The Balmuda The Toaster and Breville's Smart Ovens both promise exceptional countertop cooking, but they serve two very different users. The Balmuda is a highly specialized appliance from Japan using unique steam technology to create bakery-quality toast with a crispy shell and moist interior, wrapped in a minimalist design. In contrast, Breville ovens are multi-functional kitchen workhorses, offering numerous cooking functions like baking, roasting, and air frying in a durable, feature-rich package.
Here’s a detailed guide to help you decide which of these premium toaster ovens belongs on your kitchen counter.
Balmuda The Toaster
The Balmuda is a luxury toaster oven celebrated for its singular focus on perfection. By injecting a small amount of steam into the oven cavity at the beginning of the toasting cycle, it creates a thin layer of moisture on the bread's surface. This allows the inside to warm up and retain its natural moisture before the outside gets a final, perfect blast of heat for a golden, crunchy crust. It's a statement piece designed for a design-conscious consumer who values aesthetic quality as much as performance.
- What it is: A premium toaster oven using patented steam technology and precise heat control to produce perfect toast, pastries, and pizza.
- Key features: Steam injection technology (using 5cc of water), five distinct cooking modes (Sandwich Bread, Artisan Bread, Pizza, Pastry, Oven), precise digital temperature control, and a compact, minimalist Japanese aesthetic.
- Price: Around $300 - $400
- Dimensions: 14.1" (W) x 12.6" (D) x 8.2" (H), fitting easily on most countertops.
- Materials/Construction: High-quality construction with brushed aluminum and high-grade plastics, available in colors like black, white, and gray.
- Style: Sleek and minimalist, with clean lines and simple controls that complement modern, contemporary, or Scandinavian kitchen decor.
- Pros: Creates unparalleled toast quality. Its steam technology makes bread crispy on the outside while remaining soft and moist inside. The beautiful design sets it apart as a true countertop showpiece. It also heats up exceptionally quickly.
- Cons: A very high price for a machine that primarily excels at toasting. It has a small interior that fits a maximum of two slices of standard bread, and its functions beyond toasting and reheating are limited.
This appliance is perfect for the toast aficionado or design purist who is willing to pay a premium for unmatched toasting performance and a stunning kitchen aesthetic.
Shop this product: us.balmuda.com/products/the-toaster
Breville Smart Ovens
Breville's line of Smart Ovens are praised for their versatility, power, and intelligent cooking technology. These countertop ovens are designed to be reliable kitchen workhorses, effectively serving as a second oven for everything from toasting and baking to roasting vegetables and air frying. Features like the Element iQ system intelligently distribute heat where and when it's needed, ensuring even and consistent cooking results every time. They are built for home cooks who demand flexible and dependable performance.
- What it is: A line of multi-functional countertop ovens packed with smart features for toasting, baking, roasting, broiling, and other cooking tasks.
- Key features: Element iQ system for smart heat distribution, convection fan technology, LCD screens with intuitive presets, and a wide array of cooking functions (some models include air frying, dehydrating, and slow cooking).
- Price: Varies by model from $200 - $400+
- Dimensions: Sizes vary, but popular models like the Smart Oven Pro are around 18.5" x 14.5" x 11". They require more counter space than the Balmuda.
- Materials/Construction: Durable stainless steel housing and interior, built for longevity and frequent use.
- Style: A sleek, modern utilitarian look with a professional stainless steel finish and a button-heavy but intuitive digital interface.
- Pros: Extremely versatile with up to 10+ cooking functions in one appliance. It offers great value by combining multiple kitchen gadgets into one. Many models have large interiors that can accommodate a 13-inch pizza or a whole roasted chicken.
- Cons: Its larger footprint takes up significant counter space. Does not include any steam technology for toasting. The complexity of its various settings might be overkill for someone who just wants a simple toaster.
Breville is the go-to for home cooks and families who need a single countertop appliance to handle dozens of different cooking tasks reliably and consistently.
Shop this product: breville.com/us/en/products/ovens/
Balmuda vs. Breville Comparison
Dimensions & Scale
There is a significant difference in size between these two ovens. The Balmuda The Toaster is compact and thoughtfully designed to minimize its footprint, making it ideal for smaller kitchens, apartments, or anyone precious about counter space. Its lean profile allows it to fit neatly under cabinets without dominating the area.
Conversely, a Breville Smart Oven is much larger and bulkier. While its size allows for a more spacious interior capable of roasting a chicken or baking a full batch of cookies, it demands a dedicated spot on the countertop. If kitchen space is at a premium, a Breville might feel overwhelming, whereas the Balmuda feels like a small, curated accessory.
Functionality & Performance
Performance is where the core philosophies of these two brands diverge. The Balmuda is a master of one trade. Its steam injection feature is legitimately innovative, producing better results for toast, bagels, and reheating pastries than almost any other appliance. However, its other "modes," like the small oven setting, are constrained by its low capacity and limited temperature range.
