The main difference between Authenticity 50 and Brooklinen comes down to manufacturing focus, price, and sustainability. Authenticity 50 is a premium brand committed to USA-made, eco-friendly organic bedding with a higher price point, whereas Brooklinen offers stylish, high-quality bedding at a more accessible, mid-range price by manufacturing both overseas and in the US.
Here's everything you need to know to decide which bedding brand is right for your home.
Authenticity 50
Authenticity 50 is a luxury bedding brand built on a "seed-to-stitch" promise, with every part of their product sourced and crafted entirely in the USA. They appeal to shoppers who prioritize transparency, eco-conscious materials, and exceptionally high-quality craftsmanship, positioning themselves as a premium investment in sustainable home goods.
- What it is: A direct-to-consumer brand offering super premium, 100% American-made bedding and home essentials.
- Key features: Uses certified organic cotton, low-impact dyes, and sustainable manufacturing processes. Strong emphasis on ethical production and transparency.
- Price: Luxury. Sheet sets range from $250 to $500.
- Style: Minimalist, timeless, and modern. The color palette centers on neutral, calming tones that emphasize material quality over busy patterns.
- Materials/Construction: Premium, GOTS-certified organic cotton. All products are manufactured in the USA, from growing the cotton to final stitching.
- Pros: Exceptional quality and durability. Completely transparent, ethical, and sustainable USA-based supply chain. Products have a soft, luxurious feel. Supports local American manufacturing.
- Cons: Significantly higher price point than competitors. Limited product range and color selection compared to larger brands.
Authenticity 50 is ideal for shoppers willing to invest in ethically-made, American-grown luxury bedding and who value sustainability and transparency above all else.
Shop this brand: authenticity50.com
Brooklinen
Brooklinen is one of the most popular direct-to-consumer bedding brands, known for making "internet famous" luxury-quality sheets accessible. They offer a huge variety of styles, materials, and colors at a mid-range price, focusing on providing a balance of comfort, style, and value for everyday shoppers.
- What it is: A direct-to-consumer home essentials brand offering stylish, high-quality bedding, bath, and loungewear at an affordable price.
- Key features: Wide product selection including long-staple cotton, linen, cashmere, and prints. Strong online presence with excellent customer service and frequent promotions.
- Price: Mid-range. Sheet sets are typically priced between $100 and $200.
- Style: Modern, versatile, and approachable. Offers a mix of classic solids, subtle textures, and limited-edition patterns in a broad color palette.
- Materials/Construction: High-quality materials like long-staple cotton, linen, and Tencel blends sourced and manufactured responsibly in various countries, including the USA.
- Pros: Great balance of quality and price. Huge variety of products, colors, and materials. User-friendly shopping experience with easy returns. Generally more approachable and less cost-prohibitive.
- Cons: Not all products are made with organic materials. Manufacturing is global, not solely based in the USA. Quality is good for the price but may not have the same handcrafted feel as premium competitors.
Brooklinen is for the savvy shopper who wants stylish, comfortable, and reliable bedding without the luxury price tag and appreciates having a wide variety of options.
Shop this brand: brooklinen.com
Authenticity 50 vs. Brooklinen Comparison
Materials & Quality
Authenticity 50 places its entire identity on its materials and American-made quality. They use GOTS-certified organic cotton, and their seed-to-stitch process ensures meticulous oversight at every step. This results in an exceptionally durable and soft fabric that is designed to last for years, reflecting its premium price point.
Brooklinen also uses high-quality materials like long-staple cotton, but their sourcing is global. While they prioritize quality control and responsible manufacturing, their focus is on delivering a luxurious feel for a reasonable price, not on an exclusively organic or American-made supply chain. Their bedding is very well-made and durable for daily use, offering excellent quality for the cost.
Style & Aesthetics
Authenticity 50's aesthetic is minimalist and timeless. Their collection consists mostly of solid, neutral colors that champion the quality of the fabric itself. This understated style is designed to create a serene, sophisticated bedroom and pairs well with almost any decor, from modern to classic.
