Ashley Furniture is a massive national brand known for its affordable prices and a vast, trend-driven selection, making it a go-to for budget-conscious shoppers across the country. In contrast, Gardner White is a regional retailer in the Midwest that focuses on a more curated collection, balancing competitive pricing with better quality materials, durability, and a hands-on customer service experience.
Let's break down the details to help you decide which is right for your home.
Ashley Furniture: The Budget-Friendly Trend-Setter
Ashley Furniture is one of the largest and most recognizable furniture manufacturers and retailers in the United States. Its success is built on offering an enormous selection of stylish furnishings for every room at very accessible price points. This makes Ashley a popular destination for first-time homebuyers, college students, and anyone looking to furnish a space without a huge financial commitment.
- Product mix: A comprehensive selection covering the entire home, including sofas, sectionals, bedroom sets, dining tables, mattresses, outdoor furniture, and home decor. Their product catalog is one of the largest in the industry.
- Style/vibe: Caters to nearly all tastes by offering a wide spectrum of styles, from traditional and rustic farmhouse to sleek contemporary and modern designs. Collections are often updated to reflect current interior design trends.
- Price point: Highly affordable and value-oriented. Sofas often start around $399, beds can be found from $299, and complete dining sets are frequently available from $299–$799.
- Quality: Construction is focused on affordability, often utilizing materials like engineered wood, particleboard, and durable synthetic fabrics. While great for the price, the long-term durability may not match more expensive brands, and warranties are generally limited to one year on structural components.
- Customization: Select collections offer customization options, allowing you to choose from various fabrics, colors, and configurations to better suit your space.
- Sales: Known for frequent sales and promotions, especially during major holidays like Presidents Day, Memorial Day, and Black Friday. Financing options are almost always available.
- Delivery & Assembly: Home delivery is available nationwide. Many items, especially case goods like dressers and tables, will require customer assembly, though professional assembly services may be offered for an additional fee.
Ashley Furniture excels at providing trendy, accessible furniture for shoppers who prioritize price and selection above all else.
Shop Ashley Furniture: ashleyfurniture.com
Gardner White: The Quality-Focused Regional Retailer
Gardner White is a well-established furniture retailer serving Michigan, Ohio, and surrounding areas. For over a century, the brand has built a reputation for providing quality furniture paired with excellent, personalized customer service. While still offering competitive prices, Gardner White puts a stronger emphasis on durability, better materials, and an overall better shopping experience, including professional delivery and setup.
- Product mix: A well-curated but comprehensive selection of home furnishings, including sofas, sectionals, dining sets, bedroom furniture, mattresses, and home accessories.
- Style/vibe: Leans toward modern, transitional, and contemporary styles. The aesthetic focuses on clean lines, sophisticated finishes, and timeless designs that won't feel dated in a few years.
- Price point: Competitive mid-range, offering a step up in quality from an entry-level brand. Sofas typically begin around $499, beds from $399, and dining sets usually range from $399 to $899.
- Quality: Emphasizes higher-quality craftsmanship, using a mix of solid wood and premium engineered wood. Fabrics are often more durable, and some collections feature GREENGUARD-certified materials. Warranties are more generous, often covering frames for up to five years.
- Sustainability: The company places a visible focus on responsible sourcing and eco-friendly practices, including offering products with sustainably sourced materials and GREENGUARD-certified upholstery for low chemical emissions.
- Sales: Runs frequent sales events and offers attractive financing options to provide customers with good value.
- Delivery & Assembly: Known for its exceptional delivery service, which often includes professional in-home setup at no extra charge, removing a major hassle for customers.
Gardner White is an excellent choice for shoppers who want long-lasting, stylish furniture and value a supportive, full-service shopping experience.
Shop Gardner White: gardner-white.com
Ashley Furniture vs. Gardner White Comparison
Price Comparison
Ashley Furniture is typically the more affordable option, with lower starting prices across almost every category. A sofa at Ashley might start at $399, whereas a similar style at Gardner White will likely start closer to $499. Ashley also runs aggressive promotions and deep discounts more often, making it a clear winner for those on the tightest of budgets.
However, Gardner White argues for better long-term value. While the upfront cost is slightly higher, the investment often pays off through more durable materials and construction that won't need to be replaced as quickly. When comparing prices, it’s important to factor in the potential value of Gardner White’s professional delivery and setup, which can be a significant cost-saver elsewhere.
