Bed Bath & Beyond operates as a high-volume, affordable retailer offering a vast selection of practical home goods, while Crate & Barrel is a design-focused brand known for modern, high-quality furniture and decor at a premium price point. Bed Bath & Beyond prioritizes value, variety, and frequent promotions, whereas Crate & Barrel emphasizes timeless style, craftsmanship, and durable materials for long-term investment.
Here is a detailed breakdown to help you decide which home goods retailer is the right choice for your needs.
Bed Bath & Beyond: The One-Stop Shop for Home Essentials
Bed Bath & Beyond is an established American retailer famous for its extensive inventory of home goods spanning every category, from bedding and bath to kitchen gadgets and small furniture. The brand is positioned as a one-stop-shop destination for anyone needing affordable, functional items for their home, appealing directly to first-time homeowners, college students, and budget-conscious families looking for practicality and value.
- Product mix: A massive range of products including bedding, bath towels, kitchenware, small appliances, home decor, storage solutions, and simple furniture pieces. It features both well-known national brands and its own private labels.
- Style/vibe: Broad and eclectic, covering everything from traditional to basic contemporary styles. The aesthetic is generally practical and mainstream, often catering to current trends at accessible price points rather than a specific design philosophy.
- Price point: Highly affordable. Small home essentials are often under $50, while accent furniture can range from $150–$500. The brand is known for frequent sales, clearance events, and promotional coupons.
- Quality: Quality is variable and corresponds closely with price. While you can find durable goods from national brands, many of the lower-priced private label items are made with more economical materials like engineered wood and basic textiles, which may not be suited for long-term, heavy use.
- Rewards program: The Welcome Rewards program offers perks for members, often including discounts, free shipping, and rewards on purchases. This replaces the famous coupon model a lot of legacy shoppers might remember.
- Sales: Constant sales and promotions occur year-round. Major shopping holidays like Black Friday see significant markdowns across all categories.
- Return policy: Most items can be returned within 30 days of purchase for a full refund.
- Delivery & Assembly: Offers standard shipping, with many items also available for in-store pickup. Assembly is typically required for furniture items and is straightforward for the customer to complete.
Bed Bath & Beyond is an unmatched source for variety and affordability, perfect for stocking up on practical household items without overspending.
Shop Bed Bath & Beyond: bedbathandbeyond.com
Crate & Barrel: The Modern & Timeless Furnishing Brand
Crate & Barrel is a premium home furnishings brand known for its modern, timeless design and commitment to quality. The store appeals to style-conscious consumers looking for sophisticated furniture, elegant decor, and high-end kitchenware that blend form and function. Crate & Barrel's collections are curated to create a cohesive, contemporary home aesthetic, making them a favorite for design enthusiasts and those investing in long-lasting pieces.
- Product mix: Focuses heavily on furniture for every room, including sofas, dining sets, and beds, alongside a curated selection of kitchenware, dinnerware, lighting, rugs, and decor. They are also known for their extensive wedding registry service.
- Style/vibe: Clean, modern, and minimalist. The aesthetic emphasizes sleek lines, natural textures, and a neutral color palette, creating a look that feels both contemporary and enduringly versatile.
- Price point: Mid-to-high range. Sofas typically start around $1,000, dining tables often cost $1,500 or more, and accent chairs are generally in the $500–$1,200 range. Prices reflect higher-quality materials and construction.
- Quality: Emphasizes high-quality, durable materials like solid hardwoods (often FSC-certified), natural fiber textiles, and hand-finished details. Their furniture is built for longevity, making it an investment.
- Customization: Many upholstered items, including sofas and chairs, are available in a wide array of fabrics and colors, allowing for personalization to fit your space perfectly.
- Services: Offers free design services with professional stylists who can help with everything from space planning to selecting finishes via in-store or virtual appointments.
- Delivery & Assembly: Provides white-glove delivery service for furniture, which includes assembly, placement in your room of choice, and removal of packaging. Standard shipping is available for smaller items.
- Return policy: General merchandise can be returned within 30 days for a refund. Custom or made-to-order furniture is often not returnable.
Crate & Barrel provides design-forward, well-crafted furniture and decor for those willing to invest in pieces that will define their home for years to come.
Shop Crate & Barrel: crateandbarrel.com
Bed Bath & Beyond vs. Crate & Barrel Comparison
Price Comparison
There's a significant price gap between the two. Bed Bath & Beyond is built on affordability. You can equip an entire bathroom or kitchen with basics for under a few hundred dollars, and simple furniture pieces like a bed frame might cost around $150 during a sale. Their frequent discounts and coupons make it a go-to for shoppers prioritizing budget.
Crate & Barrel operates in a mid-to-high price tier. Their furniture is an investment, with sofas starting at $1,000 and solid wood dining tables often exceeding $1,500. While they hold seasonal sales, the deep, recurring discounts of Bed Bath & Beyond are not part of their model. The value from Crate & Barrel comes from the longevity and build quality of its pieces, not the initial price tag.
