Boll & Branch is built on a foundation of organic, ethically-sourced luxury, offering premium bedding at a higher price point, while Brooklinen targets the direct-to-consumer market with high-quality, stylish home textiles at a more accessible cost. The primary distinction lies in Boll & Branch's commitment to Fair Trade and GOTS-certified organic materials, versus Brooklinen's focus on providing excellent value and a wider variety of styles.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right bedding brand for your home.
Boll & Branch: The Sustainable Luxury Bedding Brand
Boll & Branch has carved out a niche as a premium home brand that places sustainability and ethical production at its core. It appeals to discerning, eco-conscious consumers who are willing to invest in the story and process behind their products. The brand is known for its exceptionally soft organic cotton, transparent supply chain, and a minimalist design aesthetic that promotes timeless elegance.
- Product mix: A focused collection of high-end bedding, including sheets, duvet covers, quilts, and blankets. They also offer a curated selection of bath towels and robes.
- Style/vibe: Understated luxury and timeless sophistication. The color palette primarily features neutral, earthy tones and classic patterns designed for a serene and elegant bedroom environment.
- Price point: Premium mid-range. A queen-size Signature Hemmed Sheet Set typically costs around $200–$250, while their plush blankets start at about $150.
- Quality & Materials: The brand's signature is its 100% organic, GOTS and OEKO-TEX certified cotton. The materials are known for their exceptional softness, breathability, and durability, designed to get even softer with each wash.
- Sustainability & Ethics: This is their key differentiator. Boll & Branch is Fair Trade Certified, ensuring fair wages and safe conditions for workers. Their entire supply chain, from farm to finished product, is designed to be responsible and transparent.
- Sales: Sales events are infrequent and are typically tied to major holidays. You’re less likely to find sitewide discounts compared to other direct-to-consumer brands.
- Return policy: Offers a 30-night risk-free trial. You can sleep on the sheets and return them for a full refund if you're not satisfied.
Boll & Branch is the choice for shoppers who prioritize an ethical backstory and certified organic materials as much as they do comfort and style.
Shop Boll & Branch: bollandbranch.com
Brooklinen: The Accessible Luxury Bedding Choice
Brooklinen exploded in popularity by disrupting the traditional bedding industry, offering high-quality essentials directly to consumers at a fair price. The brand focuses on comfort, style variety, and a straightforward shopping experience. They appeal to a broad audience, from first-time apartment dwellers to homeowners looking for practical yet chic bedding, bath, and loungewear without the luxury markup.
- Product mix: An extensive range of home essentials, including sheets in sateen and percale weaves, linen, cashmere, bath towels, shower curtains, loungewear, and home accessories.
- Style/vibe: Modern, versatile, and casual elegance. Brooklinen offers a wider spectrum of colors and patterns than Boll & Branch, including classic solids, subtle stripes, and limited edition styles.
- Price point: Accessible and budget-friendly. Their bestselling Luxe Sateen Core Sheet Set for a queen bed is around $150, and blankets often start at $80. They also encourage savings through bundled sets.
- Quality & Materials: Uses high-quality materials like long-staple cotton for softness and durability. While usually not organic, their products are OEKO-TEX certified to be free of harmful chemicals.
- Customization: Offers the ability to mix and match colors and patterns in their bedding bundles, giving you more flexibility to create a custom look.
- Sales: Runs frequent sales and promotions throughout the year, especially around major holidays like Black Friday and their annual Birthday Sale, making it easy to get a good deal.
- Return policy: Features an industry-leading 365-day return and exchange policy, even on washed or used items, which shows immense confidence in their products.
Brooklinen delivers stylish, comfortable, and durable bedding at an outstanding value, making high-quality materials accessible to a wider audience.
Shop Brooklinen: brooklinen.com
Boll & Branch vs. Brooklinen Comparison
Price Comparison
There's a clear price difference between the two brands. Brooklinen is consistently the more affordable option. For example, a queen sheet set from Brooklinen typically costs between $100-$150, whereas a similar set from Boll & Branch will run you $200-$250. This price gap exists across product categories, including blankets, duvets, and towels.
Boll & Branch justifies its higher price with its investment in Fair Trade Certified factories and 100% organic materials. For consumers willing to pay a premium for ethical and sustainable guarantees, the cost is worth it. For those focused purely on getting comfortable, quality sheets for the best price, Brooklinen offers clear value.
