The main difference between a Blackstone and a Cuisinart griddle comes down to design philosophy and price. Blackstone griddles are known for their rugged, utilitarian build and excellent value, making them a favorite for campers and tailgaters. Cuisinart offers a more polished, contemporary design with premium materials, positioning their griddles as a stylish, high-performance addition to an outdoor kitchen, often at a slightly higher price point.
Here's everything you need to know about these two griddle giants to choose the right one for your backyard cookouts.
Blackstone Griddle
Blackstone has become almost synonymous with outdoor flat-top cooking, offering a wide range of griddles that emphasize durability, practicality, and performance. Famous for their heavy-duty steel cooktops and easy setup, these griddles are built to handle anything from simple backyard breakfasts to elaborate tailgate feasts.
- What it is: A line of durable, high-performance outdoor flat-top griddles known for versatility and value.
- Key features: Heavy-duty cold-rolled steel cooking surface, multiple independent burners for precise temperature zones, rear grease management system on most models, and foldable legs for portability.
- Price: Generally ranges from $200 to $400 for their most popular models.
- Dimensions: Available in a wide variety of sizes, from portable 17” and 22” tabletop models to large 36” four-burner units.
- Materials/Construction: Features a thick steel cooktop that requires seasoning, a sturdy powder-coated steel frame, and durable legs built for outdoor stability.
- Style: Rugged and functional, with an industrial, all-black aesthetic that prioritizes durability over a polished appearance.
- Pros: Excellent value for the price. Durable and built to last in outdoor conditions. Large cooking surfaces are perfect for feeding a crowd. Easy-to-use grease management system simplifies cleanup. Widely available in major retail stores.
- Cons: Steel cooktop requires an initial seasoning process and regular maintenance to prevent rust. Utilitarian design may not appeal to those seeking a sleek, modern look. Can be heavy and bulky to transport, even the "portable" models.
The Blackstone griddle is perfect for the outdoor cooking enthusiast who prizes performance and durability and wants a versatile, do-it-all flat top for camping, tailgating, or everyday backyard use.
Shop this product: blackstoneproducts.com
Cuisinart Griddle
Leveraging its strong reputation in kitchen appliances, Cuisinart brings its focus on quality design and user-friendly features to the outdoor cooking space. Cuisinart griddles stand out with their sleek aesthetics, high-quality materials, and convenient features that cater to the home chef looking to expand their culinary skills to the patio.
- What it is: A lineup of stylish and high-performance outdoor griddles from a trusted kitchenware brand.
- Key features: Multiple stainless steel burners, easy-to-clean surfaces, and contemporary designs with stainless steel accents. Many models include integrated vents for even heating and removable grease trays.
- Price: Typically ranges from $250 to $500.
- Dimensions: Offers a range of sizes, from compact tabletop models ideal for small patios to larger cart-style units that compete with full-size grills.
- Materials/Construction: Often employs a mix of high-quality stainless steel and reinforced framing. Cooktops may feature advanced finishes for better heat distribution and easier cleanup.
- Style: Modern and sleek, with polished stainless steel finishes and streamlined profiles designed to complement contemporary outdoor kitchen setups.
- Pros: Aesthetically pleasing design elevates the look of your outdoor space. Excellent construction from a well-respected brand. User-friendly features often make for simpler cleanup and operation. Strong warranty and customer support.
- Cons: Priced slightly higher than comparable Blackstone models. Sometimes offers a smaller cooking surface area for the price. Design often prioritizes looks, which may lead to less rugged components compared to Blackstone.
A Cuisinart griddle is ideal for the home chef who values a sleek, modern aesthetic and is willing to invest a bit more for premium features and polished design in their outdoor kitchen.
Shop this product: cuisinart.com
Blackstone vs. Cuisinart Griddle Comparison
Price & Value
Blackstone is the clear winner when it comes to raw value. Their griddles, commonly priced between $200 and $400, offer incredible performance and durability for the cost. They are built to be workhorses, and their widespread availability at retailers like Walmart and Lowe's means you can often find a good deal.
Cuisinart commands a slightly higher price, usually from $250 to $500, positioning itself as a more premium option. The extra cost is justified by more refined materials like stainless steel, a more polished design, and the backing of a major kitchen appliance brand. If you're budget-conscious, Blackstone offers more for your money in terms of pure cooking area and rugged construction.
Quality & Materials
Both brands build quality products, but they take different approaches. Blackstone focuses on heavy-duty, functional materials. Its powder-coated steel frames and thick, cold-rolled steel cooktops are designed for longevity and can take a beating at a campsite or in the backyard. The trade-off is that the steel top requires consistent seasoning and care to prevent rust.
