Ashley Furniture is a mass-market retailer known for its vast selection of affordable, traditional styles, making it perfect for budget-conscious shoppers. In contrast, Crate & Barrel offers a more curated collection of modern, high-quality furniture at a premium price point, emphasizing durable materials and sustainable sourcing. The primary difference is Ashley's focus on accessibility and value versus Crate & Barrel's commitment to investment-worthy design and longevity.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right home decor retailer for your space.
Ashley Furniture: The Affordable & Accessible Option
Ashley Furniture is one of the largest furniture manufacturers globally, offering a massive selection of home furnishings that cater to a wide range of tastes and budgets. The brand is a go-to for first-time homebuyers, renters, and families looking for stylish, functional pieces without a hefty initial investment. Its extensive network of showrooms and robust online store makes it one of the most accessible options in the country for outfitting any room in your home.
- Product mix: A complete assortment of home furniture, including sofas, sectionals, beds, dining sets, home office furniture, outdoor sets, and decor. They cover every major category.
- Style/vibe: Mainly traditional, transitional, and casual-contemporary. Designs are meant for broad appeal, featuring familiar shapes, comfortable upholstery, and versatile finishes.
- Price point: Budget-friendly to mid-range. Sofas often start around $399, dining room sets can be found for under $800, and complete bedroom sets typically run between $700 and $1,500.
- Quality: Construction focuses on keeping costs low. Materials commonly include engineered woods, particleboard, and standard fabric upholstery. Durability is decent for the price but not intended for heirloom-quality longevity.
- Sales: Constant sales and promotional events occur throughout the year, especially around major holidays. Financing options are also available to make purchasing more manageable.
- Return policy: Returns for online orders are generally accepted within 30 days, though restocking fees may apply for larger items. In-store policies can vary.
- Delivery & Assembly: Offers several tiers of delivery, from doorstep drop-off to in-home assembly for an additional fee. This flexibility allows customers to choose based on budget and convenience.
Ashley Furniture excels at providing an enormous variety of styles at prices most people can afford, making it a practical choice for furnishing a home quickly and economically.
Shop Ashley Furniture: ashleyfurniture.com
Crate & Barrel: The Modern & Timeless Investment
Crate & Barrel is a premium home furnishings brand known for its clean, modern aesthetic and commitment to high-quality materials and craftsmanship. It appeals to design-conscious consumers who value longevity and timeless style. From its sophisticated furniture collections to its extensive kitchenware and home decor, Crate & Barrel provides a curated shopping experience for those willing to invest in pieces that will anchor their home's design for years to come.
- Product mix: Full home furnishings with a special emphasis on living, dining, and bedroom collections. They are also famous for their kitchen items, tableware, and popular wedding registry service.
- Style/vibe: Modern, minimalist, and contemporary. The aesthetic is defined by clean lines, neutral color palettes, natural materials, and sophisticated yet functional designs.
- Price point: Mid-to-high range. Sofas typically start around $1,200, solid wood dining tables often exceed $1,500, and bedroom pieces can cost $2,000 or more.
- Quality: Emphasizes durability and premium materials. You'll find kiln-dried solid wood frames, high-performance fabrics, and meticulous construction. Many pieces are designed for both residential and contract-grade use.
- Customization: Offers a wide array of customization on upholstered furniture, including dozens of fabric and leather options. Some wooden furniture collections also have multiple finish choices.
- Sustainability: Strong focus on responsible sourcing, with many wood products being FSC-certified and upholstery meeting GREENGUARD Gold standards for low chemical emissions.
- Delivery & Assembly: Primarily offers white-glove delivery, where trained professionals assemble your furniture, place it in the room of your choice, and remove all packaging materials.
- Return policy: Generally offers a flexible return policy for non-furniture items. Custom-order furniture is often final sale.
Crate & Barrel is the ideal choice for those seeking refined, long-lasting furniture and who prioritize sustainable, quality materials in their home.
Shop Crate & Barrel: crateandbarrel.com
Ashley Furniture vs. Crate & Barrel Comparison
Price Comparison
There's very little overlap here. Ashley Furniture is fundamentally a budget-friendly brand. You can furnish an entire living room for the price of a single sofa from Crate & Barrel. Ashley makes furniture ownership accessible with sofas starting under $500 and frequent BOGO deals or holiday blowouts.
Crate & Barrel operates in the mid-to-high end of the market. Its pricing reflects its investment in higher-quality materials, more sophisticated design, and durable construction. A basic Crate & Barrel sofa will start around $1,200 and can easily go up to $4,000+. The brand caters to shoppers looking for "forever furniture" and are willing to pay for it.
Style & Aesthetic
Ashley's design philosophy is about mass appeal. Its collections span traditional (think rolled arms and dark wood), casual contemporary, and modern farmhouse. While they offer on-trend pieces, their core catalog consists of safe, versatile styles that fit into the average American home without making a bold statement.
