Ashbrook offers stylish, budget-friendly furniture with a distinct focus on modern farmhouse and transitional aesthetics, making it a great fit for smaller, contemporary spaces. Ashley Furniture, one of the largest furniture retailers, provides a vastly wider selection of styles from classic to modern, serves a broader range of price points, and supports its offerings with an extensive network of physical showrooms.
Let's compare these two brands to help you decide which is the right choice for your home.
Ashbrook: The Stylish & Affordable Choice
Ashbrook is a contemporary brand that tailors its collections to younger professionals and first-time homeowners looking for trendy yet functional pieces at an accessible price. The brand emphasizes value and practicality, with designs that blend clean lines and rustic charm, perfect for modern apartments and casual living environments.
- Product mix: A focused selection of sofas, beds, dining sets, accent chairs, and storage solutions built for everyday living and functionality.
- Style/vibe: Primarily modern farmhouse and transitional. Expect neutral colors, simple silhouettes, and a comfortable, casual feel that is easy to integrate into various decor schemes.
- Price point: Budget to mid-range. Sofas begin around $399, dining tables from $299, and full bedroom sets typically fall in the $500–$1,000 range.
- Quality: Construction uses a balance of cost-effective and durable materials like engineered wood, MDF, and resilient fabrics designed for casual use.
- Shopping Experience: Mostly an online-first model, prioritizing convenience and direct shipping, though they have a few showrooms in major cities.
- Sustainability: The company promotes eco-friendly manufacturing processes and transparent material sourcing.
- Warranty: Most items come with a 1-year limited warranty covering frames and fabrics.
Ashbrook is a strong contender for shoppers who want trendy, value-focused furniture for contemporary small to medium-sized spaces.
Shop Ashbrook: ashbrookfurniture.com
Ashley Furniture: The Established & Versatile Retailer
As one of America's most recognizable furniture brands, Ashley Furniture is known for its incredible variety and accessibility. Its massive catalog covers everything from timeless classics to the latest trends, catering to almost any taste, budget, or room size. Ashley's strong retail presence makes it a go-to for those who prefer to see and feel furniture before buying.
- Product mix: An extensive range of home furnishings including sofas, sectionals, bedroom suites, dining room collections, mattresses, outdoor furniture, rugs, and decor.
- Style/vibe: Extremely broad, with collections spanning traditional, classic, rustic, contemporary, industrial, and coastal styles.
- Price point: Affordable to mid-range. While entry-level sofas are priced similarly to Ashbrook (starting around $399), Ashley offers a much wider spectrum of prices and options, often with deep discounts during frequent sales events.
- Quality: Materials include engineered and solid wood, veneers, and a variety of upholstery including high-performance fabrics. The quality and longevity generally increase with the price point.
- Shopping Experience: A true multi-channel retailer with a user-friendly website and a massive network of company-owned and licensed stores across the country.
- Delivery & Assembly: A robust logistics network provides various delivery options, including white-glove service and assembly for an additional fee.
- Sustainability: Ashley Furniture pursues sustainability with responsible wood sourcing initiatives and some FSC-certified products, reflecting their scale and industry position.
- Warranty: Most furniture includes a 1-year limited warranty.
Ashley Furniture’s strength lies in its vast selection, competitive pricing, and the ability to furnish an entire home from one place, suiting a wide variety of customer needs.
Shop Ashley Furniture: ashleyfurniture.com
Ashbrook vs. Ashley Furniture Comparison
Price Comparison
Both brands target budget-conscious shoppers. Ashbrook’s pricing is straightforward and consistently affordable, making it a great choice for those on a tight budget who need stylish pieces. Their entry-level sectionals and dining sets are particularly competitive.
Ashley Furniture often matches these initial price points but really stands out with its frequent promotions and sales. Shoppers who time their purchases carefully can find significant discounts on a wider range of items. Ashley also extends into higher mid-range territory, offering more premium collections that provide better materials and construction for a slightly higher investment.
Quality & Materials
Ashbrook’s furniture is built with affordability in mind, primarily using engineered wood and MDF with durable, everyday fabrics. This construction provides solid value for the price but may be better suited for lighter or short-term use, like in a first apartment or a less-frequented room.
