Bassett Furniture is known for its highly customizable, American-made pieces with a traditional aesthetic, allowing you to choose everything from fabric to wood finish. In contrast, Pottery Barn offers a curated collection of stylish furniture that leans into classic, rustic, and farmhouse designs, focusing on creating a cohesive and warm home atmosphere.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right home decor retailer for your space.
Bassett Furniture: The Customizable American Heritage Brand
With over 100 years of history, Bassett Furniture has built a reputation for well-crafted, durable furniture that blends classic design with modern needs. Their main appeal lies in extensive personalization, allowing customers to act as co-designers by selecting specific fabrics, finishes, and configurations to build their ideal pieces. This makes Bassett a top choice for discerning homeowners who want tailored furniture without the full custom price tag.
- Product mix: A comprehensive range of home furniture, with a strong focus on sofas, sectionals, beds, bedroom sets, and dining room furniture that serve as foundational pieces for the home.
- Style/vibe: Primarily traditional and transitional. Designs feature timeless silhouettes, classic craftsmanship, and a focus on neutral colors and understated elegance that won't go out of style.
- Price point: Mid-range to upper-mid-range. Sofas typically begin around $1,200, while complete bedroom sets often range from $3,000 to $5,000+.
- Quality: Known for durable construction, often using kiln-dried hardwood frames, high-resilience foam cushions, and sturdy fabrics designed for longevity. Warranties are offered on frames and cushions.
- Customization: This is Bassett's key strength. The brand offers hundreds of fabric and leather options, multiple wood finishes, and various hardware choices for most of its upholstery and case goods.
- Services: Bassett locations provide expert in-store and in-home design consultation services to help customers navigate their extensive customization options.
- Delivery & Assembly: Full-service delivery and assembly are available, with teams ensuring pieces are set up correctly in your home.
Bassett is ideal for those who prioritize long-lasting quality and want to create unique pieces of furniture tailored perfectly to their space and style.
Shop Bassett Furniture: bassettfurniture.com
Pottery Barn: The Classic Cozy Home Retailer
Pottery Barn is a household name in home furnishings, celebrated for its warm, inviting aesthetic that makes any house feel like a comfortable home. The brand excels at creating a cohesive, stylish look with its curated collections that span furniture, decor, lighting, and textiles. Their designs blend classic American style with rustic, coastal, and farmhouse influences, making them a go-to for families and individuals aiming for a timeless yet relaxed interior.
- Product mix: A complete home outfitter offering sofas, beds, dining sets, lighting, rugs, bedding, decor, and outdoor furniture. Their comprehensive selection makes it easy to furnish an entire room or home from a single source.
- Style/vibe: Warm, classic, and versatile. The overall aesthetic is cozy and sophisticated, mixing farmhouse charm with traditional silhouettes and touches of modern design.
- Price point: Mid-range to premium. Sofas generally start at $1,299 but can go much higher, and bedroom furniture can range from $2,000 to $5,000.
- Quality: Pieces are built to last using high-quality materials like kiln-dried hardwood, down-blend cushions, and durable performance fabrics suitable for everyday life.
- Customization: Pottery Barn offers a good selection of fabric choices for their upholstered items, including many performance options, but the range is less extensive than Bassett's.
- Sustainability: The brand places a strong emphasis on responsible sourcing, with many items made from FSC-certified wood, recycled materials, and organic cotton.
- Delivery & Assembly: White-glove delivery is standard for most large furniture items, which includes un-packaging, assembly, and placement in the room of your choice.
Pottery Barn is a perfect match for shoppers who want a beautiful, comfortable home with a distinct aesthetic and appreciate the convenience of a one-stop-shop for stylish furnishings.
Shop Pottery Barn: potterybarn.com
Bassett vs. Pottery Barn Comparison
Price Comparison
Both brands operate in the mid- to upper-mid-range price tier. Bassett sofas start around $1,200, while a Pottery Barn sofa typically starts at $1,299. For larger items like bedroom sets, both brands can easily run from $3,000 to over $5,000. Frequent sales and promotional events occur at both retailers, often around major holidays, offering significant discounts.
The pure value proposition differs slightly. With Bassett, you are paying for the customization and domestic craftsmanship that goes into building a piece to your exact specifications. At Pottery Barn, the price reflects their curated design aesthetic, quality materials, and the convenience of their expansive, coordinated product line.
Style & Aesthetic
The two brands target different versions of classic American style. Bassett leans more traditional and transitional, focusing on timeless silhouettes and elegant forms that serve as a lasting foundation for a room. Its designs are less about fleeting trends and more about enduring appeal, often with a more formal feel.
Pottery Barn embodies a warmer, more relaxed aesthetic that blends farmhouse, rustic, and coastal styles. Their pieces often feature distressed finishes, natural textures, and cozy fabrics designed to create an inviting, lived-in atmosphere. Pottery Barn is more trend-aware and tends to refresh its collections to reflect contemporary interior design directions while maintaining its core classic identity.
