The Bonavita BV1900TS and the OXO Barista Brain are two top-tier coffee makers that champion precise brewing, but they serve different users. The Bonavita BV1900TS is a minimalist powerhouse focused on straightforward, one-touch operation for perfect temperature and saturation, while the OXO Barista Brain offers programmable features, adjustable brew sizes, and a modern digital interface for a more customized experience.
Here's everything you need to know to choose the right coffee maker for your morning routine.
Bonavita BV1900TS
The Bonavita BV1900TS is built for coffee purists who want exceptional drip coffee with zero hassle. It forgoes complex features like clocks and auto-brew timers in favor of perfecting the fundamentals: maintaining the ideal brew temperature and ensuring even water distribution over the coffee grounds. Its simple, one-touch operation and Specialty Coffee Association (SCA) certification make it a reliable choice for consistently great coffee.
- What it is: An 8-cup automatic drip coffee maker with a thermal carafe, designed for optimal brewing performance.
- Key features: One-touch brew operation with auto-off, 1500-watt heater for precise temperature control (195°-205°F), optional pre-infusion mode to bloom grounds, wide showerhead for even saturation, and a flat-bottomed filter basket.
- Price: Around $180
- Style: Utilitarian and minimalist, with a durable stainless steel finish that blends into any kitchen without demanding attention.
- Materials/Construction: Features a double-walled stainless steel thermal carafe and durable, BPA-free plastic for all parts that contact water or coffee.
- Pros: Brews consistently excellent coffee at the perfect temperature. Pre-infusion cycle improves flavor extraction. Incredibly simple to use. SCA-certified performance. Durable and long-lasting build quality. Compact footprint for most countertops.
- Cons: No programmable features or auto-start timer. The carafe can be tricky to pour from when nearly empty. The minimalist design might seem too basic for some.
The Bonavita BV1900TS is for the coffee drinker who values taste and consistency above all else and prefers a simple, functional machine that gets the job done perfectly every time.
Shop this product: amazon.com/Bonavita-BV1900TS-Carafe-Coffee-Stainless/
OXO Barista Brain
The OXO Barista Brain combines the brand's signature user-friendly design with advanced brewing technology. This coffee maker is built for those who appreciate both precision and convenience, offering a microprocessor-controlled brew cycle, programmable features, and a sleek digital interface. It allows for a more tailored coffee experience, whether you're making a full pot for guests or just a few cups for yourself.
- What it is: A programmable 8-cup smart coffee maker featuring a thermal carafe, designed for intuitive setup and a customizable brew cycle.
- Key features: Microprocessor-controlled brewing that replicates the pour-over method. Bright LED interface with 24-hour programmable start timer. Adjustable brew size setting (from 2 to 8 cups). Freshness timer indicates how long a pot has been sitting. Single-button operation for ease of use.
- Price: Approximately $220
- Style: Sleek and contemporary, with a modern aesthetic that makes it a statement piece on the kitchen counter. Features a clean digital display and polished metal accents.
- Materials/Construction: Made with high-quality, resilient plastics and a durable stainless steel thermal carafe, reflecting OXO's commitment to quality materials.
- Pros: Auto-brew feature is perfect for busy mornings. Allows you to choose your brew size. The intuitive interface is easy to program. Modern, high-end design looks great in contemporary kitchens. Highly-rated customer support.
- Cons: More expensive than the Bonavita model. Larger footprint takes up more counter space. Might offer more features than a minimalist coffee drinker needs.
The OXO Barista Brain is designed for the modern coffee enthusiast who loves waking up to perfectly brewed coffee and values customization, convenience, and a high-tech kitchen aesthetic.
Shop this product: amazon.com/OXO-Barista-Brain-Coffee-Maker/
Bonavita BV1900TS vs. OXO Barista Brain Comparison
Brewing & Features
The most significant difference lies in their approach to brewing. The Bonavita BV1900TS is engineered for one task: to flawlessly execute a single brew cycle at the ideal temperature every time you press the button. Its optional pre-infusion mode blooms the coffee for better flavor, but the machine is otherwise completely manual in its operation.
In contrast, the OXO Barista Brain is all about control and convenience. You can program it to brew automatically up to 24 hours in advance, select whether you're making 2 cups or a full 8-cup pot, and even see how long the coffee has been in the carafe with a freshness timer. It uses an intelligent microprocessor to mimic pour-over brewing by controlling water temperature and brew time.