Ashley Furniture offers more variety in its materials. While their most affordable lines use similar components to Ashbrook, their mid-range collections often incorporate solid wood frames, higher-grade veneers, and more robust upholstery options. Thanks to extensive product testing, many Ashley pieces are built for greater longevity and are often a wise choice for high-traffic family homes.
Style & Aesthetic
This is a key differentiator. Ashbrook has a curated, trendy aesthetic focused squarely on modern farmhouse and simple transitional designs. Its catalog is cohesive and easy to navigate if this is your preferred style.
Ashley Furniture is far more diverse. Whether you’re looking for a formal, traditional dining set, a plush leather recliner, or a sleek, contemporary sectional, you’re likely to find it. This variety is excellent for shoppers who are still defining their style or want to mix and match different looks.
Fit & Sizing
Ashbrook’s collections are generally optimized for small to medium-sized living spaces. Many of their sofas, loveseats, and dining tables are well-proportioned for city apartments, condos, and starter homes, where maximizing space is crucial.
With its massive scale, Ashley offers furniture suited for almost any room dimension. From compact accent chairs to enormous, family-sized sectionals that can anchor a large great room, their product range provides options for both cozy corners and expansive layouts.
Shopping Experience
If you prefer buying from the comfort of your home, Ashbrook's straightforward online platform is designed for you. Product pages are clear and the process is simple and direct.
If you need to sit on a sofa, open a drawer, or feel the fabric before you commit, Ashley Furniture’s extensive network of stores is a major advantage. Their hybrid online and in-store model offers the best of both worlds - you can browse online and then visit a showroom to finalize your decision. This hands-on experience can provide a lot of confidence in a large purchase.
Sustainability & Ethics
Both brands state a commitment to improving their environmental impact. Ashbrook highlights its eco-conscious manufacturing and sourcing methods, appealing to environmentally aware consumers.
As a much larger operation, Ashley has more established and widely certified sustainability programs. They actively promote responsible wood sourcing, have earned FSC certifications for certain products, and invest in reducing manufacturing waste.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends entirely on your style preferences, space, and how you like to shop.
Choose Ashbrook if:
- You love the modern farmhouse or simple transitional aesthetic.
- You are furnishing a smaller space like an apartment or starter home.
- You want on-trend furniture at a consistently affordable price point.
- You prefer the convenience and simplicity of an online-first retailer.
Choose Ashley Furniture if:
- You want a huge variety of styles to choose from, ranging from traditional to modern.
- You value the ability to see, touch, and test furniture in a physical showroom.
- You need furniture to fit a larger space or are looking for larger pieces like oversized sectionals.
- You are a savvy shopper who looks for major sales and financing options.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Ashbrook or Ashley Furniture cheaper?
Their starting prices are very similar, making both highly affordable. Ashbrook maintains consistently low prices, while Ashley Furniture often has an edge during major sales events, which happen frequently and can bring prices down substantially.
Which brand has better quality furniture?
For long-term use in a main living area, Ashley Furniture's mid-range collections generally offer superior durability due to better materials and more robust construction. Ashbrook delivers solid quality for its price, making it great for less demanding cases or shorter-term needs.
What style of furniture is Ashbrook known for?
Ashbrook specializes in modern farmhouse and transitional styles, featuring clean lines, neutral colors, and a gently rustic appeal.
Does Ashley Furniture only sell classic/traditional styles?
Not at all. While they have a strong classic and traditional selection, Ashley Furniture offers thousands of items in contemporary, industrial, mid-century, and eclectic styles.
Which brand is better for small apartments?
Ashbrook is an excellent choice for small apartments. Its collection is intentionally designed and scaled for compact living, with many space-saving and multi-functional pieces.
Where can I buy Ashbrook furniture?
Ashbrook is primarily an online brand sold through its website, though they also have physical showrooms in select large cities.
Do both brands offer a warranty?
Yes, both typically provide a 1-year limited warranty that covers manufacturing defects on frames and fabrics, a standard practice for furniture in this price range.
Do both brands offer delivery and assembly?
Yes, both companies offer home delivery. Ashbrook usually ships items for self-assembly, whereas Ashley Furniture frequently offers professional assembly services for an additional fee, facilitated by their extensive retail and logistics network.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