Breville is the jack-of-all-trades and a master of most. Its Element iQ system delivers precise and even heat, making it fantastic for baking, roasting, and standard toasting. With modes for air frying, broiling, and more, it can genuinely replace a full-sized oven for many daily tasks. While it makes very good toast, it cannot replicate the moist-interior, crispy-exterior texture that makes the Balmuda famous.
Materials & Construction
Both brands excel in build quality but with different approaches. Balmuda uses premium aluminum and high-quality plastics to achieve a lightweight yet sturdy feel. The focus is on tactile experience - from the satisfying click of the knobs to the smooth finish of the housing. It's built like a premium piece of consumer electronics.
Breville opts for a more industrial and robust approach. The heavy-duty stainless steel construction feels solid and permanent, designed to withstand the wear and tear of a busy kitchen. It's built like professional-grade kitchen equipment, prioritizing durability and functionality over delicate aesthetics.
Price & Value
At around $300, the Balmuda offers poor value if judged purely by a feature list. You're paying a premium for its specialized technology and iconic design. The value proposition is in the qualitative experience - the "perfect slice of toast" that no other machine can make. It is a luxury item, and its price reflects that.
Breville offers far more concrete value for the money. For a similar or slightly higher price, you get an appliance that performs the job of five or six others. By consolidating baking, roasting, air frying, and toasting, it saves both counter space (relative to owning all those gadgets separately) and money, making it a highly practical and logical investment for most kitchens.
Who Each One Works Best For
The Balmuda is for the specialist: design enthusiasts, foodies who obsess over small details, and single individuals or couples in modern homes with a minimalist aesthetic. It’s for the person who sees beauty in an appliance that does one thing perfectly and is willing to pay for that perfection and design pedigree.
The Breville Smart Oven is for the generalist: families, avid home cooks, and anyone who wants maximum functionality and reliability from a single countertop appliance. It’s for the practical user who needs to roast vegetables on Tuesday, bake cookies on Thursday, and toast bagels on Saturday morning, and wants an oven that can handle it all with ease.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both of these ovens are excellent in their own right, but they cater to completely different priorities and lifestyles.
Choose the Balmuda The Toaster if:
- You believe toast can be an art form and you want the best possible result.
- Kitchen aesthetics are a top priority, and you love minimalist, design-forward products.
- You have limited counter space and only need a small appliance for toasting and reheating.
- You are buying a specialty luxury item and price is not the main consideration.
Choose the Breville Smart Oven if:
- You need a versatile appliance that can bake, roast, air fry, and more.
- Functionality and performance across a wide range of tasks are more important than specialized features.
- You cook for a family or frequently host guests and need a larger capacity.
- You are looking for the best practical value and want one machine to do the job of many.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between Balmuda and Breville toaster ovens?
The primary difference is steam vs. versatility. The Balmuda uses a unique steam injection technology to create perfect toast with a crispy exterior and moist interior. Breville Smart Ovens are multi-function appliances with features like convection and air frying that act as a second oven for a wide array of cooking tasks.
Is the Balmuda The Toaster worth the high price?
Whether it's "worth it" depends on your priorities. For toast connoisseurs and design lovers who value its specific results and aesthetic, the price is justified. If you're looking for a versatile appliance with many cooking functions, a Breville offers much better value for the same amount of money.
How does the steam function on the Balmuda actually work?
Before toasting, you pour 5cc (a tiny teaspoon's worth) of water into a small slot on top of the oven. When you start a cycle, the oven rapidly heats the water, filling the chamber with steam. This steam toasts the bread's surface gently while trapping moisture inside before the final blast of heat creates a perfect crust.
Can the Balmuda The Toaster do more than just make toast?
Yes, but its capabilities are limited. It has modes for reheating pastries, pizza, and an oven mode for simple heating tasks like baked potatoes or gratin. However, due to its small size and simple heating elements, it's not a true substitute for a conventional or Breville countertop oven.
Which Breville Smart Oven is the best competitor to the Balmuda?
While no Breville model uses steam, any model from their popular Smart Oven line, like the Smart Oven Pro or the Smart Oven Air Fryer, can be considered. These models offer superior flexibility and cooking power for around the same price, though they serve a completely different purpose.
Which toaster oven is bigger?
The Breville Smart Ovens are significantly larger and heavier than the Balmuda. The Balmuda is designed to be a compact, space-saving appliance, while Breville ovens are built to maximize interior cooking capacity and require substantial countertop real estate.
Which brand is more durable?
Both are known for high-quality construction. Breville's heavy-duty stainless steel build is designed for rigorous, varied use over many years, making it exceptionally durable. Balmuda is also well-built with premium materials, though its focus is more on refined aesthetics. Both should offer excellent longevity.
Do I really need a countertop oven if I have a full-sized oven?
A Breville countertop oven can be incredibly useful as it preheats faster, uses less energy, and doesn't heat up the entire kitchen, making it perfect for small meals or side dishes. The Balmuda doesn't replace an oven's function, it's a specialty toaster that does its job better than a full-size oven’s broiler or a traditional pop-up toaster.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