Brooklinen offers a much more versatile and trend-aware aesthetic. They provide a broad range of colors, from muted neutrals to vibrant hues, along with tasteful patterns and limited edition collaborations. This variety makes it easy for customers to find bedding that perfectly matches their personal style and existing decor.
Price & Value
There is a clear price difference between the two brands. A queen sheet set from Authenticity 50 starts around $250, reflecting the cost of organic materials, ethical labor, and entirely domestic production. The value here lies in longevity, sustainability, and supporting the US economy.
By comparison, a best-selling queen sheet set from Brooklinen typically costs between $150 and $200. Brooklinen's value comes from its ability to deliver a near-luxury experience - softness, thoughtful design, and durability - at a price that is accessible to a much broader audience.
Sustainability & Ethics
Sustainability is the core principle of Authenticity 50. From organic farming practices to non-toxic dyes and fair wages within their US factories, every decision is guided by environmental responsibility and ethical treatment. Their transparency about this process is a key selling point.
While Brooklinen is moving toward more sustainable practices and responsible sourcing, it is not the central pillar of their brand. They focus on quality partnerships and have taken steps to reduce waste, but they don't have the same level of certifications or the strict domestic-only supply chain that Authenticity 50 does.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands provide excellent bedding, but they cater to very different priorities.
Choose Authenticity 50 if:
- You exclusively want products that are 100% made in the USA.
- Sustainability and organic materials are your top priorities when shopping.
- You are willing to invest a premium price for exceptional craftsmanship and durability.
- You prefer a minimalist, timeless aesthetic with high-quality neutral tones.
Choose Brooklinen if:
- You are looking for the best balance of quality, comfort, and affordability.
- You want a wide selection of colors, patterns, and materials to choose from.
- You appreciate a straightforward, modern shopping experience with good customer service.
- You want stylish, reliable bedding that feels luxurious without the high-end luxury price.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Authenticity 50 and Brooklinen?
The biggest difference is their core mission. Authenticity 50 is dedicated to creating premium, 100% USA-made organic bedding with a focus on sustainability. Brooklinen's mission is to offer high-quality, stylish, and comfortable bedding at a more accessible price point through a direct-to-consumer model and global manufacturing.
Which brand is softer?
Both brands are known for their softness. Authenticity 50 uses premium organic cotton that results in a very soft, breathable finish that gets even softer with each wash. Brooklinen's Luxe Sateen sheets are famously buttery and smooth right out of the box. Softness is subjective and depends on the specific fabric weave you choose from either brand.
Are Authenticity 50 sheets worth the price?
For shoppers who prioritize American manufacturing, organic materials, and long-term durability, Authenticity 50 is often considered worth the investment. The price reflects a transparent and ethical supply chain, which adds value beyond the product itself.
Does Brooklinen have organic options?
Yes, Brooklinen has introduced an Organic Collection made from 100% long-staple organic cotton. However, this is just one part of their much larger product catalog, whereas organic materials are standard across the board for Authenticity 50.
Where are Brooklinen products made?
Brooklinen works with manufacturers around the world, including in the USA, Portugal, Turkey, and India, to source their high-quality textiles and craft their products.
Which brand has a better return policy?
Both brands offer customer-friendly return policies. Brooklinen has a generous 365-day return window, allowing you to return or exchange products even after use. Authenticity 50 offers a 100-night trial period, giving you ample time to decide if their products are right for you.
How is the sizing and fit for these brands?
Both Authenticity 50 and Brooklinen design their fitted sheets with deep pockets to accommodate a wide range of mattress depths, including thicker modern mattresses and those with toppers. They both provide standard American bedding sizes.
Which one should I choose for a gift?
Brooklinen is often a safer choice for a gift due to its wider style variety and more accessible price point. Its popular starter sets and bundles make for a comprehensive and well-received gift. Authenticity 50 is an excellent choice for a more specialized, luxury gift for someone you know values sustainability and American-made goods.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
