The core difference between Bonavita and OXO coffee makers comes down to philosophy: Bonavita is built for precision brewing for coffee enthusiasts, while OXO focuses on user-friendly design and convenience for the everyday coffee drinker. A Bonavita machine prioritizes ultra-consistent water temperature and even extraction above all else, often with a bare-bones, one-touch interface. In contrast, an OXO machine emphasizes features like programmable timers, intuitive single-dial controls, and modern aesthetics to simplify the morning routine.
Here's a detailed comparison to help you choose the right coffee maker for your kitchen counter.
Bonavita Coffee Makers
Bonavita has earned a reputation among coffee purists for its simple, high-performance machines that consistently produce a professional-quality brew. The brand focuses on the key elements of good coffee - precise temperature control, pre-infusion, and even water distribution - without adding unnecessary bells and whistles. Many of their models are Specialty Coffee Association (SCA) certified, affirming their ability to meet rigorous industry standards for home brewing.
- What it is: A line of specialty drip coffee makers designed for coffee enthusiasts who prioritize technical brewing performance.
- Key features: Powerful 1500-watt heater for rapidly achieving optimal brewing temperature (195°-205°F), pre-infusion mode to bloom ground coffee, wide showerhead for even saturation, and an insulated stainless steel carafe.
- Price: Typically ranges from $150 to $250.
- Style: Sleek, minimalist, and utilitarian. Designs feature clean lines with stainless steel and black matte finishes that feel functional and professional.
- Materials/Construction: Built with durability in mind, featuring stainless steel boilers and carafes, high-quality thermal glass, and BPA-free plastics.
- Pros: Excellent brewing precision delivers superior tasting coffee. Rapidly heats water to the correct temperature. SCA-certified models are available. Simple one-touch operation. Durable and built to last.
- Cons: Lacks convenience features like programmable timers or clocks. The utilitarian design can seem too basic for some kitchens. Higher price point for a machine with few features.
A Bonavita coffee maker is for the person who values the final quality in the cup over all else and appreciates a machine dedicated to the pure mechanics of great coffee.
Shop this brand: bonavita.com/collections/coffee-makers
OXO Coffee Makers
OXO built its name on creating thoughtfully designed, ergonomic kitchen tools, and its coffee makers reflect that heritage perfectly. These machines are made for a seamless user experience, combining modern aesthetics with practical features that simplify the process of making great coffee. An OXO machine delivers a reliable, high-quality brew while offering modern conveniences that fit into a busy lifestyle.
- What it is: A line of user-friendly drip coffee makers designed for the modern consumer who values convenience, reliability, and thoughtful design.
- Key features: Intuitive single-dial interface, programmable 24-hour wake-up timer, options for brew volume, double-wall stainless steel thermal carafe, and rainmaker shower head for uniform saturation.
- Price: Generally priced between $100 and $200.
- Style: Contemporary and approachable. Combines sleek stainless steel with black plastic, large buttons, and clear backlit displays for an intuitive and modern look.
- Materials/Construction: Uses a mix of sturdy BPA-free plastics, glass, and stainless steel accents, prioritizing ease of cleaning and ergonomic handling.
- Pros: Extremely easy to use with intuitive controls. Programmable timer is perfect for busy mornings. SCA certification on premier models ensures quality. Sleek design fits well in modern kitchens. Offers excellent value for its price.
- Cons: While it maintains good temperature, it may not offer the same obsessive level of precision as Bonavita. Relies more on plastic in its build compared to some Bonavita models.
This is the ideal coffee maker for anyone who wants a consistently great cup of coffee from a machine that is a breeze to use and looks sharp on the countertop.
Shop this brand: oxo.com/categories/coffee-tea/coffee-makers.html
Bonavita vs. OXO Coffee Makers Comparison
Brewing Performance & Precision
This is where the two brands differ most. Bonavita's entire purpose is brewing precision. Its powerful heater maintains an exact temperature range (195°-205°F) throughout the cycle, and its pre-infusion feature allows coffee grounds to bloom, leading to a more balanced extraction. Many of their machines are SCA-certified, reflecting this commitment to quality.
OXO also makes excellent coffee and offers SCA-certified models, proving it can brew to a high standard. However, its primary goal is balancing performance with convenience. It makes a consistently great cup of coffee, but it caters to users who might also want to set a timer or quickly choose between a full pot and a single mug, while Bonavita focuses purely on the technical aspects of the brew.