Cuisinart emphasizes a premium feel with high-quality stainless steel components and more refined construction. Their griddles often incorporate features that align with their indoor appliance philosophy - easy to clean, aesthetically pleasing, and user-friendly. While durable, a Cuisinart griddle's polished finishes might be less forgiving of rough handling compared to Blackstone’s more utilitarian build.
Style & Aesthetic
Style is one of the biggest differentiators. Blackstone griddles have a distinctly rugged, no-frills, industrial look. The all-black, powder-coated finish is practical and meant for the outdoors, but it doesn't try to be a showpiece. It’s a tool designed for serious outdoor cooking.
Cuisinart, on the other hand, puts a premium on appearance. Their griddles are sleek and modern, often integrating shiny stainless steel that matches other high-end outdoor kitchen appliances. If you're designing a stylish patio or outdoor cooking space, a Cuisinart griddle is more likely to visually complement your setup.
Fit & Sizing
Both brands offer a versatile range of sizes. Blackstone is known for its massive 36" four-burner griddles that can cook for a huge crowd, but they also offer highly popular 22" portable models that are perfect for camping. Their product line is broad and addresses nearly every need, from the solo camper to the family that hosts large parties.
Cuisinart provides similar sizing options, with excellent tabletop griddles like the "360° Griddle Cooking Center" and larger, cart-style units. Their larger models are often feature-rich, but Blackstone tends to offer more cooking surface area for the dollar, especially in the larger sizes.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both Blackstone and Cuisinart make fantastic griddles, but they cater to different outdoor cooks.
Choose the Blackstone if:
- You prioritize value and want maximum cooking space for your money.
- You need a durable, rugged griddle for camping, tailgating, and heavy outdoor use.
- You enjoy the process of seasoning and maintaining a traditional steel cooktop.
- Functionality and performance are more important to you than modern aesthetics.
Choose the Cuisinart if:
- Aesthetics are a top priority, and you want a griddle that looks great in your outdoor kitchen.
- You are willing to spend slightly more for premium materials like stainless steel.
- You prefer the backing and reputation of a well-known kitchen appliance brand.
- You appreciate user-friendly features and an easier out-of-the-box experience.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between a Blackstone and a Cuisinart griddle?
The primary difference is design philosophy. Blackstone focuses on rugged functionality and value with heavy-duty steel construction. Cuisinart offers a more refined, stylish product with premium materials like stainless steel and a modern aesthetic, often at a slightly higher price.
Which brand is better for a beginner?
Both are great for beginners, but in different ways. Blackstone is simple to use and has a massive community online for support and recipes, which is great for learning. Cuisinart might feel more approachable for those familiar with household appliances, as the design and features are often more intuitive and may require less maintenance than a Blackstone's seasoned top.
Do I have to season a Cuisinart griddle like a Blackstone?
It depends on the model. Blackstone's signature cold-rolled steel tops require seasoning to create a non-stick surface and prevent rust. Some Cuisinart griddles use similar materials needing seasoning, while others may feature non-stick or pre-treated surfaces. Always check the manufacturer's instructions for your specific model.
Which griddle is more portable?
Blackstone is famous for its portable Adventure Ready line, especially the 17" and 22" models with foldable legs and latching covers. While Cuisinart also offers portable tabletop models, Blackstone has built its reputation on its rugged, easy-to-transport designs made specifically for camping and tailgating.
Which griddle has better heat distribution?
Both brands provide excellent heat distribution with their multi-burner designs. Blackstone's thick steel plate is known to retain heat incredibly well, ensuring even cooking across the surface. Cuisinart also engineers its griddles for consistent heat output, often using cleverly placed vents to manage temperature.
How does the grease management system compare?
Most Blackstone models feature a rear grease management system, where grease is directed to a collection cup at the back of the griddle. It's a simple and effective design that's easy to clean. Cuisinart systems vary, but many feature a 360-degree grease trough that drains into a removable cup, which is also highly effective.
Are the prices similar?
Generally, Blackstone is more budget-friendly. A popular 36" Blackstone often costs less than a similarly sized model from Cuisinart. You're typically paying extra for Cuisinart's style and material choices.
What type of cooking is each one best for?
Both can cook the same types of food, from bacon and eggs to hibachi and smash burgers. A large Blackstone is ideal for big-batch cooking for crowds. A Cuisinart griddle excels in a more curated backyard setting where its appearance and precise features can shine for creative home chefs.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
