingredients and small-batch production.
They share Talenti's appeal to seekers of gourmet gelato, often with a specific regional Italian influence that feels both timeless and delicious.
Shop now at lagelateria.com
17. Sundae School
Sundae School creates decadent, handcrafted gelato and sorbet with a focus on Asian-inspired flavors like Thai Iced Tea and Mango Sticky Rice. Their artisanal batches and innovative profiles offer a premium experience for adventurous palates.
With a gourmet appeal similar to Talenti's, Sundae School stands out for its unique, culinary-driven flavors that go beyond the traditional Italian script. It's a great choice for expanding your gelato horizons.
Shop now at sundaeschool.com
18. Bacio di Latte
Bacio di Latte is an Italian gelato powerhouse known for its incredibly rich, creamy textures and authentic flavors like Stracciatella and Tiramisu. They adhere to traditional recipes and high-quality ingredients, often with a slightly more upscale, boutique-style presentation.
As a close competitor to Talenti, Bacio di Latte is a perfect match for those who crave a truly authentic Italian gelato experience, and their charming gelaterias are an added bonus.
Shop now at baciodilatte.com
19. Marco Polo Gelato
Specializing in Italian gelato with a modern sensibility, Marco Polo offers delicious flavors like Lemon Meringue and Hazelnut. Their emphasis on natural ingredients and artisanal methods delivers a taste and quality comparable to Talenti's premium standards.
Marco Polo is a fantastic option that balances authentic taste with high-quality craftsmanship, providing fresh takes on classics that feel both familiar and exciting.
Shop now at marcopologelato.com
20. Fior di Loto
Fior di Loto makes premium gelato and sorbet with a strict commitment to natural, locally sourced ingredients. They deliver authentic flavor profiles, including excellent seasonal fruit sorbets and classic gelato options, always emphasizing artisanal quality.
They are similar to Talenti in their dedication to craft but frequently lean into regional recipes and local ingredients, offering a fresh, farm-to-pint experience.
Shop now at fioridiloto.com
21. Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams
Jeni's is a cult-favorite artisanal ice cream brand beloved for its incredibly smooth, buttercream-like body and unique, gourmand flavors. With combinations like Brambleberry Crisp and Salted Peanut Butter with Chocolate Flecks, they use whole ingredients and dairy from grass-pastured cows.
While technically ice cream, Jeni's competes at an even more premium price point than Talenti. If you appreciate Talenti's ingredient focus but are looking for more complex, creative, and foodie-driven flavors, Jeni’s is the ultimate upgrade.
Shop now at jenis.com
22. Van Leeuwen Ice Cream
Van Leeuwen makes rich, decadent French-style ice cream using a high concentration of egg yolks, resulting in a dense and custard-like texture. They offer both classic dairy and widely acclaimed vegan options made from simple, high-quality ingredients.
Their minimalist branding and commitment to craft feel similar to Talenti, but their specialty is French-style ice cream. With an impressive range of both classic and wonderfully niche flavors, it's a great pick for those who value purity of ingredients and texture.
Shop now at vanleeuwenicecream.com
23. McConnell's Fine Ice Creams
A California institution, McConnell's has been making ice cream from scratch for over 70 years. Their products are known for a pure, dense texture without added stabilizers, using local, sustainable Central Coast ingredients. Expect rich, clean flavors like Sea Salt Cream & Cookies or Eureka Lemon & Marionberries.
Like Talenti, McConnell’s is dedicated to honest, flavorful, and high-quality recipes. This is a brand for purists who believe that incredible ice cream starts - and ends - with phenomenal ingredients.
Shop now at mcconnells.com
24. Häagen-Dazs
Häagen-Dazs is one of the original premium ice cream brands, famous for its rich, dense texture and intense flavors derived from simple, high-quality ingredients like cream, milk, sugar, and eggs. Their lineup ranges from timeless classics like Vanilla Bean to sophisticated collections like their Spirits line.
At a similar price point to Talenti, Häagen-Dazs is a widely available option for shoppers seeking a dependably luxurious experience. While Talenti offers the lighter texture of gelato, Häagen-Dazs provides a classic, creamy ice cream indulgence.
Shop now at haagen-dazs.us
25. Ben & Jerry's
Ben & Jerry's is the king of chunky, super-indulgent ice cream packed with fun mix-ins and creative flavor cores. Known for their whimsical names and social mission, flavors like "Cherry Garcia" and "Phish Food" are beloved worldwide.
While Talenti's vibe is sleek and sophisticated, Ben & Jerry's is fun, funky, and all about the add-ins. If you sometimes wish your premium dessert had more brownie chunks, cookie dough, or caramel swirls, this is the brand to reach for.
Shop now at benjerry.com
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