Crate & Barrel has a distinct, curated aesthetic that is modern and timeless. Their furniture features clean lines, understated colors, and natural textures like wood, linen, and steel. The look is sophisticated and intentional, perfect for creating a cohesive, design-forward interior. If you love uncluttered, minimalist, or Scandinavian-inspired spaces, Crate & Barrel’s collections will be a perfect fit.
Quality & Construction
The quality difference aligns directly with the price gap. Ashley Furniture utilizes materials like engineered wood, particleboard, veneers, and polyester fabrics to keep its prices low. While functional, these pieces are not designed to withstand heavy, long-term use and may show signs of wear sooner.
In contrast, Crate & Barrel builds furniture to last. They use kiln-dried solid hardwood frames, fine veneers, performance fabrics designed to resist stains and fading, and robust construction techniques. The tangible difference in weight, sturdiness, and finish is a primary reason for the higher cost and makes their furniture a more durable long-term investment.
Shopping Experience
Ashley Furniture offers a straightforward retail experience. Its website is vast, and its physical showrooms are typically large, no-frills spaces where you can see a huge amount of merchandise. The focus is on variety and visible low prices.
Shopping at Crate & Barrel is a more polished experience. Their stores are beautifully designed to inspire, showcasing furniture in thoughtfully styled vignettes. Their website is clean and user-friendly, and they offer valuable services like free in-store or virtual design consultations to help customers plan their spaces.
Delivery & Assembly
Ashley provides flexible delivery options. Customers can choose more affordable doorstep delivery and assemble pieces themselves or pay extra for full-service in-home delivery and setup. This à la carte model helps keep initial costs down.
Crate & Barrel typically defaults to a much more seamless White Glove Delivery service for large items. Their team schedules a delivery window, brings the item into your home, performs any necessary assembly, and removes all packaging. This premium service is built into their shipping costs and ensures your investment arrives in perfect condition.
Sustainability & Ethics
Crate & Barrel has made sustainability a core pillar of its brand identity. They actively promote their use of responsibly sourced wood (often FSC-certified), recycled materials, and low-emission finishes (GREENGUARD Gold certified). This transparency is a key selling point for eco-conscious shoppers.
Ashley Furniture has sustainability initiatives, but they are less central to their branding and marketing. As a volume-focused manufacturer, their primary mission is affordability, and deep dives into sourcing and materials are less transparent than at more premium brands.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice comes down to your budget, style priorities, and how long you expect your furniture to last.
Choose Ashley Furniture if:
- You are furnishing a space on a strict budget.
- You need furniture quickly for a first apartment, dorm room, or starter home.
- Your style preferences lean toward classic, traditional, or casual looks.
- You're shopping for a temporary space or a room that doesn't see heavy daily use, like a guest room.
Choose Crate & Barrel if:
- You plan to invest in high-quality pieces that will last a decade or more.
- You love a clean, modern, and minimalist design aesthetic.
- Good craftsmanship and sustainable, non-toxic materials are important to you.
- You want a premium shopping experience, including design services and seamless white-glove delivery.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Ashley Furniture or Crate & Barrel cheaper?
Ashley Furniture is significantly cheaper than Crate & Barrel across all product categories. Ashley focuses on providing budget-friendly options, whereas Crate & Barrel is a premium brand with prices that reflect their focus on higher-quality materials and design.
Which has better quality furniture?
Crate & Barrel has better quality furniture. They use superior materials like solid hardwood frames and performance fabrics, and their pieces are constructed for long-term durability. While Ashley Furniture is functional, it is built to a lower price point and isn't intended to last as long.
What is the style difference between Ashley and Crate & Barrel?
Ashley Furniture offers a wide range of popular styles, with a focus on traditional, transitional, and casual-contemporary looks. Crate & Barrel maintains a more focused and distinct modern, minimalist aesthetic with an emphasis on clean lines and neutral palettes.
Is Ashley Furniture good for first-time homebuyers?
Yes, Ashley Furniture is an excellent choice for first-time homebuyers. Its affordability, frequent sales, and vast selection make it easy to furnish an entire home without a massive upfront investment.
Does Crate & Barrel furniture require assembly?
Most large furniture from Crate & Barrel is delivered with their white-glove service, which includes full assembly and placement in your room. Some smaller items may require minimal self-assembly.
How long will Ashley furniture last?
The lifespan of Ashley furniture can vary, but most users find it suitable for short- to medium-term use (around 3-7 years), especially with regular daily use. It's not typically considered heirloom furniture.
Which brand is better for families with kids?
This depends on the family's priorities. Ashley is great for families on a budget who may not want to worry about kids being rough on expensive furniture. However, Crate & Barrel's highly durable performance fabrics are often better at resisting stains and wear, making them a strong, albeit more expensive, long-term option.
Do both brands have physical stores?
Yes, both have a strong physical retail presence. However, Ashley Furniture HomeStores are far more numerous and widely distributed across the United States, especially in suburban areas and smaller cities, while Crate & Barrel stores are typically found in major metropolitan areas and upscale shopping centers.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
