The Baratza Preciso and the Breville Smart Grinder are both popular choices for home coffee enthusiasts, but they cater to very different priorities. The Preciso emphasizes manual control, high-precision grind consistency, and a durable build for serious home baristas, while the Breville Smart Grinder focuses on convenience, automated features, and a user-friendly digital interface for a broader audience.
Here's everything you need to know to decide which grinder is the right fit for your coffee routine and countertop.
Baratza Preciso Grinder
The Baratza Preciso is a highly respected conical burr grinder designed for coffee lovers who want maximum control over their grind size, especially for espresso. It has a reputation for its exceptional precision, robust construction, and straightforward, no-frills operation that prioritizes grind quality above all else.
- What it is: A high-precision manual coffee grinder with hardened steel conical burrs, aimed at dialing in the perfect espresso shot.
- Key features: 40 macro-adjustment steps, plus a micro-adjustment lever with an additional 11 settings, offering unparalleled fine-tuning.
- Price: Around $200-$250 (often found used or refurbished as it's a classic model).
- Style: Utilitarian and functional with a professional, almost industrial look. It's built for performance, not flashy aesthetics.
- Materials/Construction: Features a sturdy metal body and high-quality internal components designed for longevity and repairability.
- Pros: Exceptional grind consistency for espresso, durable professional-grade build, allows for precise micro-adjustments, excellent customer support and parts availability from Baratza.
- Cons: Lacks any automatic dosing or programmable features, its classic utilitarian look might not appeal to everyone, has been discontinued and can be harder to find new.
The Preciso is for the hands-on coffee enthusiast who enjoys the process of manually dialing in their shot and needs consistent, fine grounds for espresso.
Shop this brand: baratza.com
Breville Smart Grinder Pro
The Breville Smart Grinder Pro is an automated, all-in-one grinder that combines ease of use with consistent performance. It features a sleek digital interface, programmable settings, and a wide range of grind sizes, making it a versatile choice for people who brew everything from French press to espresso and value convenience.
- What it is: An automated digital coffee grinder with programmable dosing and 60 precise grind settings.
- Key features: Stainless steel conical burrs, intuitive LCD screen, programmable shot/cup timer ("Dosing IQ"), and includes two portafilter cradles.
- Price: Approximately $200
- Style: Modern and sleek, with a brushed stainless steel finish that fits well in contemporary kitchens.
- Materials/Construction: A mix of brushed stainless steel housing and some durable plastic components, like the hopper and grounds catcher.
- Pros: Extremely easy to use with its digital display and presets, automates dosing for consistent results, wide grind range suitable for many brewing methods, sleek and modern design.
- Cons: Grind consistency at the finest espresso settings may be less precise than the Preciso, more plastic parts can mean less long-term durability compared to the Baratza.
The Smart Grinder Pro appeals to coffee drinkers who want a user-friendly, feature-packed machine that delivers consistent results with minimal fuss.
Shop this product: breville.com/us/en/products/coffee-grinders/bcg820.html
Baratza Preciso vs. Breville Smart Grinder Comparison
Grind Quality & Burr Type
The core difference lies in their precision. The Baratza Preciso uses high-quality conical burrs and a revered macro/micro adjustment system. This combination allows for extremely fine-tuned adjustments, making it the superior choice for espresso enthusiasts who need to make tiny changes to dial in the perfect shot. Its grind consistency in the finer range is exceptional for its price point.
The Breville Smart Grinder Pro also uses stainless steel conical burrs and offers 60 grind settings, which is plenty for most users and brew methods. While it's very capable for espresso, it doesn't offer the tiny micro-adjustments of the Preciso, which can be critical for high-end espresso machines. However, it's an excellent all-rounder that performs consistently from coarse to medium-fine.
Ease of Use & Features
The Breville Smart Grinder is the clear winner for convenience. Its digital interface, presets for different brew methods, and programmable "Dosing IQ" allow you to set your grind time down to 0.2-second increments. You simply choose your grind size, set the time, and press start for a consistent dose every time. This automation makes the morning routine fast and repeatable.
The Baratza Preciso is a fully manual machine. There is no timer, no digital screen, and no dosing automation. You turn it on to grind and turn it off when you're done, weighing your beans before or your grounds after. This hands-on approach is preferred by purists who want total control but is less convenient for those seeking a quick and easy workflow.
