The Baratza Encore and the KitchenAid Burr Grinder serve the home coffee market but cater to very different users. The Encore, from coffee-specialist brand Baratza, is a functional, entry-level burr grinder celebrated for its consistent performance and repairability. In contrast, grinders from KitchenAid prioritize style and kitchen ecosystem compatibility, offering a fashionable appliance with adequate performance for casual daily coffee.
Here's everything you need to know to decide which coffee grinder is right for your countertop.
Baratza Encore
The Baratza Encore is widely recommended as the best entry-level burr grinder for anyone serious about improving their home coffee. It forgoes flashy features for a simple, reliable design focused entirely on one thing: producing a consistent grind. Its 40 individual grind settings allow for precise control for everything from French press to pour-over, making it a favorite among coffee enthusiasts.
- What it is: A high-performance, entry-level conical burr grinder designed for home coffee enthusiasts.
- Key features: 40 individual grind settings, high-torque DC motor for slow and cool grinding, user-serviceable parts.
- Price: Around $169
- Style: Simple, utilitarian, and function-forward with a black plastic body and compact footprint.
- Materials/Construction: Hardened alloy steel conical burrs housed in a durable plastic chassis. Designed for longevity and repairability.
- Pros: Excellent grind consistency for the price point, versatile for multiple brew methods, built to last, great company support, and easy to find replacement parts.
- Cons: Utilitarian aesthetic isn't for everyone, plastic construction feels less premium than some alternatives, lacks a digital timer or built-in scale.
The Baratza Encore is ideal for someone who prioritizes coffee quality and wants a reliable, no-frills tool that will perform for years.
Shop this product: baratza.com/product/encore
KitchenAid Burr Coffee Grinder
The KitchenAid Burr Coffee Grinder brings the brand's iconic style and user-friendliness to coffee grinding. Designed to visually complement their famous stand mixers, this grinder targets casual coffee drinkers who value aesthetics and convenience. It offers straightforward operation and performs well for standard brewing methods like automatic drip, all while looking great on the kitchen counter.
- What it is: A stylish burr coffee grinder from a trusted kitchen appliance brand, focused on design and ease of use.
- Key features: Matching retro-modern aesthetic, multiple color options, decent performance for daily drip coffee, user-friendly controls.
- Price: Typically ranges from $70 to $150 depending on the model and promotions.
- Style: Signature retro-modern look available in various colors to match other KitchenAid appliances.
- Materials/Construction: Metal and plastic components with a focus on a polished, clean appearance and simple functionality.
- Pros: Beautiful and iconic design, available in many colors, fits perfectly into a styled "KitchenAid kitchen," easy to use for beginners.
- Cons: Lacks the grind precision and consistency of the Baratza Encore, not suitable for more demanding methods like espresso, less focus on long-term repairability.
This grinder suits the design-conscious consumer who wants a good-looking, reliable appliance for their daily drip coffee.
Shop this product: kitchenaid.com/countertop-appliances/coffee-products/coffee-grinders
Baratza Encore vs. KitchenAid Grinder Comparison
Grind Consistency & Performance
This is the most significant point of comparison. The Baratza Encore is built from the ground up to provide excellent particle size consistency, which directly impacts the flavor of your coffee. Its 40 settings allow you to dial in the perfect grind for anything from a coarse French press to a fines-free pour-over. This level of control is crucial for unlocking the best flavors from specialty coffee beans.
The KitchenAid grinder, while functional, does not offer the same level of precision. It grinds coffee more than adequately for an automatic drip machine but struggles with consistency at the finer and coarser ends of the spectrum. For a casual daily coffee drinker, this difference may not be noticeable, but for anyone using manual brew methods or seeking top-tier extraction, the Encore is clearly superior.
Materials & Construction
Baratza focuses on function over form. The Encore's body is mostly durable plastic, but the parts that matter - the motor and the conical burrs - are engineered for years of consistent use. A key part of Baratza's philosophy is durability and repairability, they make it easy for owners to order and replace burrs and other parts, extending the grinder's life indefinitely.
