If you appreciate the beauty of handcrafted cast iron that feels as much like an art piece as it does a kitchen tool, you’re likely a fan of Smithey Ironware. Their skillets, with their signature smooth, polished finish and vintage-inspired design, have set a high bar for what heirloom cookware can be.
Smithey marries traditional American craftsmanship with a modern, minimalist aesthetic, creating pans that are a joy to cook with and display. For those who love that blend of form, function, and enduring quality, there are other fantastic brands out there delivering a similar experience. Here are 23 brands like Smithey worth exploring for your next kitchen investment.
1. Le Creuset
A true icon in the cookware world, Le Creuset is famous for its heirloom-quality enameled cast iron, available in a stunning rainbow of colors. Their Dutch ovens and skillets, priced from $150 to over $500, offer incredible heat distribution and a durable enamel coating that prevents sticking and resists stains.
While Smithey focuses on raw, polished cast iron, Le Creuset offers a more colorful, lower-maintenance alternative. If you want Smithey's performance and longevity but with a vibrant look that requires no seasoning, Le Creuset is the top choice.
Shop now at lecreuset.com
2. Lodge
Lodge is the quintessential American cast iron brand, known for making incredibly durable and affordable cookware for over a century. With most pieces priced between $20 and $200, Lodge makes cast iron cooking accessible to everyone. From skillets to griddles, their products are workhorses built to last.
Unlike Smithey's smooth, polished finish, Lodge has a rougher, sand-cast texture that builds up a great seasoning over time. It's a more rustic, no-frills alternative that delivers the same fantastic heat retention at a fraction of the cost.
Shop now at lodgecastiron.com
3. Milo by Blue Origin
Milo creates handcrafted, American-made cast iron with a sleek, minimalist aesthetic designed for the modern kitchen. Priced around $150 to $250, their cookware emphasizes durability and heirloom quality, just like Smithey. Their designs feature clean lines and a contemporary, understated look that feels both timeless and fresh.
Milo is a great alternative for cooks who appreciate Smithey's dedication to craftsmanship but are looking for a slightly different take on modern cast iron design.
Shop now at milo.com
4. Victoria
Victoria is a family-owned company that has been producing dependable cast iron cookware for generations. With prices often falling between $20 and $80, it's an excellent budget-friendly choice. They offer a huge range of products with practical features like longer handles and larger pour spouts.
While their finish is more utilitarian and less refined than a Smithey skillet, Victoria cookware is praised for its durability and performance. It’s perfect for someone wanting the cast iron experience without the premium price tag.
Shop now at victoriacookware.com
5. Finex
Finex stands out immediately with its distinctive octagonal shape and polished, easy-release cooking surface. This premium, handcrafted cookware is designed with a modern, industrial vibe, featuring coiled stainless steel handles that stay cool longer. A skillet will typically run you $200 to $250.
Like Smithey, Finex is made in the USA and prioritizes top-tier craftsmanship. The key difference is the aesthetic - Smithey is elegantly minimalist, while Finex is bold and geometric. It's for the cook who wants an heirloom piece that makes a statement.
Shop now at finexusa.com
6. Field Company
Born from a desire to recreate the beloved cast iron pans of the past, Field Company makes skillets that are remarkably lightweight and smooth. Ranging from $125 to $200, their pans are designed to be easier to handle than traditional cast iron without sacrificing performance.
They share Smithey's dedication to quality American craftsmanship and smooth cooking surfaces, making them a direct and popular competitor. If the weight of standard cast iron is a concern for you, Field Company offers a fantastic, lighter alternative.
Shop now at fieldcompany.com
7. Staub
A giant in the world of high-end enameled cast iron, Staub is celebrated for its deep, rich colors and exceptional quality. Made in France and priced from $200-$600, Staub's pieces feature a black matte enamel interior that excels at browning and braising, plus lids with self-basting spikes for superior results.