Materials & Construction
Baratza grinders are built to be workhorses. The Preciso features a robust build with more metal components and is designed to be easily repairable - Baratza is famous for its excellent customer support and readily available replacement parts. This focus on longevity means a Preciso can last for many years with proper maintenance.
The Breville Smart Grinder looks premium with its brushed stainless steel housing but incorporates more plastic in its construction, particularly in the internal gearings and hopper. While it's well-built and reliable for everyday home use, its design is not as focused on long-term serviceability as Baratza's.
Price & Value
Both grinders typically fall within a similar RRP, making them direct competitors. The value proposition is different for each. The Baratza Preciso offers incredible value in its unparalleled grind precision and commercial-grade build quality, especially for espresso lovers.
The Breville Smart Grinder's value comes from its rich feature set, user-friendly automation, and versatility. For the price, you get a sophisticated machine that takes the guesswork out of grinding for almost any coffee brewing method you can imagine.
Style & Footprint
The Preciso has a classic, utilitarian design that looks at home next to prosumer espresso machines. It's tall and straightforward - function over form. The Breville Smart Grinder has a distinctly modern, sleek aesthetic that's designed to complement contemporary kitchens and appliances. It's slightly shorter and more streamlined, making it a good fit under most cabinets.
Who Each One Works Best For
The Baratza Preciso is best for the coffee hobbyist or aspiring home barista. If you live and breathe espresso, enjoy the tactile process of dialing in a grind, and prioritize build quality and grind consistency above all, the Preciso is built for you.
The Breville Smart Grinder is ideal for the enthusiastic coffee-making parent, busy home professional, or technology-focused gadget-lover who appreciates efficiency and versatility. If you prefer an automated, set-it-and-forget-it workflow that produces great coffee across a wide range of brew styles without much fiddling, this Breville coffee grinder is a better everyday choice.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both are excellent grinders, but they serve different users. Your choice depends on what you value most in your coffee routine.
Choose the Baratza Preciso if:
- You primarily drink espresso and need precision to dial in shots.
- You enjoy the manual, hands-on process of making coffee.
- Durability and repairability are your top priorities.
- You prefer function over modern digital features.
Choose the Breville Smart Grinder if:
- Convenience and automation are most important to you.
- You brew multiple types of coffee, from drip to French press to espresso.
- You appreciate a modern, sleek-looking appliance on your counter.
- You want repeatable, consistent dosing at the push of a button.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the main difference between the Baratza Preciso and Breville Smart Grinder?
The main difference is control versus convenience. The Baratza Preciso offers granular, manual control for exceptional grind precision, especially for espresso. The Breville Smart Grinder offers digital controls, presets, and programmable dosing for an easier workflow.
Which grinder is better for espresso?
The Baratza Preciso is generally considered better for espresso. Its macro/micro adjustment system allows for finer tuning of the grind, which is essential for getting the perfect shot from a non-pressurized portafilter.
Is the Breville Smart Grinder good for beginners?
Yes, it's an excellent choice for beginners. The LCD screen, clear settings, and preset options make it very intuitive and remove a lot of the guesswork from learning to grind fresh coffee.
How long do the burrs last on these grinders?
For typical home use, the hardened steel burrs on both grinders can last for several years (grinding roughly 500-1000 lbs of coffee). Both Baratza and Breville offer replacement burrs, but Baratza makes the replacement process particularly easy.
Which one is easier to clean?
Both are relatively easy to clean. The hopper and outer burr on both models can be removed for regular brushing. The Breville's grounds tray is arguably a bit easier to handle, but both require routine maintenance for optimal performance.
Will the Preciso or Smart Grinder work for French press and cold brew?
Yes, both grinders have a wide enough range to produce the coarse grind needed for French press and cold brew. The Breville Smart Grinder's user-friendly system makes it easy to switch settings, while the Baratza requires more mindful manual adjustments.
Does the Baratza Preciso have an automated timer or dose setting?
No, the Preciso is a fully manual grinder. It does not have a timer or any automatic dosing features, which distinguishes it from the automated Breville. You control the dose by a simple on/off switch based on the required or desired weight of ground beans.
Which grinder is quieter in use?
Both coffee grinders are relatively quiet for home use, though they can still be noticeable in a quiet room. Their sound levels are similar, with both machines offering a less disruptive experience than some other models.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