Design & Usability
OXO is the clear winner on usability and convenience features. Its single-dial interface, backlit LED screen, and programmable wake-up timer are designed to make the morning routine as frictionless as possible. The design is modern, thoughtful, and looks fantastic in most kitchens.
Bonavita's design is utilitarian. It’s a simple machine with a one-touch brew button and an auto-off feature. There is no clock, timer, or customization settings. This simplicity is a deliberate choice to focus entirely on brewing, but it can be a drawback for users who want more modern functionality.
Materials & Construction
Both brands produce well-made, reliable machines. Bonavita leans slightly more into professional-grade internal components, with its stainless-steel-lined thermal carafes and powerful boilers designed for long-term, consistent performance. The exterior is simple but reflects a robust build.
OXO uses quality materials, including double-wall stainless steel carafes and BPA-free plastics, but puts more emphasis on the external feel and ergonomic design. The construction feels solid and thoughtfully engineered for daily handling and cleaning.
Price & Value
OXO generally offers a better value proposition for the average consumer. With prices sitting between $100-$200, users get a high-performing, often SCA-certified machine packed with useful features and great design. It’s an excellent all-around package.
Bonavita coffee makers, priced from $150-$250, ask for a higher premium for what is technically under the hood: best-in-class temperature control and extraction components. The value is in the coffee quality, not the feature set.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both Bonavita and OXO create exceptional coffee makers, but they truly excel for different types of drinkers.
Choose Bonavita if:
- The absolute quality and clarity of your coffee is your top priority.
- You want a machine with SCA-certified, professional-grade brewing technology.
- You love simplicity and prefer a single button over clocks and programmable features.
- You want a durable, no-frills workhorse that's laser-focused on making great coffee.
Choose OXO if:
- You want a machine that is incredibly easy and intuitive to use every day.
- Convenience features like a programmable 24-hour timer are important to your morning routine.
- You appreciate a sleek, modern design that is thoughtfully engineered for usability.
- You want a top-rated, SCA-certified coffee maker that delivers amazing value for the price.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Bonavita and OXO coffee makers?
The main difference is their focus. Bonavita prioritizes professional-grade brewing precision - accurate temperature and even extraction - above all else. OXO balances high-quality brewing performance with modern convenience, user-friendly design, and features like timers and brew-strength selectors.
Are Bonavita and OXO coffee makers SCA-certified?
Yes, both brands offer several popular models that are certified by the Specialty Coffee Association (SCA). This certification indicates that the machine can meet strict requirements for water temperature, brewing time, and overall extraction quality. Always check the specific product page for certification details.
Which brand is more durable?
Both brands are known for making durable products. Bonavita often appeals to coffee purists due to its robust internal components, like powerful stainless-steel boilers built for longevity. OXO's machines are also very well-built, with a focus on durable plastics and parts designed for daily ergonomic use and easy cleaning.
Do OXO coffee makers have a clock or timer?
Yes, a key feature of many OXO models is the programmable 24-hour start timer, allowing you to wake up to freshly brewed coffee. They also typically feature a display clock.
Do Bonavita coffee makers have a programmable timer?
Generally, no. Bonavita machines have a minimalist design philosophy and intentionally omit features like clocks and timers to focus purely on the brewing process itself.
Which brand is easiest to clean?
Both are quite easy, but OXO arguably has a slight edge due to its user-focused design. OXO products often have easily detachable parts and are designed with everyday cleaning in mind. Bonavita's simple construction also makes it easy to maintain.
Which one makes hotter coffee?
Both brew coffee at the SCA's optimal temperature range of 195°-205°F, and both typically include a double-wall stainless steel thermal carafe to keep coffee hot for hours. The temperature in the carafe should be very similar with both machines.
Can I control the brew strength on these coffee makers?
On some OXO models, you can select whether you are brewing a full pot or a small batch, which adjusts the brewing cycle for optimal extraction, effectively controlling strength. Bonavita machines don't have a strength setting, you control strength by adjusting your coffee-to-water ratio.
Which coffee maker has a better carafe?
Both brands use high-quality, double-wall stainless steel thermal carafes that keep coffee hot for hours without a warming plate, which can scorch the flavor. Their performance is very comparable, though the handle designs and pouring spouts differ slightly based on brand ergonomics.
Where can I buy Bonavita and OXO coffee makers?
Both brands are sold directly on their websites and are available through major retailers like Amazon, Williams Sonoma, Bed Bath & Beyond, and various specialty coffee retailers online.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
