Boll &, Branch is a luxury brand focused on providing exceptionally soft, 100% organic bedding with a timeless and elegant aesthetic. In contrast, Brooklinen is a direct-to-consumer brand offering stylish, high-quality bedding in a much wider variety of modern colors, patterns, and fabrics at a more accessible price point.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right bedding brand for your home.
Boll &, Branch: The Organic Luxury Choice
Boll &, Branch has built its reputation on producing sumptuously soft bedding using only the finest 100% organic cotton. The brand emphasizes transparency, from ethical sourcing and fair trade practices to eco-friendly manufacturing. Their target customer is someone willing to invest in premium, sustainable products that offer a classic look and unparalleled comfort.
- Product mix: Primarily focused on the bedroom and bathroom, offering sheets, duvet covers, pillowcases, mattress protectors, inserts, and bath towels.
- Style/vibe: Timeless, elegant, and understated. The color palette heavily favors neutral, soothing tones like white, ivory, and light earth tones, creating a serene and classic look suitable for refined interior styles.
- Price point: Premium. A queen-sized Signature Hemmed Sheet Set typically costs around $250–$300, reflecting the high-quality organic materials and ethical production standards.
- Quality: Exceptional. The brand famously uses long-staple, single-ply organic cotton, which results in softer, stronger, and more breathable fabric that resists pilling and gets softer with every wash.
- Sustainability: This is a core part of the brand's identity. All their cotton is Fair Trade Certified, GOTS certified organic, and made without harsh chemicals or toxins.
- Return policy: Offers a 30-night risk-free trial. You can return items for a full refund within that window, even if they've been used and washed.
Boll &, Branch is the ideal choice for shoppers who prioritize sustainable, organic materials and a classic aesthetic over trendy designs and are willing to pay a premium for that guarantee of quality and ethics.
Shop Boll &, Branch: bollandbranch.com
Brooklinen: The Stylish, Accessible Option
Brooklinen disrupted the bedding industry by offering "internet-famous" sheets directly to consumers, cutting out the middleman to provide high-quality products at a fair price. They cater to a modern consumer who values style, choice, and convenience. The brand has expanded beyond bedding to include towels, loungewear, and home accessories, becoming a one-stop-shop for stylish home essentials.
- Product mix: A comprehensive range of home goods including sheets in various fabrics (percale, sateen, linen, cashmere), duvet covers, pillows, comforters, towels, loungewear, and even shower curtains.
- Style/vibe: Modern, versatile, and trend-aware. Brooklinen offers a huge array of colors and patterns, from classic solids to limited-edition prints, allowing customers to easily express their personal style.
- Price point: Mid-range and accessible. Their bestselling Luxe Sateen Core Sheet Set in a queen size typically runs about $160-$180, often available in bundles for extra savings.
- Quality: Very high for the price. They use long-staple cotton to ensure durability and comfort. While not exclusively organic like Boll &, Branch, their products are OEKO-TEX certified for chemical safety.
- Sales: Known for frequent sales events, especially around holidays, and offers evergreen "bundle and save" discounts that encourage buying full sets.
- Return policy: Exceptionally generous. Brooklinen offers a 365-day return or exchange window on most products, giving customers an entire year to make sure they love their purchase.
Brooklinen appeals to design-savvy shoppers who want numerous options to customize their space without breaking the bank and value a flexible and friendly shopping experience.
Shop Brooklinen: brooklinen.com
Boll &, Branch vs. Brooklinen Comparison
Price Comparison
There is a clear price difference between the two. Brooklinen is significantly more affordable than Boll &, Branch. A Brooklinen queen sheet set starts around $130-$180, while a comparable set from Boll &, Branch begins around $250 and can go higher.
This premium at Boll &, Branch is directly tied to their certified organic materials and fair-trade supply chain. Brooklinen's direct-to-consumer model, non-organic materials, and focus on volume allow them to keep prices lower. Furthermore, Brooklinen runs sales far more frequently, whereas Boll &, Branch promotions are rarer and less steep.
Quality &, Materials
Both brands use high-quality, long-staple cotton, which is a key indicator of durable, soft, and breathable sheets. The main distinction lies in the sourcing and type of material. Boll &, Branch uses exclusively 100% GOTS certified organic cotton, ensuring a product free from pesticides and harmful chemicals and produced under strict environmental standards.
Brooklinen’s cotton is OEKO-TEX certified, meaning it’s tested and free from harmful substances, but it is not organic. Brooklinen also offers a much wider variety of materials beyond cotton, including linen, flannel, Heathered Cashmere, and TENCEL™ sheets, giving them an advantage for shoppers with specific fabric preferences.
Style &, Aesthetic
The brands' styles are worlds apart. Boll &, Branch champions a timeless, minimalist luxury. Their collection is dominated by solids in muted, sophisticated colors. It's a "buy once, buy well" aesthetic that won't go out of style.
Brooklinen thrives on trends, variety, and personalization. They launch new seasonal colors and limited-edition patterns regularly, from stripes and windowpanes to vibrant collaborations with artists. If you want your bedding to be a statement piece and enjoy changing your look, Brooklinen's massive catalog is far more appealing.
Sustainability &, Ethics
Sustainability is Boll &, Branch's primary calling card. The brand was built on the promise of creating a better product in a better way. They provide in-depth information about their fair-trade factories and organic cotton farms. For the eco-conscious consumer, there is a clear and verifiable commitment that justifies the higher price.
While Brooklinen isn't as focused on sustainability, they have made considerable efforts. Their OEKO-TEX certification ensures product safety, and they have introduced more eco-friendly fabrics like linen into their lineup. However, it is not the central mission of the brand in the way it is for Boll &, Branch.
Return Policies
This is a major point of difference. Boll &, Branch offers a respectable 30-night trial, which allows you to sleep on their products and return them for a full refund if you're not satisfied. This is fairly standard for online bedding companies.
Brooklinen, however, offers an industry-leading 365-day return and exchange policy. This incredibly generous window removes almost all risk from the purchase and shows extreme confidence in their products' long-term performance and durability.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends entirely on your personal priorities for comfort, style, budget, and ethics.
Choose Boll &, Branch if:
- You prioritize organic, sustainable, and ethically-made goods above all else.
- You prefer an exceptionally soft, sateen-like feel.
- Your aesthetic is classic, elegant, and you favor neutral color palettes.
- You are looking to make a long-term investment in premium, foundational bedding.
Choose Brooklinen if:
- You love having a wide variety of fabrics, colors, and patterns to match your decor.
- You're looking for the best quality and style within a more moderate budget.
- You want the peace of mind that comes with an extraordinary 365-day return policy.
- You enjoy the savings from frequent sales events and bundled sets.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Boll &, Branch or Brooklinen cheaper?
Brooklinen is significantly cheaper across the board. Their starting prices are lower, and their frequent sales and bundle deals provide additional savings.
Which has better quality sheets?
Both brands offer excellent quality, but they prioritize different aspects. Boll &, Branch quality is linked to its certified organic cotton and meticulous manufacturing. Brooklinen’s quality is in its durability and long-staple cotton delivered at a great price point.
Can you return items to both stores?
Both brands have different return policies. Boll &, Branch has a 30-night risk-free trial for most items. Brooklinen has a 365-day return and exchange window for most products.
Which brand is better for sustainability?
Boll &, Branch is the clear leader. Sustainability and ethical practices are foundational to their brand identity.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