KitchenAid prioritizes a premium look and feel. Their grinders often feature heavy bases and metal exteriors that feel substantial and look great. However, the internal components are not as specialized as Baratza's, and the product is treated more like a standard appliance, with less emphasis on user serviceability for long-term maintenance.
Style & Versatility
There is no contest here: KitchenAid wins on traditional kitchen aesthetics. Available in a range of classic colors like Empire Red and Contour Silver, their grinders are designed to be a centerpiece. If your goal is a cohesive, stylish kitchen where every appliance matches, a KitchenAid grinder is the obvious choice.
The Baratza Encore has a single style: functional. Its simple black box design is meant to blend in, not stand out. This form-follows-function philosophy appeals to coffee purists who see their grinder as a tool, not a piece of decor.
Price & Value
The KitchenAid Burr Grinder is typically priced lower than the Baratza Encore, coming in between $70 and $150. For this price, you get a beautiful appliance that performs a basic function well. The value lies in its design and role within the KitchenAid ecosystem.
The Baratza Encore, at around $169, represents a different kind of value. You are paying for superior grind quality, long-term durability, and the ability to maintain your machine. For anyone who spends money on high-quality coffee beans, the Encore provides tremendous value by getting the absolute best flavor out of them.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both grinders are good choices, but they serve entirely different goals and users.
Choose the Baratza Encore if:
- You consider coffee a hobby and grind quality is your top priority.
- You frequently use manual brewing methods like pour-over, Aeropress, or French press.
- You purchase specialty coffee beans and want to get the best flavor from them.
- You value a tool you can repair and maintain for a decade or more.
Choose a KitchenAid Grinder if:
- Your primary concern is having a stylish, well-designed kitchen with matching appliances.
- You primarily drink automatic drip coffee and aren't overly concerned with perfect grind consistency.
- You are a casual coffee drinker who values simplicity and brand familiarity.
- You are looking for a gift for someone who loves the KitchenAid brand.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the Baratza Encore and KitchenAid grinders?
The main difference is their purpose. The Baratza Encore is a performance-focused tool designed for coffee enthusiasts to achieve consistent grind size for various brew methods. The KitchenAid grinder is a design-focused appliance for casual users who want a stylish gadget that matches their kitchen decor.
Which coffee grinder is better for a beginner?
It depends on the beginner's goals. If the goal is to simply stop using pre-ground coffee, the KitchenAid is incredibly user-friendly and a great starting point. If the goal is to get into specialty coffee brewing as a hobby, the Baratza Encore is the better investment for long-term growth.
Can you use a KitchenAid grinder for espresso?
While technically you can grind beans finely with a KitchenAid, it generally does not produce a consistent enough grind for high-quality, unpressurized espresso machines. The Baratza Encore is also considered an entry-level grinder and may struggle with the finest espresso settings, but it performs better than the KitchenAid for this purpose.
Is the Baratza Encore worth the extra money?
If you care about the taste of your coffee, absolutely. Grinding consistency has a massive impact on flavor, and the improvement you get with the Encore over more basic grinders is significant. Its durability also means you likely won't have to replace it for a very long time.
Which grinder is easier to clean?
Both are relatively straightforward to clean. The upper burr on both units can be removed to brush out coffee grounds. The Baratza design is very easy to disassemble for deeper cleaning, which is a key part of its maintenance-friendly approach.
Which one is more durable?
The Baratza Encore is designed to be more durable in a functional sense. Baratza offers replacement parts for almost every component, so even if something breaks years down the road, you can fix it. KitchenAid grinders are well-built, but are designed more as a unified appliance that would be replaced rather than repaired piece-by-piece.
How loud are these grinders?
All coffee grinders are fairly loud, and both of these are comparable. The Encore has a high-torque, low-speed motor that mitigates some of the high-pitched noise, resulting in a lower grinding sound than some blade grinders, but it is not silent.
What type of burrs do they use?
The Baratza Encore uses high-quality 40mm steel conical burrs, which are praised for their consistency and longevity. Most KitchenAid grinders use stainless steel flat burrs, which are good but are generally not considered as durable or consistent for a wide range of grind sizes as conical burrs in this price category.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