Quality & Construction
Crate & Barrel has a clear advantage in quality. The brand uses superior materials like solid hardwoods, kiln-dried frames for upholstery, and durable performance fabrics. The construction is meant to last for years, with a focus on craftsmanship that you can see and feel. For shoppers looking for pieces that will withstand daily use and still look great in a decade, Crate & Barrel is the stronger choice.
Bed Bath & Beyond offers products with a wide range of quality. While they carry trusted national brands, their proprietary, lower-priced items often utilize materials like particle board, veneers, and basic polyester fabrics. This is suitable for decorative items or pieces with light use, but their furniture may show wear and tear more quickly over time.
Style & Aesthetic
The style philosophies of the two brands are worlds apart. Bed Bath & Beyond offers a little bit of everything - from modern farmhouse to simple contemporary - aiming to have something for everyone. Its style is often trend-driven and prioritizes function and accessibility over a specific design point-of-view.
Crate & Barrel promotes a distinct, curated aesthetic that is modern, clean, and sophisticated. Its collections are designed to work together, featuring neutral palettes, elegant silhouettes, and natural textures. It's the ideal choice for someone who wants to create a polished, timeless, and cohesive look in their home.
Product Selection
Bed Bath & Beyond's selection is vast and utilitarian. It truly is a "one-stop-shop" where you can buy a blender, bath mats, bed sheets, and a coffee table in the same order. Their breadth of inventory across home essentials is unmatched, particularly in categories like small appliances, cleaning tools, and storage solutions.
Crate & Barrel's selection is more focused and curated. While its kitchen and dining departments are extensive, the core of the brand is its furniture collection. You won't find the sheer volume of gadgets that BB&B stocks, but you will find beautifully designed, high-quality furniture and decor for every room in the house.
Sustainability & Ethics
Crate & Barrel has made sustainability a core part of its mission. The company prioritizes responsibly sourced materials, evidenced by numerous products made from FSC-certified wood, which ensures forests are managed responsibly. They also emphasize ethical production and transparency in their supply chain.
While Bed Bath & Beyond has made some strides towards offering more eco-friendly products, it's not a central pillar of their brand identity. Shoppers intentionally seeking brands with strong environmental and ethical commitments will find Crate & Barrel's approach more comprehensive.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands are leaders in their respective markets, but they serve very different customers. The right choice depends entirely on your budget, style, and priorities.
Choose Bed Bath & Beyond if:
- You have a strict budget and need affordable home essentials.
- You're furnishing a first home, dorm room, or a temporary living space.
- You need a wide variety of practical items, from kitchen gadgets to bath linens, all in one place.
- You love hunting for deals and taking advantage of frequent sales and promotions.
Choose Crate & Barrel if:
- You are investing in high-quality, long-lasting furniture and decor.
- You love a clean, modern, and timeless design aesthetic for your home.
- Materials, craftsmanship, and sustainability are high priorities for you.
- You want a curated shopping experience and appreciate services like design help and white-glove delivery.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Bed Bath & Beyond or Crate & Barrel cheaper?
Bed Bath & Beyond is significantly cheaper. Its business model is based on volume and affordability, with frequent discounts and lower everyday prices across all categories. Crate & Barrel is a premium brand with prices that reflect higher-quality materials and design.
Which has better quality furniture?
Crate & Barrel has far superior quality furniture. They use durable materials like solid wood and kiln-dried hardwood frames, with construction techniques designed for longevity. Bed Bath & Beyond's furniture is more budget-friendly and generally not intended to be a long-term investment piece.
What is the main style difference between them?
The main difference is curation versus variety. Crate & Barrel has a focused, modern, and timeless aesthetic with clean lines and neutral tones. Bed Bath & Beyond offers a broad mix of styles meant to appeal to a wide range of tastes, prioritizing practicality over a singular design vision.
Can you return furniture to both stores?
Yes, but the policies differ. Both generally offer a 30-day window for most non-furniture items. However, furniture returns can be more complex at Crate & Barrel, especially for custom pieces which are often final sale. Always check the specific return policy for large items before purchasing.
Which is better for outfitting a kitchen?
It depends on your needs. For small appliances, cookware sets at every price point, and an endless variety of kitchen gadgets, Bed Bath & Beyond is the ideal choice. For high-end dinnerware, artisanal cutlery, entertainer's-grade barware, and stylish kitchen furniture, Crate & Barrel excels.
Is Crate & Barrel considered a luxury brand?
Crate & Barrel is best described as an upper-mid-range or premium brand. While not in the same tier as ultra-high-end luxury design houses, it represents a significant step up in quality, design, and price from mass-market retailers like Bed Bath & Beyond.
Does Bed Bath & Beyond still offer physical coupons?
The famous paper "20% off one item" coupons have largely been discontinued in favor of the digital Welcome Rewards program. Shoppers can now sign up to receive discounts, earn rewards on purchases, and access promotional offers online.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