Like Smithey, Staub represents a significant investment in beautiful, high-performance cookware. Staub is the choice for those who prefer an enameled surface and love the distinct, jewel-toned French aesthetic.
Shop now at staubusa.com
8. Barebones Living
Barebones Living creates cookware and outdoor goods with a rustic, rugged, and vintage-inspired charm. Their cast iron collection, priced around $100-$250, feels right at home in a cozy kitchen or over an open fire.
The aesthetic and commitment to durable, natural materials align nicely with Smithey's brand ethos. If you appreciate the handcrafted feel of Smithey but lean towards a more outdoorsy or rustic style, Barebones is a perfect match.
Shop now at barebonesliving.com
9. Camp Chef
As the name suggests, Camp Chef specializes in gear for outdoor cooking, delivering durable and affordable cast iron designed to withstand the elements. Their products, ranging from $20 to $150, are utilitarian and built for performance over aesthetics.
While lacking the polished refinement of a Smithey product, Camp Chef's cookware is a true workhorse. It's a fantastic, budget-friendly option for camping enthusiasts or those who need rugged gear for their backyard grilling adventures.
Shop now at campchef.com
10. Hearth & Hand with Magnolia
This exclusive Target line by Joanna Gaines offers cookware that captures the popular modern farmhouse aesthetic. Including cast iron pieces priced accessibly from $20 to $50, the collection features a simple, rustic-chic design that looks great on the stove.
While you won't get the same artisanal, handcrafted quality as Smithey, Hearth & Hand delivers a similar visual style at a very budget-friendly price point, making it great for beginner cooks or those on a budget.
Shop now at target.com
11. Victoria + Albert
Primarily known for luxury bathroom fixtures, Victoria + Albert extended their design expertise into a line of ultra-premium cast iron cookware. Priced from $400 into the thousands, these pieces are investments in high design, high-end enameled cookware with sculptural silhouettes and a contemporary feel.
Both Smithey and Victoria + Albert sit at the premium end of the market, but they appeal to different tastes. Smithey's beauty is in its traditional form and polished finish, while Victoria + Albert's is in its sleek, avant-garde design.
Shop now at vandabaths.com
12. Made In
Made In is a direct-to-consumer brand that has quickly become a favorite for its professional-grade cookware at very competitive prices. Their cast iron pieces, around $100-$250, offer excellent performance and durability, with a sleek, minimalist style that feels rugged yet refined.
They share Smithey's commitment to quality materials and American production. Made In is an excellent choice if you like Smithey's performance-first approach but prefer a slightly more industrial and streamlined aesthetic without the premium artisanal price.
Shop now at madeincookware.com
13. Borough Furnace
Borough Furnace is a small-batch, family-run workshop that hand-casts its skillets, resulting in pieces with a distinct, rustic character. Priced from $150 to $250, their cookware is heavy, durable, and has a charming, rugged aesthetic that celebrates the casting process.
Like Smithey, Borough Furnace represents a deep commitment to handcrafted, American-made cookware. While Smithey polishes its pieces to a mirror-like sheen, Borough embraces a rougher, more industrial look forged in tradition.
Shop now at boroughfurnace.com
14. Junta
Junta is an exciting newcomer offering small-batch-crafted cast iron cookware with a distinctly artistic and modern twist. For around $100 to $200, you get a pan with unique, almost geometric design elements that stand out in the kitchen.
They share Smithey's focus on small-scale, thoughtful production. Junta is for the home cook who wants heirloom quality but is drawn to unique, design-forward silhouettes that blur the line between a cooking tool and a modern art object.
Shop now at juntahome.com
15. Sophie Conran for Portmeirion
This collaboration blends the practical kitchen sense of designer Sophie Conran with Portmeirion's classic style. The line includes high-quality cast iron and ceramic cookware priced from $100 to $300, featuring gentle curves, elegant details, and soft colors.
While functionally robust, the design is intentionally decorative and elegant, created to move from oven to table beautifully. It serves those who appreciate Smithey's quality but prefer a more traditional, English country aesthetic.