Quality & Materials
Both brands produce high-quality products, but their material focus differs. Boll & Branch uses exclusively 100% organic cotton, earning them certifications from GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard) and OEKO-TEX. This guarantees the material is grown and processed without pesticides or harsh chemicals, resulting in an exceptionally soft and pure product.
Brooklinen uses high-quality, durable long-staple cotton, which is also OEKO-TEX certified for chemical safety. While their materials are excellent for the price point and are known for their durability, they are not typically organic. The choice comes down to whether "organic" is a non-negotiable feature for you.
Style & Aesthetic
Boll & Branch excels at a refined, minimalist luxury. Their collections feature sophisticated, subtle textures and a calming palette of neutrals, blues, and grays. It’s a perfect fit for a mature, elegant bedroom design that values timelessness over fleeting trends.
Brooklinen offers more variety and a more modern, casual feel. With a broader range of colors, including seasonal and limited-edition patterns, their bedding appeals to a wider array of design styles from modern to bohemian. Their mix-and-match bundle options also encourage more creative personalization.
Sustainability & Ethics
This is where Boll & Branch shines. Their entire business model is built on ethical sourcing and sustainability, with Fair Trade and GOTS certifications to back it up. They provide traceability from farm to finish, giving customers confidence in the product's journey. Everything from their factories to their packaging is designed with environmental and social responsibility in mind.
Brooklinen has made efforts toward responsible manufacturing and uses eco-friendly packaging, but it is not a central part of their brand identity. They prioritize quality and accessibility, while sustainability is a secondary consideration rather than a primary mission.
Return Policies
Both brands offer excellent customer-centric policies, but Brooklinen's is unmatched. They offer a 365-day window for returns or exchanges, allowing customers an entire year to decide if they love their products. This generous policy is a huge selling point and reflects their confidence in their bedding's long-term performance.
Boll & Branch provides a 30-night risk-free trial, which is ample time to test out new sheets. While very good, it doesn't compare to Brooklinen's year-long guarantee.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends entirely on your personal priorities and budget.
Choose Boll & Branch if:
- You exclusively shop for organic, chemical-free products.
- Ethical manufacturing and fair labor practices are important factors in your purchasing decisions.
- You have the budget to invest in premium, sustainable textiles.
- You prefer a timeless, minimalist aesthetic with serene, neutral colors.
Choose Brooklinen if:
- You are looking for the best possible quality and comfort at an accessible price point.
- You value an extremely generous return policy that removes purchase risk.
- You enjoy having a wide variety of colors, patterns, and modern styles to choose from.
- You're a practical shopper who takes advantage of seasonal sales and bundle deals.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Boll & Branch or Brooklinen cheaper?
Brooklinen is significantly cheaper than Boll & Branch. Across all comparable products, Brooklinen's direct-to-consumer model and use of non-organic materials allow them to offer much more accessible price points.
Which has better quality bedding?
Quality can be defined in different ways. Boll & Branch offers a higher-end material (100% organic cotton) with prestigious certifications, which many would consider "better." However, Brooklinen uses high-quality long-staple cotton that is very durable and soft for its price, providing outstanding value. Both are excellent, the choice depends on your preference for organic materials.
Is Boll & Branch really organic?
Yes. Boll & Branch products are made from 100% GOTS certified organic cotton, which is the highest standard in organic textiles. They are also Fair Trade Certified, which relates to the ethical treatment and pay of workers.
Can you return sheets after washing them?
Yes, both brands allow you to return sheets after using and washing them within their trial periods. Boll & Branch offers a 30-night trial, while Brooklinen offers an exceptionally long 365-day return window.
Which brand has softer sheets?
Softness is subjective and depends on the weave. Boll & Branch's sateen sheets are renowned for their silky soft feel right out of the box. Brooklinen's Luxe Sateen sheets are also very smooth and buttery. For a crisp feel, both brands offer percale options. Many users agree Boll & Branch feels slightly more premium, but Brooklinen is exceptionally soft for its price.
Do Boll & Branch and Brooklinen ever go on sale?
Yes, but with different frequencies. Brooklinen holds several major sale events a year, offering significant discounts. Boll & Branch sales are much less frequent and are usually held only around major shopping holidays, with more modest discounts.
Which brand is better for hot sleepers?
Both brands offer excellent options for hot sleepers. Look for their percale weave sheets, known for being light, crisp, and breathable. Brooklinen also offers 100% linen sheets, which are highly regarded for their natural temperature-regulating properties.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