Quality & Construction
This is where the two brands differ most. Ashley Furniture's business model is built on volume and affordability, which means using cost-effective materials like particleboard, engineered wood, and synthetic fiber fabrics. While functional for everyday use, the materials may be less resilient to heavy wear and tear over many years.
Gardner White positions itself a step above in quality. Many pieces feature solid wood elements, higher-grade engineered wood, and more durable upholstery options, including performance and GREENGUARD-certified fabrics. The craftsmanship tends to feel more substantial, and longer warranties - up to five years on frames - provide greater peace of mind about the furniture's longevity.
Style & Aesthetic
Ashley Furniture boasts an incredibly diverse and extensive range of styles. Whether you're looking for a rustic farmhouse dining table, a traditional leather armchair, or an ultra-modern sectional, you'll likely find it at Ashley. Their inventory is heavily influenced by current trends, making it a great place to achieve a specific, popular look for less.
Gardner White's selection is more thoughtfully curated, focusing primarily on modern, transitional, and contemporary designs. Their aesthetic goal is timeless appeal, offering sophisticated pieces with clean lines and neutral palettes that can easily adapt to evolving decor. While you won't find every single style, the options are generally refined and style-conscious without being overly trendy.
Shopping Experience
Shopping at Ashley can be done online from anywhere in the country or in one of their many large-format showrooms. The experience is what you'd expect from a major national retailer: a huge selection to browse and a focus on self-service, though staff are available to help.
As a regional retailer, Gardner White provides a much more personalized and high-service experience. Their knowledgeable staff are known for being helpful without being pushy, and their standout professional delivery and setup service is a major differentiator. If you value attentive customer care, Gardner White has the edge.
Sustainability & Ethics
While Ashley has some sustainability initiatives in place, the company is less transparent about them. It's difficult to find specific information about material sourcing or eco-friendly manufacturing on a per-product basis.
Gardner White makes its commitment to sustainability a more prominent part of its brand identity. They actively promote their use of sustainably sourced wood and collections that feature GREENGUARD-certified fabrics, which are tested for low chemical emissions. For the eco-conscious shopper, Gardner White provides more clarity and better options.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends entirely on your budget, style, and long-term needs. Both retailers offer great furniture, but they serve different customer priorities.
Choose Ashley Furniture if:
- Your primary concern is staying within a tight budget.
- You want a massive selection of styles to choose from, especially trend-driven looks.
- You are furnishing a starter home, apartment, or a temporary space.
- You don't mind assembling some furniture yourself to save on costs.
Choose Gardner White if:
- You prioritize quality, craftsmanship, and long-term durability in your furniture.
- You value a personalized shopping experience and full-service delivery with setup.
- You live in their service area (primarily Michigan and Ohio) and prefer to shop local.
- You are looking for more sustainable options, like GREENGUARD-certified materials.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Ashley Furniture or Gardner White cheaper?
Ashley Furniture generally has lower starting prices and offers more frequent deep discounts. It is the more budget-friendly option for shoppers looking for the lowest upfront cost.
Which brand has better quality furniture?
Gardner White generally offers higher-quality furniture. Their emphasis on better materials like solid wood, superior construction techniques, and longer warranties makes their pieces a better investment for long-term durability.
Where can I shop at Gardner White?
Gardner White is a regional retailer with physical showrooms and delivery services primarily in Michigan, Ohio, and surrounding areas. In contrast, Ashley Furniture has stores located across the entire United States and offers nationwide shipping from its website.
Which is better for families with kids?
For durability, Gardner White is likely the better choice. Their more robust construction and higher-quality materials can better withstand the daily wear and tear of a busy household. Look for performance fabrics from either brand for added stain resistance.
Which has more modern styles?
Both brands offer modern furniture, but with different approaches. Ashley offers a wide variety of trendy, modern pieces in its massive catalog. Gardner White has a more curated collection of modern, transitional, and contemporary designs that tend to feel a bit more timeless and sophisticated.
How are their delivery services different?
The delivery experience is a key differentiator. Gardner White is known for its high-quality, professional in-home delivery and setup service, which adds significant convenience. Ashley also offers home delivery, but furniture assembly is often a separate service at an additional cost.
Can you return furniture to both stores?
Yes, both retailers have return policies, but they can be restrictive for large furniture items. Furniture deliveries should be inspected carefully upon arrival for damage. It’s critical to read each brand's specific return policy before purchasing, as made-to-order items and clearance pieces are often non-returnable.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