Shop now at portmeirion.com
16. Field & Fire
Producing artisanal, hand-forged cast iron cookware, Field & Fire celebrates a rustic, traditional style. Their pieces, priced around $150 to $250, have a rugged charm that speaks to traditional techniques and high-quality materials.
Like Smithey, they embrace an artisanal ethos focused on longevity. However, Field & Fire skews more rustic and less polished, appealing to those who want a pan that feels like it came straight from a historic blacksmith's shop.
Shop now at fieldandfire.com
17. Lynx
Lynx, primarily known for its high-end professional grills, also produces premium cast iron designed for serious cooks. Ranging from $200 to $350, their cast iron cookware offers a sleek, polished look similar to Smithey but is engineered to meet the demands of commercial kitchens and high-heat grilling.
If you're looking for Smithey's polished style and craftsmanship but in a package built for intense, professional-level use (especially outdoors), Lynx is an excellent, heavy-duty alternative.
Shop now at pro.lynxgrills.com
18. De Buyer
A French institution, De Buyer has been crafting professional-quality cookware since 1830. While famous for their carbon steel pans, their cast iron, priced from $100 to $300, is equally impressive. The aesthetic is purely functional and traditional, built for performance in the world's best kitchens.
De Buyer and Smithey share an unwavering focus on durability and cooking performance. But where Smithey's design is refined and modern-American, De Buyer remains staunchly traditional French-utilitarian to its core.
Shop now at debuyer-usa.com
19. All-Clad
All-Clad is a powerhouse in the premium cookware space, best known for its legendary multi-ply stainless steel pans. Their venture into cast iron brings the same commitment to quality, with pieces typically priced between $150 and $600. Their cast iron skillet has an industrial look with flared sides and a comfortable handle.
Similar to Smithey, All-Clad is an investment in American-made, high-performance cookware. If your kitchen is already stocked with All-Clad's stainless steel, their cast iron will fit right in.
Shop now at all-clad.com
20. Maine Coast Craft
Maine Coast Craft operates as an artisanal Etsy shop, creating handcrafted cast iron ware with a distinctly rustic and traditional aesthetic. Priced between $150 and $250, these pieces emphasize natural finishes and old-world quality.
This is a great option for someone who loves Smithey's small-scale, American-made approach but wants cookware with a much more organic, less-polished, and beautifully imperfect character that a small maker creates.
Shop now at etsy.com
21. Stargazer Cast Iron
Stargazer is another maker praised for its stunningly smooth, satin-like cooking surface. American-made and priced competitively around $125-$200, their skillets feature a unique flared rim for drip-free pouring and a forked handle designed for comfort.
If you love Smithey's polished finish but are looking for a slightly different handle design and a more matte exterior look, Stargazer is a top-tier cast-iron competitor that offers exceptional cooking performance.
Shop now at stargazercastiron.com
22. Butter Pat Industries
Sitting at the ultra-premium end of the market, Butter Pat Industries crafts cast iron skillets that many compare to the legendary slickness of vintage Griswold pans. Their pieces are incredibly smooth, and their designs are elegantly thin-walled, resulting in slightly faster heat-up times. Prices for their skillets often start over $300.
Like Smithey, Butter Pat is all about American craftsmanship and achieving the perfect cooking surface. This is the brand for the connoisseur who wants what some collectors call the modern equivalent of the most coveted vintage cast iron.
Shop now at butterpatindustries.com
23. Great Jones
Great Jones brings a youthful, design-forward energy to the cookware scene with their enameled cast iron pieces. Most famous for their 'The Dutchess' Dutch oven (~$160), they offer cookware in fun, retro-inspired colors like broccoli green and mustard yellow. The silhouettes are thoughtful, with mid-century modern lines and a beautiful oval shape.
For those who admire Smithey's quality but wish it had the colorful personality of Le Creuset with a more approachable, modern vibe, Great Jones perfectly fills that niche.
Shop now at greatjonesgoods.com
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