Dimensions & Scale
Both coffee makers brew up to 8 cups and use a thermal carafe to keep coffee warm. The Bonavita has a noticeably smaller and more compact footprint, making it a better fit for kitchens with limited counter space. The OXO is slightly taller and wider to accommodate its digital display and more complex internal components, giving it a more substantial presence on the countertop.
Materials & Construction
Both are built to last with quality materials, featuring stainless steel thermal carafes and BPA-free plastics. Bonavita's construction feels rugged and utilitarian - it's designed for durability over aesthetics. OXO’s build feels more refined and design-forward, with smooth finishes, thoughtful ergonomic touches, and a focus on how the user interacts with the machine, from the handle to the buttons.
Price & Value
The Bonavita BV1900TS typically retails for about $180, while the OXO Barista Brain is priced around $220. The $40 price difference directly reflects the contrast in features. Bonavita delivers exceptional value for those who purely want the best possible brew quality. The extra cost for the OXO buys you convenience and customization - the programmable timer, brew size selector, and modern interface are what you're paying for.
Style & Versatility
Style is a key differentiator. The Bonavita's stainless-steel-and-black-plastic look is purely functional, it's clean and minimalist, designed to perform without standing out. It fits well in any kitchen but won't be a focal point. The OXO Barista Brain, with its sleek profile, digital display, and polished accents, is designed to be a centerpiece appliance in a modern kitchen. Its contemporary aesthetic is a major part of its appeal.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both coffee makers are excellent choices, but they cater to very different preferences and priorities.
Choose the Bonavita BV1900TS if:
- You prioritize brew quality over any other feature and want consistently delicious coffee.
- You want a simple, straightforward machine with no learning curve.
- You have a "form follows function" mindset and prefer a minimalist design.
- Your budget is under $200 and you want maximum performance for your money.
Choose the OXO Barista Brain if:
- You want the convenience of a programmable timer to wake up to fresh coffee.
- You often brew smaller batches and want to adjust the machine accordingly.
- A sleek, modern design that complements your kitchen aesthetic is important to you.
- You are willing to pay a premium for advanced features and a high-tech user experience.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the Bonavita and OXO coffee makers?
The main difference is simplicity versus features. The Bonavita BV1900TS is a simple, one-touch brewer focused solely on optimal temperature and water saturation. The OXO Barista Brain offers customization through a programmable timer, adjustable brew sizes, and a digital interface.
Are both coffee makers SCA certified?
Yes, both the Bonavita BV1900TS and the OXO Barista Brain are certified by the Specialty Coffee Association (SCA), meaning they meet rigorous standards for water temperature, brewing time, and even extraction.
Which coffee maker brews hotter coffee?
Both brewers are designed to reach the ideal brewing temperature range of 195°-205°F, which is crucial for proper coffee extraction. Neither has an advantage in temperature, as they both meet the SCA standard for heat. Both use an insulated thermal carafe to keep coffee hot instead of a warming plate, which can scorch coffee over time.
Can you program the Bonavita BV1900TS to start automatically?
No, the Bonavita is not programmable. It features a simple on/off switch and is designed for manual, on-demand brewing.
Does the OXO Barista Brain have a warming plate?
No, like the Bonavita, the OXO Barista Brain uses a double-walled stainless steel thermal carafe to maintain temperature without continuing to "cook" the coffee, preserving its flavor for much longer.
Which carafe is easier to pour from?
Ergonomics is central to OXO's philosophy, and its carafe is generally well-regarded for comfortable pouring. Some users find the Bonavita carafe can be tricky to empty completely. However, both function well for serving.
How easy are they to clean?
Both machines are relatively easy to clean. You should descale them regularly according to manufacturer instructions. The filter baskets and carafes should be rinsed after each use. The stainless steel exteriors can be wiped clean with a damp cloth.
Which one is a better value?
Value depends on your priorities. If your top priority is the taste of the coffee itself, the Bonavita BV1900TS offers unbeatable value by delivering SCA-certified brew quality at a lower price. If you value convenience, automation, and modern design, the OXO Barista Brain provides excellent value by adding useful features for a modest price increase.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