Quality & Construction
Both Bassett and Pottery Barn are reputable for their quality construction. Each brand uses durable materials like kiln-dried hardwood frames and high-quality cushions to ensure their furniture holds up to daily use. Bassett's reputation is built on its history of American craftsmanship, and its quality control is excellent, particularly on their custom-built pieces.
Pottery Barn also markets its durability, with a focus on family-friendly performance fabrics and robust construction. While both offer solid, long-lasting furniture, shoppers often associate Bassett with heavy-duty, traditional furniture building and Pottery Barn with stylish, reliable everyday quality.
Customization Options
This is where Bassett clearly stands out. The brand's defining feature is its deeply customizable approach. Customers can choose from hundreds of fabrics and leathers, select different wood finishes, and even pick out hardware for many pieces. This process is often facilitated by in-store design consultants who help create a truly one-of-a-kind item.
Pottery Barn offers a respectable level of customization for its upholstered furniture, allowing you to choose from a curated selection of dozens of fabrics, including performance options. However, the scope is far more limited compared to Bassett's extensive bespoke program. For case goods like dressers or tables, customization is generally not an option at Pottery Barn.
Shopping Experience
Bassett's business model revolves around its showrooms and design centers. The in-store experience is heavily service-oriented, encouraging customers to work with design professionals to build their furniture. Their online portal complements this by offering visualization tools to explore options before visiting a store.
Pottery Barn has mastered the omnichannel approach, providing a seamless experience between its well-designed website and beautiful physical showrooms. Their online platform is rich with inspiration, customer reviews, and detailed product information, while their stores allow you to see and feel the products in person. Their white-glove delivery service is a well-established and reliable standard for furniture purchases.
Sustainability & Ethics
Both brands have made commitments to sustainability, but Pottery Barn is more vocal and transparent about its efforts. They prominently feature products made with FSC-certified wood, recycled materials, and organic fibers. This strong public commitment makes them a leading choice for eco-conscious shoppers.
Bassett also pursues responsible manufacturing, using eco-friendly materials and working to reduce waste in its domestic factories. While their practices are solid, they are a less central part of their brand identity compared to Pottery Barn.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends on your style preferences, budget, and priorities. Both brands offer quality furniture, but they cater to different tastes and needs.
Choose Bassett if:
- You want to customize your furniture with specific fabrics, finishes, and hardware.
- You prefer a more traditional or transitional design aesthetic with timeless appeal.
- You value working with an in-store design consultant to create the perfect piece.
- Your top priority is solid, American-made craftsmanship built to your exact specifications.
Choose Pottery Barn if:
- You love a warm, cozy, and inviting style that blends rustic and classic elements.
- You want to furnish an entire room with coordinated pieces, from the sofa to the decorative pillows.
- Sustainably sourced and eco-friendly materials are a high priority for you.
- You prefer a seamless online shopping experience with the option to see items in a showroom.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Bassett or Pottery Barn cheaper?
Their price points are very similar, with starting prices for key items like sofas being almost identical. However, the final cost at Bassett can vary more widely due to its extensive customization options - premium fabrics or finishes will increase the price. Both brands fall into the mid-range to premium furniture category.
Which has better quality furniture?
Both brands are known for high-quality, durable furniture made with sound materials like kiln-dried hardwood. Bassett's reputation is built on generations of solid American craftsmanship, while Pottery Barn focuses on stylish, family-friendly durability. Neither is definitively better, the choice often comes down to personal manufacturing preferences.
Which brand is better for custom furniture?
Bassett is the clear winner for customization. While Pottery Barn offers a good selection of fabric choices for sofas and chairs, Bassett's entire business model revolves around allowing customers to personalize almost every aspect of their furniture, from hundreds of fabrics to wood finishes and hardware.
What is the style difference between Bassett and Pottery Barn?
Bassett's style is more traditional and transitional, focusing on timeless, elegant silhouettes. Pottery Barn's aesthetic is warmer and more relaxed, blending classic American design with rustic, farmhouse, and coastal influences.
Which brand is more sustainable?
Pottery Barn has a more prominent and public commitment to sustainability. They actively promote their use of FSC-certified wood, recycled materials, and fair-trade practices, making them a top choice for eco-minded consumers.
Can you return furniture to both stores?
Yes, but policies differ. Pottery Barn generally has a straightforward 30-day return policy for most items (though some exceptions apply). Bassett's policy can be stricter, as custom-ordered furniture is often considered final sale. It's crucial to confirm the return policy before purchasing, especially for customized pieces.
Which brand is better for families?
Both are excellent choices for families. Pottery Barn extensively markets its durable performance fabrics designed to stand up to kids and pets. Bassett also offers a wide range of durable fabrics through its customization program, allowing you to select a material that best suits your family's lifestyle.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
